One of the last old school pizza joints on Long Island and it happens to be in Cherry Grove! Service is commensurate with a gay beach town. IYKYK. Food quality is always consistent and always look forward to pizza on the weekends! read more

I've eaten at and from a lot of pizzerias and this is by far and away one of my favorite. The pizza is amazing, the staff could not be friendlier, and there is so much to enjoy there. Pair that with the location and you simply have a winning combination. read more

I ordered the chicken parm with vodka sauce, it was fresh and delicious. Our server Taylor was wonderful. Unlike some of the stagnant servers on the island, she served up a lovely vibe as well! read more

Nice seating outside, cool place to stop by. Heads up, utensils are plastic, plates from papers or plastic. Pasta was very good. Garlic bread very good, and hero's also tasty. Only thing was not my thing: soups. They aren't my favorite... nice service and polite. read more

Cherry Grove Pizza - Outside seating - Pizza Near Me - Fire Island, New York

See all

Pizza was very tasty. Better than expected. Service was ok. Sat outside which was a good location weather was nice.

After two of us were seated thin short male server asked us to switch tables to across the patio and offered us a free drink to move. Another server was covering the table We never got our free drink. He just wanted a larger party and is trying to push guests around to other servers toget more. This is unacceptable. Four shrimp with a salad was $44. If you like being shuttled around and treated poorly you'll love this place. read more

I loved this place until tonight. Food is always on point. Service is always excellent even when it is packed. Tonight there was hair in my lasagne. It was dark already so i couldn't see well. Next thing i know I'm chewing on a long thick hair. I used the phone flashlight and saw 3-5 strands of long dark hair. When i told The waitress all she offered was to discount our drinks ( an iced tea and seltzer). My husband told the guy inside and all he did was deduct ten bucks in addition to the soft drinks. No offer to replace the meal ( although i lost my appetite at that point anyway). I give this place tons of business every summer. I Bring friends etc. I will stick with island breeze and sandcastle from now on. read more

Great variety of pizza. Dinner specials are good too! Can't go wrong with Cherry Grove Pizza!

Fast and friendly service with a nice outdoor patio. The baked clams were really good, very generous and a good price with nice seasoning. The pizza was ok, I didn't love my pepperoni slice. The nice part is that they have gluten free options, my friend loved his gluten free pizza. read more

Cherry Grove Pizza - Baked Gourmet Clams - Pizza Near Me - Fire Island, New York

Vastly overpriced low quality Italian food and they have the audacity to only take cash. People seem drawn to it but maybe I have higher food standards. Friends wanted to go there last week so I'm like ok. They liked it. I forced myself to eat 1 meatball and some ziti and had heartburn for the rest of the night. True Italians would turn their nose up at this establishment. read more

Excellent food and service great pizza .. had the special of the day seafood angel hair pasta was delicious

Awesome food! Great friendly staff. Perfect vibe and price for FI Everything was so good and piping hot. Our group also had mozzarella sticks, minestrone soup, salad, delicious pizza and pinwheels. Yum read more

See all

Best pizza I've ever had hands down. I've only gone during the day so I can't say much about it at night, but it's always a nice spot to sit and eat. The service is always amazing, the people who work there are so friendly. 11/10 read more

Great outdoor seating and friendly vibe with good healthy options along with other goodies!

U know when u revisit your favorite places & U look forward to certain simple food like pizza or chicken parm with pasta because it's comforting and tastes like the version of your Italian Sicilian or Greek grandmother or mom or friend made? And it's a welcoming feeling? Yesterday my friend and I took our friends to one such simple eatery, #CherryGrovePizza in CherryGrove FireIsland NY . And we were starving! The simple pizza and chicken parm and 2 slices took 40 minutes to get to our table of 4 (this is a New York pizza eatery not a linen tablecloth napkin type place). And CASH ONLY we were informed (no where in print on the menus). We were starving. The food finally arrived. One look and I knew this wasn't going to b good. The pizza looked weak and looked nuked. It prob wasn't but I get the ingredients were cheap. The chicken parm? I could hve been eating a damp bounty towel without any flavoring at all. Really? What happened to your recipes? You didn't just cut corners , u insulted years of hard work which was placed before you to keep the crowd coming. U may have had some tables filled that evening around 7:30 and I don't know what their gastronomic experience was but I'll advise u better get back to basic essentials. Learn all over again. I'll taste test your basics again but next time it'll b a live Instagram if not a live podcast surprise . read more

See all

The pizza options are some of the best I've ever had, anywhere around the world. Very tasty. I also like their flexibility: willing to make a pizza that is half of a specialty pizza on each side, so you don't have to order two pizzas to try their specialty flavors. I've had 2 of their baked entrees and those were very savory and tasty as well. During this time of pandemic I applaud them for their efforts with distancing and outdoor seating, and staff are in masks. They've done it appropriately, while still doing their best to maintain an enjoyable dining experience. read more

Cherry Grove Pizza - a sign for a restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Fire Island, New York

See all

The food is really good and what a pleasant place to sit outside for lunch. Friendly people, great service, and right around the corner from great ice cream. read more

Personal favorite place to eat in the Island. Other than pizza, they also got other choices like pasta, calzone, entrees, and etc. For drinks, they serve alcohols too :) Cash only. Prices are reasonable for a vacation spot. read more

To be honest, I'm pretty surprised by how good the pizza is here. They serve up pretty solid slices on Cherry Grove...who knew? I really enjoyed their garlic knot slice: three decent sized garlic knots baked into the crust of the pizza. If you are in the mood for pizza while beaching it up on Cherry Grove, pay them a visit. read more

The mozzarella sticks are so yummy. I order the Italian sub and unfortunately it was not all that but I will say the staff here goes above and beyond. They love that you came to the restaurant. They have a sense of urgency and consistently cater to guests in away I never saw before. Great business, I look forward to trying more from the menu when I return. read more

I understand this is a vacation spot and that it's summer, but come on. $19 (w/o tip and tax) for a portion of lasagna? Mediocre lasagna?? Food was vastly overpriced (even taking into account the location and season) for the quality. Service was what I expected - casual, laid-back, no frills - but if you're in the mood for pasta and head here, expect inflated prices for average quality. Also the menu prices need to be updated because the prices there weren't reflected on our bill. read more

See all

Excellent pizza and excellent service. We were actually planning on going to another restaurant for dinner and they said they only served until 7pm and the bar was open until 8pm. The pizza and pasta are excellent and priced right compared to the rest of the island. The guy that helped us was very friendly and same for the guy that was in the back which I'm assuming may have been the owner. Thank you for being open and for the great meal! read more

As good as it gets for Pizza on Fire Island. Have been going there for years and its still the same. August 2022

Meh. I've experienced better. Thank you Yelp for giving me a place to start. I was here on a Saturday afternoon just taking a stroll in Cherry Grove and craving something to eat. Luckily, Cherry Grove Pizza is pretty centrally located. Unfortunately, the food was subpar. I asked for a slice of plain cheese which cost $4.00. That is 4 slices of TWO BROS. The pizza that I was served was burnt on the bottom, cheese was hard and overall lacked flavor. One benefit to the place is that they do deliver! They deliver to Ice Palace while you are having drinks so if you're having a few cocktails, this is GREAT. Side note, Cash Only. Happy Eating Grade: C read more

Best pizza on the fire island! Quick ready spot. I love the people who work here, always so friendly.

Why is it that even a "not-so-great-by-NY-standards" pizza place beats the best Chicago pizza by miles? Why can't we get this stuff in Chicago? Probably because Chicagoans do not know how to make "real" pizza? (Yes, I am a deep dish and Chicago pizza hater). ** The cheese pizza was the best I've had in a long time. I was so satisfied after eating the pizza, I did not even crave the hot guy standing 6ft away from me in a skimpy speedo. And that's saying A LOT! ** Let the flaming begin. read more

I was not expecting much from this beachy pizzeria tucked away under the Ice Palace. I was wholly blown away by their white pizza (the ultimate beach-side pizza style) and impressed with their inventive "roni"/cheese sliced stromboli thingies called "pinwheels." The prices are decent, especially considering what they could charge here. They deliver in Cherry Grove, too (pretty funny -- it's less than a mile long). Not sure about to the Pines. I want a Cherry Grove Pizzeria T-shirt! read more

Delicious fresh pizza available with a design your own menu of topping options. Whenever I'm in the neighborhood, I drop by here for a fresh hot slice. Favorite full meal is their Baked Tuesdays presented in season... Any baked dish (eggplant parmesan for me, please) comes along with a chilly fresh crispy salad, a beverage (unsweetened ice tea, please) and a chip for a free ice cream dessert from a nearby establishment. If you are in Cherry Grove on a Tuesday, you will want to take advantage of this deal for lunch or dinner. read more

Cherry Grove Pizza - Cherry Grove Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fire Island, New York

wait a minute..... OK, I know we are on Fire Island and that everything has to be ferried over from the so called main land, it's a seasonal thing, etc. etc.. But... People.... $7.00 for a corona on a average afternoon. $2:50 for a small bottle of water, no tab-water was offered? $30.00 for a soggy, 40min wait pie (pizza) Hello......... Sorry, but we (6 of us) thought this was an awful experience and we will never be back again.. Hugs read more

Been here hundreds of times over many years always had good service and great food but today the food was awful and the service terrible . First the waitress let us sit at s dirty table, she took our order and still didn't clean it, we cleaned it ourselves she then brought me my food first so we didn't eat together, we had to wait for silverware after the food sat on our table, we had to ask for bread and got it when the pasta was half eaten but she dropped the check quickly and picked it and her tip up faster than it took for the bread to come The portion of the pasta looked smaller, the pizza tasted funny like the dough was left out to long and the bread for my sandwich tasted stale or freezer burned Next weekend we break our tradition of dinner here and back to ocean breeze or sand castle read more

In some ways this place is a little hole! As Billy A mentioned, it's located underneath the Ice Palace, a long running & well know Cherry Grove dance club (why is there no Yelp listing for the Ice Palace????) But even though it is not a fancy establishment, in recent years it has been the only place to get a reasonably priced meal in Cherry Grove! By mainland standards the pizza is a little pricey, but it is a good as or better than any pizzeria I've eaten at on the mainland. But then there is their chicken ptarmigan!!!! One friend of mine from NY City actually will make a trip out to Fire Island simply because he got the urge to have a chicken parm at the Grove Pizza. This past summer I had chicken parm at a high priced restaurant near Westborough, MA. All I could think was how the Grove Pizza's version was cheaper and better tasting! read more

My cell service on Fire Island was not the greatest, so I did not have a chance to check out the Yelp reviews for this place before my friend and I decided to pop in here for a bite to eat on a Sunday afternoon. I am surprised the reviews are so overwhelmingly positive, because our experience was very underwhelming. We opted for table service so we could sit out on the patio. Our server was slow to bring water, slow to take our order, slow to bring our food, and slow to present our check. I know it's summer and I know it's the beach and I know I was getting away from the hustle-and-bustle of the city....but hurry up already because I want to get back to laying out on the beach! I thought our pizza was just ok also, nothing to write home about. Be forewarned this place is cash only. They have an ATM inside, but the ATM fee is $4 (plus whatever your own bank charges you to use a foreign ATM). read more

Try the sausage bread -- seriously delicious. We took some to-go. It made a perfect workday dinner with a side of sauteed broccoli rabe with garlic and red pepper flakes. read more

Great place to eat. Really exceed my expectative. I really totally recommend it. A down side is they are cash only.

I have a share in the Pines and have everything i need there.... except Cherry Grove Pizza! Their gluten free pizza is fantastic. The staff is great. Totally worth the trip!! read more

The BEST regular and garlic knot slices you can get anywhere!!! We look forward to this place anytime we go to Cherry Grove. Pricey of course, but it's worth it. They have gluten free options. Stay away from their chicken parm slice. Not stellar. Cheeseburger, pepperoni, pinwheels all very good. read more

I have this one star. If I could it would be none. I understand many like it because they are drunk and/or it's the only pizza in this part of the island. This is flavorless and inedible. Plus it cost $16 for 3 slices!!!Never again!! read more

Its pretty damn good. I actually ate there two times in a four day stay. First time we ordered the whole pie which we scarffed down. the dough was great as was the cheese and sauce. Service was fine save the lack of refills on the water. 2nd time we went for slices. 2 slices: $7.50 which is a little high but to be expected on the isle. I would recommend and go again. Its quick, cheap(er) and delicious and it was right under the hotel. read more

Great service and big portions for the price. The breakfast pizza was creative and good. Also enjoyed the garlic cheese bread and meatball sub. read more

Simply Amazing Pizza - yea its a small beach town place - but the slices are INCREDIBLE! A MUST MUST MUST have.