Had the lemon chicken soup. Delicious soup! Everything we ate was so yummy!! The desert was also so yummy! We had a baklava with a creamy topping. read more

Totally disappointed in their service, went in and was seated right away, but nobody ever came to our table. I watched another couple get seated, and got service right away while nobody acknowledged our table. I do not recommend. read more

Been going here for 15 years. It had been awhile since the last time but it has diffinatly gone down hill. Service was none existent, food taste was OK but slow and sloppy. Everything has a life span...... read more

Experience was ok. My friend had a hair (looked concerning) in her gyro. We reported it and got a new one which was half off so that was nice. Employees seemed nice. The restaurant was sort of clean. There was a weird sink type thing next to our seats which was gross and green. Anyways I do love this place, the Fort Collins one is better. read more

Right in the heart of Centerra is a Greek gem. Excellent offering of a variety of different gyros. On the West side, it's a step away from what can be an intense shopping experience, in a calm space. Excellent gyros, pastas, salads and even micro brews. read more

Cafe Athens - Beef Gyros - Greek Near Me - Loveland, Colorado

Amazing food! Reminds me of a greek restaurant from the last place i lived! Fries are amazing, especially when extra crispy!

Food: We got the sampler plate for appetizer! The meat was packed with flavor and not too chewy. I loved the spanakopita, the pastry was amazing and the cheese filling was good. The baked pita chips were okay, but they were chewy and not as crispy as I'd have liked. I had the falafel gyro, I liked the tzatziki sauce, it had a good amount of sourness and refreshingness. I needed more falafels, they had only given me three, but they were delicious, crispy on the outside and spiced interior flavor. There was a lot of feta on it, maybe a bit too much for me. I had the pasta orzo for my side which was good, but sort of just tasted like tomato soup with orzo in it. The fries were good, very crispy, and good amount of salt! We had to try the baklava, because I love baklava, and this one did not disappoint, the honey was fully soaked into the phyllo pastry, and the middle section was good flavor too with the nuts. Service: Our server was great, he was very attentive, and the food came out fast, and everyone seemed to be very happy working here. Atmosphere: I liked the seating and the welcoming environment. The kitchen was visible to everyone which is always good to know. Not too loud here either but still busy. Overall: Delicious!! I had a great time here and can't wait to come back to try a few other things. read more

See all

If a restaurant issues coupons then finds ways to go around this, it's disappointing. I bought a lunch meal for $17. Then an appetizer for over $15 and a drink. Then they chose to say they can't honor the buy 1 get the second half off because it's not a main meal? This appetizer cost more than most meals. Beware as well that gratuity is added to the bill. Maybe Monday is the chef's day off as everything from the lamb to the calamari to the tzatziki sauce was bland. Sadly I won't be back. read more

See all

The sliced beef was absolutely delicious! I was glad I ordered the Gyro Platter, which had a good portion of the tasty beef. My wife's Mousaka Platter had some of the same beef, but the mousaka - layers of eggplant, potatoes and ground beef - was very bland, and we wouldn't order it again. My Spinach Rice side was fine; it just tasted like rice. My wife's Pasta Salad tasted like pasta with plain vinegar dumped on it; if that's not your thing, don't order it. No complaints about the service; they kept our drinks filled, and we tipped accordingly. Speaking of drinks, $4.50 each seems awfully high; we had water instead. A BOGO coupon that came in the mail kept the price of our lunch reasonable. I do wish the City of Loveland had not agreed to the PIF and RSF arrangement that results in less money for Loveland and more money for the real estate developer. read more

Cafe Athens - Mousaka Platter - Greek Near Me - Loveland, Colorado

See all

Great food great service. The gyro platter is enough food for two people and is always my favorite. read more

Our steady Resturant for German food the best in Northern Colorado for Gyro beef or chicken

Highly recommend the Greek salad! Hubby got the gyro combo and he liked it. The combo includes a gyro, side, and drink for $15! Try this place out if you're in the mood for Mediterranean. read more

Cafe Athens - Gyro combo - Greek Near Me - Loveland, Colorado

See all

I started writing this review before I even tasted the food. Why? Because the service was excellent. I've wanted to try this restaurant for a really long time, but haven't made it over in the nearly 11 years I've lived in the area. I was in the shopping center for a quick quick return, and wanted to grab a bite without a whole lot of fuss. I decided to see if I could get a to go meal. I was greeted upon entry and was told that to go meal was absolutely possible. I was offered a beverage and a place to sit while I waited. My food came out quickly, and I was pleasantly surprised to see that they did not charge me for the soda. I thought that was a really nice thing to do. Let me tell you that the gyro was AWESOME!! So much good flavor, and perfectly cooked. Don't sleep on this restaurant; I've been missing out for more than a decade! read more

Cafe Athens - Beef Gyros - Greek Near Me - Loveland, Colorado

Café Athens is my go-to when I need a little Greek escape without the plane ticket...or the drama. It's cozy, quick, and somehow always exactly what I didn't know I needed. The service? Friendly without being fake. The vibe? Chill without trying too hard. And the kitchen? Clearly sprinkled with some kind of Mediterranean sorcery. (Best Greek food around!) do yourself a favor and GO...you'll thank me later. read more

We LOVE LOVE LOVE cafe Athens! Everything on the menu is amazing you can't go wrong. The staff is always nice as well!

I went today for takeout at about 2:30pm. I ordered a falafel sandwich and it was mere minutes before it came out ready with friendly service.The falafel itself was ok, the pita was nice and thick and soft. The sandwich came with iceberg lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, and feta. The chunky, raw, red onions overpowered everything ( and I like onions). This sandwich would have been worth the price if the red onions were sliced thin and put through a quick pickle, this is cheap and easy and I do it at home all the time. Tzatziki is essential in a falafel dish IMO, and none was detectable. I looked at the menu afterwards and it says it comes with tzatziki and there are a choice of other sauces. When I ordered no choice of sauce was mentioned. A homemade spicy red sauce, good tzatziki always included unless it's asked to omit, and pickled onions would really improve this sandwich. read more

Everything we ordered was delicious. We shall return at least just for the hummus and pita bread and pita crisps which were phenomenal! Their eggplant souvlaki dish was very good. Their lamb souvlaki was very good. The kids devoured their Greek Pizza. Caveat: This restaurant does not serve "Feta Fries" like they do at the Great Greek Restaurant in Denver. They tried to make it here for us but it wasn't the same. It's not simply feta cheese on crispy fries. It has garlic crispy fries with melted mozzarella cheese and feta sprinkled on top. Overall, our tastebuds and bellies were platelet satisfied. Lord willing, we shall return! read more

See all

Stopped here per request of my daughter. Service was great. The host who took out to go order was super sweet and the food came out so quick! I ordered the grape leaves warm and a falafel sandwich. Both were okay. I can't say I'll go back because it wasn't my cup of tea. The grape leaves were too lemony and the rice was mushy. My falafel sandwich gyro thing the falafel were spicy which is not a usual thing and the stuffing with it just wasn't what I was use to a lot of lettuce tomatoes and some weird sauce. I didn't finish it all but I ate half because I was starving. Overall it's meh but the service was great! read more

I thought the person who answered the phone and took my order was very nice. We were in town for our Dog to be examined at University of Colorado. Wanted something different we ordered Gyros, reg and chicken. Both were fresh and flavorful. Beautiful building and not visible from the road. Tricky to get in to find it. Worth trying to find it. Enjoy,we did! read more

Had a gyro. Hunks of dried up meat with very little sauces and half a head of shredded lettuce. By far the worst gyro I've ever tried to eat. No wonder the place was very empty. read more

Cafe Athens is a great place to go for a quick meal with choices that everyone can get on board with. (They even have hamburgers for the non-Greek food eaters.) My husband and I had some errands in Loveland and needed something quick but not fast foody, and this was a great choice! Not a date night place, but the staff was friendly and efficient. The waiter was willing to share his recommendations, and when I go somewhere new, this is nice to hear. My husband had the Greek Quesadilla and the meat was perfectly seasoned, not too salty, and hot and fresh. I wasn't super hungry so I had the appetizer of Feta in Phyllo and it was just what I wanted. Should I maybe have gotten a salad to be a bit healthier? Sure, but who can resist cheese in pastry dough, hot and melty? Not me! Since we will be returning to Loveland, we will be back to try more of their great offerings. read more

Cafe Athens - Feta deliciousness! - Greek Near Me - Loveland, Colorado

See all

Great service and a taste you won't get anywhere else in Loveland. They've really stepped up their game from an unsavory experience we had with an order a few years ago. These guys deserve every star! read more

Consistently excellent and friendly (and I'm Greek :) I like the spanakopita and gyros

Oh my goodness, the fries here are insanely good! We love the combo platters because everything is so tasty that it's hard to decide. They even make good burgers! The customer service and consistently great food has made us repeat customers for 4 years. The ambiance looks like your typical Greek restaurant decor. It gets busy, especially on weekend evenings, but it's a dependable experience and decent value too, especially when they have coupons. read more

I love a good gyros and this place is always consistently tasty and yummy! The owners are often in the restaurant, staff is friendly and quick with suggestions and service. Even in this new Covid era of weirdness- they have not let me down. Also, they have a wonderful lunch special that includes any gyros, a side and a drink - love it! Definitely stop in for a bite - highly recommend the traditional and veggie gyros! read more

Cafe Athens - Traditional gyros - Greek Near Me - Loveland, Colorado

See all

I really enjoy Gyros, and have had some very legit Gyros in Germany while stationed there, and here in Greeley at another place, but Cafe Athens is by far the worse I've had! I have never had a Gyro that had unshaven meat (lamb generally)- Cafe Athens serves theirs with long thick cut strips of beef, that is just gross and not authentic. The taste of the beef was fake tasting as well. Then we had some balaclava and it tasted old and was gross too! This meal wasn't cheap either, so I am very disappointed and will not eat at Cafe Athens again. read more

Good Greek food. I enjoyed the gyro and salad I got. Mine was traditional with Greek salad and my wife got the chicken gyro and Cesar salad. She liked hers as well. read more

Cafe Athens - Gyro & salad - Greek Near Me - Loveland, Colorado

Pretty tasteless food. Most of it is canned. We only ate here because we were starving, hadn't eaten all day and couldn't manage the drive to ft Collins to go somewhere else. They make very little in-house. (We asked the waiter and he admitted the lemon chicken soup was one of the only things made from scratch; it was okay.) the gyro meat was dry, think beef jerky. What can you say when they serve the yogurt and marinara sauce in plastic to go cups? Potatoes on the moussaka tasted like they came from a mix out of a box. Really. It's NOT a Greek restaurant. Do a pass. Make the drive. Go anywhere, just don't go here. read more

This is WORTH every penny and every mile away. My husband and I drove all the way from Boulder just to visit Cafe Athens. I forgot pictures the first time, and this is our second time...still forgot pictures because it was too damn good to let sit even for a moment. My husband got the traditional gyro- value meal, which comes with a side. Yes they have the stereotypical french fries, BUT- you NEED to order the french fries, they are double fried and worth every single bite. AMAZING. I get the Taziki Nachos every time and can't ever believe they give you a BUTTLOAD! Its like 3 meals in one- with no skimp on the meat. Its a surprise how much meat there is and so filling. The fiesty feta dip is no joke, it is a MUST try and a MUST have- whether it be your meal, or to share with the table. Also the hummus is AMAZING! You can taste the difference from store bought and we absolutely love it. Even dipping it in some of those double fry french fries! In addition the Galo Pie is a must for those who dine-in. I say dine-in because when it comes to you, it is fresh- piping hot, and if you take it to go it would become one glop of whip cream. So it is a must eat only in dine in. We took it to go, and the pastry puff became soggy, whip cream soup, and the custard was luke warm. It truly takes away from the experience. Thankfully the service is FAST. However we went an hour after they opened, only one server- Stephen and almost all tables filled. He did his best! Applaud. He made sure all of his tables were taken care of. So worth the drive from Boulder- will most likely do it again (and I will try and take pictures. The first time, I didn't know what to think since my husband chose and I wanted Italian, I was a bit salty until the food came and I was HOOKED. The second time around, with only one server I was getting pretty hangry, so once the food arrived I didn't even think of picking up a phone for a photo. Woops- third times a charm- I'll be back. read more

I've been here about 5 times in the last three months and every time has been a great experience. Staff is friendly and attentive. The lamb souvlaki is fantastic. Finish your meal off with Greek coffee and baklava. Pro tip: the south facing patio is a great spot to dine outdoors and soak in some rays. read more

This restaurant has an excellent environment, friendly service, great menu choices and really decent food and at affordable prices. We always feel welcomed and pampered by the food and the service. Will be back again. read more

Food was so good. Tender lamb. Zesty tazaki. Galo pie swirl was delicious. Ate way too much. Server (Jesse) was friendly and on top of refills. I had a great experience. I got to try the alemeno (spelling?) Soup. I'll order it next time! read more

I love Greek food so obviously I had to this place while visiting Loveland. I ordered the combo platter and a piece of baklava. The meat was unfortunately pretty flavorless and the baklava was dry. The salad was made up of iceberg lettuce and unripe tomatoes. Would not recommend read more

Ordered lunch for my staff yesterday, through the Cafe Athens website. While delivered, the order was short a full meal and Sprite,. also they substituted our large tabbouleh (salad) for a Greek salad. When I called to get this corrected, I was argued with. I was told we never ordered what I said I had, and that this is what their tabbouleh looks like (lettuce, olives and feta cheese). Additionally, I was told because we had the order delivered, the problem with the order is not the restaurant's responsibility, which caused one of our people to have to run out to get his lunch elsewhere. Worst customer service ever experienced in Loveland area. Definitely the last time I will be spending any more money at Cafe Athens. read more

Great Greek meals. Plus great French that is in their fries. Fresh ingredients with flavors from over the ocean.

Forgot our rice and Tsaziki sauce for a pickup order. Didn't notice until getting home. Bummer

the best gyros in town, the Greek salad was yummy too! My littles loved the fries and we had quick friendly service, especially for a Saturday at lunch time! read more

Cafe Athens - Greek Near Me - Loveland, Colorado

See all

Great service! Wonderful, will be back! Very busy at lunch but the food was great and we were well taken care of.

The people and the food are excellent !!! When you visit make sure to have a gallo pie it's awesome read more

This place is very hard to find - it's literally behind a bunch of other stores. The food was good but the fish part that we ordered was just ok. I do like that they offer a platter of food with a ton of options on it. This way you can sample different things just from ordering one plate. Not sure we would eat there but we would consider ordering the sampler platter to go. read more

See all