Organized, a lot of options(treasures!) The only issues we…read morehad was until we purchased some items it was almost like my young daughter and I were clearly being watched! The service was okay and the owners were less tense once we were at the counter to purchase. I am not sure I would recommend this place as your first "go to" for consignment as there are some five star locations uptown.

Absolutely loved the variety of items here, from brand new stone tiling to antique meat grinders,…read moreyou can never go wrong with having a little bit of this and little bit of that. I also loved how welcoming the owners were, just enough to be helpful but not overbearing where it makes you feel like you need to rush. Lastly, I loved their prices so much, I wish I could have picked up so much more. Next time I'll have to make a trip with an empty car just to visit this store. Would highly recommend this store who loves discovering treasures like I do!

It's an OK place. If I was driving by, I would go in. It is just so small compared to other St…read more Vincent's. I don't think I would go out of my way to go here.

For years I've happily donated all kinds of items to my Columbus St Vincents (including vehicles)…read more Everything was welcomed with open arms and there was always a nice older gentlemen there to greet us with a smile. We were happy to give and loved doing it. In the past year or two it seems as though the place has come under new management. Many of our items have been rejected for really lousy reasons. Just this morning I tried donating an office chair that I have used for years. It has always served me well and never had any problems. I took it to St Vincents and it was rejected. Me: "Here you go" Them (after smelling and rolling in it): "We can't take this" Me (dumbfounded): "Excuse me? Why not?" Them: "It's too stiff in the wheels" Me: o.0 "Your rolling around on concrete." Them: "I can't sell this" Me: "Yes you can, it will sell just fine!" Them "I can't sell this" This is the second chair that has been rejected for ridiculous reasons. Additionally, my wife commented to me that their prices are going up unreasonably. It seems as though this St Vinnies has forgotten itself and it's purpose. I understand you can't take things that are broken, but we have never donated anything to you that was defective. We will happily donate our things elsewhere from now on and will no longer be visiting our Columbus St Vincents. Don't bite the hand that feeds you! :-(

Small selection of movies and electronics and the movies were higher priced than similar stores,…read morebut staff was very friendly

Madison seems to have 3 types of thrift stores. Goodwill, St Vinnies, and those run by churches…read moreand/or church ladies. This is the latter type, and they all seem to be very similar (Bethesda, Agrace, etc). Less crowds, traffic, anxiety, and clutter than Goodwill and St Vinnies, but also less selection. Check back regularly and you will find some treasures. For the most part the prices are fair. If I specifically need something, I start with Goodwill, because I have the best chance of browsing. But I dont always feel like stopping in Goodwill just to browse. Versus it can be very peaceful to stop in Boomerangs, or similar. I've probably been there a dozen times since they opened, and bought something 3 of the times. They have furniture, which not all thrift stores carry. The staff has always been helpful.

Now this time, I really liked it. I did get a blouse. It was $5.99. Spacious aisles, bright I just…read moreliked the place. I'm glad I returned.

Well organized store, mens selection is small, prices are a little higher than they should be,…read morestaff is nice enough.

Flew in for holidays on a plane ticket that said, "No luggage." No problem! I knew I could stop…read morehere on the way home. I found sweaters and jeans and pajamas so I am ready for my holiday vacation.

Friendly Manager and wonderful volunteer staff. Very clean, with a good direction and set up…read more Prices are some of the most reasonable in the area for a thrift store. Money you spend there goes to a good cause and they have great items. Very clean store, for the most part. If you have not tried this thrift store out yet, you really should give it a try. I know I'm hooked on shopping there.:)

The owners are so nice and they offer so much to the community!! It's amazing seeing all the…read moreindependent artists' work from our community featured at their store. If you're ever in town, check it out!!

I love this vintage store so much! I come here every single time I visit Baraboo, Wi.read more

I've been to the Goodwill bins tons of times and the majority of my clothing is from Goodwill or…read moresome type of thrift store. I've been in good and bad parts of cities in thrift shops - I've done it all. But when I walked into Dig & Save, I almost immediately walked out (and wished I had!). I see that others enjoy it here, but it did do anything to me compared to the Goodwill Bins. Small section of clothing, no purses or shoes (that I was able to find), and then a large area for hardwares. When I came across an extremely dirty pair of ripped boxers, I decided that my time there was done and walked out.

Love this place!! Always clean. Great deals. Pay by the pound. Vinneys is a great place to shop.read more

I love goodwill but they are pumping out really strong fragrance today. I got a headache within a…read morefew minutes and heavy congestion. It was strong coming in the door and I should have just turned around. I went home and showered and washed my hair and changed clothes. It's still in my sinuses. I hope they turn the volume down on that or I won't be returning. I've been going there regularly for years so I'm surprised. Otherwise everyone was great.

Nice & organized, friendly staff, decent employees. Definitely one of my favorite GW stores! You…read morewon't be disappointed