Visited this El Chile Poblano location for the first time today. and it did not disappoint. The service was fast and friendly, and the food was delicious and authentic! A must-try for Mexican food in the area! read more

The food is great, lots of options on the menu, and plenty of drink options. The staff is great. read more

See all

We are driving x country & pulled off the highway for gas & a quick dinner . Dennys had no help so they couldn't serve us so we found El Chili on line and drove here. This place is awesome!!!!! Great staff, great atmosphere & sofa king awesome food & prices. The place was packed on a Friday at 5:15 . Amazing beer prices and Margaritas to die for ! We have already said that we plan on stopping here again on our way x country next year. read more

See all

Coming from San Diego, I'm very tough on Mexican restaurants in Indiana. El Chile Poblano is by far the best in the area. Service is quick, efficient, and everything I've eaten has been spot on! I highly recommend it for legit Mexican food. read more

Hot and Spicy Burrito. Worst burrito I have ever had. Not hot, not spicy. Microwaved, extremely dry ground beef and chicken with no taste or seasoning whatsoever. They often don't answer the phone when trying to place a to go order. read more

I've only had one experience here but man was it horrific. My experience was consistent with a lot of the other reviews...dirty, rude, bad food, and the worst margarita I think I have ever had. I was coming from Spiceland. I usually go to a Mexican place in Knightstown. A friend talked me into trying this place. Our friendship is now rocky. When I walked in the first thing I noticed was the filth. The windows are dirty, the blinds were nasty and all of them were crooked or broken. If the customer facing stuff is that bad, imagine the kitchen. The next thing I noticed was how seemingly unhappy they were to help us. Very standoffish and just downright rude. The server wasn't any better. I saw they listed some good tequilas so I wanted a top shelf margarita. The server said "they are pre made and it's with 1800". That's not top shelf but whatever, it's a margarita right? Let's do it. It tasted like a lime flavored snow cone. I left half of it on the table. Have you EVER done that? Yeah, me neither! I ordered the Pollo Toluca. It looked good and even tasted pretty decent. When I got back to where I was staying, I had to sprint to the bathroom! YIKES. I was left with no reason to ever try it again. Hopefully my review can help them either improve or close and do something they love. read more

El Chile Poblano - a man sitting at a table with a green margarita - Mexican Near Me - New Castle, Indiana

"Never eat Mexican food north of Dallas or east of the Mississippi." But, I'm happy to say that El Chile Poblano broke all the rules. We were in town visiting family and decided to live life on the edge and try some Mexican food in Indiana. Backstory - we are from Texas where you can get good TexMex almost anywhere. We walked in and was met with the familiar smells of fajitas and thought this might be ok. The chips and salsa were on point. The salsa was thick and chunky with a good variety of flavors; onion, cilantro and maybe a hint of pepper but no so spicy you couldn't enjoy it. When learning we were from Texas the waiter brought us a small bowl of their white queso (cheese dip on the menu) and it was surprisingly good; it was a little runny but was heavy on flavors, possibly some of the house salsa mixed into the queso that gave it the flavor kick. We went on the safe side and ordered the "Texas Fajitas" and were very happy. The portion size was plenty big enough for the two of us to split. The beef and chicken were nicely seasoned and the shrimp were perfectly cooked. Overall, I would gladly go back to El Chile Poblano. Good food, plenty of flavor, friendly wait staff and perfect price point for the quality and quantity of food you get. read more

Nice restaurant, friendly staff, excellent food. This is a place tucked away in a deserted shopping plaza next to the BMV read more

Our 2st time at this location and we'll I wasn't to impressed with it. There were some pros but not enough to warrant going back. Pros: very easy and convenient location. Clean inside and out. Services was fairly quick Food was correct. were Cons:The servers were not friendly, no personality. We was the 2nd customer in the restaurant and I felt like they could've turned the music down a little. Although the food came out correct it wasn't hot at all. The Refried beans were room temperature at best I got 4 crunchy tacos and the seasoned beef tasted like sausage and it wasn't even hot enough to melt the cold cheese on top of it. It was right out of the cooler cold. 30.00 plus tip wasn't offered any kind of dessert or drinks nothing apparently we was suppose to know what they served. I just think it's Valentine's Day atleast suggest a dessert. I really wouldn't make this one of my favorite places and I definitely wouldn't recommend it to anyone. They could've done better in my opinion. read more

There are two main Mexican restaurants in New Castle, and this is one of them. I have been to this location once because we typically go to the other restaurant. My sister personally like this restaurant so we gave it a go. I am personally a huge fan of Mexican cuisine and can be slightly picky at times because of how much I do actually enjoy Mexican food. One of my favorite things to order at any Mexican style restaurant is the chicken with queso and rice Along with the fresh homemade tortillas this is how I rate Mexican restaurants along with the taste of the salsa and tortilla chips. I know that the restaurants are not a classic type of a Mexican restaurant or classic Mexican food that you would get if you were actually in Mexico, but this is what we have available to us. The chicken, queso, rice and tortillas are known by many different names at the different restaurants; Usually called the chef's special that many places. This restaurant brought us out chips and salsa very quickly, but unfortunately, the chips were cold and stale and the salsa did not taste very good. I think because the salsa was most likely not fresh. With the main course, the first thing I noticed was that the portion size was much larger than other restaurants of the same exact item. The other difference I noticed was the chicken itself. The chicken was more tough and chewy than I would typically expect at any other restaurant with the same menu item. The tortillas we're also not warm and soft, like you were typically get from a Mexican restaurant. These tortillas were cold, tough, and just not very flavorful. I am unsure if I would be personally willing to give this location another try because of my experiences at the other restaurant that is much busier and more well-known in this city. The pro of this restaurant are the portion sizes compared to the price. The con of this restaurant is that nothing was fresh. Now, this could be due to many different factors, and just being an off night for the restaurant, but it certainly left a slightly negative remark with me. My recommendation is neither here nor there, because I have only had one bad experience. If you want to give this place a try, go ahead and do so. read more

Nice restaurant, friendly staff, excellent food. This is a place tucked away in a deserted shopping plaza next to the BMV read more

my fav mexican restaurant in NC! Best food at the best price always a quick and easy experience!

No stars. This place has gone downhill exponentially since 2018. Food is AWFUL. The hostess is rude, confrontational and just a dirty young woman. Do not know if the Cartel peso has dried up or what, but I would not recommend El Chile to my worst adversary. Do yourself a favor and cook at home. read more

Their food is so good there, I would eat there every single day if I could. Their service is super good, they come with your food within 3 minutes. The designs they have in there is also amazing! The lights are beautiful, I love what they play on their TV's. They're a great restaurant to eat at, they are so underrated, and if you want somewhere to eat and not spend your whole bank account on, go here. read more

Locals recommend the restaurant on 14th over an identically named one elsewhere in New Castle. Evidently, they are owned by two separate entities. I do not know about that for sure, however. I only ate at this one, but it was fabulous. The salsa was homemade, and the fajitas al poblano was excellent. They have some draft beers, including Dos Equis, both dark and light. The prices are reasonable, and the service was quite fine. The menu is expansive. If you like Mexican food, you will not be disappointed. read more

We popped in for some carryout while at an event in New Castle. Ordering was easy (other than having a lot of choices) and the food arrived quickly and all packaged to go. Our lunch entrees also included chips and salsa. We opted for the 'regular' salsa and it had plenty of spice. We both ordered a lunch combo - cheese enchilada, beef burrito, and rice, then added a ground beef taco. Everything was hot and flavorful. Definitely worth trying if you are in the area. read more

El Chile Poblano - Lunch combo - enchilada, burrito, rice - Mexican Near Me - New Castle, Indiana

By far the best place to reunite with former high school classmates to discuss all the changes in your personal philosophy and religious views that you cannot discuss at home when back in town. This is actually the go-to reunion spot for my group and we picked it for a reason. Decent food, decent staff, decent atmosphere. All around pleasant place to eat out. Prices aren't bad. Get your beer in a boot! Do it! read more

This place is a gem! The food is exceptionally good. The menu is extra large and gorgeous, containing some interesting additions for an 'authentic' Mexican restaurant. Our Hawaiian Fajitas were awesome. Highly recommended. Everything else, with the exception of the fried ice cream, was tasty and well prepared. Come for the food, though. Service and scenery could be better. Beware: the high chairs are covered with a layer of grease! read more

El Chile Poblano - Hawaiian Fajitas. Forget the name--just try 'em! - Mexican Near Me - New Castle, Indiana

See all

I love the atmosphere, the salsa and the staff is friendly. However, this is the 3rd to 4th time that my food is so salty it is not edible. I had the La Superior tonight and both the burrito & relleno were extremely salty. I ate every bit of the salsa and chips though. I almost wonder if it is not the tomato based products they use, but whatever it needs to be addressed. I feel for the person on a low sodium diet that sneaks a meal here. The prices are reasonable for generous portions if you do manage to eat and get past the salty taste. read more

Terrible service. The waitress was very rude. Drinks were bad. Omg so terrible. Do not waste your money.

This is the only el Chile I will ever go to! They treat you right and take care of you! Quick service and always get the food right!

Favorite Mexican restaurant to eat at. Wish the salsa was thicker but food is amazing and big portions

They served the chicken and rice soup in a bowl last time and it was the best yet. It took a little while to come out, but it was well worth the wait. I can't find this delicious mexican soup anywhere else. read more

El Chile Poblano - Best Chicken and Rice soup I've had here yet. Best thing on the menu. - Mexican Near Me - New Castle, Indiana

We stopped by on the way to a concert. It was typical Mexican food. We both had chimichangas. They were good, but nothing out of the ordinary. The location was in a challenging neighborhood. The service was also really slow, and the waiter was low energy. read more

Te amo, El Chile Poblano! Born and bred in New Castle, there aren't a whole lotta options for going out to eat. This place has been mine and my family's old standby for a whole lot of years. It's great for a quick dinner or to take a large group to and get a little rowdy. How many times have I sucked down an entire margarita pitcher? Well, definitely more times than I (and my liver) would like to think about. Drinks are good (margaritas, also sangrita margarita which is I think a combination of sangria and margaritas and is 100% delicious). Food is also soooo good. My favorite on the menu is the Quesadilla Rellena which is a big ass quesadilla stuffed with your choice of chicken, beef or shrimp (or combo!) and sauteed peppers, onions tomatoes, etc. Comes with your own rice, beans and guacamole salad which is important when you're trying to clear the 5,000 calorie mark. I've had fajitas, enchiladas, chimichangas, soup, random salad, random other entrees and everything is so good. Service is as you would expect - quick and to the point. Have a bit of a language barrier depending on who you get, but that's part of the fun. If you find yourself in New Castle and need something that's not the McDonald'sBurgerKingWendy'sPizzaHutClusterFuck on State Road 3, then dip stop at El Chile and fill up on comida mexicana read more

This has been one of our favorite restaurants in New Castle, the last 5-6 times we have been there, its been disappointing. A employees Childs was on her IPAD/Tablet and it was so loud, 3 tables away, we could not carry on a conversation. Then last week, we (just 2 two of us) went on a Friday afternoon, and they had the worst service. it took 20 minutes for us to get chips and sodas. Very, very slow service. 45 before we got our food, after we ordered. there were 2 people at another table. that's it. there are other instances. BUT tonight was the worst. Then tonight i ordered a fajita to go. and one to eat in the restaurant. OUR waitress, after discussing it several times, (i wanted to take a fajita meal to go, and one to eat there,) she put all the fajita meat and veggies on mt skillet. Then brought the beans, rice, and guacamole salad to go. I asked where the meat was, she said it was all there!! so if the person that was getting the to go order wanted meat, they had to eat mt leftovers! This was not what i ordered. She just shrugged her shoulders, I don't know when I'll go back, if I ever do. Extremely disappointed. read more

Mexican restaurants in central Indiana differ on three points: cleanliness, service, and salsa. El Chile Poblano scored on all three. I had the Burrito Poblano, which is their version of the "stupidly large burrito." It was very flavorful, but I agree with Abbe C. that the food was a little salty. I still enjoyed it. Cheerful, friendly staff--and the salsa was good. If I lived in New Castle, this would be one of my go-to spots. read more

See all

I'm in New Castle a few times a year, and if I'm craving Mexican, this is my go to place. I'd like to give it a 5 star, but it's not quite deserving. The service CAN be spotty, but is usually pretty darn good. The food is tasty, but for Mexican fare, pretty basic. The menu LOOKS big, but upon further perusal, there aren't a ton of choices. But, there ARE enough for the casual diner. Considering that New Castle is a little bit off of the beaten path, I'd say they are worth a stop if you're in town. read more

I've been to this restaurant only once, but it was such a pleasant and wonderful experience. The decor is phenomenal, it's such a festive looking place and the food is equally as amazing. The staff is wonderful and seem super friendly. read more

Very good food, decent service, and great prices. In my opinion this is the best Mexican resturant in New castle. read more

El Chile Poblano - Nachos Al Carbon - Mexican Near Me - New Castle, Indiana

See all

We were on our way back home, going through New Castle at lunch time so a quick look on yelp suggested El Poblano. One our favorite foods is Mexican and this place looked and sounded good. Well, it did not disappoint. The previous reviews were right on. Fresh hot chips and salsa were served as we sat down to order. The fajetas were on the lunch menu so we ordered the chicken, $7.99. They were as good as any we've ever had. Everything was made with fresh ingredients which really made the meal. The service was quick and very friendly. It's definitely on the list for a return on our next trip up that way. read more

I love this restraunt SO MUCH! They usually have very good service and great food! I'm only giving a four because whenever they're busy they can be a little slow. read more

I had to come to this restaurant as it seems to be a favorite meeting place for old high school classmates. There are chips and salsa on the table before you can even read through the menu, and the staff was very quick and efficient. My food was a little salty, but I still enjoyed the shrimp al mojo y ajo. The margaritas were really great - no skimping on the tequila here! My fellow diners can be a bit rude and demanding (yes, my parents), and it was water off a duck's back to the staff. I have to eat gluten free food due to celiac disease, and I didn't get sick, which is big for me. In a town littered with fast food and very little amusement, El Chile Poblano offers variety and as much atmosphere as you'll find in a dying post-industrial town. I will probably be back one more time before I leave to finish off my oy-vey-cation. If you're stuck in New Castle, I recommend dining here! read more

food is VERY good, fresh and tasty, the wait staff is good but not very friendly. Should be a 5 but seriously I prefer the staff to have some small amount of cheer/charm..... read more

This is really my favorite restaurant in New Castle. So cozy, food is great. Clean and service is good.

Huge Portions of fabulous food, Friendly Service, Great Prices. This is the best restaurant in New Castle.

Their pretty awesome here. They give you a lot of food for your money. It is really reasonable for the quality of the food. They are nice if you smile at them and try to stir up a conversation with them. Many of them do not speak proficient English so that is why you must create your own customer service environment here. They will be really nice to you once you do. I just wish they wouldn't watch so much Mexican TV. read more

I ordered the Burrito Pablono. Large in size disappointing in taste. Unfortunately the vegetables inside the cheesy tortilla weren't cooked. The cheese on the cheese on the tortilla was yummy. The service was good nice atmosphere and large televisions read more

My wife and I eat here all the time. The food is great and no matter what u pick from the menu we are always pleased. With friendly smiles and great service you wont be disappointed. read more

I am a native of New Castle and my parents live nearby. I live out of state. This restaurant is the best Mexican around. The service is great and the happy green juice is worth the drive. I look forward to coming to New Castle to visit knowing that a good Mexican restaurant is nearby. My parents enjoy it being in the neighborhood. read more