Cobb salad is the best, great pizza and stuffed bread. Eaten there over the years and the quality of their food is always top notch. Highly recommend read more

Easy ordering, Order directly and you will have the opportunity to order ahead if the restaurant is closed.....Wings were jumbo and very tasty, pizza was above average for the area the easy ordering makes it great!!! This definitely is a great option for pizza regulars.... Business is take out "mostly " They do have a high top in the entrance. read more

See all

Ordered 2 pizza's on Saturday, one was totally burnt on the bottom and the other tasted bad. Our whole family got sick, can't reach them to compain becase it is cell phone read more

Awesome pizza from a little take-out place. I happened to head home this way and spotted Anna's on my maps app. I am so glad I did! No need to go into gun-wavin' New Haven! Just go here! Very reasonably priced too. read more

This pizza is simply amazing, if you like thin, well done with an even amount of cheese and sauce. Right here at Anna's read more

Anna's Prospect Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Prospect, Connecticut

It's supposed to be abeetz outside of New Haven according to Portnoy whom I usually trust. It wasn't. We all ate it but it lacked flavor and the crust was charred but tasteless. If I closed my eyes and ate the claims casino, I'm pretty sure I would have zero idea there were claims or bacon on it. If you live very close, it'll do but I drove 20 min and was disappointed. read more

Anna's Prospect Apizza is a very small pizza shop. They do have two high top tables, and four chairs, but it's mostly for take out or delivery. Besides pizza they also have appetizers, salads, calzones, stuffed breads, classic dinners, grinders, club sandwiches, and wraps. I ordered a large sausage pizza. The pizza was delicious, crust was thin, crispy and perfectly baked. Their sausage and sauce was very good. Excellent New Haven style pizza. I definitely will be returning . read more

See all

First time and probably last time . Came highly recommended but it fell short of expectations of flavor, texture of the chewy crust. No wow. In the land of the greatest pizza o see no reason to go back. read more

See all

Delicious food and great service. I've ordered from Anna's many times and am always pleased with the result. Delivery can take a bit long depending on where you live and when you order, but overall a big hit in our house! read more

The pizza at Anna's is awesome. The dough is crunchy. The mozzarella cheese taste neutral and the pizza sauce is great. Highly recommended. read more

Anna's Prospect Pizza - Pie at Anna's. - Pizza Near Me - Prospect, Connecticut

Got the boneless bbq wings for the first time. They are so good such tasty sauce and crispy chicken read more

Anna's Prospect Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Prospect, Connecticut

Annas has Great pizza and wings, Almost everything on their menu is great. They also have reasonable prices and fast delivery. read more

Very good stuffed breads and pizza . Love their salads also. Consistent quality and good customer service. Best delivery around.

The pizza is consistently delicious! The right balance of sauce cheese and thin crust. Are go to spot for take out pizza when traveling through. read more

Got the buffalo chicken egg rolls that I've seen on the menu but havent jumped at yet. They come with 4 eggs rolls. When I got them they weren't exactly what I was expecting visually but that's okay. I was expecting to see the Chinese style egg rolls which are short and thick. What I got were visually similar to as a longer version of those Mexican roll ups in the freezer section. Not taste of course but visually. Inside I was expecting blue cheese crumble or blue cheese dressing but they used a shredded cheese instead which actually tasted fine. Not sure what cheese. The use Frank's Red Hot Sauce I believe as its also used on their Buffalo Chicken pizza. The chicken itself is diced. It'd imagine that's the probably the best way to do it and it seem to be proportioned correctly throughout the egg roll. The flavor was good overall. For being different than what I was envisioning, it still met my taste bud satisfaction. It was hot/spicy but not too much that a spicy sensitive eater would have to avoid it. My only wish as that these were a little thicker and that they gave you blue cheese as a dipping sauce instead of ranch dressing. These were delicious and I would recommend them to others who are admirers of Buffalo Chicken anything. Its definitely worth the try read more

Anna's Prospect Pizza - These are the Anna's Buffalo Chicken egg rolls. Once I saw them on the menu I knew I had to try them. - Pizza Near Me - Prospect, Connecticut

See all

I placed an order tonight, a chicken wrap and a ham and cheese grinder to be delivered. It took 2-hours before we got it, and was absolutely horrible. This is now the 3rd time now we have had bad service and the food is terrible. If I could give a negative star review I would. I love supporting local businesses and thought I should give Anna's a 3rd try, very disappointed. Go to Haven the food is excellent! read more

Inconsistent. we order from Anna's every so often now for the past 5 years since we've lived in the area. First off they are extremely overpriced. The pizza is OK. The flavor of the sauce and quality of the cheese is different every time. unfortunately the last order I placed will be the last time I order from them. They refused to honor the coupon that is attached to their menu, (response I received was due to the pandemic they can't afford the coupons) OK I'm all for supporting small businesses~ BUT... 90 minutes late The pizza we receive was inedible. The cheese was oily And just plain gross. Pizza was literally inedible!! I called to ask them if they changed suppliers. The Young lady that answered the phone was rude and dismissive to my concerns. Family of six. our bill was nearly $160 after delivery fees and tip. Never Again!!! read more

Still love this place but we just ordered our usual Friday night order which went up $10 ($34 to $44) with a $3 delivery fee and $7 increase on food! That's crazy! read more

stopped by here and the pizza was absolutely horrible. it had been many yrs since I visited this place, I kinda figured it may not be the same, I went against my better judgement..Total waste of money.. read more

Ordered a grilled chicken caesar salad and this is the chicken that came in it - kinda grossed out! read more

Anna's Prospect Pizza - chicken in caesar salad - Pizza Near Me - Prospect, Connecticut

Although delivery was great, food was ok. Wings was "ugh" under cooked (pink inside). Mozzarella sticks were cold. Might not order from here again. read more

Anna's Prospect Pizza - Coming from a NYer, pizza was ok. - Pizza Near Me - Prospect, Connecticut

See all

So I've mentioned before how blessed I am to live in a small town with no less than THIRTEEN pizza options...it's a good life people. It just so happens that I also work in an area with multiple pizza options. Not quite 13, but enough to keep it fresh. See as today was my monthly "Fat Face Thursday" lunch, I decided a pizza was in order. Coworkers have mentioned Anna's multiple times but somehow I never got around to trying it. Today was the day! Firstly, let's get this out of the way: they call themselves "New Haven Style" pizza. That term in and of itself is way to ambiguous to live up to as there is no single defining characteristic of a New Haven pizza. It's not a strike from me, and it's totally fine to play that card, but I'm not going to speak to that or do any comparisons there. As far as I'm concerned, it's a pizza. Scanned the menu and was actually torn between 3 or 4 of the gourmet pies. Finally landed on the Philly Supreme. Hard to go wrong there. Place my order over the phone and was told 20 minutes. LOVE IT! Pizza was ready and hot when I arrived and I raced back to the office to fill my face hole as soon as possible. Before we get to flavors and textures, let's just say that visually this was one of the best looking pies I've ever seen. Nice bit of crisp on the crust and the cheese and toppings "looked" cooked. I understand that most pizzas look cooked, but when one is cooked properly, you can tell without even tasting it. Taste-wise, no complaints at all. Super fresh topping, sweet and tangy sauce. Just an amazing pie all around. And the crust was exactly how I like it: thin, crispy, and "New Haven-ey". I may have multiple other pizza options at work, but after trying Anna's I don't really see a need to exercise any of those other options. SOLD! read more

Anna's Prospect Pizza - Have you ever seen anything more beautiful than this Philly Supreme? If you have, I bet it didn't taste as good. - Pizza Near Me - Prospect, Connecticut

Unsure of the 3 star overall rating here. The pizza here is great and a real alternative to New Haven pizza. I think folks in this town are too connected to Bakis and Hometown. read more

I've been coming here since we moved into town back in 2005. There are several other pizza restaurants in town, this is the best by far. The owner works very hard to serve quality food. I've never heard any bad reviews from all of my friends who got there to eat. Keep up the great work!! Always great food, never a bad meal! read more

See all

Great neapolutan pizza, excellent marinara!!! Try this place. Good Italian food at a good price

Stopped for a lunch grinder and had a Philly Works. The sub was ready in 15 minutes. Tasted fine, good steak and cheese with veggies. Lots of bread in the grinder - and my rating is just because it wasn't a memorable sandwich. If I lived in the area I would buy again when in the mood. read more

I think Anna's has the best pizza is prospect. Sauce is great and pizza tastes as close to wood fired as you can get without using wood

I'm sorry to leave a poor review however ordering take out is a bummer when you receive low quality food. The pizza was insanely freeway. The images are after we dabbed it with paper towels hoping to make it better. The slice missing I put upside down on a pan to cook off the grease but it really didn't do much justice. Maybe the bacon they use is very oily?They may use too much oil or the cheese quality isn't so good. Unsure but not edible unfortunately and at 10:30 there aren't many other options. I remember this pizza place being great years ago - maybe owner change? read more

See all

In a town where there are 4 pizza restaurants, this one which is merely a hole in the wall in a storefront decided to not only charge a ridiculous amount for a large pizza but also now charge for delivery. 28.00 for a large pepperoni pizza delivered is insanity. Of course they don't tell you there is a delivery charge till later. All three other places are a better choice and a more reasonable choice with better pizza. read more

We were in town to see my nieces and newborn nephew, and we were hungry. My sister recommended the pizza at Anna's in Prospect. I ordered two pies - one with pepperoni and bacon and the other with mushroom. The prices for the size of the pizza were fair and the time it took for them to prepare the pizza was right in line with how long they said it would take. The pizza tasted pretty good. I didn't really taste the flavor of the toppings though - I would have guessed a quality cheese pizza if I was blind-folded, as the flavor of the cheese, sauce and crust were very good and overpowered the toppings. You can even smell the Parmesan cheese through the box! Anyway, if you live nearby, make sure to take advantage of the coupons on the flyers if you happen to receive their flyers in the mail. On the grand scale of pizza places, this was pretty good but no where near the best I've ever had. Definitely no where near the worst either, so 3 stars is adequate for me! read more

I placed my order at 11:30 AM and the pickup time was 11:55. Unfortunately, Anna's was closed on a Tuesday even though the website showed open status and the online ordering process took my money. Also, no one is answering the phone at Anna's. read more

I was visiting a friend and we ordered twice from Anna's. First night: pizza. It was ok. Nothing exciting, not bursting with flavor. Just pizza. Night two: I ordered plain spaghetti for my daughter. Plain spaghetti apparently means covered in parmesan cheese. Unhappy 6 year old and then unhappy Mom listening to the complaints. I ordered a steak and cheese sandwich. Lacking steak and it was extremely dry! Too bad there are only 2 places in Prospect that deliver! read more

Annas makes the best New Haven style pizza around!! They've been my favorite pizza restaurant since I've moved to Prospect. I have never been disappointed with anything I ever ordered from them, and I love their customer service! They're all very friendly. My favorite pizza is their bbq chicken and onion! read more

Anna's Prospect Pizza - Anna's makes the best pizza around! - Pizza Near Me - Prospect, Connecticut

I love Anna's and believe it is the only pizza we all should eat from this area. The bacon and onion is on point. Real bacon strips- not bacon bits. Love the crust. Amazing and a must have. read more

We don't live in this side of town after eating at a place(which I will not mention) the appetizer was so bad we had to leave. Had about an hour between our kids soccer game and we wondered upon this place!! Almost missed it. Pizza was amazing! and we made it back to the field on time. 5 stars read more

i've been buying pizza,grinders,salads,and wings from anna's for a while now,to be honest the service,deliveries,pick ups are always on time,& if the order is arriving late cause of their saturated constant customers calling amd arriving to pick up,they make sure they gove you a call with that said im crystal clear. you should give it a try you dont have to drive all the way to new haven for pizza!!!! read more

Got a small pizza and wrap and cost me $30 plus a $5 tip- ridiculous. I'm not cheap especially when it comes to food but it's mediocre at best so that cost is nuts. Not only did they charge a fee to deliver when I'm literally 7 mins away but they also charged 14.99 for a small pizza when it was advertised on a recently mailed menu as12.99. Ended up feeling bad the delivery guy didn't get the delivery fee so I tipped him but definitely never ordering again. read more

Hmm, what to say about Anna's? What I've come to learn about Anna's is that their quality is hit or miss. When my wife and I first started ordering Anna's, every time we got the pizza and wings it was amazing. Over time, it's become more sporadic; some nights the pizza and wings are awesome, sometimes not; sometimes the wings are plump, juicy and tasty, and other times they're small and dry. I really hope Anna's pays attention to their reviews because, as one other reviewer put, I really want to LOVE Anna's, as I did in the beginning. read more

Very disappointed. My husband and I liked this place a lot until tonight. We thought they had the best pizza and wings in the area but no longer. We ordered wings and they were small, all bones, no meat, and previously frozen! Total garbage. My husband called to speak with he owe we and he blew him off saying he was too busy to talk??!! Really you sell your food but are too busy to talk about the quality?? Shame on you!!!! read more

Anna's Prospect Pizza - You call that a wing?? - Pizza Near Me - Prospect, Connecticut

Service was excellent and very friendly. Unfortunately, pizza was some of the worst pizza I have ever had. Half bbq half cheese. The crust was thinner than a 8x11 piece of paper and piled with greasy toppings. I struggled to eat the cheese and only took one bite of bbq. read more