Castaldo CPA

I can't say enough good things about Newton Sankey & Co! They have been our accounting firm for…read morethe past 10 years and have helped us grow as a company in so many ways. George has helped me make sound financial decisions for both my personal and business accounts. I highly recommend Newton Sankey & Co for your accounting needs!!

From the owner: George J. Sankey CPA PC is a Miller Place, NY Accounting firm that takes your business seriously…read more We understand your financial and business needs and will work to resolve all financial problems.

Covati & Janhsen

4.3

(6 reviews)

Mark is very professional. Went through everything with me for my taxes. And explained…read moreeverything perfect

I had great experience in prior years but this year is different. I dropped off our tax documents…read moreon Thursday March 5th and usually about 2 weeks to be completed as we were told in prior years. We received a call on Friday March 20th by one of their office staff that our return was ready to be picked up. My husband, son and I went to sign and pick up our tax forms and thought we would be receiving our IRS return roughly 2 weeks from picking up our forms. It is now Monday March 30 almost April and our return was never sent to the IRS by their office and this I only found out because I had logged on to the IRS website to check on our refund but they did not have our information so I called Covati and Janhsen and that's when they said it was never sent to the IRS. So if I didn't check the IRS website for our refund, I would have never known my return wasn't filed. I trusted their office with our documents and return yet our forms just sat somewhere in their office without being filed and without even a call. If I didn't call them who knows how long before our return would have been sent to the IRS if even at all. So disappointed unfortunately we will not be returning.

Rossman Tax Service

3.8

(13 reviews)

Have been working with Rossman Tax for over 25 years. They are patient, kind, helpful, and…read moreunderstanding. We wouldn't have anyone else prepare our taxes.

These people are fan frigging tastic. I don't know what I did before without there quick turn…read morearound. And always getting me thousands back in federal and state returns.

R&G Brenner Tax + Accounting

4.2

(5 reviews)

Met with senior tax accountant Mr. Juan Gonzalez and we are very pleased with his knowledge and…read moreexperience. Would recommend this tax preparation service.

Amy Runnalls is an amazing person to work with. She prepares taxes at this location. She is damn…read moregood at her job and works her tail off. She is taking on new clients in the up coming tax season. Once u find a good accountant, tax preparer, friend good with taxes (what ever you want to call it) you build a relationship and you find yourself returning years to come. And trust me Amy is the best of the best. The company she works for is great and has awesome new client deals! Call up the selden office to find out all the deals Jan -April . Even if your behind a couple years they helped me with that and I couldn't be more grateful. Oh and trust me this company is cheaper than H&R Block!!

Soloway Agency

2.8

(5 reviews)

I've been a customer of Soloway Agency for over 20 years and can't say enough about their customer…read moreservice and attention to detail. I usually don't leave reviews but David and his team are fantastic and deserve a much higher yelp rating.

I have been using their services since 1996. They are registered with the BBB and will appear with…read moreyou in the event of an audit. I have been very happy with their services and even though I have moved 700 miles away, I continue to use their services still. I didn't know they did that, until after I moved and spoke to David. It is very convenient for me to mail them my paperwork and I'm confident my taxes are prepared by true professionals. My tip is that you should call early to make an appointment, because they do book up solid, fast.

Alfred F. DiCanio CPA, PC

Been going to Alfred for almost 3 years, hes's the best & honest, I'll never go anywhere else.read more

Great Experience. Honest and Informative. Alfred gets you as much money on your return as possible…read more Alfred goes over all your deductions and asks you questions that maybe you didn't think about you could write off. Just Awesome and Not Stressful. Recommend Highly.

Computer Guy Next Door

(22 reviews)

effective, honest, and efficient. My portable hard drive was damaged and he successfully repaired…read moreit very quickly.

Cleaned up my massively infected laptop in one day- not the easy way by erasing everything- the…read moreright way. Thorough, timely, great communication during repair, and fair price. This should be your go to place. Thank you Mike.

Global Employment Solutions

Global Employment Solutions has helped me find work. No matter how many times a week I called, to…read morecheck in, my recruiter, Shawn Ball has always been welcoming. I like getting a response, so whether it was a yes or a no to having work for me, my questions were always answered right away. I was placed in friendly, respectable work environments and was treated equally and not just as a "temp". I felt as if I was cared for to an extent because Shawn would either call or send me an email asking how everything was going & that I was comfortable at the assignment. I recommend Global Employment Solutions to anyone I know who is looking for work.

Organize Your Life

3.8

(4 reviews)

Cynthia was recommended to me by a dear friend and am so glad she was. I was six months into a new…read morerole and working from home. My goal with Cynthia was to help me set up and organize my new home office. WOW I got so much more. She helped me get rid of so many books and unnecessary papers. I am so organized now and love, love my new home office space. Thanks Cynthia!

I decided to hire a professional organizer when I finally realized I needed help to go through…read moreyears of accumulated things and I didn't know where to begin. Cynthia is a talented, experienced and hardworking professional organizer. She is passionate about her work and I can tell cares deeply about her clients. She knows that "getting rid of stuff" can be painful and difficult for many. With a compassionate and friendly personality she will guide you along at your own pace. The results can be life changing and I love my new organized home!

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

7 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Sean L.

2 months ago

I was a client of Castaldo CPA for several years. If the firm's response is that I am no longer a client, that is true, but only because my account was transferred away from their firm. In March, shortly before tax deadlines, I was informed that my account would be handled by another CPA firm as part of what was described as a merger. I was told: "We've spent the better of last year vetting him/going over our clients with him, so he's well equipped to handle it. We'll still be involved but ultimately, he will be preparing the returns/signing them as the preparer." As a client, I relied on those representations when deciding to remain with the successor firm. Unfortunately, my experience after the transfer was disastrous. Tax matters that should have been handled professionally were not. Communication became increasingly difficult, payments continued to be collected, and eventually my calls, emails, texts, and portal messages went unanswered altogether. I later learned that similar complaints about communication and client service had already been publicly posted about the successor firm before my account was transferred. The consequences have been significant. I have spent substantial time, money, and effort trying to untangle issues that arose after the transfer and am now working with new professionals to address problems that should never have occurred in the first place. My concern is not simply that my account was transferred. My concern is that clients were asked to place trust in a successor firm that Castaldo CPA stated had been thoroughly vetted. My experience did not reflect that assurance. Choosing a CPA is one of the most important financial decisions a person or business can make. Mistakes, missed filings, and lack of communication can have serious tax and financial consequences. Based on my experience, I would strongly encourage prospective clients to carefully consider how client transitions are handled before placing their trust in this firm. read more

Johura Begum ..

1 year ago

I recently returned for tax preparation and had a great experience. The service was smooth, professional, and everything was handled with care. They took the time to explain things clearly and made sure all the details were accurate. The value for the service is excellent, and the quality really stands out. I left feeling confident and well taken care of. Definitely recommend to anyone looking for dependable tax help. read more

Andy R.

11 years ago

James has been a great coach in providing great advise toward maximizing my tax benefits for my automotive business. I would recommend james not only for my business but as my personal financial consultant. James is an outstanding CPA. read more

JJ L.

11 years ago

I highly recommend James to everyone that wants affordable price for a quality job! nice and supportive stuff and since then i never had a problem filling taxes;they really know the Job and the get it done right!! read more

Jennifer M.

11 years ago

BEST ACCOUNTANT EVER!!!!!!!!!! The service is exceptional! I've tried the rest but he is the best!! Been doing my taxes for five years now and wouldn't have it any other way!! read more

Michele D.

100

5 years ago

Great experience. Attentive to all my concerns. Great great company, I recommend to use them.

Kelly H.

10 years ago

Local, pleasant, affordable, quick. No complaints.

Castaldo CPA - accountants - Updated August 2026

People found Castaldo CPA by searching for…

People who viewed Castaldo CPA also viewed

Hoffman & Bentovim

3.7

(3 reviews)

called to discuss a question regarding a 529 savings account . He was EXTREMELY rude and…read moredismissive with his reply. I'm not even a client Haha.. Just imagine how he is with actual paying clients. Steer clear , totally un professional, invest your money with someone who actually cares and is willing to give you the time of day to answer a question.

Highly recommended. Hoffman and Bentovim have been doing my personal and business tax returns for…read moreover 20 years. They do my kids returns too now that my children are grown. I have found their advice helpful and accurate. Their projections for our LLC's estimated taxes especially helpful.

Value Tax Services

3.0

Horrible experience. Tax preparer ("Sam") is not a certified accountant. My 2024 return was done…read moreincorrectly and I have been paying IRS charges ever since my taxes were done. This has been a complete NIGHTMARE. Avoid this tax preparer at all costs!!!

I went here to do my taxes for the second year in a row. They are great people that always treat me…read morenice. They got me my full refund for a very affordable price.

Andreola Tax & Accounting

Wonderful and professional experience. My taxes were done in a quick and detailed manner. They are…read morefriendly and knowledgeable and are highly recommended

Linda M. Eicholz, CPA

Linda M Eicholz CPA 3771 Nesconset Hwy. Ste 102B…read moreSouth Setauket, NY 11720 Linda@Eicholzcpa.com Office Phone (631)331-4369 Office Fax (815)550-8817 After using Turbo Tax for many years, CPA's before then after Turbo Tax ...I'm so happy my wife and I found the best of the best of Certified Public Accountants Linda M Eicholz... There are plenty of good CPA's but then again there are best of the best ones out there too and we found the best CPA's. Linda M.Eicholz CPA listens to your concerns and answers your questions you may have. She works hard using most current technology and her so many years of schooling, knowledge, experience of all the tax laws. Linda M. Eicholz CPA is a Business, Professional and Personal certified experienced Accountant, she has the intelligence to get the correct figures in the right boxes, any write offs, earnings all your information needed to get you the best trusted correct tax return form filled out according to the laws of our greatest country in the world, "The United States Of America." I'm very confident anyone seeking a great excellent intelligent CPA that has the experience to properly and honestly get your yearly taxes done right you will love to have Linda M Eicholz CPA to assist you getting your taxes done 100% accurately...

I had a client request an accountant who is patient and willing to explain the tax laws and rules…read more I gave them Linda's name. Several months later I met with the clients and they raved about Linda. Thank you!

Seader Fitzgerald Cpa's CPA

Jeff is both thorough and trustworthy. I would highly recommend him with all of your accounting…read moreneeds

They have been doing my taxes for about 10 years! I even moved out of state and still use them!…read moreThey are amazing!

Wagner & Zwerman

Vincent Preto is the best! The firm has been doing our taxes for years. The company was originally…read morerecommended to us and we could not be happier with their competence as CPA's and their patience with our questions.

Educators Tax Management

Great service, efficient, honest, found us breaks the others missed.. found our new tax guy after…read moreseveral YEARs of disappointing returns.. give him a call, you won't be disappointed.

Best Tax guy for teachers, knows everything that a teacher is able to claim and does it for a great…read morevalue. Have recommended Kevin, to many people and they have recommended him. Once you use Kevin, you will never leave!

Ed Murphy and Company

4.6

(18 reviews)

Fantastic team to work with. Been a customer for over 20 years. Ed and his team are knowledgeable,…read moretrustworthy and stand behind their work.

Great company and I highly recommend them for personal and corporate taxes! Staff were extremely…read moreprofessional.

Weisman & Co CPA's

3.7

(3 reviews)

I used Lanny Weisman for my accounting, however, it turned to be a nightmare after I signed the…read moreretaining contract with him. Fits he told me that he was half way of the work after one month ands asked me to pay him. Several months later, he still said only half way after collect nearly all payment. Then he asked for more money and said it's too much work, and left me in the middle of nowhere

Lanny Weisman is one of the most professional and kind people I have ever had the pleasure of doing…read morebusiness with.

JAD Accounting Solutions