When Wifey surprised me with a Cooperstown trip I knew it was going to be an amazing weekend and…read morethere really ain't much about the trip I wouldn't give five stars...including Mickey's Place. I knew the shopping in Cooperstown wasn't going to bring many, if any, bargains so I was just hoping to find some cool stuff. I spent a LONG time in Mickey's, but walked out with just a single item...a new Brooklyn Dodgers cap. They had a great selection of clothing, caps and memorabilia, but the hat was all that came home with me. I'll be back someday...

So, I was a little hesitant to order from Mickey's place because of their posted return/exchange…read morepolicy. I received one of the Mets '62 heritage series hats which was a little small and came with a soft brim instead of the firmer brim I was familiar on New Era hats. Clyde responded to my email the very next day and explained that older versions of these hats had softer brims. He then located the next size up in the newer version with the firmer brim and waived the shipping to send it back out to me. I also picked up one of the NY Giants Heritage hats. These are 50% wool and 50% polyester and shrink up nicely after a bit of wear. I definitely prefer these to any of the 100% polyester on field hats from New Era. They are hands down, the best fitting hats I own. And Mickey's Place has, like, all of them. While I have historically ordered from the Hall of Fame store (which also has excellent customer service), the selection at Mickey's Place is excellent. I would definitely recommend shopping here! Looking forward to visiting in person this summer and snagging one of the Brooklyn Dodgers heritage caps.

Heaven for true card collector hunters. I spent an hour, could have spent a day, looking through…read moretheir $1, $5, $10, and $15 boxes. Adam, the owner, is a nice guy who loves the hobby.

Cheers to the only card shop on Main Street that isn't trying to rip off tourists. Great selection,…read morereasonable prices on singles and packs. No $6 junk wax packs here, no hilariously overpriced raw modern cards, no new boxes marked up 100% from the price you'd pay on Target's website.

I have almost as much fun shopping in this store as I do walking through the Hall of Fame. I…read moreremember going here as an 8 year old and wanting everything in the store. Now I'm 31 and I want two of everything. Sure, they have all the stuff you'd expect to find in a Cooperstown gift shop: name/number t-shirts for current stars and Hall of Famers; New Era hats for all 30 teams, as well as vintage teams like the St. Louis Browns and Colts 45s; bumper stickers for the Yankees, Mets and Red Sox. But what makes this place special is the vintage souvenirs and fan gear. Remember puffy stickers? Remember 4-inch buttons with players' pictures on them? Remember batting helmet sundae and cereal bowls? Remember painter-style hats with MLB team logos? Remember ceramic bobbleheads? They're all here. And they're authentic. They don't sell replicas or reproductions of kitschy 70s and 80s fan collectibles. They sell originals, the same ones I was browsing over in 1989. One case contains mid-80s stickers for several MLB teams with a sign that says, "Ask about your favorite team!" I didn't see the Yankees, so I asked. "We've been sold out of them since the early 90s," replied the shopkeeper. "Once these are gone, they're gone forever. They don't make them anymore." In a strange way, I was more excited to hear that. Despite this, prices are fair and don't seem too far off from what they were in the 1980s. After you're done in the Hall, come here for a very different trip down memory lane. Even if you don't buy anything (doubtful) you'll leave with a smile on your face.

Visited in November. Super friendly staff. They were extremely helpful and recommended tons of…read moreplaces nearby to visit. I bought adorable Cooperstown trucker hats for my young nephews and they wear them all the time!

Great variety of items. Everyone very friendly. Good prices, there is a lot of competition in the…read morearea.

Great store with a good staff. Located right on Main St in…read morefront of Legends Field. Huge collection of everything baseball. Gifts or collectibles for all ages. Prices are comparable to all the other souvenir shops on the strip, but this one has a really good selection, especially signed memorabilia and jerseys. Some collectibles are very different too ( "one off" stuff) As for the pricing on collectibles, you need to know your pricing\ value here just like you would anywhere else. But loads of affordable gifts too.

Waste of time.. my son bought two fishing pole dropped 350 dollars on them got home and one if them…read morehas a broken tip and the tensioner doesn't work so he can't even put his line on the pole and fish. Tried to return it so my son didn't get fucked out of his hard earned money and NOPE dicks didn't do it !!! Such bullshit. How many other customers have they screwed? The worker thinks she knows more what's wrong with the pole then I do and she kept proving the wrong pieces were working. Lmao. Maybe if she shut up and actually listened to the customer rather than argue she would of actually heard what was wrong with it. Very rude the whole thing is bullshit and has not been made right or handled properly !!

Great customer service. They helped me get a golf driver tool when needed and always offer what I…read moreneed.

Let's be honest, most of downtown Cooperstown, NY is a gigantic tourist trap. It's very much like…read morethe town of Niagara Falls. They have a captive audience of bus tours and summer tourists that are visiting the Baseball Hall of Fame, and so the streets are lined with baseball-themed cafés, gift shops, and the usual touristy stuff. They do have some cool local farmers' markets on the weekends, but most everything else is focused on the baseball fans. Guilty as charged... my best friend is a huge New York Yankees fan, and he asked me to bring him back "something" from Cooperstown. As my Dad and I were walking back towards our car we spotted the Where It All Began Bat Company along Main Street. I looked through the front windows and saw displays of full-sized and miniature baseball bats that had been painted and personalized for the various Major League Baseball teams. I went into the shop and looked over the full-sized Rawlings and Louisville Slugger souvenir baseball bats all of which can be personalized by their on-site laser engraver with up to three lines of text. They also have miniature bats, whether bearing a MLB logo or a Cooperstown-themed logo, and those can be painted and also personalized. I got my friend an 18" miniature baseball bat, painted Yankees blue, and engraved with his name and the MLB logo. They were able to show me samples of finished bats so that I'd know what to expect. I was able to pay for the bat, the engraving, and the shipping down to South Florida, which meant one less thing to lug around in my luggage! Glen got the bat within a week, and he was thrilled with this unique gift and conversation starter. His wife has informed me that he hung up over his desk at home, and that she occasionally catches him standing in front of a mirror taking practice swings. Classy gift.....SCORE!!!

Rude service. I walked in to look for a bat rack for my…read morehusband's bats. I was not looking for particularly a certain style, but a rack that can hold about 10 bats. There was a young, thick man sitting behind the counter, never got up and glued to his computer and phone. It did not bother him there was someone walking around the store. I walked by the store couple of times and he is still in the same poistion.

While we were playing at Cooperstown, we booked a tour at the Cooperstown Baseballism shop. This…read moreis a must do for any team competing at Dreamspark or All Star Village. Everyone there was great. The gentleman that gave us the tour was phenomenal. Extremely knowledgeable, got the players and parents involved and went above and beyond to make the tour memorable due everyone. One of the parents even said that we should've done the tour before the tournament to get the kids pumped up. After the tour, you can go crazy in there just choosing from hats, shirts, hoodies with great baseball sayings on them. It was buy one get one 50%, so the kid got site shirts and a pair of hats. Don't miss out on this opportunity when here. If you go with your team, they hand out limited editing pins, which we all know the kids go crazy for the pins.

Booked a tour based on recs. We walked in at 2:55 to let them know our group was ready. Three, 20yr…read moreold kids just stood there, no greeting no welcome then told us to stand by the map. Waited until about 3:10 and went back to the front desk and told them we were ready and they told us to keep waiting. A few minutes later we walked out. A parent from our group went back about 20min later and the manager says, "we told you guys to wait". This was a terrible experience. Do not expect anything out of the tour or the employees.

Great prices for a business recently changing the focus of their business. He is building things…read moreregularly and is very friendly and knowledgeable.

Brought in a very nice "big" deer hide (140 LBS dressed) and only got 4 dollars for it. Hardly…read moreworth the effort of selling it compared to the price of deerskin gloves. I dont mind someone making a profit but come on now.