According to Yelp, the three-star rating that I am giving to Capitol Hill Baptist Church is a rating of "A-OK!'.... yet my own thoughts on once having been a member of this church are much, much more complicated.
The leaders and the congregation are certainly enthusiastic (in an orderly way) in their love and espousal of Christ's message of repentance and salvation. Being a Baptist church which holds to Reformational, Calvinistic theology, there is a strong emphasis on salvation being "by grace alone through faith alone in Christ alone."
The sermons are expositional in nature, with the preaching tending to be "verse-by-verse" through entire books of the Bible. Regular attenders are encouraged to become members of the church, and members are encouraged to live lives of winsome, joyful evangelism. It's a very warm congregation in many ways. I was actively loved, helped, encouraged, and exhorted by the fellow members during my time at Capitol Hill Baptist Church (also called "CHBC" by many of the members).
There is another side to life at CHBC though, and it's one that can be hard to see *until* one has already become a committed member. The leaders espouse what they call "Biblical church discipline" as one of their so-called "9 Marks of a Healthy Church."
At CHBC, Biblical church discipline means that any person who is a member of the church, and who is found, *by the leaders*, to be in what they consider to be unrepentant sin (according to their interpretation and application of the Bible), can become involved in a process which may result in virtual excommunication from the life of the church.
In theory, as preached from the pulpit, this Biblical church discipline is supposed to end, either with the person's repentance from his/her sin and restoration to full, active life in the church, or with the person's excommunication from the church-- but even in the latter case, the person is *not* supposed to be utterly shunned by the leaders and the congregation.
Again, this is in theory, as preached from the pulpit. In practice though, people who are excommunicated *do* end up being shunned. Many of them lose almost their entire community of friends at CHBC. I saw it happen to people there, and it could be devastating to them.
I understand that the intentions behind the shunning were often probably good. "Tough love." "Force them to face their sin." "Don't coddle them and allow them to feel good in their rebellion." However, the people being disciplined often just ended up being emotionally wrecked.
I was never disciplined while at CHBC. There was never a need. I was a happy and committed member. I did eventually move to a very theologically and ecclesiologically similar church in New Mexico, and I was also a happy, committed member there.
During those years though, I began to read more widely and began to do very serious research into the subject of church history-- well before the Reformation. In particular, I began to read the early Church Fathers and discovered *their* interpretations of Scripture-- readings which often clashed with certain things that I had been taught as being "Biblical" at CHBC and at my new church.
Long story short (or not!)-- after much study and prayer, I became convicted that I needed to return to the Catholic Church, which I had left many years earlier. Due to this conviction, which I acted on, I did undergo a process of "Biblical church discipline" at the church in New Mexico-- *but* I was not shunned by the leaders or the congregation.
However, when news of my "Catholic reversion" began to spread on the internet, and through other ways, I was shunned by the huge majority of my friends from CHBC. Not by all of them, mind you... but by most of them. I was "unfriended," without one word to me, publicly or privately, on Facebook, by the main preaching elder of the church. I was also unfriended by other members of CHBC-- people whom I had worshiped alongside for years and considered to be true friends.
Eventually, I moved from New Mexico back to the Maryland/D.C. area. I continued to be a practicing Catholic Christian-- and continued to be shunned by most of my CHBC friends. The reason for this shunning, as far as I can tell, is that at CHBC, one is taught that "the Catholic Church teaches a false gospel of works-righteousness." The elders at the church literally believe, and literally preach, that if one consistently believes, and consistently practices, what the Catholic Church teaches, then one is, by definition, not a Christian and will, short of "repentance," go to Hell.
This is very important for anyone visiting CHBC to know. The leaders do not consider "consistent Catholics" to be Christians-- and if you are a member of CHBC, and you ever leave for either the Catholic Church or Eastern Orthodoxy, you will not only undergo church discipline at CHBC, but you will quite likely lose most of your friends from the church. Fair warning! read more