LOVE LOVE LOVE their mussels and linguini, clams and linguini, and garlic bread! My parents rave about their sandwiches and salads too. We only do take-out. They give you LARGE portions, and great aluminum trays. I'm actually taking two trays to our annual family reunion today, 8/13/22. Their prices remain reasonable, despite this crap economy, which is truly appreciated! Nice staff as well. read more

We love this place. The food is always amazing. The pizza is great, cheesesteaks super and the staff is alway friendly and helpful. I highly recommend them. read more

The food is always fantastic when I come here. We have not tried the dining area but have only ordered to go. The pizza is great and we are here every week during football season for our pizza and wings. I have tried to go their Ravioli Antonino that is a blush red sauce with tomato and spinach. My boyfriend had gotten the Lasagna which was a big portion. The raviolis pictured are double the size of regular ones and there were 6 along with salad and garlic bread. What stands out is that their garlic bread has minced pieces of garlic and tomatoes and the side salad comes with peppers which is a nice touch versus your average salad. I highly recommend eating here!! Plus the guy Joe was very helpful and there was a girl that usually helps and is friendly, I think her name's Gianna. All around great Italian restaurant to eat at. Thank you for creating superb food and excellent service :) read more

Casa D'Amico - Ravioli Antonino - Pizza Near Me - Stratford, New Jersey

Food is good, there is no denying that. The service is adequate, and the ambiance is that of a nice pizza parlor. But over the recent past prices have increased disproportionately higher than that of similar locations, and they've instituted a 3.5% "service charge" for payment other than cash. But most disappointing is that they have shrunken their portions significantly. During recent visits I've had lasagna, and most recently I had the veal parm entree. Both were shockingly small. I thought the lasagna was small during my prior visit, but I just attributed it to one of those things, but with the recent veal parm experience, you can clearly see that shrinking the portions is part of their strategy to help offset rising costs or decreased attendance. There comes a point where an establishment has to realize what it is (it's a pizza parlor), and too much is too much for what you're getting. I'd recommend looking elsewhere for fare that's just as good and more reasonable in price and portion size. I will be choosing elsewhere for casual Italian from here on in. read more

The food was super good! Authentic Italian the appetizers were hot and the seafood was fresh. Stuffed mushrooms were full of crab meat! Sweet and savory. The calamari was fried perfect and fresh no rubbery texture at all smooth and buttery. The complementary bread was perfect and the peppers to accompany were Devine roasted to perfection. The owner came out and greeted us and checked on us. His entire family was there having dinner and it warmed my heart. All the food is cooked with Italian love. Best Alfredo I have ever had. The stuffed broiled fish was good too. Portions are huge!!! All I needed was wine or a cocktail. (It's BYOB) I'll will only eat at mom and pop Italian restaurants from now on. If the owners not on the premises and he didn't cook something don't even think about it!!! I'll be back for Italian delights again. read more

Casa D'Amico - Calamari and shrimp with butter sauce and breadcrumbs (special) - Pizza Near Me - Stratford, New Jersey

There was a lot of talk about the grandma pie in town, so we finally went and got it for ourselves! It was very good, we liked it better than a normal pie. We'd definitely order it again. The mozzarella sticks were crispy and the tomato sauce is a hearty, tasty sauce. read more

See all

Meat lovers pizza is delicious! Delivery was fast and exceptional . Hands down, best pizza in town!

Went to the restaurant part of Casa D'Amico tonight for my wife's birthday. Dining area was very nice and elegant. Service was just ok. As for my meal I ordered the Shrimp Parmigiana. Menu stated " shrimp dipped in a batter in tomato sauce and then baked to perfection. Well what i got was 5 pieces of shrimp on top of linguini covered with mozzarella cheese. Medium size shrimp. Price $26.95. Very very disappointing. Shrimp was not in a batter or even baked. For the price i would not recommend this place. Waitress did take 10% off the bill. Saved a whole $7. read more

My review is based off of take out and delivery. I have never dined in. This is your neighborhood takeout joint. Very good pizza, sandwiches and pasta. We have ordered everything off the menu but desserts. The calamari is hand cut and breaded. Even though we get it to go it is still yummy. Meatballs are homemade not bought. Portions in their entrees are hefty. I do like the fact they have a separate entrance for their takeout and one for dine in. Pictures will be posted if I can ever take one before we shove the food in our faces. read more

The pizza was very good. The service was great. The ambiance is wonderful. When I am in New Jersey, that's where the family goes.

Great food serviced fresh and hot for awesome prices!! Been a while since we visited there but the place is like going to grand moms for dinner. read more

Grandmas pizza is the best! Shrimp scampi is delicious as well. Best around for delivery. Also beautiful dining area if you choose to do a sit down. read more

Friendly girl answered the phone, that's a plus. But the food .. not so much. And they charge 3.5% fee for using your card? Which had I known about this ahead of time like maybe when I ordered I would have brought cash. The guy that gave me the food wasn't the most pleasant but whatever. When I grabbed the box I thought it was empty. It was so light for having 2 pizza turnovers in it. Then both myself and my daughter thought they smelled funny but we couldn't figure out what it was so we just hoped it was just a smell but it was also a funny taste so I am not sure if something was old or rotten or the sauce was older but something was def off. We shared a turnover and there was about half of it left bc we just couldn't keep eating it. The old bay fries however were pretty decent. read more

Best food ever. Service is not always the best, but the food makes up for that. Cute little restaurant

We got penne alla vodka (which comes with a side salad and garlic bread) and chicken parm sandwich with onions. We've gotten the vodka sauce here in the past and it was addictive. Today the sauce tasted delicious as well but not the same. The chicken parm wasn't bad- it was a little bland. Overall food was tasty! read more

See all

Great food. Great pizza. Nice family run business that is very popular in town. They get super busy on weekends.

We have been dining here regularly for the past 6 months. Just moved into the area. We have loved everything we got. Love all their pasta dishes. Love the taste of their gravy. They serve peppers and pizza bread at your table, very good. Service is great. Very clean place. My new favorite place. read more

A neighborhood gem! The food is always fresh and delicious! The staff is great, especially Anne Marie and Jackie! The owner Vinny always comes out to greet everyone! The menu is huge! There is so much to recommend, Calamari, veal dishes and the aged ribeye steak is read more

We stopped in on a road trip to get a decent meal after a day of traveling, and were so glad we did! We had a lovely dinner. Objectively, I've had better Italian food, but this was pretty darn good! They have all the basics you'd be looking for- pizza, linguini, fettuccini, eggplant parm, gnocchi, salads, and some great sounding specials with crab and lobster. The garlic bread with peppers in tomato sauce was great! I never eat restaurant bread, but I didn't miss out on this one! The portions were large. Our servers were lovely and took great care of us. read more

Absolutely delicious from start to finish! I live almost 40 minutes away, but go as often as possible due to the authenticity of the food. The atmosphere is clean and very friendly, rarely do i have an unused dish or utensil left on the table, and the waitstaff pays attention without disrupting. Bathrooms are clean as well. 5 out of 5 stars, every time. read more

Casa D'Amico - Last nights dessert - Pizza Near Me - Stratford, New Jersey

As soon as I walked in, I felt so welcomed. This family owned business has such a friendly staff and the restaurant is very clean. Now, let's get to the food. From the soup and salad to the main course, I couldn't stop saying "This is sooo good!" I ordered penne a la vodka and it was delicious! I will be a regular here and I can't wait to try the rest of their menu. read more

Casa D'Amico - Pizza Near Me - Stratford, New Jersey

Well, this wasn't the best investment of my money. I decided to get the lasagna which came with a side salad and garlic bread. No complaints with the garlic bread or the sauce they use or even the customer service. The food is lacking and if you're going to charge people $13 for lasagna can you please make sure it looks like lasagna I'm going to post exactly what they gave me. read more

Casa D'Amico - Side salad - Pizza Near Me - Stratford, New Jersey

See all

My fiance and I loved our pizzas from Casa D'Amico! We've been meaning to try dinner from our local restaurant and decided that during the pandemic would be a great way to support small business. My cauliflower pizza with peppers and onions was INCREDIBLE- the crust was thin and crispy, not at all cauliflower-like. My fiance doesn't like cheese and they correctly made his goofy "pizza" with just sauce and pepperoni as requested. The kind counter folks were pleasant and quick to pick up from too. We'll definitely be ordering from here again soon so it's still around after the pandemic! :) read more

Would I recommend this place ABSOLUTELY!! We probably eat here once a week. Either take out for pizza or eating in. The food is excellent!! Well tonight was my birthday. So my husband arranged w the owners son to surprise me with a dessert and candles. Well he came out with ice cream on top of brownies with candles in them, and he sang to me. I was completely surprised. It's things like this that make us come back to a place. Also we love to support small business read more

Casa D'Amico - Surprise birthday dessert! - Pizza Near Me - Stratford, New Jersey

Great stuff. I've tried about a dozen different items and they all rock. Nice people. Go here!!

Delicious food; the pasta was cooked to perfection. Me and my wife enjoyed our dinner and dessert here. We will definitely be back soon!

Closest thing I have come to for pizza coming from North Jersey. Chicken and meatball parm sandwiches huge and delicious.

This is a good place for pizza but faulty advertiseing for there brownies I bought a browny for 5:95 and I only got one I thought it was was a pan for 5:95 read more

Had a party last night for my wife's birthday and had a great experience. The food was excellent and Vinnie the owner was very accommodating and continuously checked on us throughout the night. I noticed a review mentioning a case of beer being in sight. Friday night the day before the party, we dropped off beer and wine so we didn't have to worry about bringing everything the day of. I'm sorry that they may have seen my byob liquor that was meant for us the next day but this place and most other family owned restaurants in the area are byob. Would definitely recommend this place this restaurant for dinner or a small party. read more

Started out good. Bread drinks roasted peppers came out right away. Waited about 15 mins to place order. Waited about 20 mins for soup which was good. Salad next. Then waited a long time for our mussels and clams dinner. Hubby had red sauce he said it was good. I had white sauce. Mine was bland. No flavor of clam no wine no garlic. All in all we were there 2 hours and 20 mins. Mostly waiting for service, food and then our check. One waitress was running around like a nut while the other was sitting down chatting with what appeared to be family. I would be ok with the wait if the food was worth it. read more

Nice little place got two grilled chicken Caesar salad's kind of pricey for just lettuce and chicken however the chicken was clean and there was a lot of it would've liked to of seen maybe some Parmis on cheese slices for $10 a pop seemed kind of blah staff was very cordial seemed like a place that has been open for quite some time I'd probably tried again but I don't think I would go out of my way to get there read more

The best Italian food and neighborhood bistro I've ever experienced... I'm from NY and so is the owner. First time I tasted their food I thought it was authentic NY style Italian pizza and food, and i was right! But with their own unique style and quality , very well done and always good consistent service. It doesn't get any better than this and I've been everywhere. I order at least a handful of times a month. It's fast it's local and you cannot find any better within a 20 mile radius or more! read more

staff were very rude, including grace. it was a very small premises and looked dirty. the food was good, but i found multiple hairs and i am very sure that they did not even clean the salt, pepper, cheese, or garlic shakers. they looked dirty. i do not recommend, i was trying to eat with my friends and they told us all to leave while we were ordering THEIR food. read more

This place is great!! What a gem! How could I have gone so long without going here! Came here for dinner on a Saturday, and they were fairly empty. We were seated right away and I ordered the lamb rack special, and my mom got the tortellini in a cream sauce. As we were waiting, the owner/chef came out to talk to us for a bit. What a great guy! We chatted for quite awhile, and kept checking in once we got our food to make sure everything was to our liking. The lamb was perfect! So tender and a great flavor! My mom's pasta was also spectacular, The cream sauce was done very well! To end the night, the owner gave us free cannolis! Perfect ending to a great meal! Highly recommend, and will be coming back! read more

Casa D'Amico - Pizza Near Me - Stratford, New Jersey

Ordered three dinners from here for pickup tonight around 630/700. This used to be our go-to for hearty pasta dinners that wasn't just some run of the mill generic Italian sandwich shop (which we have a glut of in this area). This was the last night we'll order, however. It wasn't so much the mediocre food but the atrocious service we received afterwards. I was sitting next to the person who placed the order - 1 meatball sadwich/extra sauce, Gnocchi Blush Sauce, and Penne blush sauce/side of sausage. Pretty stock order. My dad brings it home and - there's a sausage sandwich instead of meatball. The gnocchi platter didn't have much food at all, but I just assumed they'd decided to cut back portions. The flavor was bland. Mom thought her penne was passable. Garlic bread received had raw garlic on it, which is weird. I called D'Amicos pretty soon after we discovered the error to let them know that they sent us someone else's sandwich and to see if they would send us out a new one. The gentleman on the other end argued with me, telling me that the lady he spoke with definitely ordered it. I advised him no, that was not the case, as I heard her order it. I asked for another to be delivered and he initially asks if I'd be comfortable with a 20-30m wait. I agree. He says he'll have it done in 5 if I just come get it. No - I won't. He argues with me again, this time telling me it will be a 45 min wait for delivery. I still agree and we confirm my address. It's now 1105pm and we're still waiting for the sandwich. I'm remaining hopeful we'll get it in time for New Year's. Here's the thing. Even if you're 100% convinced that you and your perfect ears heard something that did not in fact happen - you are a business dependent on customers. I don't care what bad day you had, if you feel bloated or if you burnt the ravioli. I paid for food that didn't come out right AND I even came to get it from you. Just drop off another sandwich and keep the repeat business. Damn. Edit: my dad spoke with the owner a few days later and fulfilled his promise of bringing the sandwich back. They had a wonderful chat and resolved the issue. My dad says he's pleased with how the conversation went and feels good about the interaction. read more

Great Italian food! Gravy is good. Prices are reasonable. They only complaint I would have is the wait before a server came to ask us what we wanted to drink. Not one bad thing to say about the food. It was delicious!!! I recommend chicken Parmagiana, gnocchi, veal parmagiana, spaghetti with oil and garlic. read more

Wonderful small 100% family owned and run. Paid attention to all our needs ..very personal.Excellent "Seafood Trio" new year's eve special was exquisite. .scallops.large shrimp.and crab meat..blush sauce over Penne. How can you top this place if you love Italian.. plus BYOB! I love veal and the Saltimbocca was mouth watering delicious. .check my picture out. 5 star plus in every aspect.. the Tiramisu was perfect and delivered with a candle for my wife's birthday :-) read more

See all

Excellent service, food was amazing and a warm ambiance. We will absolutely be visiting again! read more

Casa D'Amico - Pizza Near Me - Stratford, New Jersey

It used to good. But recently for few months, their food is very greasy. Not good quality anymore.

I have been ordering from here and eating inside for several years... Tonight I received the worst service and food!! Over and hour wait for tortellini Alfredo that was cold as ice! And only a child's portion.... #disappointed Recently received feedback from your staff which did not satisfy my complaint of the last service received, by ur staff! Like above states ordered delivery n eat in for several years... Until this recent order, we hv been excellently surprised! This was a complete disappointment! COLD TORTELINI plate size for a child & over an hour wait for delivery! And I am precisely correct in stating it was Ur Casa D'amico. Unfortunately ur response was spiteful and insulting to a used to be long time customer. It was constructive criticism which could help ur service... That you care nothing of! read more