I fully expect to update this review in the fullness of time - but I believe in rating not just the location, but the experience, in the context in which it transpired. So, in the interest of full disclosure: My wife and I tried out the Gertrude Street Enoteca after an evening of cocktails at The Everleigh. We probably had 4 each, things were not entirely fuzzy, but playing a game of darts was most definitely out of the question.
We had the nibbles, and the staff at The Everleigh were always happy to make a suggestion or two. Sadly, The Everleigh does NOT offer much by way of nibbles, they have no kitchen, no storage, so there really aren't any options besides some basics (sigh) so we were forced to wander on our way.
Most other visits have wound up with us at Belle's Diner downstairs, but, Belle's was packed, so we wandered along the road. MaryAnn had mentioned the Enoteca and we happened to glance across the street and see it, so, in we went.
It's cozy, has a GREAT atmosphere and I saw some spectacular looking wines on the shelves and on the menu.
However, we were in the mood for food, so we went for that part of the menu - and had an excellent chicken stuffed with veal dinner. It was the only "dinner of the day" option, and the rest of the food menu was more in line with the true character of the location as a wine bar.
We loved our meal, had a great glass of white each (I forgot to note which, and after the cocktails, it probably didn't matter) and I finished with a love Bas Armagnac.
The staff were friendly, the feeling very much one of comfort, and I got the sense that if you return more than a few times, you're instantly a regular.
So why not more stars?
Simple: My fault. We arrived after cocktails, we weren't looking for a wine bar experience, and we didn't actually have one. We only tried the dinner of the day, and everything went swimmingly. Not a single complaint.
But I think that to more accurately rate the Enoteca would require arriving sober, going through a few reds, having some nibbles on the side, and truly enjoying a few hours there. I'm not sure we did it justice by simply showing up after a night of drinking.
We *WILL* be back, and I am sure I will update this review and star-count. But I think the context of our visit is important; don't choose the Enoteca if you're not looking for the full experience it has to offer. We really enjoyed our meal, but, I feel it deserved more than we were able to give that night. read more