I've had the same issue with the redemption of the free pizza that others have had (not allowing me to pay for the topping, EVEN THOUGH the coupons do not indicate it must only be a plain pizza - and, no, the handwritten sign when you go in does not count as notification, especially if you ordered by phone). But, remember, this is Hammonton, and businesses in Hammonton work under their own rules (the rule is: they are the best and there is no better / more effective way of doing anything). God bless, but that's how I've just had to make my way as a customer here. If more businesses stopped treating customers as wrong (or worse, as idiots), the businesses would absolutely THRIVE in Hammonton. The pizza is OK, but I like this type of thinner pizza, so I get by, but as soon as I find a better pizza that is in town, I will switch. read more

We have always gone here for our Italian food/pizza but not anymore. Like so many other reviews they have horrible customer service. I don't know what happened lately but I have never been treated that bad while spending a lot of money at an establishment. read more

My family used to really enjoy this place, with cheery little Sunday lunch get-togethers for pizza and garlic knots. I thought I'd go in just to see what happened with the place over the years, but wow... Where's the love? The building is dark, and smells like an old grease trap. Workers and my order both seemed gloomy - I wanted meat. Like good stromboli breads, large hot pockets, melty cheesesteak inside crispy pizza crust. I was told that I should get the steak pizza turnover if that's all I was looking for, because their strombolis (even the cheesesteak one) had multiple meats regardless, and I don't like ham. When I got the first one out, it looked more like the turnover turned over in its grave, leaking out a quarter-cup of oil as soon as I poked in. It was soggy, bland, no crispiness at all -- 2lbs of pure Hubba Bubba mozzarella, with small chunks of meat scattered within. It all cooled and hardened inside 5 minutes after cutting in (soggy bread and hard cheese, no bueno), and my stomach was queasy for hours afterwards... Not what I wanted, but I should've chosen the calzone if I wanted this kind of cheesy mess. The price was a bit much for that, too, and it doesn't help any more that they apparently charge extra if you don't use cash. I think I'll go for ShopRite next time, and just keep the past good memories... read more

Brother's Pizza - Soggy on the bottom, too much cheese. I poked it with a stick; I think it's dead. - Pizza Near Me - Hammonton, New Jersey

I was so excited to find a pizzeria in New Jersey that serves a tomato pie like they do in Utica, NY or Italy . A pie that can stand on its own without the need to be smothered in cheese. So, I went to Brothers Pizza with high expectations. And they did not disappoint. The crust was hand tossed and had very good flavor. The sauce they used is specific for a tomato pie; thick, garlicky, with a touch of Parmesan. Soooo fucking good!!! It was even better the next day reheated. Only knock is that it could have been cooked a little longer to get a more crispy crust. Grilled chicken Parmesan heroes were ordered too. Very tasty & plenty of chicken, just not enough sauce and a chicken filet should mean whole, uncut chicken. Their chicken filet comes sliced. Overall, Brothers Pizzeria makes my list of Pizzeria's that know what they're doing. Real good stuff here! read more

See all

Great service and massive portions with great taste. Daily specials and arguably the best pizza in the Hammonton area.

HORRIBLE CUSTOMER SERVICE!!!!!! I called to make an order for pick up. I usually spend at least $100 every time I visit Brothers Pizza. I called to order four pizzas and 50 wings. I let the girl on the phone know that I had 20 coupons for free pizzas. I asked to add a topping for two of the pizzas , which is six more dollars. I was told you cannot order anything but a cheese pizza with the free coupons , it doesn't say anything about not being able to add toppings anywhere. . If I'm still paying the additional money for the topping, what is the difference? I can tell you what the answer is. I will go to a different pizzeria from now on. just to give you an idea I have 60 coupons just from this year. That's the kind of customer that Brothers Pizza will now lose. . Just to add to the experience the girl on the phone when I told her I don't usually order cheese pizzas. She told me oh well I guess they'll go to waste then. that is very ignorant to a customer but it's horrible customer service. I know I'm only one customer but I spend a lot of money when I come there if you get enough unhappy customers that's how you lose a lot of business. read more

The place has been around for ever and the food & service is great !!! My favorite dishes are the chicken Caesar salad with provolone and beacon, pizza steak & meatball parm. read more

Soup pizza! Pretty low quality ingredients used across the board. Decent prices and they are reasonably fast. Good last resort option.

Brothers Pizza, Hammonton NJ. Hammonton not to be confused with any of the other brothers pizzas. This was 1st stop of Philadelphia Cheesesteak Adventure, Jersey Shore part 2 and it was a great start. We got the brother special which included fried onions, peppers, mushrooms and sauce. At the recommendation of Joe O we got it on the garlic bread. $1.75 extra for the garlic bread, I didn't like that. The roll did not hold up and there was not a lot of meat. However, this was a very tasty cheesesteak. The ingredients on this Cheesesteak played great together. I would absolutely consider going back and getting a regular cheese steak on garlic bread and/or a brother special cheesesteak on regular roll. The people are great. I got my order wrong and then I sat at a table after ordering at the counter. I was a mess and they were great. read more

See all

In a town with a dozen pizzerias, Brother's stands out as one of its leaders. We love the taste of the food.

Delicious pizza! On my way home from out of town I picked up a Brothers Special and a large pepperoni. The restaurant is hidden in a shopping plaza next to a Shop Rite. This is not a thin and crispy style pizza common to the area. The special is loaded with toppings and worth every bite. Staff was welcoming and friendly to boot. Highly recommended. read more

Brother's Pizza - Brother's Special pizza, hold the onions - Pizza Near Me - Hammonton, New Jersey

Brothers was my all time childhood favorite place for pizza and cheesesteaks. If no one else will say it, I will. Their pizza has been hit and miss for years. Until recently their cheesesteaks were the best, not just in Hammonton but possibly all of NJ. The last 2 times Ive ordered a cheesesteak there has been less meat, more undercooked onions and a less than stellar roll. See the picture. Theres more onions on the sandwich! Just a shame. read more

Brother's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hammonton, New Jersey

We had a Brothers Special, Tomato pie, and a half pepperoni and half Hawaiian. All were great and more than enough food for 9 people. We are visiting from out of town and their pizza really hit the spot! I definitely recommend this place! read more

Brother's Pizza - Yum! - Pizza Near Me - Hammonton, New Jersey

See all

Great service. People are so friendly. Food was great. I miss east coast food. My slice of pizza made me so happy. The cheese steak was awesome. Will come back during my travels read more

Brother's Pizza - two plates of food on a table - Pizza Near Me - Hammonton, New Jersey

Nice menu with a range of options. The value for the price makes this a good choice for a casual dinner. The place is hopping on Friday nights! Spaghetti Bolognese is excellent. Sometimes the pizza can be a bit too oily for my taste, but it is still good. read more

Really good pizza and a frequent buyer reward! Has been in Hammonton for years and still fantastic!

Great local pizza restaurant! Love everything they make here. Great family who owns it and wonderful addition to our town!

The portions were generous. I got the pizza, my daughter got a pasta, my wife got the meatball and my son got the panzotti(sp). All were good. Service was fantastic considering a soccer tournament just let out. Be prepared to take home food as portions were a healthy size. read more

Brother's Pizza - Dessert menu - Pizza Near Me - Hammonton, New Jersey

The best pizza. Period. I come here at least once a week for a pizza. The pizzas are NY style. The crust is flavorful, the sauce is tasty, and the crust is thin. Perfect pizza to fold and just dig in. I'm a fav of their cheesesteaks, and their garlic knots as well. read more

Best Pizza Place in Hammonton. I only go here for my take out. Love You guys. TY. SEE YA SOON.

Rarely do I ever find myself in South Jersey but somehow I came here for some noms. It seems like this is a neighborhood joint with lots of regulars. We weren't that hungry so we ordered a few appetizers and one entree to share. Maybe I'm just not used to the prices around the area, but the food was so inexpensive and such an incredible value! The garlic knots appetizer comes with 6 decently-sized knots and it's only $2.75. I really enjoyed the garlic knots and marinara sauce. The service was good too. We surprisingly didn't try the pizza but we saw them being made and they looked great. read more

Great pizza! I am a big pizza person and will travel for pizza. I came from Monmouth county and I'm so glad I made the trip! The staff was super friendly and nice. I got their plain slice and be far better than any local pizza place near me. It was all a home run. The cheese, sauce and dough spot on. I will glad come again. read more

Picked up slices of pizza , it was so bad. Pizza slice couldn't stand as pizza should . I'm glad I just got slices , I end up throwing it away. It was so sloppy. super oily. i had much better better pizza then this. Greasy and oily, just awful. read more

I grew up going to Brothers. Recently ordered pick up and couldn't wait to get home. I ordered a chicken sandwich which has always been my favorite. Unfortunately, they ran out of rolls and neglected to tell me. I get home and find they've "made" a roll out of pizza dough. Terrible, hard and chewy. I actually went to the grocery store for a roll so I could put the inside of the sandwich on a decent piece of bread. No plans to return and certainly would suggest this place read more

My girls love this pizza! Especially my 7 year old who is super picky. She will devour 3 slices easy haha. Boyfriend likes it as well. I got salad once and it was pretty bad. The chicken was black? And had a horrible taste. Like they marinaded it but then fried it without breading? Idk. But it was terrible. But I can say the pizza is yummy. read more

Because of my fellow yelpers I decided to give this place a try and all I have to say is DELICIOUS !! The cheesesteak I ordered was REAL steak and seasoned to perfection!! Next time I visit, I will definitely try the pizza and the garlic knots read more

Ordered a large takeout order for Father's Day. Everything was very good.Mushroom pizza, cheese, pizza, Steak Special Sandwich, Panzarottis, salads. Order was ready on time. All three salads were large and tasty. We ordered Antipasto, Chefs, and Caesar. Prices were reasonable. read more

Water tasted like toilet water with ice. Ordered a Stromboli with ham and salami there was a mountain of unmelted cheese. The cheese was cheap and only between one piece of each meat. The French fries tasted like the oil hasn't been changed in months. My daughter got a burger the tomatoes were pink and hard, the meat tasted unseasoned and like complete garbage. My girlfriend got a veggie wrap that she struggled to even eat it. However, my son had a great meal cause he ate baby food out of a jar and was lucky to miss the meal we got here. I do not know how someone can own a business and serve slop like that and take people's money and go to sleep at night. The bathroom was dirty, there was pee on the seat, water all over the sink, and the floor was dirty. This is the first time I've ever wrote a review and would not recommend this place to anyone. If I could put negative stars I would. read more

I am familiar with Chicago deep dish pizza, but I haven't loved NY-style thin crust pizza until now. I invited my husband's friends to Atlantic City, and we were visiting Batsto Village in the Wharton State Forest. After finishing our visit, we were hungry and decided to try this little pizza place out. We ordered a couple of different pizzas. I don't recall which one the other pizza was, but one was a white pizza. I have never encountered a white pizza before, but this one was topped with broccoli and cheese with a creamy white garlic sauce. AMAZING. The sizes were larger than we expected, so we ended up taking the other pizza back to our resort. We noticed other patrons were speaking Italian. That's always a good sign when your own community members patronize your business. The service was friendly, and our friend was so pleased with the pizza that she went up to the owner to compliment her food. When we reheated the pizza back at the resort, it was almost as good as when it was served to us at the restaurant. So now I know why my husband raves about East Coast pizza since he lived in NY for a few years. Where can I get this white pizza on the West Coast? Or do I have to order it by mail from the East Coast? read more

The pizza was good I would give it a better rating however I ordered six pies spent over $80 and asked for paper plates and they told me they would have to charge $.10 a plate! Are you serious I just spent $83 buying pizza from your store you can't give me some plates what a disgrace. If I hadn't already paid for the pizza I would've went someplace else! read more

Best wings I think I've ever had. The wood fired pizza is also excellent. If you're in Hammonton you owe yourself a visit

I've been going to Brothers pizza since I was little. The food was great! The waitress with the crazy red hair was so ignorant!!! She will be the reason I or my family will NOT!!! Go back. She stood in the middle of the room and complained about my small order. I wanted to walk out but my husband wasn't comfortable with that. This waitress has been with the pizzeria for years . I think she needs a lesson in manners and customer service. Good luck on your visit. I would order at the counter. read more

Ordered chicken parmigiana, salad and pasta fagioli. Chicken was beaten thin so could not understand why it was uncuttable and tough. Sauce was tangy. Came with a roll made of pizza dough which was doughy. Love my bread and butter but couldn't enjoy this dough. Soup was weak in color, tasteless with crunchy beans. No elbow noodles but sporadic spaghetti noodles chopped in soup. Not ham based. Not representative of a South Jersey pizzeria. read more

Things have gone back to good ol' Brother's Pizza that we are used to. Good job! We love the pizza and the speed of takeout service. Great place to grab a quick, delicious meal. read more

I'd give it zero stars if that was an option. First time we tried it my sandwich came out 15 minutes late and was cold. Second time I tried it the pizza was greasy at best. The third time I ordered a prior to go and it was disappointing in every way. I don't know how they stay in business. read more

This place is classic Italian American fare. Tomato pie, garlic knots, and buffalo chicken cheesesteak are highly recommended. Their specialty pies are usually excellent, too. read more

Best pizza ever! Come here every time we are in town from California to get the best pizza ever. All food here is worth a try not only pizza! Great job read more

I love Brother's pizza! their sausage pie is delicious. sweet slices of sausage. addictive. crisp crust, very friendly in there.

Good, not great pizza. Ordered the special (sans anchovies). The service was efficient for a busy Friday evening. On the positive side, the pizza was cooked perfectly, no soggy bottom and zero burnt crust. Unfortunately, the pie tasted like it had little, if any sauce. The crust was thicker than necessary, especially the ends. Will continue to search for the best Philly/South Jersey pizza. read more

A real hole in the wall pizza shop. I love the pizza and order them all the time. It is a jersey/NY style pizza, with thin, crisp crust, grease, and lots of cheese. It's not for vegans, it's for real pizza lovers. A great price too, a ten and a 1 dollar bill for a large plain pie? Hard to find anymore. read more