Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    C. Thomas Haytmanek Jr., MD

    5.0 (1 review)
    Closed 8:00 am - 5:00 pm

    C. Thomas Haytmanek Jr., MD Photos

    You might also consider

    More like C. Thomas Haytmanek Jr., MD

    Recommended Reviews - C. Thomas Haytmanek Jr., MD

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - C. Thomas Haytmanek Jr., MD

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Vail-Summit Orthopaedics & Neurosurgery - Peter C. Janes, M.D. Hand, Knee, Orthopaedic Trauma, Sports Medicine, Wrist

    Vail-Summit Orthopaedics & Neurosurgery

    3.3(16 reviews)
    0.1 mi

    Going to Vail-Summit Orthopaedics after I dislocated my shoulder was the worst thing that ever…read morehappened to me. I was told there was a 97% recovery rate for my condition and that I'd be back to rock climbing and sports in a number of months. However, both the 1st and 2nd surgeries performed by Dr. Paul Abbot completely failed. My strength and mobility plummeted 80% after my treatment at this facility. I was in FAR better health prior to walking into VSON. They ruined my body. Another surgeon did his best to clean it up a couple years later. He gave me some improvement, but 13 years later I am in crippled agony. I've called a few times over the years to plead for some consideration to my outcomes, but they do not care for that. They are of course happy to see me again, restart the process, and give me another enormous bill, but there is no real sympathy or concern shown for how they ruined my athleticism and left me with chronic lifelong pain at the age of 22. Imagine paying tens of thousands of dollars for this outcome. It genuinely keeps me up at night. That and the pain. Maybe their new doctors are better, but don't be fooled when they say they care about you.

    I had an amazing experience, both with the staff and Dr. Max Suiter. He gave me an injection in my…read morehip within 24 hours of my initial visit. Feeling so much better thank you Vail-Summit orthopedics.

    Photos
    Vail-Summit Orthopaedics & Neurosurgery - Nathan L. Cafferky, M.D. Hip, Joint Replacement & Revision, Knee, Orthopaedic Trauma

    Nathan L. Cafferky, M.D. Hip, Joint Replacement & Revision, Knee, Orthopaedic Trauma

    Vail-Summit Orthopaedics & Neurosurgery - Richard B. Cunningham, M.D. Joint Replacement, Knee, Orthopaedic Trauma, Shoulder, Sports Medicine

    Richard B. Cunningham, M.D. Joint Replacement, Knee, Orthopaedic Trauma, Shoulder, Sports Medicine

    Vail-Summit Orthopaedics & Neurosurgery - William I. Sterett, M.D. Joint Replacement, Knee, Shoulder, Sports Medicine

    See all

    William I. Sterett, M.D. Joint Replacement, Knee, Shoulder, Sports Medicine

    Joel Matta, MD - Joel Matta, MD

    Joel Matta, MD

    4.5(11 reviews)
    0.0 mi

    His surgery permanently damaged my Lateral Femoral Cutaneous Nerve in my right thigh leaving me…read morewith a permanent burning sensation (Meralgia Paresthetica). This is a common result with anterior total hip replacement because the nerve runs in various ways right where the surgery is done. I stressed my concerns during pre-surgery consult. Matta lied to me with witnesses present telling me this will not occur with his surgery because he moves the incision away from the nerve. After I was diagnosed by several neurologists and surgeons Matta stated he does not look for the nerve when he does the surgery. Avoid him and get your hip replaced with the MINI POSTERIOR APPROACH. Do not fall for the hype of the anterior approach. It is dangerous to your nerves!!! Only a $$$ maker for the hip surgeons.

    I am 6 day post op. I had severe arthritis in my left hip & was dealing with lots of pain for…read moreawhile. Dr Matta was referred to me by 4 of my clients, another MD & a recovery room nurse. I have to say the surgery was amazing. I ditched the cane 4 days post op. My PT exercises he has given me gets easier. I do have a lot of muscle tightness & soreness. I way over did it with walking my dog on Friday. So now I have learned to go outside 4 times a day & walk a block & back to keep moving. His anterior approach is amazing. I also found him incredible warm & caring. I highly recommend him to anyone that wants a great surgeon with incredible bedside manner also.

    Photos
    Joel Matta, MD - Hip and Pelvic Reconstruction

    Hip and Pelvic Reconstruction

    Joel Matta, MD - The Steadman Clinic | Vail CO

    See all

    The Steadman Clinic | Vail CO

    Peter Millett, MD Shoulder Surgeon & Sports Medicine Specialist

    Peter Millett, MD Shoulder Surgeon & Sports Medicine Specialist

    3.3(7 reviews)
    0.0 mi

    I had my fifth shoulder surgery with Dr. Peter Millett in July 2024. It is now March 2026…read more Before that surgery, I had already been through multiple procedures from other surgeons that left my shoulder in a severely compromised state and ultimately forced me to retire from being a professional athlete in my 30s. By the time I found Dr. Millett at the Steadman Clinic, I was already at what I would call a code red -- physically, financially, and mentally. I had spent hundreds of thousands of dollars, even with good insurance, trying to fix what had been done to my body. I flew out to see Dr. Millett three separate times, spending thousands more, because I believed I was finally going to someone who would operate with a higher level of care, precision, and commitment to patient outcomes. What I asked for was very clear: I asked him to evaluate and remove the graft placed in 2020 and the BioBrace placed in 2022, because I strongly felt they were causing mechanical issues, inflammation, and long-term wear on my normal tissues. Instead, while I was under anesthesia, Dr. Millett chose to cut my long head of the biceps tendon, despite it being intact and showing no clear clinical signs of pathology. This decision makes no sense to me -- especially given that he knew my short head of the biceps and coracoid had already been compromised in prior surgeries, and that I had ongoing issues related to that anatomy. Rather than addressing the root cause I came to him for, my anatomy was altered again. Now, I'm left with: - A visible deformity in my bicep - Roughly 30-40% loss of strength - Constant pain with quick movements - Pain when lifting, pressing, or even performing basic daily tasks - Persistent popping and clicking in both the front of my shoulder and my shoulder blade - Difficulty with simple things like putting on clothes or carrying groceries Most concerning -- the original issues I came in for were not addressed. I want to be clear about something: I do not blame Dr. Millett for the surgeries done before him. But I do hold him accountable for this: He did not listen to me. After seeing 30-40 orthopedic surgeons over the course of this process, I've noticed a consistent pattern in the field -- a level of ego and overconfidence that often overrides patient input, even when the patient has lived in the body and experienced the problem for years. I understand that surgeons rely on their training and experience. But when a patient is already on their fifth surgery, with a highly complex history, the standard should be higher -- not more aggressive. Another major issue that needs to be acknowledged is the financial structure of orthopedic surgery. This industry generates enormous revenue through procedures, implants, and devices. Patients are rarely made aware of the deeper financial incentives that exist behind the scenes. I am not saying surgeons act with bad intent. But I am saying there is a clear conflict of interest, and patients need to understand that. What concerns me further is that after performing surgery on me, Dr. Millett ultimately referred me to another specialist in Boston. If that level of expertise was needed, I question why that referral didn't happen before I was operated on -- not after. At this point, I am living with the consequences: - Ongoing mechanical dysfunction - Increased pain - Further altered anatomy - And a significant loss in quality of life This review is not written out of anger alone -- it is written to help others. If you are considering surgery: Slow down. Ask more questions. Get multiple opinions. Understand exactly what will be done to your body. Do not assume that experience or degrees or educational institution alone guarantees the right decision. Because once your anatomy is changed, you don't get it back. And never assume that you will come out better. You could be much much worse and then there is nearly nothing you can do about it.

    Very thankful for the opportunity to learn from Dr. Peter J. Millett -- a world-renowned shoulder…read moresurgeon, outstanding scholar, dedicated mentor, and true advocate for patients. As an international visiting surgeon, I was deeply inspired not only by his surgical excellence, but also by his innovation, academic vision, and commitment to teaching. The professional, open, and supportive environment he and his team have created made this experience truly meaningful. With sincere gratitude and respect. Looking forward to future collaboration.

    Photos
    Peter Millett, MD Shoulder Surgeon & Sports Medicine Specialist
    Peter Millett, MD Shoulder Surgeon & Sports Medicine Specialist
    Peter Millett, MD Shoulder Surgeon & Sports Medicine Specialist

    See all

    C. Thomas Haytmanek Jr., MD - orthopedists - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...