Just know what to expect and you won't be disappointed- the customer service is for sure lacking - but the food is on point - this is a small take out spot with a ton of soul food options - the food is usually always good - especially the Mac and Cheese read more

Brooklyn Fish - Chicken & Soul Food - Soul Food Near Me - Amityville, New York

See all

Brooklyn Fish has been around many years. Staff has changed & throughout the years the menu has evolved into more of a soul food restaurant instead of the fried fish spot it used to be. And this has been a good thing. Old reviews are not reflecting the delicious high quality food they have been serving as per late. I even had to order dinners for 2022 Thanksgiving because my son was sick at that time. It turned out to be the perfect take out option. Everything was fresh & DELICIOUS! It's not a pretty storefront. Know that upfront. But don't judge a book by its cover. The fish, seafood and soul food have been outstanding. Standouts are the Turkey Wings & Greens. 5-7-2023 read more

See all

Had the food and it was delicious and real soul food. Definitely worth trying the food if you are craving some soul food.

Starting off with the chicken i thought it had good flavor as far as the sauce goes. I got a nice piece of chicken that had hella meat on it.... But it was a little bit dry. The mac and cheese was alright but i feel like it lacked a bit of flavor. The yams was the best part i think nice and soft with really good flavor. The collard greens were solid pretty good. Overall i think this place was pretty decent good for the moneys worth with a variety which is important. read more

Brooklyn Fish - Chicken & Soul Food - BBQ Chicken Dinner - Soul Food Near Me - Amityville, New York

The food was definitely great! I Caught them before the dinner rush I guess , I wasn't surprised at how fresh the food was, the ladies behind the counter where working hard ! But great food, good place to stop by and grab dinner for the fam while on the way home from work. read more

Brooklyn Fish - Chicken & Soul Food - Turkey Dinner ‍ - Soul Food Near Me - Amityville, New York

The customer service is moderate. But the food is worth it. The collard greens always hit. The mac and cheese recipe is to die for. The chicken is smoked well and juicy. As well as the fried chicken, which is crispy. The sweet potatoes are delicious and the ribs are flavorful. read more

Tried to order a big batch of fried chicken wings but they told us they ran out so they gave us equal parts bbq chicken, fried chicken, and baked chicken. I don't know how this place is in business!! It was DISGUSTING. Dry, greasy, bland... such a waste of money. We also ordered yams and those weren't great either. 0/10 read more

Brooklyn Fish - Chicken & Soul Food - baked chicken - Soul Food Near Me - Amityville, New York

See all

We ordered the rib dinner and BBQ chicken dinner. For sides we shared the mac and cheese, collard greens, rice and beans, and green beans. I have honestly never had a WORSE meal in my life. The BBQ ribs were so tough it was like eating jerky covered in a super sweet BBQ sauce. I couldn't tell what was meat and what was bone due to how hard they were. The chicken again had a sauce that was way too sweet and you could tell all of this food had been sitting all day long in heat. The mac and cheese tasted more just like butter noodles and were incredibly bland. The rice and beans were extremely dried out and the rice was hard and tasted stale. The green beans oddly enough tasted like fish and were very mushy and overcooked. The only thing that was edible was the collard greens... edible... not good. I will never order from here again, it was a complete waste of money. read more

Brooklyn Fish - Chicken & Soul Food - Threw it all out - Soul Food Near Me - Amityville, New York

See all

I can't really give a review but I would not try and order again. Way back 15 years ago my office friends would get lunch from here so we decided to order via grub hub. We get a call saying they don't have a certain side and we say, no problem just replace with another. 15 minutes later she calls and says they can't make crab legs and what complete entree would we like to replace it. We said none, just remove it. She says she can't and we say we can't until it's delivered and then we can get it taken off since it won't be there. 15 minutes later she calls and says she isn't sending any food because she will get a bad review on grub hub if we don't pick another item. So we ended up cancelling the order which probably wasn't going to be so great anyway based on her terrible attitude and customer service. I hate even writing this but it was a mistake to even try ordering from them. I hope it was an off night for them and that's all read more

Great food good fried fish sides are always fresh and delicious this place always hits the spot God bless

I would highly recommend this restaurant. The food is great I just came back from Miami and my husband and I tried Trick Daddy's soul Food restaurant. The food was good but nothing like Brooklyn Fish & Chicken. Give them a try! read more

Recommend this place, it's pretty good. I got the shrimp and chips. But they have some of everything. Soul food, seafood or a regular hamburger/cheeseburger. Service is pretty fast. read more

Went on a Sunday night to buy some side dishes for my family. This is my 4th time coming in. Today is the day the hurricane was supposed to hit Hard. Lucky for us it was not too bad. I came in And the woman running things did not even acknowledge me. She had no mask or gloves on and she was eating as she looked At me and walked to the refrigerator to get her soda. After 30 more seconds she finally said give me a minute I will be right with you. She proceeded forward and asked what I would like. I asked for my side orders and she looked confused and asked me no meat? I said no thanks and she made my sides. Very expensive but I already knew that. She proceed to get An attitude with me as she wrong me up because she was very bad at math. The order came up to 24 bucks so o gave her 2 twenties. Then I realized I had a $5 bill so I told her let me give the 5 instead so you can keep your change for another customer. That took another 3 mins to explain why that benefited the establishment since she mentioned she did not have much change. To boot the sides must of been old because I had to throw them out. Disgusting is an understatement. read more

Brooklyn Fish - Chicken & Soul Food - three bowls of food - Soul Food Near Me - Amityville, New York

See all

2 room establishment, 1 for ordering and the other has a few tables and the hot food buffet set up. The older woman taking the order can be somewhat intimidating but luckily I was very polite and she reciprocated. I ordered a seafood platter with no fries and she gladly asked if I wanted to swap it out for rice. I declined. I also ordered a small catfish nuggets. Took about 15 mins but it's understandable since the food was fried fresh. The catfish nuggets were tasty and was a decent amount for $6.99. The seafood sampler which consisted of 3 pieces of whiting, 3 pieces of shrimp and 3 scallops was ok at best. No seasoning at all. I would only go back for the catfish nuggets. The food wasn't the best but if definitely wasn't the worst. read more

See all

The food was great the service was slow. There is place to sit. This is a pick up your food and go type of place. If is much more than fish and chicken. They sell soul food and Spanish food. read more

First off customer service was not that good, they told me I couldn't order anything that had to be cooked yet they fry fish to order. The potato salad I got was very questionable on how long it's been there. The prices were ridiculous!!!! 3.99 for two wings and for an or which only comes with 3 and a side was 15 dollars!! They had food under the hot lamp for what seemed like some hours. 2/10 would not recommend read more

ok so I've been here once . today would be my second time expect I didn't get the food I walked out . The short light skin girl with the curly hair was very rude & aggressive! not to mention she was yelling over the food . I'm pretty sure spit landed . The service was horrible. I do not recommend. read more

This will be the the fifth time coming to this restaurant. There are more hits than misses, starting with the major attitude of the old lady. She's extremely nasty and consistently rushes customers through their orders. Even when being chastised by a customer, who she was practically screaming at because no one could understand her. He and several of us told her about how rude and disrespectful she always is. Her response was that we don't have to buy anything from her. So all of us left, with the majority of us not even placing an order. We're in a pandemic. To the owners, be happy you still have a customer base. Be happy you haven't closed the doors. And since you don't need our business, that may be sooner than you think. read more

Skip this place folks. The place is dirty, over priced and the food was disappointing. Stopped for lunch, ordered baked chicken that had a fishy taste, rice and beans with no taste and soggy green beans. And I stress dirty. read more

The best soul food I have had in this area. I had the fried chicken with 3 sides and every one was perfectly seasoned. Just wish they served more than 2 pieces of chicken. This is authentic soul food and done right. read more

Brooklyn Fish - Chicken & Soul Food - Collards, mac and cheese and candied yams. Ate the fried chicken in 0.5 seconds. Just wish there was more. Excellent, authentic soul food! - Soul Food Near Me - Amityville, New York

I got some fried fish greens and brown rice everything was good. They mixed collard greens and kale with smoked meat outstanding. It's usually hit or miss with their greens but this time they outdid there self. So if you want down home fried catfish with either french fries grits or spaghetti this is the place to go read more

Brooklyn Fish - Chicken & Soul Food - Fried catfish collards and kale mix and brown rice and peas - Soul Food Near Me - Amityville, New York

My goodness no matter what you choose to eat the food is on point. It's seasoned well, cooked to perfection. Meats falling off the bone, fish so good. If you want some good soul food go and check it out!! Yum!!!! read more

Good value for the money. Food is delicious and its a true home cooking. Instead of fast food places up the road, people need to venture here and try some comfort food. Fried okra...yum!! read more

See all

The hot food buffet is the SOUL TRAIN line dancing straight into my tummy. They have Pig Feet! Cooked to perfection. Yes, like grandmother used to make. In fact, it is so good I can't leave in the car just tasting a small portion. I MUST keep going!!! You see, eating Pig Feet requires hot water and soap. You are eating with your hands. No pearl-clutching here. They will fry your fish any way you want. I love fish/grits. So get your VOTE on then to go celebrate by taking home a great meal and watch CNN for election results. read more

This place is a hit or miss. I don't live locally so when and if I'm in the Amityville area I'll get a takeout order. The greens, and yams are very good. I love their fried shrimp and fries. The fish I stand clear of as the fish (flounder/whiting) typically doesn't taste fresh as (I don't like fishy seafood). The customer service is horrific. The ladies, are down right rude and unprofessional. I thought it was my brown skin but then I came to realize they are just tacky, and lack proper etiquette. In addition to the poor customer service the place could use some TLC. PS. Service with a smile never grows old. Proceed at your own risk. read more

I have seen this place for years on my many visits to Long Island and I never tried it. I really regret going against my intuition. The place gets one star for the corn bread and yams which are sweet so I guess they can get tht right. When you see the prices, you would think the fish was made of gold & coming from the best part of the Atlantic Ocean. The seafood is made to order and the customer service is average So I Ordered a fried seafood platter with shrimp, scallops, whiting, and French fries. Unfortunately.... The whiting fish is bland literally no flavor, I was eating something that looked like fish and smelled like fish but tasted like nothing. Sadly, I couldn't even save it with salt or pepper. The batter and fish need serious help. Scallops- straight from the freezer and terribly fried. Once again, no flavor. Shrimp- the saving grace, seemed to be the only thing cooked with an ounce of seasoning. French fries- typical from the freezer. No way to mess them up. If you like an ounce of salt on your food & you adore fried seafood, don't go to this place. You will be highly disappointed. read more

Mannnnn, I'm all the way from Boston. This food had me excited by all of the pictures. The food was mediocre. The fish kinda soggy, fries were good and the mac and cheese taste buttery soft but not flavorful. Ugh I'm so disappointed because I wanted to like this place so bad. read more

Brooklyn Fish: the neighborhood soul food restaurant. There are two locations one in North Amityville and one in Wyandanch,NY. Let me tell you I love to eat, Italian food, Chinese food, Greek food,and food from cultures around the . But sometimes you like some down-home old-fashioned soul food. At Brooklyn Fish, they have A large variety of dishes to choose from. I will start with the soul food dinners which include two sides and cornbread.They have flounder,Whiting, porgies for bluefish, salmon, red snapper for Seatrout known better as weak fish croaker, kingfish, fishcakes, catfish , Cajun catfish,seafood platters, codfish shrimp ,a half a pound of shrimp ,a pound of shrimp , scallops , oysters ,crabcakes tilapia ,chicken fingers ,clam strips shrimp and scallop. They have chicken by the pieces , Brooklyn fish and chicken soul food dinner's rib dinner 1299 beef rib dinner 1399 Turkey dinner 1099 fresh chicken 1099 baked chicken 1099 barbecue chicken 1099 meatloaf 1099 ribs and fries 799 sausage and peppers with onions 799 pork chops 1099 You can get a half a rack of ribs for 1199 and fries a dollar extra you can get a full rack of ribs for 1899 fries a dollar extra Desserts banana pudding 275 cheesecake five dollars red velvet cake 350 sweet potato pie 325 They have kids meals also. They also have a large variety of side orders which includes yellow rice ,rice and beans ,french fries ,onion rings ,macaroni and cheese ,coleslaw ,collar greens and a slew of mouthwatering things to choose from.Brooklyn fish is located at 524 Broadway Amityville, NY 11701, tel.#631-789-6522 ,fax # 631-789-6525 and 1393 straight path Wyandanch New York.11798 tel #631-920-5800 fax#631-920-5740. Monday-Thursday 6am-11pm Friday&Saturday 6am-12pm Sunday 6am-9pm read more

Delicious food and fast service for the price, if you're looking for fine dining you're in the wrong place, I've been here many times and always enjoyed the meal , peace read more

Ordered from this place and only received 1/1 of my order. When I called, they're laughing in the background. Unprofessional !! Do not order from here!! Last time I will order from here!! read more

This review is for fan #109 I learned about turkey wings here. They give you 2 or 3 of these massive, fatty things in a platter. Rather than a date, bring a roll of paper towels and a cup of water to eat with. It's a saucy, sticky, delicious mess. To me, a meal of the wings, collared greens and macaroni n' cheese are truly a lovemaking session in eating by my lonesome. It's an event. I'm the type of person who always has to be producing, but if I spent a night eating turkey wings from here for an hour and the rest of the night recovering, I would still feel complete fulfillment with my life. I guess that's love. Damn. There's no seating. Instead it's one store housing the counter, and the other housing a buffet behind the glass. You can stare and pick or choose a fish among about 15. It's always stressful trying to choose. read more

Honestly I would give it no stars at all! When this establishment first opened the food was always hot and fresh and the portions were good. Fast forward to now, the fish is greasy, not hot, overpriced for the portions, which though the prices have gone up the portions have gotten smaller. I feel they have gotten too comfortable so the food isn't up to par anymore. Save your money!! read more

This place first opened up as a small unorganized fried fish Togo restaurant. Roughly a year after opening they opened up to a local town favorite for fried fish and ribs. What makes this place soo good are the different type of fish to order that comes with either a side of slaw, spaghetti, fries, grits or rice. What ever you choose I am sure it will taste good read more

The food here is gross & overpriced Spent almost 50 dollars on lunch for 3 people and none of it was good. The fried chicken was raw & skin had no flavor The Mac & Cheese was overcooked & it was like they took cheap slices of cheese and mixed it with the macaroni The fried shrimp was ok but some of the shrimp weren't deveined . Never Again!!!!! read more

Someone recommended this place, so I tried it. I will say they cooked my fish n shrimp to order. However the shrimp was overcooked and the rice had the smell of being in a pot where the bottom burned. Yams were nice n rich. read more

See all

Delicious and flavorful soulfood and seafood. I'm from the south where we take both quite seriously but I approve! I blame this place for making me a chubby wubby since I've lived in NY. read more

Brooklyn Fish - Chicken & Soul Food - Soul Food Near Me - Amityville, New York

Went Brooklyn Fish on Monday around 2:00 p.m. to pick up my order because I was visting from out of town. The lady that works the register is nasty and has no type of customer service. She was very rude to me. read more

Brooklyn Fish & Chicken is a great to go restaurant serving a large variety from many choices of fried fish and ribs chicken turkey wings , yummy collard greens Mac & cheese candied yams. The prices are right and the food is great. read more

I used to go here all the time. The food is good when it is fresh. You can tell when you're getting days old macaroni and cheese and no one really eats at the location so it's annoying that you pay around $10+ for a good meal and come home with something you wouldn't want to eat and throw it away. The mac and cheese is really good when fresh. Same situation with the meats and chicken. It drys up and you can taste the difference. read more

I came to this place based on a Facebook recommendation. I ordered fish and grits. The service was sub par and somewhat unprofessional. However, I observed the cook frying up four pieces of whiting, and she served me three pieces with the grits. What were they going to do with that one lone piece, pray tell? I asked what would I have to do to get that one piece, and I was charged an extra $2.00 for it which would have ended up wasted. The food was okay--but I will say that the lunch menu looked somewhat impressive. Overall, I would not go out of my way to patronize this establishment. read more