A hidden gem for unique finds. The selection is well curated. You can tell a lot of thought goes…read moreinto what they pick. Mara is so welcoming and friendly. Def worth checking out!

Shady establishment. Overpriced consignment, considering most people who consign with them don't…read moreget nearly the money they deserve back. 90% goes into the pocket of the owner. Moody staff members.

Wow, pure class is found here at S&M. Simply amazing…read more A must stop if you're in Sag Harbor. Elegance finds its way here. Not a prettier setting to get delicious cold brew coffee or afternoon delight with Rose`. Delicious treats and pies. Great outdoor space. Jewelery, dresses, trinkets and more can be found next door. High end. And now a historical 2 floor sleepover suite accommodations are a beautiful stay. I highly recommend.

This is such a cute boutique and I love all of the fashion pop ups they offer. My favorite place to…read moreshop in Sag Harbor when I visit my friend there in the summer. The little barn is chic and the outdoor garden area is perfect for relaxing with a beverage after shopping.

Below the Blue is so awesome! A must stop in if you're in Montauk. Locally owned by Ariel, total…read moresweetheart, and very knowledgeable. Tons of smelly fresh goodness from candles, to aromas. Jewelery for days, even custom necklace and earrings. Really cool bags and stylish beach hats Brushs, towels, mirrors A great place for gifts, trinkets and organic minded people. I highly recommend

I've been here so many times, but this experience I had was exceptional. Over the weekend I…read moredesigned my wedding jewelry with (Ollah, I hope I spelled her name right)! But she was amazing !!!! She worked with me with my inspiration, added her personal touch, and made the experience so memorable. She worked with us for an hour and was so patient. She did such an amazing job that I will cherish forever. Can not recommend this place enough!!

Great little souvenir shop in the heart of Montauk. Tasteful…read moresouvenirs to enjoy when you return home from your vacation Friendly helpful staff

The store owner is beyond racist and has absolutely no shame in it. Don't work in customer service…read moreif you are going to make people of color feel uncomfortable and unwelcome. Do better.

A nice little shop with some great toys and unique gifts. The ladies that run the store were…read morefriendly and helpful. They wrapped our birthday gift and we felt like the store has an old world charm. Not sure why there are some negative experiences list, but if you come in with an attitude it will not be tolerated and rightfully so! It is the Hamptons so the prices reflect the environment. I would make this shop a regular destination when walking on Main Street.

So rude! Walked in holding a coffee (that had a lid) and was rudely told to step out OR place my…read moredrink in the "drink basket" while I shopped. As if! I am so shocked that you would ask a grown adult to leave a TOY STORE because they have a drink. I walked in a number of other clothing stores for that matter and was not asked once to leave because of my drink. Do they seriously expect me to leave my drink unattended in a "drink basket". These women are crazy. Didn't read the other reviews until after the fact but this place doesn't deserve any business if you ask me! My mom decided to shop around a little and they were even rude to her when she asked simple questions about items for sale. NEVER going here again.

Lovely service. Spotlessly clean. Interesting finds. I'm donating some fab dog paintings from my…read morecollection, as an example.

As much as I'd love to rate this place with 5 stars due to the fact that the money goes to animals…read moreI just can't. The two gentleman working at the front are very sweet but unfortunately the two elderly women were my biggest problem. Not only do they price the items high but they have the worst attitudes I could ever imagine. We are in there spending money to support animals, be a little nicer. Instead of showing kindness, love and laughter, they make negative faces, rude hand gestures and are just overall those cranky old jealous grandmas that just hate life. So with that being said, support your local animals by donating to ARF directly not through this negative attitude thrift shop.

This is a wonderful find ! Been coming here every time I happen to be visiting the area. And I…read moresave stuff to donate as well. Staff are friendly volunteers , reasonable prices , organized and displayed in departments . There are men, women and children's clothing , housewares , jewelry & bric a brac . I have found some great stuff and deals here . Enjoy!

Leslie is so helpful. The store has some of everything, and beautifully organized and curated…read morewithout high prices. With so few good thrift shops left (none west of this one, until The Hospice in Westhampton which is high-priced and very selective about what they'll take, and the one in Hampton Bays only open on Saturday mornings in the summer), this is the best to shop at and to donate to.

I live in California so I have yet to be able to visit the store in person but I love that I am…read moreable to shop with them virtually. The assortment of furniture, table top & textiles is absolutely perfect for our home and everyone there is so helpful over the phone, via email and on Instagram. Now they just need to open one in Marin!

Stunning decor at great prices. Love coming in here, staff is so friendly & helpful food.read more