Always great food. Have ordered out pizzas and dined in subs and fries. Helpful staff is always nice. Hidden gem right off 95

I've tried Hilltop in the past but it's been a while. Yesterday, I need a slice and swung in but didn't get the impression that "slices" were apart of the offering. With that the guy peaked in the back and said, "I got one" and did a reheat and boxed it up. While I waited I noticed the menu had a huge complement of breakfast and sandwiches. Today I grabbed a bacon, egg, cheese on toast and it was awesome and quick. As for yesterday's slice, it was decent if you like garlic, which I don't mind. The breakfast sammich was a 5/5. read more

Hilltop Pizza and Subs - Bacon, Egg and Cheese Breakfast - Pizza Near Me - Edgewood, Maryland

The guy making food and the guy handling cash at the register is the same guy With no gloves in between the two jobs. Speaking of, The register literally looks like it came out of a sewer. Didn't have my phone to take a pic. 3 registers and none of the card readers work. Will have to watch my account the next couple of days. I only ate because I paid online first. Ordered a grilled chicken garden salad. For some reason they like to serve their salad fresh out of the food warmer. Served with Ken's dressing, idk how Ken's is still business. Cheese on the pizza is the cheapest I ever tasted. Will not return read more

Hilltop Pizza and Subs - Grilled Chicken Salad - Small - Pizza Near Me - Edgewood, Maryland

See all

Updated review 10.28.2022. I have ordered from here more times than I'd like to admit and I've truly fallen in love with the food. I've never had anything that I didn't enjoy. But tonight, I decided to treat myself to a cheat day and got their baklava cheesecake. Y'all. This is the best cheesecake I've ever had in my life. I mean it is literally the best of both desserts in one. Perfect about of sweetness, nice creamy cheesecake, flaky top phyllo layer, just absolute perfection. I have a feeling it will be my go to cheat meal lol. read more

Hilltop Pizza and Subs - Cheesesteak in a bowl and crab dip - Pizza Near Me - Edgewood, Maryland

See all

The pizza is very satisfying. We stopped here driving back to NYC so it was really random. The service was slow but the pizza was delicious. It is a good place to stop. We got the veggie pizza and were very pleased. It was a big pie and we had some slices left over to take on the go. read more

Hilltop Pizza and Subs - a menu on a table - Pizza Near Me - Edgewood, Maryland

Awesome food every time. Their cheese is phenomenal. We order there twice a month. Food is consistently perfect.

Ordered a large meat lovers pizza and a gyro last night. Very, very good. The only reason I gave three stars was price. The pizza and gyro came to $25, decent price for what I got but by the time it was delivered, 0.2 miles to my hotel, the cost had gone up to $35. They have more extras. One of them was explained as an innovation fee? $2.99 delivery fee, I should have picked it up myself, according to Google maps it is a 4 minute walk. Anyway, very good food but keep an eye on your bill. read more

Great food. It's the to go to place for breakfast delivery. Their breakfasts are delicious. They have great prices too. Our favorites are sausage gravy, egg breakfast, french toast, BLT club, best potato skins ever and the same can be said for the rice pudding. Their delivery people are quick and friendly. I highly recommend you give it a try. read more

Food is excellent and prepared as you wait. The Lamb Gyro are some of the best I've had. If you like calzones, get the meat eaters . If you need to gave it delivered, it took me about 20 minutes to get it, still hot. read more

I was there last night. The chicken parmigiana hero was excellent. Not fancy at all. Not expensive. Definitely a good hero. I'd go back. read more

Very good pizza and fast service!! I am from Michigan and we come to Abingdon a few times a year. I will definitely be coming back here for more pizza. Done exactly how I like it. read more

Contrary to the review from 9/19/2021, this place is actually still open. It is my option that Hilltop has the best subs in Harford County. Most places I go, a side is needed alongside the 12 inch sub in order for me to really feel full. Hilltop's subs are what I'd call overstuffed, and a side isn't needed with their 12 inch sub to fill me up. And the best part is, compared to other sub places around, they aren't more expensive, so it really is more bang for your buck. Full disclosure. as of the time of this review I have not tried their pizza yet. Although, the last time I went in to pick up an order I watched them roll out dough to make one, and if I hadn't already ordered a sub, I probably would've been tempted to order a pizza. They are always friendly on the phone, and despite usually being busy around 6pm most days, they are usually pretty quick with the deliveries. read more

Small but great place. Ordered a pizza to go, it was ready within 10 minutes and it tasted great. Great value, strongly recommend.

This place has the best subs in Harford Co. The rest of their food is decent, but the subs are where they shine. I think it's the bread. These people work HARD, and you can tell by the demeanor that they are exhausted. The people are nice, but they aren't like cheery Chik-fil-a nice. You'll get a monotone "what can I do for ya" and unenthusiastic "thanks," but that's about it. No warm fuzzies, but honestly I don't care because the food is hot and good. You should eat here!! read more

The only thing I had a problem with so far is the steak quesadilla. It was literally cheese steak meat. Used to real steak. Was a little disappointing. read more

Subs are good, service is good and orders are correct. special requests like toasted roll or extra onions are no problem. We have been a customer for years and the food and service are consistently good. Thanks Hilltop! read more

Hilltop used to be my go to for a cheesesteak sub. They were overfilled with meat and great price especially with military discount well. Not anymore. Got two cheesesteak sub Philadelphia style. Barely a trace of mushrooms and where the sub used to be bulging with meat - there was barely anything to write home about. These were two very disappointing subs. The meat probably was less the four ounces for entire sub. And to top that off. The military discount is $1 off a $30 bill. Disappointed and may start looking for a go to sub shop. Hilltop will be on bottom of list now read more

Here is a twenty dollar extra large turnover. This used to be my favorite stop when I'm edgewood and I always order the same thing. Now It seems this has become thier xl turnover. It's about a half or third what used to be called the same thing. It is so sad when a great places goes this far down hill read more

Hilltop Pizza and Subs - Here is a twenty dollar extra large - Pizza Near Me - Edgewood, Maryland

Ordered a burger, sub and fries from here not long ago. The food arrived fast and was delicious!

Best grilled chicken over Greek salad! Super fresh and great service. That's my 'go to but their sandwiches and wraps are great too.

I order from here so often and I am never disappointed by the food! Great service and fast delivery all the time! You should try there cheese steaks 10/10!! I highly recommend that you give them a try! read more

I ordered a chicken cheesesteak and it was not good at all. The cheese wasn't melted, they have the shredded lettuce and it was piled on top.. it was totally dissatisfying. I could not eat it all and soon after I had a stomachache. Hopefully this was a one time thing and it doesn't happen often. However I will not be going back. read more

Pretty good pizza but the baklava cheesecake was the best I've ever had. Will definitely be getting that every time I stay in the hotel across the street. read more

Hilltop Pizza and Subs - Cheesecake - Pizza Near Me - Edgewood, Maryland

Best gyro I've had in MD. Awesome wings and delicious pizza. First off, let me say this place completely surprised me. I had no idea it was a Greek place. We came home home from work and had a menu in our mailbox and decided to give it a shot. So glad we did. It has its own parking lot and is right under El Rodeo. The place is really clean inside and has lots of room with tables. They have a TV inside as well so you can watch while you eat. We ordered a large pie of cheese pizza, wings, and a gyro plus fries. The pizza was very good, with plenty of cheese. The sauce was really flavorful. The wings were plump and the wing sauce was great. They have a unique texture to them compared to other place's wings. It is almost like they are slightly breaded. The gyro was incredible. Tons of meat and tzatziki sauce, and the pita was really soft. Not only was this delicious but also cheap (9.95 for lg pizza, 6 something for the gyro, and 9.95 for 15 wings). This is definitely going to our new go to place for pizza, wings, and subs. We WILL be back. read more

See all

AMAZING CUSTOMER SERVICE! Got a topping wrong on my pizza, didn't even blink an eye and they were apologizing and said they are sending another right away! That's what I call A+ service! Everyone makes mistakes! This place is my go-to when I want pizza... and that's every day read more

I think the sign for a great restaurant is how many police officers are eating there. Highly recommend getting the Shrimp Cheesesteak. Grilled shrimp in a kinds traditional cheesesteak. Very good and very affordable surf and tuft! Saved for a return! read more

This pizza spot is a hidden treasure. I ordered a large italian sausage and waited while they made it. The pizza was fresh and piping hot. I dont normaly ever get italian sausage but wanted to try something new and it was well worth it. The crust was kind of thick and very cheezy. The sausage was the perfect compliment to the cheese. I will definitely be back. While standing at the counter I also couldnt help but notice some delicious looking cheese cake slices behind the counter. I will have to try a slice before I leave. read more

Hilltop Pizza and Subs - Pizza Near Me - Edgewood, Maryland

See all

Place is closed. Very sad. Drove up, place was dark, open side hanging down and not on. 2 other cars pulled up, looked and drove off. Place had great cheesesteaks and great breakfast. I will miss it. read more

I've been ordering from Hilltop on Slice since I moved here a year ago. My wife and I feel the pizza is about a 6 but the subs are phenomenal and they even have breakfast!!!! Their food is always consistent and they have made one mistake on a wrong fountain drink and they replaced it within 15 minutes. Great local small business read more

Literally one of the worst carry outs in the area. We ordered fries and mozzarella sticks. I repeat FRIES AND MOZARELLA STICKS. They were both over cooked and borderline inedible. Other times I've ordered other menu items and was equally disappointed. This experiment is over. This place sucks! read more

This food was ah-mazing! It was hot and fresh. The sub was so big my daughter and I split it. It was packed with meat. During this time of quarantine I am happy to have stumbled upon the place. read more

We dine here quite often whether it's the $10 pasta special mon-weds or a chicken quesadilla! We are always satisfied. The $6 cheese pizza is always a win . The home made cheese cakes are amazing as well.. to be honest haven't had one dish where it was not anything but amazing. It's becoming our go too.. it's large portions and always fresh. read more

Actual name is "Hilltop Pizza & Subs". Pretty much what you would expect from the name, not high cuisine, just fairly quick carryout. What you might not deduce is that they serve some of the best carry out food in the area. They may not be the fastest, but people swear by their Philly cheesesteak subs (which I must try someday), and I can state without any reservations that they serve the best Gyros in the area, bar none. They take the time to make food that's better than par, with fresher than expected ingredients, rather than push crap out the door that will give you indigestion within a half hour of eating. The only advice I could give them would be to switch to shoestring fries and let them cook until golden. That would be a knockout recipe for your cheese fries and mega fries, and would hold up longer before becoming soggy. Worth a visit if you're looking for fast food. read more

We ordered delivery and the food was as hot as could be expected and on time. We ordered pizza, steak sub, fries, and potato skins. All food was pretty good. However, consistent with other reviews, the order wasn't quite right. One of the pizzas we ordered was a Hawaiian pizza with the addition of bacon and jalapeño. We received a pizza with only bacon and jalapeño. You pay extra for the specialty pizza so I can't figure out why they wouldn't include the toppings that come with it, which we paid for. We'd order again but would maybe try adding extra notes to ensure we get what we ordered and paid for. read more

Avocado salad was great, box of fried stuff was standard. Picked up so minimal interaction with counter staff, decent meal.

The food was really good. You should definitely call your order in if you don't like to wait. I love that I'm never disappointed when I ask for my wings to be fried hard. read more

I ordered a Italian sub with lettuce, tomato, onions and bananas peppers. The meat taste terrible and the lettuce, tomatoes, onions, was not fresh at all. The banana peppers were not fresh and very soft. I through half the sub away and could mot eat the other half at all! It was terrible and horrible! I called requested my money back! The manager would not at help to give my money back or any suggestions for the nasty sub! I told him I could not eat the other half and trashed the other half. DO MOT GO THERE TO GET A ITALIAN SUB AT ALL THEY NASTY, HORRIBLE ! MOST ALL IT IS TERRIBLE! The manager was nasty & mean too! DON' T HO THERE! You will very disappointed!! read more

Got a Large 14" pepperoni pizza, cream of crab soup and kids's meal mozzarella sticks/ fries. It was delivered 30 minutes earlier than the predicted time. The food was good and the kids were happy. read more

If I could give this place zero stars I would. Two separate occasions we ordered online and both times had to call after 1 hour and a half and they had not even made the food yet. Ridiculous. Will not order again. read more

Not a good place to come off the interstate to. No slices. Ordered the tuna sub with cheese. No cheese. So much mayonnaise I couldn't eat it. But a few rusty tables outside if you want to eat outside. Leave this place to the locals read more