Great slice and great service place been there for more than 60 years and still a solid choice

Returned to my old stomping grounds. Used to frequent Brothers during high school. Returning brought back many memories. And nothing has changed since coming today. The pizza had a firm under carriage. Thin sauce. And a thick cheesey top layer. The sauce was a miss for me. It was soupy and didnt have much flavor. It works as a binding element to the firm crust and cheesey layer. Great for the traditional NY fold. After the first bite, the sauce just splattered to the plate. Its an average slice. Decent and solid. read more

See all

Got a chance to be in NY again and of course hit up Brothers Pizza. Still great. Wife and friend tried slice of grandma pizza. I tried a vite and thought it was ok, a bit more freshness from the sauce and all. But I waited for the simple cheese that always hits. I mentioned the pizza tasted better when we got slice that was reheated last time vs the whole pie. Gentleman confirmed yes reheating the slice makes for crisper crust and tastier pizza. He offered to make the whole pie well done and let it rest few minutes and pop it back in oven to reheat. It def was better than the last whole pie but I still think slice was better lol. Maybe pizza really needs to cool down a lot before reheating. Either way we loved it yet again, and kid brought the 2 slices leftover all the way back to LA, lol. Maybe I'll steal a bite whenever that gets reheated toasted up in the air fryer lol. read more

See all

4.5 There's a reason this place is a staple in the Queens pizza scene--and it's simply because their pizza is damn good. My pictures don't do it justice, mostly because I ask for my pies cooked lightly, so the cheese isn't fully melted in the middle. Still, the bottom of the pie was crispy, and the crust had a nice chew. The sauce had great flavor, and the cheese tied everything together. From the outside, it's nothing special. Honestly, it's easy to miss since it's on Horace Harding, where you're usually driving by pretty fast. And let's be real--the interior isn't anything to write home about either. It's just a good ol' fashioned pizza joint. But you're not coming here for ambience. You're coming here for great pizza, made by people who clearly care about what they're serving--and it shows. If I had one negative, it's that I wish the pies were a bit bigger. I noticed their pizza boxes are 16", compared to the 18" you get at some other places. read more

See all

Good pizza solid mushroom slice , friendly staff. If you like thin pizza this is a good spot to try

Grandma's eggplant parm! Actually grandma never made me eggplant parm, or I might not have left for college. Granted the place looks a bit dated, so what. Was all very clean and efficient, and there whole family were there working the food line. I watched as they did everything correct.. nicely toasted fresh bread.. nice juicy slices of eggplant. Heated in the pizza oven then brought to the kitchen for fresh assembly. I would say this was vastly better vs a chain pizza down the block. Highly recommended. read more

Brother’s Pizzeria - Eggplant Parmesan - Pizza Near Me - Fresh Meadows, New York

See all

Brother's is old school neighborhood pizzeria that has been at this location on Horace Harding Expy for decades. The pizza oven is older than me, the wood paneling has seen better days and the spinning counter stools have seen a lot of bottoms. The most recent renovation is the new exterior sign because the old one was missing a lot of letters. During Covid, they had put up a curbside shack to expand seating, but eventually, it had to be removed. When you walk in, there are always a bunch of regulars at the counter stools having lunch and talking baseball in the Spring and football in the Fall. The Mets rule here. I still remember the first time I had a slice from Brother's was at a birthday party that my son was invited to over 20 years ago. After seeing the name on the box and tasting the pizza, I made a mental bookmark (B.Y., Before Yelp) to check them out. And the rest is history, though I waited until now to write a review. The pizza is classic New York style Neapolitan, round thin crust and Sicilian thick squares. It's best to order and dine-in for the freshest, hottest tasting pie, but if you must take-out, it's still not bad when you get it home. I hate using one of the delivery services because you don't know how long it takes to get your pizza. We love it with sausage and usually mushrooms, but the mushrooms are not fresh here, coming out of a jar. The heroes here are really good made fresh in the kitchen. The Veal Parmagiana hero is great and I'll have to try some of the others for lunch. Prices are very reasonable, even after post-Covid inflation. Definitely have to try the pasta dinners next time because they make a good sweet red sauce. read more

Brother’s Pizzeria - Veal Parmigiana Hero - Pizza Near Me - Fresh Meadows, New York

I don't consider my self a pizza connoisseur, but i've tried quite a few pizzerias throughout my lifetime being from NY and all..the verdict on this is just "average tasting" pizza in my opinion. It could've used more cheese and it also arrived cold. We added more mozzarella cheese..also had to add garlic, cayenne and black pepper to enjoy it after warming it up. The crust was also too soft, so we had to stick in the toaster oven after the microwave.. We also ordered a side of buffalo wings and they were hard and semi dry..maybe we caught them on an off day Idk. read more

Brother’s Pizzeria - 8 Slice Cheese Pizza Pie - Pizza Near Me - Fresh Meadows, New York

No drinking water given unless you pay for bottled water. This ruined the entire experience. I've never been to a restaurant that doesn't offer complementary water in a cup. read more

Full disclosure, this is the pizza my sister got for her daughter's birthday party at the park. She said that the service was good so I'll trust her on that. The pizza is probably the most generic non offensive single served sliced pizza. That's not a bad thing. It's fine for a kids party and if you're in the area and you're hungry it's perfectly passible. read more

Old school pizza was, is and will ALWAYS be the best. 62 years and still going strong. read more

Brother’s Pizzeria - Lentil soup for the winter. NICE!!!!! - Pizza Near Me - Fresh Meadows, New York

Excellent amount of cheese and a bit of a thinner crust than a normal place. A good ratio of crust to cheese for me. Staff were very kind and friendly. The interior is dated but good pizza comes from places that don't need updating. Would order my next pie from here. read more

Wow accidentally found this spot and must say this is prob the best pizza I ever ate. I'm a born n raised ny'er from Brooklyn. It's one of those places you would prob walk by, definition of a hidden gem. Def give them a try! read more

I visited Brother's Pizzeria as I was feeling nostalgic & was visiting nearby. The pizzeria was established by brothers Pete & Joe & we used to get pizza here regularly since I grew up a few blocks away. My dad used to pick up a pie every week & talk to Pete & Joe like they're family. I got a classic slice of cheese pizza & a peach Snapple to wash it down. The pizza was perfect, as I remembered from years ago, thin crust & crispy. The sauce & cheese had perfect flavors. Yum. The Pizzeria is under a new owner of 15 years who told that Pete comes in every Monday for few hours. Unfortunately I'm leaving on Sunday otherwise it would have been great to see him. read more

Brother’s Pizzeria - Classic Cheese Pizza Slice & peach Snapple - Pizza Near Me - Fresh Meadows, New York

Step into the early 1970's for the great slices, sandwiches and staff helping customers and throwing dough you remember (if old enough) from your childhood. Very plain, simple interior, extraordinary quality of ingredients and food at Brother's. We were staying across the street and so glad we crossed the expressway to get fantastic slice and sandwiches---excellent flavor and excellent prices for tremendous value. We usually stay in Brooklyn or Manhattan when visiting family, in the future will take a side trip out to Flushing to get a slice, or two, or.... read more

We stopped at Brother's Pizza in Flushing on our way out of the city and were so glad we did. It's a no-frills spot with just plain and grandma pies ready (but you can add your own toppings, which keeps everything fresh). My dad and I both went for the plain slice, and it was genuinely great--crisp crust, balanced sauce, and just the right amount of cheese. What really stood out, though, was the atmosphere. The owner took time to joke around with us and ended up chatting through most of our meal. You can tell this place is run with heart. It has an old-school, nostalgic vibe that makes you feel like you've been coming there for years, even if it's your first time. There are a few tables if you're dining in, plus counter space that's perfect if you're stopping in solo. Definitely worth a visit. read more

Getting into LGA late at night I looked for some pizza places on the way home and this seemed good. It was okay. I think we just do it better on long island, though queens is technically long island, not about to start all that :P nassau county whatever. It was perfect for us as we headed home right off the parkway. read more

What's going on? Use to come here for delicious specialty slices. Went yesterday and all they had was plain slices! Nothing else! No one inside at 5:30 pm on a Friday and it's Valentine's Day! I guess going out of business. Wow a staple on fresh meadows for many years read more

Good pizza. Old school pizza like I remember when I was a kid. Crunchy crust. Melty cheese and tasty sauce. Always consitant.

First time I tried food here and was greatly disappointed. The buffalo wings tasted like a cup of salt was poured on them. They were so dry,bony ,and anemic like. One of the worst wings I had. Garlic bread did not taste good too. Just tasted like stale old bread with raw chopped garlic on top. The only reason I didn't give one star is because the beef patty tasted great. Really enjoyed the texture of the bread and was cooked well. read more

Brother’s Pizzeria - Dry bony super salty wings - Pizza Near Me - Fresh Meadows, New York

See all

Another great pizza pie! Their pizza is so good. Better than any other pizza shops I the neighborhood. Just look at this Brother Special pie. read more

Brother’s Pizzeria - Brothers Special. Large pie. - Pizza Near Me - Fresh Meadows, New York

Thank you, for always being there, Brother's Pizzeria. I always stop in when I'm visiting my parents, and enjoy the nostalgia of the place that's been serving the best pizza in the area for over 40 years. This visit, I sat on the same stool I always did when I was a child, and ordered my usual slice with extra cheese. And it was just as I remembered - crispy bottom, holding up the weight of the extra cheese, nice & hot out of the oven - perfection. I also ordered a pie and some beef patties to bring back to California for my family - a new generation of kids who love Brother's. May they continue to do so for 40 more years. read more

See all

I ordered 2 pies, one plain and another with mushrooms and sausage, that came to about $39.50. the pizza is always made to order, great sauce, lots of cheese and a nice crust on every pie that is why we always order from them even when we have Villa Rustjca Pizza down the block. We placed a call and we were told 20 minute for pickup. We got there a few minutes before and the pies were coming out of the oven as we walked in. We noticed they have put up outdoor dinning, and they also included a note with the pizzas that they will be closing from 9/1/20 to 9/14/20, back for business on 9/15. read more

Brother’s Pizzeria - Delicious pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fresh Meadows, New York

See all

Reasonably priced, good quality ingredients, will definitely be ordering in the future read more

Brother’s Pizzeria - Pepperoni Roll - Pizza Near Me - Fresh Meadows, New York

Very good, fast delivery, and def get what you pay for. We ordered a large pie half sausage and half plain plus a large chicken salad. The salad was huge and fully loaded aside from being fresh and delicious. The pizza was just right. read more

Brother’s Pizzeria - Large pie half sausage and half plain - Pizza Near Me - Fresh Meadows, New York

See all

Pls becareful . There was a roach inside a meatball sandwich dead I ordered for a delivery . Was so disgusted . Made me not eat out anymore . :( read more

I was in town on a work trip and stumbled across Brother's Pizza. Really all I have to say is "WOW". The pizza and the garlic knots were both amazing. My coworker got wings and she liked those a lot. Service was very friendly and quick. Great prices. If I'm ever back in the area I'm not sure I'd consider eating dinner anywhere else. read more

We were staying in Fresh Meadows and wanted a local Italian place for a light meal. We were greeted by a cast of characters, making us feel at home in an old fashioned authentic pizzeria. The pizzas were huge, so we opted for single slices, which were great. There's nothing fancy here, just fun workers and good food -- which was the New York experience we were looking for. It's an easy walk from the two Marriot properties - you can see it across the highway. read more

It doesn't get much better than the "made to order" rolls here. We tried the chicken roll on a recent visit, and came back a few days later for a sausage and peppers roll. They were both huge and delicious! The plain slice is great too. It's old school NYC pizza through and through. Sicilian was good as well. Either one is a solid choice to munch on while you wait for your roll to come out of the oven. read more

Love This place. I have been coming here for years. I just realized that I have never wrote a review. So, here it is. This place is consistent. They always have a solid slice. Their delivery service is great. Their food is yummy. They created an outside heated dining area to go with the Covid dining flow in Queens. It's not fancy, but it us reliable and yummy. read more

Brother’s Pizzeria - Outside view from the street - Pizza Near Me - Fresh Meadows, New York

See all

Best pizza in America lowkey. That cheese? Omg it just hits different. It's so flavorful and herbaceous and different from every other pizza place. The service is good too but the pizza is just phenomenal. read more

Visited from Atlanta. The pizza was good and so was the service when I came in last minute with a friend. Would eat here again if I was craving pizza in queens. read more

Brother’s Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Fresh Meadows, New York

Over my many years as a New Yorker, I've been told that many different restaurants have be best pizza; and yes while they've been good, they're never the one pizzeria that I go back to time after time. Brother's Pizzeria has been the only pizza that I crave consistently and the one I go back to after a long trip. Brother's Pizzeria is your typical neighborhood pizza joint that serves up one of the best slices that I've ever eaten. Their slices have a perfect bottom crust, able to stand up on it's own and not flopping over. I think I've had every type of toppings that Brothers serves, I even had my first anchovy slice here but by far my favorite go to topping is their fresh garlic slice. Adding fresh garlic on top of a slice gives it a nice bite that far outclasses the dried stuff. If available, I'd also recommend their grandma slice, a thin crust slice with lots of cheese, a bit of sauce and some pesto on top. They don't always have it but I always ask to see if they got it. In my opinion the defining quality of a New York slice is the crispy thin bottom crust and Brother's has never ever disappointed. During Covid times, they have set up an outdoor dining area in front and mandate masks to be worn at all times. I can't wait til we can all go back to the times when we can sit at the bar and order up slices one by one. Also I'd like to mention that if you're ordering delivery or calling through the Yelp app. Please call them directly. For some reason, calling through Yelp forces the call to go to grub hub and grub hub takes a massive cut of their deliveries. So please call Brother's Pizzeria directly at (718) 445-7888 or better yet, save them into your phone like I do. read more

This place is so underrated. Chicken roll was one of if not the best I've ever had. Pizza was solid and traditional as well. 9/10 regular slice. I like this place a lot, be back for sure. read more

Very good pizza for long years taste hasn't changed. Good pleasant friendly servers. Friendly atmosphere. Good portions. Buffalo wings salty please cut down salt thank you read more

It's ok.. I was in a rush ... they warmed up 2 slices for me .. from 1 to 10 I give it a 5 .. i've had my share a various pizzas in all five New York City borrows. read more

This is my go to pizzeria in fresh Meadows. There's no other pizzeria that beats this especially for chicken rolls. They buy far have the best chicken roll in Queens. It doesn't get soggy. It's just delicious cheese, chicken and bread and you dip it in the sauce. Fantastic. You Must try. read more

They are super friendly on the phone and the pizza was yummy. We've had the plain pie as well as the white pizza pie. Both were delish.

Wow, 10 out of 10!!!!! Totally recommend! 9 times out of 10, my pizza (from OTHER places) are delivered cold & soggy. My Brothers pizza (first time ordering from here) arrived just now, HOT AND CRISPY - THANKKKKK YOUUUUUUU! *releases a huge sigh of relief* so happy and satisfied right now omgggg read more

Brother’s Pizzeria - Wow, 10 out of 10! - Pizza Near Me - Fresh Meadows, New York

An alright restaurant for getting a slice of pizza. I enjoyed the regular, Sicilian, and Grandma pizza I tried but didn't find it too be too different from other places I've tried in New York. However, the price is good, the air conditioning is strong, and the restaurant is clean. read more

See all