*Website: https://www.baileyavenuepizza.com/ Taking a cue from SexySlices, and since I live relatively close by, I decided to try out Bailey Avenue Pizza for dinner on a beautiful Saturday evening. All-in-all, they serve up a phenomenal Buffalo-style pizza! Around 5pm on a Saturday, I called and placed my pick-up order. The gentleman on the phone took my order and ran through it with me to ensure he had everything down. He came across fine, not overly friendly but definitely not standoff-ish or awkward. I was told it'd be ready in 30-40 minutes. I arrived around 35 minutes later and parked on the street next to their shop. I'll admit, the neighborhood comes across as being a bit rough, but I suppose that adds to the charm of the pizzeria itself. As soon as you walk in, it gives off Bocce Club on Bailey Ave. (Amherst) vibes, but smaller. The gentleman asked me for my name and brought my pizza out, double-checked it to ensure it was made correctly, then cashed me out - a five minute experience, not bad at all. The gentleman behind the counter was friendly and easy-going, so that was nice. So for dinner, I ordered a Half (9", eight slice) cheese and pepperoni pizza with bacon, sweet (red this time!) peppers, and onions, or as I refer to it as "The Clark Classic". This pizza is a textbook example of a Buffalo-style pizza! The mozzarella cheese on top as laid on thick and was creamy with a little hint of salt. Their red sauce was sweet-style, but not overly sweet, at least I didn't think so. In my opinion, it was the ideal balance between sweet and savory and paired amazingly well with the mozzarella cheese. The pepperoni was nicely cupped and charred on the edges and there were plenty of sweet red peppers and onions sliced on top. The sweet red pepper was a nice change-up from the regular green bell pepper. The bacon they used was excellent - Big, hearty, crispy pieces, definitely not finely diced or store-bought bacon bits. The dough and crust were totally Buffalo-style as the dough was fluffy and had great flavor and chew and the crust had a satisfying crunch to it without being charred beyond recognition. The size of this pizza is comparable to Bocce Club's or Imperial's "Half" size pizzas, so I definitely didn't walk away hungry. As for the price of this pizza, it was on the pricey side, so definitely not a pizza I'd be getting every weekend. Overall, Bailey Avenue Pizza serves up a fantastic traditional, Buffalo-style pizza, one that is quite literally textbook in look, quality, and taste! Their pizza menu is pretty limited, I noticed only two specialty pizzas, none being a chicken finger pizza, but that's alright. When I need just a good, filling Buffalo-style pizza, I'd definitely consider Bailey Avenue Pizza! read more

See all

I order a 1/2 pep and cheese im 13 BTW on the app it said 19.99 ok I order it then I try to ask for the price then he hangs up when the food gets here IT'S 30$ My mom calles the spot then he said "oh the delivery fee is 12" when my mom tells me I'm like WTF (I didn't actually say that) and the pizza is small NEVER ORDER FROM THEM 1 STAR read more

Bailey Avenue Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

Decided to give this place a shot based on some hype I've seen in some pizza groups and I kind of had some high hopes but ended up being extremely let down. We ordered a half cheese and pep. Granted it is a bills Sunday, places are busy but we ordered wayy after the bills game, about 815pm or so. When we got the pizza and opened the box, it looked very sloppy and the crust or what was supposed to be crust is pushed and smushed to the edge of the box. Upon picking up a slice, it was extremely doughy and what I would say is completely under cooked. A lot of cheese for virtually no sauce. Honestly just a sloppy, doughy undercooked messed. I will not be ordering again. read more

This pizza was the best pizza in all of buffalo. I started out getting one or two slices and then I graduated to a half a sheet of sausage and pepperoni and when I tell y'all this was some of the best pizza I'm back down south but as I traveled all over the United States for work, I realize there are certain things in certain cities I would travel back just for for instance Fayetteville, North Carolina, Asian express Thai special fried rice Buffalo, New York Bailey's sausage and pepperoni pizza why because it was big it was gooey cheesy, but it had some type of heat and I love that about the pizza I could never understand. Was it the pepperoni was it the sauce or the sausage that gave the pizza the heat that I liked and it's been bothering me ever since cause I'm just like man what is it? Bailey's pizza if y'all reply to my comment, can you tell me what is it that gives your pizza that spice or heat? That's well balanced. read more

Bailey Pizza when you need an extra large hot and cheesy slice on the go. I've never had an issue with my slice being too small here. They've been pretty consistent from the start and always a go to for a "hot n ready" pizza slice that's bigger than your head lol read more

The order was made with a guy and I called back to add an extra ten wings. The wings were made as I instructed. All extra extra crispy, ten hot and ten honey mustard. The pizza I asked for a half a box with mushrooms and cheese. They kept saying cheese pizza with mushrooms on top I said yes mushrooms. Once the twice the guy repeated my order back with pepperonis. I assured him I don't eat pork please don't not give me pepperonis. He made my order but was kind of dismissive. I called back a few minutes later and was connected with a lady I apologize as I cannot remember her name although I asked her, she was extremely sweet. Here and I went through my order twice and confirmed it. I received a text when the order was ready and 5 minutes later the same nice sweet voice of the lady called to let me know the order was ready. The pizza had zero mushrooms. I didn't purchase the food I just made the order. The person who purchased didn't want to do anything about it although I did. I really wanted those mushrooms. There was not much sauce but a lot of cheese and the crust was a good crust. Personally I like and equal balance of all three ingredients. Because half the order was made correctly I'll give it two stars and I would eat the wings from here again. I would give the lady 5 stars and whoever made the pizza 3 stars. Where are my mushrooms ? And please put more sauce on the pizza. To the guy who initially took my order sir...really? Not everyone has the same order. Please do not be dismissive when taking orders to ensure customer satisfaction and customer retention. In addition you know who has had a craving and may be spending their last eating at this restaurant. It makes sense to do your best to make all your customers happy abs satisfied especially when spending their money. read more

The toppings on this pizza are consistently fresh and abundant. The sauce is exceptional. It is one of my preferred pizza establishments in Buffalo, New York. read more

Bailey Avenue Pizza - Bailey Pizzeria Special (Whole) with some modifications, no meat just vegetables. - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

THIS is GREAT Buffalo style pizza! I am so glad I finally got to try this! Really easy ordering online and ready ASAP Rocky! We ordered a half cheese and Pepp well done (~$17ish) and wow yeah I bodied my respective slices with as much passion as I could muster. The half has about 8 very LARGE and dense slices. And the cup and char Pepp is done perfectly in good ol buffalo fashion. Dough is thick with good chew and flavour, light on the sauce (how I like it, in contrast to a more saucy buff style like imperial). Heavy on the cheese... the calcium gains we all need and great seasoning. I enjoyed every last finger licking moment here and will certainly be ordering again!! Thank you Bailey Ave pizza Crew! read more

Bailey Avenue Pizza - Half pepp - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

This pizza is the best thing that I ever had the wings are AMAZING LOVE the French fries great customer service and great pizza and a subs

i've been going to Bailey's pizza for over 20 years and I had nothing but the best pizza and buffalo the people very very friendly soft-spoken. I went there today and I ordered a half a box of pizza, extra sauce, double cheese, single pepperoni and I don't know why I did not open up my box of pizza like I generally do but I didn't, I go home open up my pizza they put single cheese on my pizza. I paid for double cheese and hard ass, chicken wings, fried chicken the guy David was so nasty and rude. I advise everyone that used to go to Bailey's pizza on Andover and Buffalo New York they are a rip off. They have new owners, poor business people food is horrible. read more

Bailey Avenue Pizza - Baileys pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

It doesn't get any better ! I always order large pizza with cheese pepperoni and mushrooms! Awesome! Thank you Bailey Avenue Pizza!

Bailey Ave. The so called GOAT SAUCE: 8/10 CRUST: 7.5/10 CHEESE: 10/10 PEPS: 10/10 ONION: 10/10 OVERALL: 9.0 Very good pie. Can see why so many love it. Had it before and don't recall enjoying it as much as I'm enjoying this one. Crust was a bit too dense for me, which was surprising because it was thinner than I thought it would be. Take out only. read more

Bailey Avenue Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

This is my second time getting pizza and wings here and it was amazing!! Wings are crispy and full of flavor. Pizza toppings are very generous as well. Affordable cost for 50 wings and pizza combo too. Highly recommend you try them out. Use the app names Slice and you can get 10% off your order as well read more

Bailey Avenue Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

Reputation may be a little concerning...lol...but overall the pizza is delicious and a nice size for the price of the slices

Baileys is absolutely Great Pizza in Buffalo. Every time we order, everyone in the family is real happy. Pepperoni and Onion is my Jam. The people that complain about the time it takes for orders or delivery are simply don't understand you have to wait for great food. read more

Bailey Avenue Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

I ordered two orders of one half pizza and Chicken Wings. I specifically told the lady on the phone not to fry the chicken wings hard. I told her I'm a senior citizen and I can't eat those hard chicken wings. My son went in there to pick up the orders and brought it to the car while I waited outside. I've been wanting me some good Chicken Wings for a while. I've gotten wings from there before and they were good. I tried eating the wings in the car and they were so hard that I couldn't even get the meat off the bone. We were over halfway home and I didn't feel like going back. But I called them when I got home and told them that all the wings were too hard. The lady on the phone promised the owner will call me back. They never did. Don't ever buy any chicken wings from Bailey Ave., Pizza again. I'll only buy the pizza never again will I pay $70 for something? I can't eat. Stay away from their Chicken Wings. They are hard and horrible. furthermore, they had one wing drumstick and nine flats in the box. They didn't even have the decency to give you equal amount of flats and drumstick. The wings weren't even that hot after we waited outside for approximately an hour for them to cook the wings. remember, I told you so don't buy the wings from them because they don't care and they're not very friendly people. they never call and offered to make things right. I'm very disappointed in Bailey Avenue pizzeria on the corner of Bailey and Andover in Buffalo, New York. I hope and pray they read this review and learnfrom it because we the customers determines whether they stay in business or not. Can someone suggest another place where they have good pizza and wings? At least a place that give you what you want and follow your request flawlessly. I had to throw those wings away because I couldn't eat them after spending $70. But the pizza was good to their credit. read more

Best pizza in wny hands down. They know how to cook a pizza. Great crust, cheese, sauce, pepperoni. Awful neighborhood but these guys can make a pizza like none other!! Great bbq wings too. Had a couple crackheads walk up to me during my visit. Part of the atmosphere i guess lol. read more

Bailey Avenue Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

Definitely a nice slice of cheese pie. I will be back in the future for sure if I'm in the area .

I ordered half a cheese and meatball pizza, with wings in a combo deal. The pizza tasted like a somewhat soggy meatball sub with the combination of the doughy crust, sweet red sauce, and meatballs. I liked the combination but the slices were very flimsy because it was so soft and 50% cheese. The wings were forgotten and delivered an hour later and were plain and very crunchy like fried chicken without the grease. I don't know what I was expecting but this was not it. So minus one star for attention to detail and another star for it being doughier than I would like. I would like to be able to pick up a piece and hold it instead of all the cheese sliding off in a heap when picking it up read more

Pizza Way Over Hyped it's Giving little Cesar's idk if it's the cheese or the sauce but it's No for me big ass slice of card board

I get slices every blue moon and every time I do the pizza is GREAT! Just enough sauce, cheese and pep. The slices are $4 each. read more

Bailey Avenue Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

Best Pizza Slices in the town!!! $5.50 per slice but it's worth it!! I have noticed the slice has changed slightly in recent years; the dough used to have more yeast which made the pizza more fluffy which I prefer when eating pizza in Buffalo but the flavors are still the same great quality. I can't think of a better pizza in Buffalo than Avenues read more

My sister called it the BEST Pizza in Buffalo. I was like.... "REALLY? What about Leonardi's, Bocce's, LaNova's, Diva's, Bozanna's, Imperial???" Needless to say, I was very skeptical so I went by for a few slices... MAN! The flavor was reminiscent of the ORIGINAL BOCCE's on Clinton: nice flavorful sauce, good sauce-cheese ratio, and tons of round pepperoni. I called my sister the other day and conceded! She was right! Needless to say, I have purchased several whole pizzas since that day!! EXCELLENT! read more

I never ordered from here before but I've driven by it 100 times. Finally decided to order from there and OMG was that an awesome decision!! Got half a pizza with pepperoni and mushrooms and 10 wings with med sauce. The pizza was perfect it wasn't real thick but not to thin either and it has a nice crunch to the bottom of it which was a nice surprise. When ordering from another well known pizza place on the same street, the dough is always super mushy and not cooked well enough. There was a good amount of cheese and a ton of pepperoni. Could've had a little more mushrooms since I paid more for those but anyway...And the wings were also perfect with a really good, tasted like, homemade blue cheese. Overall this place, even though a little pricey, was really good and will definitely be ordering from here again! read more

Bailey Avenue Pizza - Awesome pizza!! - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

Baileys pizza was great I try to get it when I want pizzA other then New York style pizza great toppings anD load with cheese my favorite is sausage and pepperoni read more

So my Brother gave me 2 slices for me to try it was banging! Like every one say it beats everyone around hands down. There secret don't be stingy on anything which shows up in the price$$$.He gave me pepperoni cheese and mushrooms the combo is well balanced with the dough I loved it was light and airy. Heavy dough is horrible makes you bloated and full it's a good ratio. Keep up the good Work I just refuse to pay $4 a slice. read more

Yesterday I called to place an order for 50 wings, half plain/BBQ. I should have hung up when they asked for a 'deposit! Ghetto fabulous....Never again. The wings definitely were made hours before and refried when my order was placed. The wings were dry as sand and brick hard. Don't order from this place. Entry looks like it hasn't been cleaned since Leonardi's left and the door is left open to allow thousands of bugs to fly about. Change the name from Bailey to Bum! Truly zero star worthy. read more

This pizza is delicious, they're not stingy on the toppings at all. All the food from here I tasted was fresh, and tasty!! read more

Bailey Avenue Pizza - Sooooo Good!!!! - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

Do you like Imperial Pizza or Bocce Club? Try this place, it's a hole in the wall with some of the best pizza in Buffalo. Arguably better than imperial and bocce... read more

Best Pizza in Buffalo. Similar to Bocce Club. Try the super steak hoagie as well! The original owner worked for manybshops before Avenue. He had great recipes and I believe his family took it over upon his death. read more

We ordered a half pizza from here at 630 pm and did not receive it until 930 pm. First of all, the HALF pizza was $18 because they charge so much to add toppings and it's incredibly small for that price. Also, after waiting over 2 hours, we called and they told us that our pizza was already out for delivery and would arrive any minute. 30 minutes later, we called again and they told us our pizza just finished and was leaving for delivery shortly. So basically every time we called we got a different story and nobody knew or cared what was going on with our order. Nobody ever offered an apology for the wait or offered a discount which I feel a 3 hour wait would permit. The pizza finally arrived, 3 hours later, and the delivery driver didn't even want to come inside the building to give it to me. He wanted me to come outside and walk to his car to get it. This is probably the worst customer service I've ever experienced and I will definitely NEVER order from here again. read more

Iam so disgusted by their Customer Service!!...I have 2 little kids and currently pregnant and I called and placed and order at 6 pm. I was told my order would take 1.5 hrs I did not get my food until past 10pm!!!!....I called several times and the female that answered the phone was rude as hell!!!...and the manager and the delivery driver do not have effective communication!!...needless to say I WILL NEVER ORDER FROM THIS DUMB ASS PLACE EVER AGAIN!!! read more

If I could give this place no stars, I would. I am not one to complain but this place offered THE WORST customer service I've ever experienced. I placed my online order for a half of a pizza at 630 pm and did not receive it until 930 pm. The fact that half of a pizza took 3 hours to make is absolutely absurd. Not to mention it was $18 with ONE TOPPING. After 2 hours of waiting, I called to check on the status. I was told my order was out for delivery and would arrive soon. 30 minutes later, I called again and was told my order had just finished cooking and would be on its way shortly. When the delivery guy showed up, he didn't even want to walk into the building to bring the pizza to me. Not to mention, when I took the first bite, it tasted like it had been sitting out for 3 hours... WHICH IT WAS. The miscommunication between the staff is ridiculous. I was not given an apology either time I called to follow up, and I was not even offered a refund for waiting. I will never order from here again. read more

Unfortunately bocce club seems to rely on their past legacy, We have already quit order pizza because of past quality issues. The pizzas were burnt so bad they were barely edible, and some visitors wouldn't even touch them. Our most current order for delivery took over two hours, the hot foods were colder than the cold subs. Additionally one cold sub was missing the topping. Showed up with meat cheese only. It is a shame that a company with a long well established legacy demonstrates no quality control not does it seem to be concerned about customer service any longer...Times change and in this case not for the better. read more

The reason for the low rating was customer service rather than the food. Before the fire the consenses was about the same. Good thing to grab on a quick whim but not a bocce or carbones. Now it's on a whole other level. So kudos. But I called at 8:16(checked my phone) young woman was very professional but almost 2 hours later a guy answers phone roughely(I can imagine because of the last hour rush to be done I get it) and states they are no longer doing delivery and I let him know I put an order in almost 2hrs ago(1hr and 40minutes at this point). He states there was no order placed and I must've called the wrong number. Now I'm frustrated everyone makes mistakes but my 3 year old was waiting patiently for a while and went to sleep on some good home cooked food but no pizza as promised. Working in food service and customer service from an employee to management experience it's frustrating when you give 100% then poor service with absolutely no empathy for the mistake made. Things happen but there's no excuse for poor customer service with no apology. An apology alone would have prevented this review. I'm an optimist but this is the last time I ever order from them for a while. I won't be missed I hope they continue to make great food but the customer service must be better. read more