I love Jay's agency. I have them for years, then made a silly mistake of switching to progressive…read more I've had nothing but trouble with progressive and Jay and his staff made it so easy to come back to them! I love how quickly they always get back with me. Never leaving again!

Received a mailer from the agency and was shopping for home insurance anyway, so I requested a…read morequote based on the info they had versus what I currently have. Their mailer said $454 per year. Nothing changed from the info they already had but the quote came back at $1279 per year. Wasted two hours collecting data and submitting. If you get something in the mail, just triple the price and decide if it is worthless. No one has the time these days for bait and switch.

They are knowledgeable and have many insurance groups to go thru to get the best deal. Was very…read moresatisfied with the friendly service

From the owner: Lancaster Insurance Agency has been serving the Evansville community for over 80 years. We are here…read moreto help with all your insurance needs from Personal to Business.

Baylee is excellent. She helped me quickly and got me an amazing rate. Cheaper than The General and…read moreall the other sleazy companies I was trying to get the cheapest rate from. The General quoted me $134.10 for LESS coverage than State Farm is providing me for $90! With State Farm I actually have an agent locally, too.

Ashley was very knowledgeable and made switching insurance companies and adding renter's and life…read moreinsurance very easy! Highly recommended!

Johanna saved us a ton on our insurance ... it seems like every insurance company uses that line…read morenowadays, but in our case it was true. But even more important than saving us money, when we've had a problem, American Family has done an amazing job at handling it. From a busted back window to a fender bender to a tree that blew down in our backyard tearing up our fence and porch, we have had nothing but good experiences. I hear so many people who go to some other companies and pay large premiums and then the company abandons them in their time of need. Saving money is one thing. Having the people you're paying be there when you need them is where the rubber meets the road. I highly endorse this company.

I couldn't be any happier with the professionalism and prompt matter in which they handled and paid…read moremy claim. Thank you!