A Newton and Young Insurance was recommended to me by the owners of the Roadhouse to insure my food…read moretrailer and truck. They were very helpful and always followed through with phone calls and emails with quotes and information. They always went above and beyond!! Competitive prices but the service is the reason I'll always use them for any future Insurance needs. Good people!!

From the owner: A Newton & Young Insurance is an independently owned and locally operated agency offering property…read moreand casualty insurance products. Our team of professionals have over 75 years of combined experience navigating Florida's crowded and noisy insurance marketplace. With all the internet, radio, television, and print advertisement today, how is a consumer expected to differentiate between companies let alone products? The key is realizing that a professional is best equipped to provide guidance through all the noise and clutter. Our team will shop the marketplace with multiple carriers and look for the best coverages at the most competitive rate. We understand that an insurance policy purchased on line in 7.5 or 15 minutes may not cover all your loses at claim time. Contact one of our specialists to customize a policy suited to your individual needs. We are proud supporters of the Armed Forces and their families. Our team thanks all who have served to protect this great Nation. Our owner, Cindy grew up in a military family and greatly appreciates the efforts of our service men and women. Her father, the late A Arwood Mays, Veteran AMCS, USNavy served 30 years to protect our country. Talk to us about many of our products that provide military and special technical training discounts. Companies include: Travelers, Progressive, National General, Heritage and Foremost. Florida Family, American Strategic, Ark Royal, Capitol Preferred, Heritage, Cypress and Geo Vera.

Luke was extremely professional, thorough and knowledgeable…read more He was patient and calm as he answered all of my questions. Thanks to Luke my experience in switching auto insurance from a different company to State Farm was very smooth.

Hard pass.i waited almost 2 months to receive my homeowners refund which they mailed to my address…read moreof which the property had been sold. Also when I signed up for an auto policy i waited almost 2 months to receive my insurance card that I like to keep in my vehicle. I called repeatedly and explained that I wanted a physical card for my wallet. All I got was the run around. Unlike a good neighbor, State Farm was not there. Poor service to say the least. Next!

I went to a class to learn about things that will affect my life as I age. I was very impressed and…read moreinterested in what they had to teach us. Then they fed us dinner from an Italian restaurant. The food was good. It seems that they truly are interested in helping me make very important decisions in my life. Thank you very much. Pros: learning my options for the future. Two class speakers were very good. Cons: I hate Orange Park. It took me an hour to get there. Traffic is terrible. Recommend? Absolutely

I needed help with my Medicare and Bill Green was there to help me through it. (Thanks Bill!) After…read moremy meeting with him I had a meeting with their Financial Advisor, Justin Nichols. I can't say enough about how I thought I was in a good place financially, but he was able to save me several several thousand in fees, and took the time to make me understand what he was thinking. It was impressive!! He found another 401k that I thought was lost, and put them into an account that has been kicking ass. I wish my wife and I would have talked to him sooner.... We would have retired on a beach somewhere a few years ago. Overall, Bill is the mad scientist of Medicare, and Mr. Justin has quite a talent for investments. I see now why they have over 400 straight 5-star reviews. Highly recommend!!!!

The people running this agency are wonderful to work with. They took time to learn about me and my…read morefamily in order to make sure we were covered. They answered all of our questions. Now we have our car, house and boat all insured with them.

Cole was very helpful and informative. I had an interesting request for insurance and he was able…read moreto get everything sorted out in a timely fashion. Very easy to work with and always available.

From the owner: We specialize in the following Florida Insurance Services: Auto Insurance, Home Insurance, Renters…read moreInsurance, Business Insurance, General Liability, Workers Compensation, Boat Insurance, RV Insurance, Motorcycle Insurance And Much, Much More! At Varsity Insurance our ultimate goal is to create lasting relationships with each of our clients so that we may continue providing excellent service for many years to come.

I had been a customer of this business for over 30 years. That relationship ultimately ended due to…read morea failure to ensure that my insurance premium was paid. The issue arose when the insurance company was changed and proper follow-up was not completed. I contacted the office more than 30 days ago to have the matter corrected. At that time, I was told that they had contacted the mortgage company and provided the required insurance information. However, approximately one month later, I received another letter from the mortgage company stating that there was no insurance coverage on the property. I contacted the office again and requested that, since they indicated they would be emailing the mortgage company, I be copied on the correspondence. When I received the email, it was sent only to me and not to the mortgage company. Additionally, it contained incorrect information: it referenced the wrong insurance policy and the wrong property. The information was being sent to the incorrect insurance company. Specifically, the house that does not have a mortgage was listed with policy information intended for the house that does have a mortgage. At that point, I simply wanted the issue to be properly handled and resolved by their office. However, in their response dated 12/15/2025, they did not state that they would take responsibility for resolving the matter. As a result, I no longer had confidence that the issue would be addressed correctly or at all. Due to these repeated errors, lack of follow-up, and loss of trust, the matter remained unresolved and ultimately led to the termination of a long-standing business relationship.

My family has used him for almost everything for two decades. He truly cares about his customers…read moreand provides wonderful service. Highly recommend!