They catered a graduation party for us. The foodie in our family raved about the shrimp cocktail -always amazing - and the caprese salad. Very consistent. We love this place read more

We had fried dans crab cakes and they were awful. Could not finish eating them. Had the broiled flounder and it was cooked so long it was mush. I am done with this place. we always looked forward to coming here over the years but no more. read more

When I left with my order. There was a lot of laughter directed at me. When I got home and opened the order, it was dried out old food and something worse than warmed over leftovers. Now; I got the joke. I was paying good money for inferior food. When an establishment has that much contempt for their customers, I wonder if the food has been tampered with. Possibly with foreign or bio-hazardous material. I am finished with Avalon Seafood. read more

Crab cake was fried and not grilled like we asked for and the crabmeat was not fresh. The food over the years has been so so. Better save your $$ and cook at home. read more

My family has been ordering lobsters from Avalon Seafood for years. Given that 4th of July was going to be a bit different in the light of pandemic, we decided to order steamers and lobster for a dinner at home. I placed the order by phone two days ahead of time and everything was ready for pick up at the time I needed it. Steamers were SO delicious--not one grain of sand in any of the ones had. Lobsters were perfectly cleaned and cooked. read more

Avalon Seafood - Steamers - Seafood Markets Near Me - Avalon, New Jersey

See all

Always great. Nothing fancy or extravagant. Fresh quality seafood at a reasonable price. Fried scallops were excellent --plump, fresh, and juicy. Clam strip was was full of tender fried clam strips. King Crab and Clams were steamed to perfection. The cream of crab soup was just OK for me. It was entirely too heavy on the Sherry. It was all I could taste. I ordered the king crab leg dinner. I received a few crab legs with steamed clams which I didn't order. I don't know what happened here. No explanation upon pick up, and I didn't know it until I got home. I have had this dinner in the past, and it was all crab legs. Overall my family was very satisfied. read more

See all

I would have given no stars if I could. Ordered dinner for 6:00, they absolutely had no idea about the order. As if that wasn't bad enough the Crab Legs were rotten, and smelly. So very sad, this place has been our go to for over 30 years. Never again. read more

Delicious fresh food on the go! We stopped in here for some takeout on the way out of Avalon and it hit the spot! The portions were large, The service was quick, and the food was fresh and delicious. We also got some fresh seafood to take home. We would definitely stop here again on the next trip. read more

Avalon Seafood - Fried clam strips - Seafood Markets Near Me - Avalon, New Jersey

Take out order of calamari, clam strips and chicken fingers. All were tasty. Calamari was tender and seasoned but marinara was watered down. Chicken fingers were ok but homemade honey mustard was delish. Clam strips were good too. Very friendly staff. Food was good just not OMG I cant wait to go there again. Loved the fresh fish available to cook at home maybe we will try that next time. read more

See all

half our dinners were cold and dry. sat too long. never go back. Expensive halibut dinner was terrible. We waited 40 minutes after stated pickup time. Staff were terribly RUDE read more

Quality seafood and well run family business. Coming here for 20 years and always good, never a problem with ordering or waiting too long - its a well run operation. Our go-to's are Dan's Lump Crabmeat broiled with fries and the broiled scallops with a baked potato. Best seafood On Seven Mile Island! You are at the beach - eat fresh! read more

We ordered the lobster dinner and the broiled seafood combo platter. The clams were the tiniest clams I have ever seen, honestly! The dinners were just bland, nothing special. Disappointed and still hungry. read more

Owner extremely rude and disgruntled. There is no reason to be rude to a customer bc they are there purchasing seafood instead of pre made dinner (which aren't that good anyways.) Made feel like I was a bother as opposed to a valued customer. He also speaks to his employees with distain. Limited options on the island but skip this one if possible. read more

This was a good option for takeout on a night when the kids wanted to hang at our rental house and eat on the dock. Prices, while high for takeout, were certainly lower than a lot of the substandard seafood restaurants in the area. NE Clam Chowder was good, as was the Lobster Mac n' Cheese. Crab Imperial, as an option to crab cakes, was a casserole type dish with good texture, but not a lot of taste. Shrimp Scampi had delicious shrimp but bland pasta. The Dan's Lump Crab Cake (which we had broiled instead of the fried option) was "the best I've ever had" according to my husband. Warning though: Portions are not large. Service was super friendly and helpful. A good option for when you're tired of mediocre and expensive Shore dining. read more

Wrong potato, extremely bland flounder, and definitely not "generous" portions as advertised. And when I showed up on the exact time they told me, the cashier asked the expeditor if my order was ready, and he snapped back a grouchy "No!" He also later asked the crowd why everyone was here at 7:25. Maybe that's because they were told that on the phone? They seemed to be more annoyed that they were crowded as opposed to grateful. I did call back and told them about the wrong potato and they said I could come back but wasn't a drive I wanted to do again. I should have checked my order before I left the store because a woman in front of me came back with a platter and must've had an issue also. Better options available elsewhere. read more

Really nice seafood. Fresh. And tasty. We hit this place very year we go. People are very nice and friendly. I left my wallet there and they called me once they figured out it was me. Didn't make a big deal of it. Could have been a nightmare. read more

SO RUDE AND SO LATE. It took forever to get our order that we phoned in. We kept asking the status and they wouldn't give us a status. Never an apology. They could have at least been nice about it. It wasn't even a big order. A smile or kind word would go a long way. Update: one person apologized and gave a discount but it was a very frustrating experience. read more

We were driving to Avalon for a day trip and were decided to try this place. The food was amazing...lobster rolls and fish tacos were tasty and a nice portion size. Also great customer service...cost was very reasonable!! read more

Avalon Seafood - Lobster roll - Seafood Markets Near Me - Avalon, New Jersey

See all

First time, last time. Wasn't worth the expense and the owners make me scratch my head with puzzlement. I walked in, THE ONLY ONE IN THE SHOP, and said I here for my pickup. Standing in front of the counter - looking at the woman at the cash register and saying again, here for my pickup. At this time another person walked in and said he was here for his takeout. They proceeded to get his order and the woman behind the counter asked me to move aside. WTF??!! I'm a professional salesperson- I know how to get a long with people. But that treatment was over the top. So much so, the customer service was terrible. Now, the food? Pass. I was looking forward to some old school seashore seafood and we'll, let's say, I wasn't impressed. The crab soup was like pudding. Really, that thick. I'll give them a ten for the crab fingers. Very small portion- but still delicious. The whole sinner is not something I've experienced in the past. Bottom line, like I wrote in the first sentence- first time, last time. Pardon the pun; but there are plenty of seafood places in Avalon & Stone Harbor that will gladly take my next $130.00/takeout order. (That's what we paid) Two stars is all I can give this operation. read more

Friendly staff offering a variety of fresh fish and also marinades! Stopped by on the bikes for some extra items we needed for dinner. Conveniently located in town and connected to a produce stand/ market good for all other needs. read more

We went back later in the week and this time, picked up 24 lobsters, crab claws/shrimp platter and also tried the calamari and fried clams. SO good! Portions were generous and they give you all the accoutrements (i.e., butter, tartar/cocktail/mustard sauces, lemons, etc.). Completely worth it. read more

Have been to Avalon seafood twice now. The food has been nothing but great, but I'm always hungry when "finished". This means one of two things; either the portions are small or I am a fat man in a thin man's body. The scallops are great and the shrimp are even better. A little on the pricey side but I guess that is to be expected in Avalon over the summer. Well worth stopping in if you do not have a big appetite. read more

We ordered 2 lbs. of steamed shrimp, at the exorbitant Jersey Shore price. Drove from Stone Harbor, past two other takeout seafood places to get here, because last year their shrimp were delicious and perfect. We got the shrimp home, and they were overcooked and rubbery. The large ones were (almost) ok, the smaller ones were terrible. And honestly, we might have been ok if they had handled it better, because we own a business and everyone makes mistakes sometimes. But we called to complain, and the immediate response was indignant. "Best shrimp you can get for the money. Of course they're not overcooked." They WERE overcooked. After pushing back a bit, the grudging response was that we could bring them back. Then they hung up, abruptly. After driving 30 minutes round trip to get these in the first place, the last thing we feel like doing is driving another 30 minutes round trip to get yelled at when we go back, so this gets chalked up to $40 worth of lessons-learned. But this is the last time we buy anything from Avalon Seafood. read more

If you decide you want seafood in the stone harbor/Avalon area.. take the trip to Cape May. I've been coming to Stone Harbor for 25 years. Safe yourself the aggravation and money. We ordered Shrimp/Scallop combo(24$) 15 little neck clams(12$), and a broiled seafood combo(30$). First off, the Shrimp/scallop combo came with only Shrimp. Second, they forgot our baked potato. Obviously we called to let them know, and ended the conversation with them offering a free meal tomorrow (ok).. now here's the kicker. I open the clams, and find multiple little pieces of what looked like either paper or chewed gum, stuck to the clams and floating around in the clam water. Completely disgusted I decided to make the trip back tonight so they can see for themselves, what they served to paying customers. Upon entering, every single staff member had an attitude. After showing them the clams, they found it funny and were chuckling in the back. They even had the audacity to ask me if I wanted a new batch, which I replied absolutely not I would like a refund. Not only was the food completely disorganized, cold and disgusting.. but they didn't even try to offer a reason/explanation as to why. They just found it funny. Well, Avalon Seafood, I find it funny that we were refunded MORE than what we even paid for the entire meal. So congratulations. Seriously people, don't bother. read more

Avalon Seafood - Seafood Markets Near Me - Avalon, New Jersey

Okay, so I worked in a fish market/restaurant for several years and the experience has taught me a lot in terms of what to buy and more importantly WHAT NOT to buy when it comes to fish. (Never buy from grocery store on a Sunday!!! Just trust me). So, with that said, I am very picky about where my seafood comes from. Avalon Seafood has a great selection of fresh food from the sea and I do not think twice about it's 'authenticity.' They are also very helpful with recipes and cooking technique...not that I need them. read more

Was worried about the food and it turned out okay. Seafood Fra Diablo was decent, a hearty red sauce with shrimp, scallops and crab over a huge bed of linguini. Also had the steamed shrimp - half a pound of shrimp and several tablespoons of Old Bay - was tasty. Others had the fried seafood combo which was well, fried. Flounder was not really a hit with the table. Everything was best hot - as the items cooled the seafood showed signs of being either previously frozen, overcooked, or both. read more

Food was good, but the servings were a little on the small side. Nothing fancy, but an easy place to order and the to-go plates are plated well. read more

Solid takeout seafood. We ordered several lobsters, crab cakes, and piles of steamers. All the food was hot at pickup and tasted great. Prices are reasonable, and they will crack your lobsters for you at no additional cost. Only glitch was they forgot to add one of the lobsters we ordered; after calling they sent a guy out to deliver it. So, they made it right. If you are looking to eat in and would like someone else to go through the trouble of cooking your lobsters, then this is a solid bet. read more

I'm so surprised to see all of the negative reviews here. We recently stopped here for takeout, which we ended up eating at the table next to the produce stand, and we were so impressed with the food. The staff was friendly and professional and answered our questions. We ordered the lobster dinners, and the lobster was cooked to perfection. It was so delicious, the best we've had in years, probably since our vacation in Maine. The corn that came with it was creamy and flavorful, and the clams were great too. I really don't have a single complaint. I can't wait to go back again soon. Wish they were open year round. read more

Who sells a customer over $76 seafood and then charges customer 25 cents for a single take out serving or cocktail sauce. What happened to common sense? read more

We have been coming to AVALON to decades, and our first night of vacation dinner is ALWAYS the BROILED SEAFOOD COMBO from AVALON SEAFOOD!! It is a FEAST OF TENDER LOBSTER, SHRIMPS, SCALLOPS AND FLOUNDER, with melted butter and cocktail sauce and your choice of Baked Potato, Sweet Potato, or French Fries. I have had Broiled seafood Combos in Ocean City, Sea Isle, Wildwood and Cape May, and THEY DON"T EVEN COMPARE. If you want to EAT LIKE ROYALTY, grab a fresh melt in your mouth seafood platter from Avalon Seafood! ...and the price is right, too!! :) read more

Went here last night and ordered two platters, flounder, scallops, and shrimp with baked potato and corn on the cob. Also order a cup of New England clam chowder. Well, the scallops were undercooked as was the baked potato and the shrimp was overcooked. The chowder was super thin and didn't taste like it had any cream in it. The only reason I'm giving it two stars is because my partner liked her flounder. The corn is in the frig so I can't tell you what that's like. For $60 which was reasonable I would have went back if the food was good. But you can count on me, NOT GOING BACK! read more

Avalon Seafood - Seafood Markets Near Me - Avalon, New Jersey

They get one star bc I was hungry and it was food. The crab cakes are a small and nasty. The staff is inexperienced to put it kindly and the food is underwhelming with no flavor. Gordon Ramsay would have a field day with this place. This place makes me wanna BYOCC. Bring Your Own Crab Cakes. read more

I've ordered takeout many times from here before. In the past it has been good. This time, however, I was very I was very disappointed. We ordered 100 steamers and they were cold, they needed to be microwaved to be edible. In fact, the only thing I ordered that wasn't cold was my lobster roll, which I would expect to be cold! Steamers were sandy and cold. Lobster roll wasn't great. I recommend trying somewhere else, unless you like expensive below average food, overall rating: poor to below average. read more

For us, this is the go to place in the area for quality seafood - either for cooking yourself or their platters. The employees have never steered us wrong with suggestions (type or quantity) and Dan, the prior owner who I understand has sold the place, was always up front making sure things were spot on. The new owners seem to have continued to keep up the quality. The quality is as good as you can get retail, I think. We have a summer tradition of lobster "fest". All the family gets together one week-end out of the summer and the house; we do take out lobster platters from here, crab claws, clams, etc., and stuff and drink ourselves in Epicurean delight. Avalon seafood is at the center of that bonding. I'm not sure it would continue to be an annual event if the quality of their "supply" was not as good as what it is. read more

Prices might be a little on the high side, but I thought everything tasted very fresh. You would definitely pay more at a seafood restaurant for the same quality. A couple of us ordered the lobster dinner and everyone was very happy. Nice staff and service too. I would definitely go there again. read more

0 stars actually..taken out probably 3 dozen LARGE orders over the years and every single one was overpriced and under quality..cold food, missing items, small portions, etc. And the sense that the staff feels like they are doing you a huge favor is really irritating. Do yourself a favor and GO ELSEWHERE. read more

It's just OK. I got a Caesar salad with crab meat. It basically was romain lettuce with soft croutons and a packet of Ken's Caesar dressing on the side. The crab meat on top was good but not worth the $18 price tag. read more

I love their fried seafood combo! They have a great staff and I must say it's the freshest seafood on the island .

Love this place. Take out only and every order is prepared perfectly. Freshest second in town most reasonable prices. They do second take out right! read more