Best comic book shop in Suffolk County by far. Very helpful and knowledgeable staff. Nice place to…read morego nerd out for a few hours. Amazing selection of fairly priced slabs. Parking is horrible; be careful crossing that road; the drivers are all speeding badly.

Best comic shop on long Island in my opinion. Jason is the owner is awesome…read more A legitimate comic store - tons of keys CGC slabs, magic cards, Pokémon cards, toys, funko, statues. Magic the gathering game night on Sunday's. Can't go wrong in here -- I highly recommend

First rate comic book store. They carry just about everything in current books and a good selection…read moreof back issues. Plus graphic novels, action figures and a lot of stuff for kids

Nice selection of books here. Came her a few times a couple years back when I was looking for…read moreissues to fill runs. They were super friendly and helpful in person and on the phone. I ended up not needing 2 books I had them dig for for me and they were super polite about putting them back (some comic shops have made rude comments when asking about stuff and choosing not to buy something last minute). I ended up coming back 2 weeks later and bought out the rest of the books that I originally did not want, as well as got some older books as well. Condition here is good. Its super clean and organized too. Wish we had a shop this big near me. Also, comic hunters, they have bins, FOR DAYS!

Great store and friendly owner and employees. Came here for Magic tournaments which were super fun…read moreand well run.

READ THIS BEFORE SELLING YOUR COLLECTION To HERO COMICS & CARDS!…read more I walk in and the owner shows me this incredible card collection he just bought from someone and starts bragging how he already sold a card for $2000. Mind you, he had no idea how to identify some of these cards. I've been in this hobby for 10+ years and I was more than happy to show him everything I know on about how to identify a card. One of the cards I helped him identify was worth $900-1300 conservatively and in NM condition. When he found out how much this card was worth he told me he didn't even factor this card into the value of the collection when he paid for the collection. He said that he thought this particular card wasn't real or was tacky. If you do not know how to evaluate certain cards don't accept them but instead do the right thing and guide your customers to a place that can evaluate a collection appropriately. This should be common sense for someone who has been in the industry as long as you have been. When the owner realized how much the card was worth he didn't seem too concerned about ripping the person off at all! Instead he said "sometimes not knowing what a collection is worth can truly payoff," then he laughed. I really tried to have a good conversation with this man but deep down my intuition was screaming that this person was lost in Greed. There was one card I wanted to buy and he wasn't even willing to sell the card for fair market value even though I helped him identify these cards. All of a sudden somehow he became the expert and was suggesting that these cards were worth more than they actually were. He kept referencing TCG player prices but he knows nothing about how this market works and pretends he does! He didn't even know how to look up these cards on TCGplayer until I showed him. The prices you find on TCGplayer are oftentimes above market value and you can almost always find them cheaper on eBay! Don't deal in a market you're clearly not informed enough to deal in. Be ethical and guide people in the right direction rather than try and fill your own pockets. It's just really sad businesses like Hero Comics exist. I feel for the customer who didn't get the value for their collection that they truly deserved. If you are looking to sell a collection get a quote from multiple card shops before actually selling your cards. If you find out your cards are worth a pretty penny reach out to an online auction that pays 90% of a cards value! Their are plenty of local card shops that know what they're doing and won't accept cards that they are not experts in. Many of these shops are fully transparent with you about the cards you have and can guide you into the right direction. And to Hero Comics, no one is perfect, do the right thing, actually reach out to the person, and be fully transparent with them on what the cards are worth and what they sell for. Give them at least a 70% commission which is industry standard for most card-shops. Take accountability, learn, and grow. I'm confident you will.

From a design perspective perhaps my favorite Barnes and Noble. Much smaller that the massive mall…read morestores, but I liked it. Good selection and a few places to sit down and browse. No coffee shop if I recall right. Didn't engage with staff so no feedback on that. I just liked how the store made me feel.

The staff at this store were polite and respectful to me. They were welcoming. The store was really…read moreclean and beautiful, very organized. They have a cool selection with books by local authors. You can find some cool gifts here, like butterfly houses.

Awesome place. My kid loved it. The sales people were very nice and patient. Only negative is that…read moreparking was very limited.

Best single selection of TCG in the Westchester area. GC behind the counter is the best.read more

Awesome place Staff is very friendly and knowledgeable a lot of Funko pops comic books and designer…read moretoys definitely a place to check out

From the owner: Funko pops, comics and toys ,etcread more

"Now popular culture Can't stop 'til it gets enough"…read more(John Mellencamp) They've only been open since June and they claim to be "home of the largest collection of pop culture items on the east coast". I can tell you that this store is huge, neatly set up, and boasts an ungodly amount of comics, collectibles, figurines, toys, games, cards, books, posters (check out the very foxy Supergirl) across the pop culture spectrum of movies, television, comic books, super heroes & villains. They even have a small sports card section, so every branch of the Nerd Tree is represented here! They don't have a website, but have a Facebook page on their business card, which I included as a photo.

I have been here 2 times and will be back, again. I bought two full comic book sets, one was a 52…read morebook set for $100, and most of these are in almost pristine condition. I then bought another 18 comic book full set for $15 and with 2 missing books (that was clearly marked as missing) and I found the other 2 online, so now I have the full set, and it only cost me $24 in all - you can't beat these prices. I'm not looking for comic books that are in perfect condition, although, most that I have received are in great condition and inside protective sleeves. I'm 54 years young and enjoying being able to buy full sets of of the classics. Great store, and I can't wait to buy my next full series.

They have a good selection of retro games, with prices on them. They don't try to look up current…read moreprices and charge you that, which some stores do. The store is bright and clean, which got me to stay and shop longer. They were running a buy 3 get 1 free, if it was under $9. I picked a $10 game, and asked if I could just pay the extra dollar, and they said yes. So customer service was great and friendly. I will be visiting again in the future.

Retro Games Plus is a cool shop filled with nostalgia and present day pop culture collectibles and…read moregames. The prices are decent and the staff is always friendly. It's a really neat shop to browse, especially for early gaming systems. It is a throwback shop that definitely makes you go "omg! I totally forgot about this game!" For nostalgia purposes, this is an awesome store!!