Excellent customer service, great food and great prices! My husband and I ate there today for the…read morefirst time and we'll definitely be visiting again! He got the chicken wings plate, and I got the beef tips with potatoes. He said the wings were slamming, and the beef tips were so tender! I highly recommend this place!

Food was awesome ! Just passing through but it was a great stop . Will visit again. I had the…read morechicken salad and it was very good

Even with the positive reviews here on Yelp, I was surprised (in a good way) at our experience…read morehere. Walking past historical markers for Confederate "heroes" and knowing the history of the city conveyed a sense that Tarboro's best days are behind it. If all of Tarboro can be as good as On the Square, it's got a lot to look forward to. My wife and I received a friendly welcome as we came through the door for our early-ish evening reservation (and got the Blue Hair Special seat next to the post in the middle of the back dining room - oh, well). Service from the start and through the meal was attentive but not bothersome. I began with the Classic Daiquiri, which was wonderfully tart rather than cloyingly sweet. Sandy had a Bees Knees as a mocktail and was charged an appropriately low price for what is basically club soda with some juice and honey syrup (for price gouging on this, I'm looking at you MACHETE). Brussels sprouts, Atlantic cod, and petit filet were all well-prepared and delicious -- and modestly priced for the quality. If I am ever in the area again, I will certainly and happily go back.

We were driving thru Tarboro and stopped at this little deli. Food was on point! I got the brisket…read moreegg and cheese sandwich. They serve breakfast all day here. Also at night, they have a lounge area. I will visit that on my next go around. Of course the staff matched the food.

Yummy sandwiches!…read more Had the turkey gobbler which was yummy and loved the broccoli salad! Service was friendly and loved the coffe house upstairs. I liked the fact they have long hours on Saturdays so it's a nice alternative to what's already in the area. Will return!

Carlie C's has a great selection of fresh produce, meat/seafood, and home products. Staff is always…read morefriendly as well!