I'll start this off by saying I am NOT an Italian food fan including pizzas, pastas, etc but my husband is. We swung by after seeing this restaurant while going to a restaurant next door. To satiate his cravings we got a serving of fried mushrooms, cannoli, and a meatball sub. I didn't expect much as I'm not a usual fan, but I can say with my trial bite for this review that it's very delicious. The sub is NOT overwhelming with the sauce which is what usually puts me off for subs. It's the perfect balance between tangy and savory without locking my jaw. You can never go wrong with fried mushrooms and their cannoli custard was delicious. Service was quick and they were very welcoming when we walked in. Great place, if you love American Italian food you'll love this spot! read more

See all

Great little pizza spot! Pizza was loaded with toppings and very fresh, Philly cheesesteak was also good and paired well with their French fries which were perfectly crispy! Friendly employees! Will be back :) read more

Casa Mia Pizzeria - Steak and cheese sub - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, North Carolina

See all

Fresh ingredients. Slice was packed with flavor. Kind service. Nice and clean interior. Plenty of seating. read more

Casa Mia Pizzeria - Cannoli - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, North Carolina

See all

Delicious NY style pizza. We had pepperoni and a Buffalo chicken. Great crust with crunchy and chewy parts. The buffalo was balanced and not too spicy. Best pizza of our trip! read more

This was a great place to grab a couple quick slices at the end of a long day! We stopped in about an hour before they closed and got their 2 slice & a drink special and added a side salad. The pizza slices are ginormous! I got the pepperoni and was not disappointed. Food came out quick too. read more

See all

Very good subs! They offer pizza by the slice, instead of having to buy a whole pizza. The tiramisu was great as well!!!!!!!!!!! I think it was be a great place to bring the family or for date night. Is a little on the expensive side. read more

Casa Mia Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, North Carolina

I love their pizza it's perfectly foldable and delicious. Great customer service and super quick delivery. I haven't eaten in the restaurant just had pizzas delivered but I would absolutely recommend casa Mia for the perfect slice!!! read more

The people were nice. We recently moved to the area and were looking for a nice pizza place. The pizza and wings were ok nothing great. Will try again soon read more

I walked in as they just opened. The place is clean all the way through. The price isn't bad for what you get. This is your pizza slice Italian joint. Everyone was friendly that was working there. I ordered 2 slices as it was just lunch. I don't know what they do different but the flavor was different from most. It was nice and hot and had a good crisp. I'll be back to try other items here as I enjoyed the atmosphere. read more

Casa Mia Pizzeria - Pepp slices - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, North Carolina

Best pizza in town, services always a pleasure. The place is clean and welcoming. How can you go anywhere else. We are from NYC originally and I can tell you this pizza takes me back home every-time. This place is a must visit. I wouldn't go anywhere else for pizza or burgers, they have a whole menu. Enjoy read more

Broken chairs but st least the employees where constantly doing something. Either cleaning or prepping. Food was ok. $5 foe a slice of pizza seems steep. The sub my husband got had little meat. It was over $30 for 2 people 2 drinks 2 slices of pizza, deep fried ravioli, and 1 sub. Not sure if we would visit again. read more

See all

The food is delicious We use pick up so nothing about service or ambiance The subs are on soft buns which I prefer over crispy ones read more

Good portions for price Food was delicious The staff were very kind and welcoming Definitely will come here again and highly recommend it! read more

I wish I could be rating the food, but I didn't even get the opportunity. I ordered over the phone, and when I gave my address, the person taking my order said it was far, but confirmed that they could still deliver after I ask if it was outside of their delivery zone. An hour later, I get a call that my address is too far and that my order won't be delivered. Mind you, I'm only a 15 minute drive away from the restaurant, and less than a mile outside of what the apparent delivery boundary is. I'm a new mom with newborn twins, and waiting that long for my order only to find out it's not coming is extremely frustrating. When I expressed these frustrations and asked for confirmation of my refund and maybe a coupon for the next time I try and come pick something up from the actual restaurant, I was told that all they could offer me is 10% off my next order. I don't feel that that rights their mistake enough for me to make the effort to give this place a chance, especially because my address was initially confirmed as deliverable during the ordering process. 10% doesn't even feel like an apology. I was really excited to try this place because it has such great reviews, but I won't be anymore. Y'all were all very nice, but the customer service effort needs work. read more

We've been ordering from this pizza spot since we moved here in 2022. So good! So far we've tried: Pepperoni with onions & mushrooms, cheese, white pizza, honey bee, chicken bacon ranch, garlic parm wings & the chicken/steak phillys. Never disappoint. The staff are so kind too. read more

Staff very friendly , awesome service . Our go to for pizza . Today we had a 14 inch with pepperoni and extra cheese ! It was good . Bless you guys read more

I was looking for a really good pizza spot, so I decided to give this place a try. When I walked in I was gretted with friendly smiles and a welcoming atmosphere. The place looked really clean which was also a plus, I ordered the 2 cheese slices and a drink special, which was one of many specials to choose from. When I got it the cheese was bubbly hot, I had to wait a few minutes to dig in and the wait was worth it because those cheese slices were delicious, the only negative was that the pizza crust at the edge was a little too crispy but other than that it was awesome!! read more

It's the best pizza in town hands down . I don't know if they get the flour they use to make the pizza dough maybe Cisco but it's good. This is the only place that nails a good sour dough pizza and manages to make it thin . Dough is crispy and chewy with just enough water ratio to allow for the customer to reheat in the oven when they get home or the next day. Every other pizza joint in this area tastes exactly the same read more

For one the staff is friendly and amazing!! Prob one of the best local pizza places in town! Not a chain! I'd choose this over any chain in this town. They have really great pizzas. Something for everyone.. tonight I got supreme pizza my son wanted ham.. and the garlic knots they sent us free for doing an online order were so cute and sooo good!! I also got fried mushrooms which hit the spot!! Gotta support local and this place is amazing!! Try it once I'm sure you won't go anywhere else.. great food made by great folks read more

See all

The best garlic knots since I've left New York. Service is ALWAYS friendly and light hearted. Pizza is well made and always has fresh ingredients. A definite must go! Keep up the good work guys! Another dozen knots to go please! read more

the pictures do not do this place justice! the food was fantastic and the staffs customer service was phenomenal! whoever made the garlic knots on 2/23 needs their badussy ate!! my bf hates pizza and he absolutely loves this pizza!! 10/10 recommended! we will definitely be back! read more

Good food. Reasonable prices. Staff very friendly. I even went there about 20 minutes before they opened once and the owner was loading some stuff through the front door and invited me in and served me even before they opened! read more

The food was really good what we ate and salad and heros we ate me and my wife . The services was terrific very on top of what ever we needed they handled it right away we did no waiting what ever we asked for great help there The ambiance the place was beautiful place to come and eat at all the time the place is very very clean place the owner came over to our table when he heard we where from New York long island and welcome us to his place he was very nice down to earth gentleman and told us anything else we need or want please ask and they will get for us we enjoyed everything about the place the places of the food where not at all Expensive at all they where about the same as they are in New York shout out to jay pizza and everyone that works there all where great very friendly and me and my wife cant wait to go back and enjoy there great food hats off to jtpizza great job joe g and jodi g read more

We are from New York long island aka friendlyjoe my wife and I went to try the pizza place food and we enjoyed the pizza it was very good with the hero's we ate as well . All the help all where kind very nice and helpful and the owner just was very nice very friendly and was very happy in meeting us and took very great care of us and the foster of the food wasn't that bad at all in the prices we paid for so from Jodi and Joe we will be back there to enjoy the place .. read more

Ordered online for delivery. The pizza arrived hot and the crust was crispy. They used fresh vegetables as well. Really excellent pizza!

After mOnths of ordering from them weekly the owner has stated I'm outside of the delivery radius. They are exactly 10 minutes away from me. This has saddened me to no end. Regardless- ---it's one of 2 things I'm happy to eat here in Jacksonville. And they're open 7 days a week. I always get BYO extra cheese, extra oil. With my sprinkling a little red pepper flakes and garlic powder on it I'm doing a happy dance like I'm 4 yrs old. 5 handclaps. read more

My husband gets a cheesesteak from here every Friday and he loves it, the customer service is amazing, Bonnie is always happy and So nice

There food is very good there service is great weather you pick it up or have it delivered. It is always hot and fresh and the staff is very friendly. There is plenty of parking also handicap parking would recommend them to anyone read more

The pizza, wings, desserts and salads are delicious. If you get fries to go, ask to leave the lid open so they won't get soggy. However, the prices have gone up so much that I walked out the last time I went to order 2 slices of pizza. I bought a pie from Dominoes instead. read more

Where has this place been?! We passed it a few times and didn't think of stopping in, but we now live in regret. Thankfully, we decided to order a little bit of everything off the menu for a fun night in! - - Knots - Cannoli - Cheesecake - and meatballs - Wings - Fried Ravioli - Fries - Salad That homemade marinara sauce is ridiculous! Please, bottle and sell it. Absolutely delicious! Pizza, spaghetti was great! That fried ravioli order was not enough! Next time we are ordering two! Wings were hot and tasty; knots were garlicky and delicious! The salad was a nice size portion along with the random order of fries! The cannoli was crispy and delicious! Service was fast, pleasant and the place was immaculate! Do yourself a favor and stop by! Support small businesses! - This place is worth it! read more

We became pizza snobs for lack of better words a few years ago while living in Florida. We don't do chains and are always in search of a good local place for pizza night when we move. We relocated to Jacksonville recently and tried a different local restaurant I see recommended often and were not impressed. My friend told me to check out Casa Mia and I'm SO glad we did. The staff is so friendly and efficient and the food was amazing. Seriously, the guy working today was one of the nicest people I've met since moving here. We had the fried pickles and ordered two pizzas, the bruschetta and chicken ranch. We couldn't pick a favorite. They were kind enough to bring out an order of complimentary garlic knots and those were delicious as well. We just found our new spot. read more

See all

This has to be the worst tasting pizza I have ever tried. To start off, I ordered a 14" pizza with sausage and beef topping and requested extra sauce and extra cheese. When the pizza was ready, I could already tell by looking at it and looking at the old pizza slices in the display that I did not get extra sauce or cheese on the pizza. On top of that, it cost nearly $24 because I guess I did get charged for the extra cheese and sauce. Even so, $24 is kind of ridiculous for a pizza this size from a place like this. Regardless, I took it home and ate some of it. It was the most bland tasting pizza you can imagine. I won't go so far as to say it tasted bad, just super bland. I gave this place one chance and that's it. I'll never go there again. They honestly must be paying the people that wrote good reviews on them. read more

I love the crispiness of this pizza joint. It's my go-to in Jacksonville. I'd take this pizza even over Abbruzos. I wish you could order through Grubhub, but they can be ordered for delivery through their online website. I've picked up before, and the staff are extremely friendly. read more

Love the pizza and the staff. Delivery is right on time. Can't beat the quality, quantity and price! My favorite place!!!!!!! read more

Best pizza in town in my opinion and they are VERY customer service oriented. Regularly order from them.

This was fantastic! I'm originally from the east coast and this was like original north end pizza in Boston. Authentic Pizza oven, not an impinger oven. Real cheese and an amazing dough that is cooked crisp. Wow! Best pizza I have had in years! read more

Casa Mia Pizzeria - Pepperoni and Sausage, Mushrooms and Olives - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, North Carolina

See all

Best calzone/ranch you'll ever have. I used to get the pizza but i think they change the recipe (pizza snob from NY, sorry). Great spot, great service. Staff is always nice! read more

Food was great, ordered a supreme pizza. Crust was thin and crisp but not to crisp. Service was also excellent. We ate here so had the opportunity to interact with the associates. Very nice group of people, very attentive to anything we needed I highly recommend and we will be back read more

Best pizza in Jacksonville but I'd recommend the pepperoni pizza rolls! Staff are always very friendly and the spaces inside are very clean.

Great pizza, crispy crust, salads are good and meatball sub was best I've had in some time, well worth a visit