I've been coming to this location a couple of times and they are always excellent, the staff is always friendly and the food is always great, I had a half of a pepperoni and black olive pizza on one side and the other half had green pepper on it and it was delicious, I also had a regular Dr Pepper and that was good too, for a family owned business I definitely recommend this pizza place. read more

Brooklyn Pie & Cafe - Pizza Near Me - Mansfield, Texas

Picked up a pizza from Brooklyn Pie & Cafe for lunch today. The service was great as usual. They are so friendly. The pie was delicious as usual. read more

See all

Mansfield's Best Pizza and Garlic Bread & Knots. Light crisp crust and perfectly chewy inside, perfect to dip the marina! Chicken Alfredo and ravioli were great also! I can't believe we haven't been back, will definitely be bringing our friends and family here for the holiday's! read more

See all

Stop sending me burnt cheese pizzas it's so frustrating I wouldn't like to eat a cracker bread of a pizza ..I like your pizzas and you guys ruin it for me when yall do this....its way to hard and you can just taste the burnt bread and that's on top of the texture being like a cracker . read more

Brooklyn Pie & Cafe - Pizza Near Me - Mansfield, Texas

amazing food and amzing service!! great family owned business, we will definitely be back!! read more

Brooklyn Pie & Cafe - Cheers to a great dinner!! - Pizza Near Me - Mansfield, Texas

Pizza was great. I'm a New Yorker living in Mansfield very skeptical of a place called Brooklyn Pizza but was very happy. Super tasty we got the pepp with extra cheese and Sicilian supreme. Love the crust the sauce is great very good chew. Will definitely be ordering again. Also side note we ordered bbq wings and so glad they were smothered in sauce very good. Yay happy. read more

It was my 1st time eating here Service very slow, cashier was very polite but very apologetic. Pizza was not good. I will not be ordering from here again read more

We love going here. Everything is fresh and good. We visit at least every other week. read more

See all

Just visited here again and the food was still excellent! We had pizza, spaghetti and side salads. The salads came with sides of peppers and olives. Owner is very sweet and personable. Highly recommend! read more

Food was really good, I definitely recommend if you're looking for a new pizza place.

We ate here on a Saturday night. No one was eating in, but plenty of takeout business. I had a 12" meat pizza and my husband had a 12" everything pizza. We also ordered garlic knots, which came out first. Warm, soft and delicious. The pizzas came out next. Each bite was so good. We each ate half our pizza and took the other 4 slices home. The pizza easily passed the next day test! Even cold, it was delicious. We have found our new favorite pizza! read more

Brooklyn Pie & Cafe - Meat pizza, 12" size - Pizza Near Me - Mansfield, Texas

First time visiting this place. Shopping center with so much to do. We stopped to eat. Everyone is friendly! We were starving the food was so good we ordered more pizza to go. We will come back when in the area :) read more

Dirty,unprofessional,unresponsive. Basically the two employees working when I visited don't not care in the least bit.

This family owned pizza spot is soooo good!! I don't even eat at chain pizza places anything because this pizza is so good! I also love their Caesar salad is great! Check them out they have weekly specials. They are always so nice every time I order. read more

Brooklyn Pie & Cafe - Pizza Near Me - Mansfield, Texas

I came into Brooklyn cafe simply because I'm tired of the fast food pizza and I came across Brooklyns and I was not disappointed, walking in we were greeted by the daughter of the owner and she was very nice and welcoming she helped us pick a size and showed us what they are known. Me and my family went for a half meatlovers and half margarita the wait wasn't that bad and once the food was brought to us we killed the pizza the pizza it's self tasted amazing the topping were fresh and the sauce was amazing the margarita pizza was my favorite simple but delicious. Overall this place is amazing and too good to be empty if you're tired of the Pizza Hut and dominoes come here you won't be disappointed. read more

Brooklyn Pie & Cafe - Large pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mansfield, Texas

Went here because it had good reviews. Didn't have a great feeling walking in. Place reeked of natural gas, nobody was up front and only 2 people there during lunch rush time. We should have turned around but didn't. We ordered chicken Alfredo which I would give 3 out of 10 score. It was sooooo pepper heavy, pasta was all different sizes and not very much sauce. We got garlic knots would rate those 6 out of 10. We also got a meat lovers pizza and asked for no ham. I would rate 3 out of 10, it tasted like chuck e. cheese. The girl came from the back with the pizza with ham all over it and asked if it was OK if it had ham on it? Um no. She didn't have any of the rest of our food. We were like um where is the other stuff? She had no clue what we were talking about. Finally got all our food 30 minutes later. They both had the personalities of a white wall. I would never go back here. Chain pizza would've been better. read more

See all

Restaurant was clean and the staff were super nice. Everyone I was with enjoyed their pizzas. Don't pass up this family owned spot!! read more

Brooklyn Pie & Cafe - Margherita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mansfield, Texas

Best pizza and lasagna we've ever had and I'm a notoriously opinionated about food. Service was 5 star and one of the owners (the wife/mom) came out and talked with us and I'm pretty sure she was born in Italy. Familia owned and Familia operated! Pretty sure it was her kids serving us. I'll probably never go to any other Italian joint in this city. read more

Food and Service was excellent. Pizza crust was perfect, I asked for crispy crust. Great place to eat!! read more

Our second time here! Decided on getting their Spaghetti and Meatballs. Absolutely delicious. Best meatballs I've had! Service was excellent. Everything made fresh! Olive Oil only. So much food! Leftovers for tomorrow's lunch! read more

Brooklyn Pie & Cafe - Spaghetti and Meatballs. Lunch tomorrow! - Pizza Near Me - Mansfield, Texas

This place is amazing!!!! 10/10 Service was great and food was even better. Upon arriving we were greeting, got our food in a timely manner and also enjoyed every bite! This pizza is really like no other, to me the taste is just impeccable! read more

I ordered a pizza, garlic knots and fried zucchini tonight. It was the worst. Where do I start. I phone ordered at 7:00pm and was informed to pick up in 30 min. I picked my order up at 7:30 and it took me less than 5 min to drive home. The fried Zucchini was 8-10 small pieces of oily mess. The garlic knots were cold with a red liquid they called marinara sauce. The pizza was cold and looked like it had been sitting for an hour already. $50.00 for this!!!!! Never again!!!! read more

Really wanted to like this spot as...Brooklyn (!) and the Stromboli was good (but really tiny for the price). We had an issue with an item that was prepared incorrectly (but delivered by Grubhub, they do not have their own delivery) but they made it right by inviting us in to get replacement (+1 star!) We decided to go in person to eat...not recommended. Inside is uninviting, dimly lit and not particularly clean. We were not provided utensils or napkins and difficult to get staff attention as it's the cooks who are in "the front". We ordered items to eat there, yet pizza was given in to-go box. Pizza crust is tasty. We ordered mozzarella sticks and calamari but neither are recommended- they are thick yet tasteless. No salt on table, but that could have helped. Calamari also served without lemon. There are numerous other options in the area and this just doesn't make our cut. Not recommended read more

Brooklyn Pie & Cafe - The basil mozzarella pizza we had originally ordered that was made without basil - Pizza Near Me - Mansfield, Texas

First time eating here. . Pizza was amazing . Staff was friendly. Would definitely recommend. 10 out of 10 .

The pizza was good not bad but not NY style.the inside was clean and comfortable.The service was good and very friendly girl that greeted us.overall we were happy but if you want NY style look elsewhere. read more

First time visiting here and came because of the reviews and yes, it is a place worthwhile and worth the money. Food was really good, imo really good for what competitors they have. They make their pies and garlic knots fresh, so call ahead of time or be patient waiting / family sit-down/ dine-in. Decor and vibe is pizza/diner atmosphere/ambiance. Left satisfied and stomach happy/not bothered 12" great for 1 or 2 people. Cashier guy and young lady server "Lily" (On receipt) is personable, cordial/nice and the owner came to thank us and get feedback as well as welcoming us to come again. Highly recommended, especially if you want something of quality. PS: I was off work, so the wait time wasn't an issue and worth it for what I received. They fell into the "Enjoyable quality pie = Sometimes longer than usual wait" category and that's what I wanted, NOT the "Bad feeling / Feed the family to just fill them = Quick/Little Caesar-esque wait time" read more

Brooklyn Pie & Cafe - 12" good and fresh pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mansfield, Texas

See all

The pizza at Brookly's is fresh and delicious! We have tried others I'm Mansfield and always come back To Brooklyn's. The restaurant is very clean and the service friendly. My husband and i highly recommend This fresh ingredients pizza! read more

Excellent food and great value. Fabulous family friendly spot, unassuming atmosphere. read more

Finally a place with good pizzas in this area forgotten by the good food and the good restaurants! Shawn (the owner) will welcome you and treat you in the most friendliest way. This is a tiny little place in a little street shopping center, it has only a few tables and it is BYOB...And the food...the food is very good! read more

See all

I have lived all over Texas and this is the BEST PIZZA IN TEXAS, hands down. I grew up in the New York/New Jersey area, where there are mom & pop pizza shops on every corner. So only the restaurants with the most authentic recipes survive. This is the closest thing I can find to that in Texas. If you haven't tried this place you're doing yourself a disservice. Their sausage pasta is pretty amazing too. read more

We ordered delivery and pizza only so that is solely what this review is based on - I wasn't able to see the facility myself, have much interaction regarding customer service. Now, down to the point. We ordered two pizzas: 1. White Pizza with onions, bacon, and eggplant. Delicious. The eggplant was not mushy and we liked how the bacon was crumbled. The onions where perfectly cooked and did not over power the pizza. Btw, being a white pizza does not mean this was alfredo sauce based... it was mozzarella and ricotta, perfect! 2. Hawaiian Pizza with sausages added. We loved how the sausage was shaved into it. Not too much sauce and they were generous with the pineapples. Another home run! We will be ordering from here again. These pizzas are not greasy and have a great crunch to the crust. It's not burned on the bottom and the toppings are all around. We had several places where the focus on ingredients only get distributed towards the center of the pizza but we had eggplant to the crust. Great choice tonight! read more

Brooklyn Pie & Cafe - Eggplant, onions, and bacon. - Pizza Near Me - Mansfield, Texas

See all

Delicious pizza and amazing crust! Nice hometown pizza place with good pizza. Great service and clean place. read more

Brooklyn Pie & Cafe - My hunk and our pizza pie! Classic 14 in pizza with pepperoni, olives, and mushrooms. - Pizza Near Me - Mansfield, Texas

See all

We stopped in here for lunch after a couple of our friends were raving about it on Facebook. It was rather quiet when we went and the restaurant was more or less empty. They have a large number of pizza and other options on the menu. They also have some lunch specials, but I was a bit disappointed to see that none of them included pizza since that is what I was looking for. My wife and I split a medium pizza that had meatballs and garlic on it. It was pretty good. I don't know if a true New Yorker would call this New York style pizza, but it was good. They used to have pizza by the slice but they had to give that up due to the lack of volume coming through. This place is worth a try and they have some coupons you get. Try it out if you are looking to try something new. They don't serve alcohol so this place is BYOB. read more

See all

Amazing customer service and friendly customer service!! Please support local businesses.

This is one of the most yummy pizza places I've ever been to. The pizza crust is delicious and the toppings are surprising and delicious as well. I highly recommend their pizza. Your pasta is a little greasy. Still tasty but greasyEverything I've had there I really enjoyed. read more

Brooklyn Pie & Cafe - Meatball onions and garlic... Extreme yummy Ness - Pizza Near Me - Mansfield, Texas

Really disappointing. I've been ordering from this place regularly for over a year and tonight they lost a loyal customer over $5. I was here two nights ago and wanted an Alfredo pizza with chicken spinach and ricotta. The person working told us they would ring it up the cheapest way. It was $23. For 8 slices. Tonight I called to order the same exact pizza going off of the recommendation of how to order it from the girl who was there two nights ago and was now told they wouldn't ring it up that way, it would be almost $29 because they should charge more for chicken. Lol pretty sure you're still making money on a $23 pizza. You guys lost a customer and all of my recommendations to friends and business partners. Fail. read more

House-made pasta and natural ingredients make for delicious soulful meals. However, long wait times come with the territory.

Came here because it was the only pizza place I hadn't tried in Mansfield. We got the fried calamari and the meatball pizza, it was a good price to me. The lady was very nice and she brought out the calamari, which was amazing, I've had calamari from fancy restaurants, this was my favorite, so well flavored. The pizza came out soon and just perfect, one of the best I've ever had. I already want to go back. read more

Brooklyn Pie & Cafe - Meatball and opinion pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Mansfield, Texas

We seen this restraunt locally and heard good praises from The Mansfield talk. We tried it yesterday and wow, everyone in the household thoroughly enjoyed the food. We tried the hot wings,garlic knots, fettuccine alfredo, chicken fettuccine Alfredo and Chicken Parmigiana. We highly recommend giving this place a try. We will definitely be ordering from here again. read more

Great thin crust pizza, but there are other crust options. Customer service was excellent We started with garlic knots which were delicious. Next time I will ask for warm marinara (my preference), they served it cold. Pizza was perfect! Really liked the crust flavor. Desserts looked wonderful but I was too full to try them. Many customers stopped in for to go orders, quiet and not crowded inside when we dined there. read more

Brooklyn Pie & Cafe - Pizza Near Me - Mansfield, Texas

See all