After visiting a nearby thrift shop that closed at 3PM, I checked a yelp and saw Lighthouse nearby…read more The store is a decent size and carries everything from toys to housewares (Tons of dinner plate sets!) to books and clothing. I can't speak for the housewares but the clothing was pretty much all under $5. Today they were running a 50% off promo on all clothing and shoes. You need to pay for any clothing before you head to the other side of the store and I think it was a $10 min for debit/credit cards.

The store is always clean and well organized. Not overly used items you usually find in thrift…read morestores. The staff are friendly and helpful. Large inventory of all categories.

We have been here a few times looking for a bargain sometimes you get lucky and find something…read moregood, just like when you go to a yard/ garage sale sometimes you leave empty handed , volunteers there are friendly, and the store is organized.

Volunteer s are so nice that works there. Amazing ladies clothes an novelty s good salesread more

Most of the volunteers are very polite. They have big selection and always worth stopping in…read moreespecially with children where you can give them a few bucks and let them fill their bag books and toy. Clothes are clean and organized nicely. It's definitely worth the check at least once a month.

Good selection of kitchen/dining wares...platters, glassware,vases. Some unique pieces. Prices vary…read morebut affordable. Downside closed on Saturday.

Sunday fun day how can you be buying anything you want for two dollars or three dollars really it's…read moreincredible. If you hunt the racks, you can find things with hundred dollar tags on crazy but true.

CHECK YOUR RECEIPTS!!!!! I had heard about this on other Goodwill's but I NEVER thought it would be…read morehere, the girl rounded up my total for their "donations" without even asking! Yeah I know it was only change but GW is such a ripoff anymore that they DON'T ANYTHING extra!!!!!! And it is the principal of the whole thing! Well I have been wanting to boycott GW for a long time and THIS is the last straw! Goodwill consider yourself BOYCOTTED!!!!

Although they are very polite, they have old raggedy products. Not worth the trip although I did…read morefind a pair of pajamas

Extremely small shop in a strip mall. Items overpriced - wouldn't consider it a thrift store by…read moretraditional standards. Was like a bad garage sale except everything was so overpriced. Owner ignored my presence. Nothing worth purchasing - items were in poor shape

Ridiculous! Will NOT ever go here again! Ripped me off$10! Very rude people! I wouldn't even rate 1…read morestar! But it makes your order to post review.

I recently donated and shopped in this store again. The VOLUNTEERS work tirelessly to get the…read moremerchandise sorted, priced and out for purchase. The cashier greeted me with a smile when I entered the store. The items as well as the store are clean and very organized. They have clothing, jewelry, collectibles, kitchen items, linens, glassware, books, electronics and much more! The shelves are always stocked with tons of unique finds! Do yourself a favor and go to the Old and New Shop....you won't be disappointed!

Decades of local knowledge, community involved, and full service - custom surfboards, lessons, and…read moregear!

By far the best shop on the island, and one of the best in NJ. Mike and his team was super…read morehelpful in helping me buy a new board. Purchased a Matador Toro and absolutely love it! What a board! Excellent quality at a very fair price. I'm confident you will have a great experience with them.

I just loved this thrift store! I visited over the weekend with my mom. They have a nice selection…read moreof women's clothes with a range of sizes including plus sizes! Everything is incredibly organized by size and color. There's a lovely selection of shoes here, with everything in great condition. The shop has some home goods as well. While visiting, there were many kind women working and straightening up around the store. They let us know that all clothes were 50% off which was a great steal as the clothes were already priced really well! Pants were about 7$, tops 5$, which was very affordable especially for the quality of the items there. This is definitely a gem that I look forward to returning to!

Great jewelry selection, which is what I mainly went there for. They have sales all the time on…read moredifferent colored tags, and large clothing and bags selection. Their home wares selections is great, as well! Everything in excellent condition. Will make sure to come here more whenever I am in town.