Great margarita and salsa. Chips a little greasy. Ordered the #6 combo - enchilada, burrito and taco. Burrito came swimming in white nacho cheese. It basically was a tortilla filled with meat - nothing else. Enchilada was ok, taco sad looking with that goopy cheese. No flavor. Tried to squirt the line on taco and it was too dried out. Disappointing based on reviews. Maybe people don't get out to good Mexican restaurants. Not sure how they got such rave reviews. read more

El Sarape - Mexican Near Me - Bellevue, Wisconsin

The food and the staff are great! We usually come here at least twice a week because the salads are delicious and healthy. They have a massive salad menu, and did I mention affordable? We love salads and had been all over town to find the freshest, most balanced salad, and I have to say, El Sarape, you have won!!! The search for the best salad is over for now. read more

See all

Fantastic. I got the pork Tostadas. Wish I hadn't had so many chips and salsa Absolutely excellent. A+. read more

El Sarape - Mexican Near Me - Bellevue, Wisconsin

This place has a lot of character. Every inch has a mural or carving- super bright and colorful. Love the chips and salsa that come with every meal. The horchata is good but very sweet. I usually water it down. I got the Burrito de Frijoles y Aguacate (bean and avocado burrito) Sarape style (smothered in a sauce of various heat levels and melted Swiss cheese). It was enormous! But I think I'll forego the Sarape style next time as it was swimming in sauce. I loved the beans with avocado in the burrito although I was a little wary at first but it ended up being a great texture. Overall, I enjoyed and would go again. read more

El Sarape - Every booth has these fantastic decorations! - Mexican Near Me - Bellevue, Wisconsin

See all

My girlfriend discovered this place as we wanted to eat Mexican food. We ordered for a Fajita combo and Chicken Enchiladas. And I must say they did not disappoint. The food was amazing and the service top class. My girlfriend spilled her drink and they brought in a new one, and helped clean the table instantly without hesitation. Her Margarita was amazing and so was my Michelada was great. I strongly recommend this place! This will probably be my new go-to Mexican place in Green Bay. read more

My food here was fantastic and service is always good. I have only been there during lunch though. The place is small (westside location is significantly bigger). I had the Mexican style steak tacos and would recommend them to anyone. My colleague had the richard (spicy meat tacos), which looked unreal and yummy too. read more

My favorite Mexican place in Green Bay. Burritos are top notch, different salsas to fit your flavor and everything is just well-seasoned. My favorite dish is the shrimp tacos. The sauce on the mild version is phenomenal and the homemade corn tortillas are great. I eat here once a month minimum read more

Fantastic food and the best place to eat in Green Bay. The price is right! read more

I ordered a chicken burrito when it was served to me it was very soggy, I had asked for a different one and was told by the waitress that I would have to pay again. I asked the manager and he said the same thing. This was 7 months ago. I haven't been there since and will not return there ever again. I had to throw the burrito away because I couldn't eat it. read more

Excellent service! Always have a great experience here. Their portions are rather large, so there's always leftovers!

I got the fajita burrito and it was good. But the salsa had a smokey flavor which wasn't my favorite and the cheese dip with jalapeños was just plain not much flavor. read more

This place had AWESOME food and AWESOME service. Best Mexican food I have had in a long time and Plenty of it. The fresh tortilla chips & pick de Gallo salsa. Excellent. You have to go here!!!! read more

Authentic food with all of the flavors. This is one of our must stops when we are out and about. Taco de lomo is my favorite and the staff is incredible. Both locations are equally good and you won't be disappointed. read more

Great food yummy margaritas leaving FULL but not broke!! Lol The service is friendly and the place is always clean. Even midweek it's busy! Hellabetter than the bell. read more

El Sarape - Mexican Near Me - Bellevue, Wisconsin

Not cooked all the way it was better four five years ago then they forgot they beans and rice

These guys got great food hands-down, definitely in the top three of Green Bay Wisconsin's best Mexican restaurants, this place is truly authentic, I visit here every time I'm in Green Bay, it's become a must have, Their tacos are great, so are there burritos and tamales, the servers are awesome, very courteous and polite, the atmosphere is what she would expect an American establishment serving Mexican food, it is cleanly, And I feel very safe eating here, no reason to think any of the food would be bad. read more

the best Mexican food in Green Bay! everything is so fresh and flavorful. Been coming here for years and have never had a bad experience. if you're a salsa fan, you can order a container to go and it comes with chips. it is so fresh and delicious, it's hard not to eat it all at once! read more

This placed is tucked in off of main street and a little hard to find. We walked in after a packer Sunday game, and the place was empty. We were seated right away, and brought chips and salsa. We got burritos and quesadillas, and they were outstanding! Really tasted like an authentic mexican restaurant which is refreshing. Service and atmosphere were great, no complaints about this place! read more

My favorite Mexican restaurant ever! I always get their shrimp tacos, they are fresh and delicious. Their pork is amazing too. Great salsa and other items. read more

Always fantastic service before and during quarantine! Clean atmosphere, Super friendly accommodating employees, and yummy margaritas! El Sarape is great for a place to meet with friends and business partners, as well as pick up for lunch or on your way home! Best Mexican food in town read more

Who doesn't love El Sarape? This place is great portions of delicious Mexican food! The chips and salsa to go is even a hit! We love to grab chips and a bucket of salsa when traveling through GB. I recommend you try the carnita tacos! Everything here is amazing. read more

My parents love this place. I've found it inconsistent. Sometimes it's very good, other times its average. I've never had a bad meal here it's just not always really good either. The service is really very hit or miss, I've been here and given 1 soda and that was it because I couldn't flag someone down to beg for another. At the end of the day, itll be at least an average experience and maybe a good one. read more

Their food is delicious!! Taste fresh and perfect! The margarita is the best I've ever had; you actually get alcohol in it. Most places you can barely even taste the liquor. read more

Excellent food and service was the best! I went off of yelp reviews and wasn't sure about outside of the place, but was overly impressed with me kindness of their employees and the quality of food. They made me feel like they were glad I came in. read more

Love there food it's fast to come out and a great filler of your stomach and a to go box if you want food later one of the best thing is there chips and my favorite meal is the Fajita it's very good choice for sharing with people or wanting to fill your leftover box read more

Dear Yelp and all fellow yelp'ers -- THANK YOU. This website is absolutely indispensable -- especially on vacation -- for finding tips on hidden gems out there that we'd otherwise never find out about. El Sarape is a prime example. We found this placed based on a search for mexican food in Green Bay, WI. 4.5 stars across 16 reviews: always a good sign... As always, yelp did not lead us astray. This place is awesome. The portions are simply monstrous: one burrito we ordered is large enough for 3 meals for a normal sized person. The carne asada was cooked to perfection and the chicken in the quesadilla (which included hot peppers which definitely gave it some tasty punch) was seasoned great as well. The fresh chips and salsa are also good. Sizable portions of great food, strong service, and tasty drinks. It does not get any better than this. read more

Great fajitas today and great enchiladas. great service again. I just wish they would make sure the salt/pepper shakers were clean. Ones we used today were so dirty and grease laden it gave us the eerie feeling they were not cleaned in a very long time. Bathroom was clean and so was the booths but you need to go over with staff to ensure clean shakers and hot sauce jars. little things like dirty salt shakers give the place bad vibes. read more

First, I have to say I moved here from Texas. I am still on a mission to find decent Tex-Mex or Mexican food up here. So, far this place was decent but certainly not great. The salsa was good and fresh but the chips were very over cooked. The margarita was good and actually had some tequila but they didn't offer a top shelf option. I had the fajitas which were just not right. There were way too many veggies and there was some kind of a tomato sauce on the platter... just wrong. I just wanted fajita meat and the onions like back home. The service was good once they figured out who would be my server. Eric was really very good. read more

Oh yes great spot for when you're really craving some Mexican food! Portions are huge, and totally worth the price!! Staff was super friendly and it was a great environment! Will definitely be back again! read more

I don't like Mexican food. Don't know why I came here to be honest. Don't know if it was good or not. This probably isn't helpful.

Oh... my... gawd.. . Smoking hot world class Mexican on the outskirts of Green Bay in a bad mini-strip mall, poor parking, bad lighting, ya-think-ya-might-be-lost? Oh yea. Pull up and there's a narrow looking restaurant with a not-so-expertly painted sign and little promise. That's the obstacle. But walk inside, and friends, this is a spot of heaven. Packed on a Friday night, that was the first clue. Lots of families, dates, folks hanging out and really having fun. The place was buzzin', friendly, *very* colorful and a wait staff totally on their toes. Folks that really known how to run a restaurant. Now, my first visit with a family friend who'd been hearing good things. I don't get to this part of the country often but when I do I'll be heading back here. And they serve breakfast. What an experience that might be. Reasons for loving this place? I only need two (or 3, or four). Negra Modelo on tap (not too cold though--what your local Old Chicago is sure to do to ruin it) served in a cold glass with lime, fantastic traditional tacos with two corn tortillas, tender meats, raw onions, cilantro and fresh limes to squeeze on top. Doesn't get any better. We tried the rib eye (great choice!), tongue and mixed meat tacos. No side of runny beans and rice with this dish (thank you), no melted cheese running all over the plates--a sure sign of pretenders. And homemade sauces packed with goodness and plenty of onion & cilantro. Nothing outta the can there. The dishes going by were turning our heads until our order came, and then it was time to put the head down and get to work. Proving once again that the best dining is often that which is unexpected. Location, signage, parking. Hell with it. Give me more folks that can pack a meal like this. Be transported from the chilly North to Mexico in a heartbeat with a visit here. Next time, and there will be one, I'll bring a larger crowd with me. read more

You can't go wrong with El Serape! An awesome dinner that won't leave you broke. Authentic food, good and quick service and great margaritas. Location and parking aren't great, but the great experience inside makes up for it. The decor is really fun. We always discuss how it might have been made or where it came from. read more

Delicious authentic Mexican food. We've never had a bad meal here. The enchiladas and quesadillas are really good. The nightly specials are a great deal. read more

This is one of our favorite Green Bay stops. Tucked in a strip mall! Great atmosphere, authentic food and super service. Kid friendly and the prices are reasonable. Would give 5 stars, but the portion sizes seem inconsistent. Definitely headed back. read more

One of the worst experience and lost a regular customer. Came in with two of my other family members in quiet afternoon. There was only 3 tables filled when we came. We always order the same thing, sizzling plate with beef and chicken with flour tortilla w/ rest of the beans ect... They give us 2 plates,... Hello there is 3 people sitting here. Took about 40 minutes for our food. So then it came our "Very HOT" sizzling plate over this burner thing. He said watch out guys is really hot. We were like oh omg okay. :D There is no sizzle or steam from the "very hot" food he just served us. The food was room temperature. The tongs they provided us was not needed. That "very hot" meat we could pick it up with our fingers. We called the manager over told them the issue. We told him to put it back in oven to keep it hot. He said he needs a candle to light it. He changed the candle said it would take min. Waiting another 20 mins to heat it up and didn't do anything. He didn't even say sorry or put it oven. Didn't discount or at least gave us drinks on the house. Also I guess they don't refill water cups? This place is a joke. Went home after few tiny bites , got really dizzy and sick. This place doesn't serve fresh hot food. The manager has poor management skills. I've always put good words about this place but being treated like that isn't acceptable to anyone. This place is not authentic Mexican food. read more

Best Authentic restaurant in town. I seem to alway order the #4 Combo. So much flavor. You have to like the bottles of Coke they serve with your dinner. Very friendly staff however is the service can be slow at times. I'm not a big Mexican food fan, but this would be the exception read more

What a wonderful building! You can feel the wings of history beating around your ears as you walk through this mansion. The dining room and the salon on the ground floor are both good size, and the ballroom upstairs is good enough for ... a ball. One of the details I love is that the restrooms downstairs has a little lounge area. Both on the gentlemen's and ladies' sides. Feels most excellent. read more

We love El Sarape!! Always the freshest foods, made well in the Mexican tradition! Their carne asada is fantastic, as well as their fish tacos! They are my favorite! read more

After a few recommendations from locals while in town travelling for work and reading the other reviews I gave it a try. This was the best Mexican meal i've ever had - compared to the others I've had in the upper midwest and vacations in Mexico. Had the " Robert's special ' - rib eye tacos, and margarita , chips and pico fresh and delicious also. Service was fenominal. The atmosphere and lighting could be improved, but the food,service , and value can't be beat read more

hands down the BEST authentic mexican restaurant in town. The restaurant is located unassumingly inside a little strip mall off of the mason/main intersection. If you weren't looking for it, it's more than likely you'd pass right by none the wiser. Once inside you're greeted by a friendly, borderline kitsche decor... but that's the beauty of this place! The FOOD is the star here. The portions are enormous, authentic and cheap. The free chips and salsa help curb your appetite while you wait and are delicious. Green Bay is lucky to have a place like this in the city. CHECK IT OUT read more