I was in Hotel Sutter a couple of days ago and gave them a poor review on the southwest salad, I need to correct that. They were respectful and responsive to my comments, thank you Sutter!! I have reordered the salad and it is now amazing! It is truly a mixed green salad with great chips included, it is now my favorite salad ever! You have to try it, it's impressive and every one sitting next to me said WOW.. read more

We were staying at the Hotel and went there for dinner Sunday night. Everything was delicious and our waiter was outstanding. We started with the calamari appetizer and the aioli was perfect. I had the short rib special with pomegranate cherry sauce and my husband had the lamb shanks. Finished the evening with football in the bar. Would definitely return. read more

My boyfriend and I went out for my birthday and decided to go to hotel Sutter restaurant. Our waiter was named Aaron , and he seemed nice, but for whatever reason, I don't think he could hear what I was saying, and he got a little frustrated and gave us a waitress. She came over and said, what's going on? We just explained to her (Danielle is her name) that nothing's going on we just want to order. So she took our order. She was super awesome and super friendly and the food was actually really delicious. We'll be back and we'll ask for Danielle . read more

The nicest lady bar tender I've ever had the pleasure to meet. Was polite and mixed a great drink. Her name is Holly. We will be back to see her again soon read more

Hotel Sutter Restaurant - Bar restaurant - New American Near Me - Sutter Creek, California

Where to start? The food and service were top notch... The Poke stack and the Mahi tacos should not be missed, and the Pig, Fig and Goat is the best "charcuterie" we've had. April, our server, made the lunch that much better. A must stop in Amador County! read more

Wow! The quality of the food has really gone down. Took my boys to dinner with week and everything was over salted and hard to eat. Decided to take them to breakfast this morning since breakfast has always been good, up until today. The only good things is the service staff is amazing. read more

The food was okay. I order a shareable steak with tots, there was so many tots, and very little meat. The service was not the best. Not as attentive as I would have liked. I felt like I was a bother. Long periods of time between visits to the table. There was noise but not too bad. Not what I expected. Service is my biggest complaint. Lack of meat was my second. read more

Hotel Sutter Restaurant - Salads - New American Near Me - Sutter Creek, California

See all

Quintessential Sutter Creek vibe. Speakeasy feel, great menu with vegan and gluten free options, beautiful presentation of meals, full bar and accordion front doors for open feel. I ordered the impossible burger and gluten free bun (I have health issues) and they separated all other items I didn't realize had gluten like the onion rings and BBQ sauce. I can't thank them enough for being conscientious of dietary issues. I'm grateful and highly recommend this place. They have adult slushes... so next time, for sure!! Our waitress Karen was exceptional. PS They also have hotel rooms... just say'n PSS You can drink and eat and stay the night. read more

Hotel Sutter Restaurant - Love the staff and vibe - New American Near Me - Sutter Creek, California

No complaints. Came on a Saturday afternoon around 3pm. The bar was pretty busy but the dining area was not. We were seated promptly, and our orders were also taken efficiently. I ordered the BLAT, which was very good. Everything about it was on point. My date had the shareable wings which he enjoyed. I also had the spiked lavender lemonade which was well made. The waitress was very attentive but not overly. Would definitely eat here again if I was in the area. read more

Hotel Sutter Restaurant - BLAT and Spiked Lavender Lemonade - New American Near Me - Sutter Creek, California

One of my favorite spots for lunch, dinner, drinks, never disappoints. Had a new apple and Brie flatbread and was to DIE for. Always waiting to go back. Nothing has disappointed. Can't wait to actually stay there! read more

We've been here before the pandemic and it was excellent then. We went to Sutter Creek today for the vendor street fair and the town was packed. We stepped inside to see how the long the wait would be. The hostess told us it would be about an hour. We left our phone number and wandered around town. We came back just short of an hour and our prospects were still not looking too good. We eventually got seated upstairs on the balcony which was perfect! We had a bird's eye view if Main Street and all the goings on. My wife ordered the brisket sandwich and I ordered the Sutter burger. Both were very delicious and prepared nicely. The service was attentive and friendly. I'm glad we ended up waiting. Thanks to the hostess for seating us in a great spot and the waitress for the wonderful service! read more

The food was delicious and our server, Olivia, was wonderful! We loved the loaded Cesar salad and the charcuterie board. We will definitely be back! read more

Terrific service and great food and drinks. And perfect room temperature despite 100+ temperatures outside. Olivia is a rock star bartender. Looking forward to next visit! read more

Outstanding service, delicious food, good local wine and a beautiful hotel/restaurant! No need to say more, it was a great experience! read more

Hotel Sutter Restaurant - Salmon was delicious, polenta cakes where a bomb! Great sauce and perfectly cooked asparagus. - New American Near Me - Sutter Creek, California

First stop, last stop! Uniquely pleasant hostess greetings and good starter information! When we were informed Brunch was over and lunch would start serving at noon, of course we went to the bar to enjoy an adult COLD beverage; we have had about 2 weeksu of over 100*!! Right away bartender, Olivia, greeted and served us one of THE BEST Bloody Mary and Long Island iced tea. OLIVIA, can provide ALL you need to eat and drink from a shot of your favorite distilled spirits to the location of the swimming hole by trees as markers! What a wonderful day spent in the foothills near our new home. Keep searching for the beauty in life and check out Sutter Creek and the Sutter Hotel! ................................... read more

A small group of us stayed over night for New years. The hotel was clean, comfortable and quaint with a lot of personality. Dinner was fantastic and full of flavor!! We had a variety of drinks and they were all very tasty. The staff were kind, professional and fun. Thank you Rebecca for making our night unforgettable and perfect!!! We really felt like VIP guests. read more

I have eaten here several times over the fast few years and have always found it to be exceptional. Recently had a Chicken Caprese sandwich with Garlic Tots and an ice tea. It was delicious. Everything was fresh and of good quality. The place was packed but our way was only 15 mins. It's a great location in beautiful downtown Sutter Creek. I highly recommend it. read more

The food and service was excellent. Hotel Sutter is one of the best restaurants in Amador County. A most stop when you come to the Sierra Foothills. read more

A few months ago we were not impressed with this restaurant but we returned tonight and were thrilled with our experience. We sat on the balcony and received excellent service from Sierra. The drinks came out quick and were delicious. The coconut prawns were perfectly cooked. Our entrees were equally yummy. My hubby loved the scallops served over a bed of herbed creamy polenta with perfectly cooked green beans. My tender stuffed gnocchi was also delicious and so rich I couldn't finish it in one setting lol. We brought carrot cake home and I can't wait to try it. Ambiance on the balcony upstairs is cozy and lovely and we'll def be driving the 30 mins to go back! read more

Comfortable, relaxing setting. Good service, quick but not pushy. Nice selection of food. Enjoyable, good for date night as well as families

Busy evening at the restaurant, glad we had a reservation, lamb chops were outstanding, cocktails were made perfectly, service was good, the only thing negative was the noise throughout the restaurant read more

4 stars only because the flies & woman manager on staff. They could install fans that could help keep those guys moving. Vornado makes retro style fans that would be ideal. And commercial ones mounted in between the indoor /outdoor area. But a few standing fans might help too as I understand the cost of commercial. Food was really great. You have to expect to pay a little more on some things because of the location. Ambience for Labor Day was perfect w/live music and the place filled up with lots of people of various ages. Now, the manager woman on duty was talking down to Mitchell as he was answering my questions about this historic hotel. He, on the other hand was very sweet and informative and made us feel welcomed. A helpful hint for the manager...instead of putting your hands on your hips standing (doing nothing) on the stairs barking at your staff... why not jump In and take the drinks to the tables?! that's what managers do! Especially when you know you are short staffed. We will definitely be back and enjoy this sweet town and the cute shops. Definitely worth the drive! read more

See all

I visited this place for food. All food photos looked great so sat in patio. The food were amazing and drinks so amazing (blackberry mojito) But I almost took a star out because,,, A swarm of flies all over my food. As soon food arrives, boom. Can't even eat food at all. It's outside I understand but it's really uncomfortable. If you go this place and having food, sit inside. Again, SIT INSIDE!!!!! No joke! read more

See all

We had an amazing dinner with excellent service. I highly recommend when you're visiting Sutter Creek. read more

See all

What happened to this place? Used to be packed and fun. Worst service ever in the bar. No bartender in sight. Drink menu says Happy Hour Sun-Thurs I asked once someone showed up. They looked at me like I was crazy. Drinks weren't even good. What a disappointment! read more

Hotel Sutter Restaurant - New American Near Me - Sutter Creek, California

Just stopped in for a quick drink and a NFL score update. The bar is cozy and the entire wall opens up to the street, which is a nice touch for cool fall breeze and for some ambient street noise. I only order a vodka soda, but the beer selection was solid and their vine list is over 20 styles deep! We didn't order any food, but I did watch a cheese board come out and it was massive. It should be for $27! There's a dining area upstairs for more of a romantic vibe, but the bar was perfect to sip a few and watch the game. I'll be back to dominate that cheese board. read more

Hotel Sutter Restaurant - New American Near Me - Sutter Creek, California

Had a lovely meal with our baby dog on the patio overlooking the quaint old Gold Rush town of Sutter Creek. Wifey had a classic breakfast that was perfectly done in its simplicity (Bacon crisp/ Eggs over easy). My Nachos (correctly pronounced in Valley Girl as "Naawchos") were mouthwateringly good. The bar/lobby/hotel is spectacular, like stepping back in time but with today's amenities. read more

Hotel Sutter Restaurant - Nachos - New American Near Me - Sutter Creek, California

Having had a fabulous chicken pot pie at Hotel Sutter a couple of years ago, we decided to take a drive down today to have that for lunch. Making a long story short, we decided to share one as we remembered that it was large and very generous with a delicious flaky crust and loaded with chicken. What we got was a "Barbie" size pie with hard crust and very little chicken. It was nearly cold and a real chore to try to divide! The only redeeming quality about the lunch was the sweet potato fries! The lunch was way overpriced. We won't be trying this place again. Guess the ownership has changed-- hope they can improve! read more

The servers are very friendly. However......the bartender pours short. Ordered Tangeray Martini's which were half full. Usually most bartenders fill to the very top. You would have thought it was his bar so pour short! Later we ordered dinner in the dining room, which lacks any ambiance. Might as well been at Denny's. Ordered a Caesar salad. Worst we've ever had anywhere in the world. Never had a Caesar with bacon bits, tomatoes or hard boiled egg. And dressing from who knows where! We we're going to order entrees but the salad was so bad, we decided to stick to. Appetizers. My wife tried the Poke Tower. Terrible and some sauce presented was worse than axle grease. I had Meatballs. No flavor and the Marinara? Came from a jar. There's nothing wrong with things from the shelf. You can add spices and flavors to make it your own. Right? read more

Food and service was so great! We will definitely be back the ambiance was amazing we really weren't expecting much but we were so in love with it honestly we've never been anywhere like here. The live music was just the Cherry ontop for us ! The crowd that night was also such a vibe everyone was just enjoying themselves and the delicious food and drinks ! So glad we took the drive it's a little out of the way being that we drove from valley springs but the drive was beautiful and the food and drinks made it worth it! 20/10 recommend! read more

Hotel Sutter Restaurant - Lava cake ! Very sweet and I love chocolate so that says a lot the ice cream on top definitely balances out the sweetness. - New American Near Me - Sutter Creek, California

See all

We made reservations a while back, knowing it was Mother's Day. We didn't know we had to have the buffet. Actually didn't even know there was a buffet. The server didn't let us order from the menu instead of having to go to the buffet. The food was luke warm at best and not very good. The cost was exorbitant ($60/ea). read more

My daughters took me to Mother's Day brunch today at Hotel Sutter in Sutter Creek. It was such a beautiful morning! We stopped first to take pictures at the Photo Booth they had set up in the lobby, then were sat on the upstairs balcony with a view of Main Street. The service was impeccable and the food was delicious! Literally an amazing spread of breakfast, lunch and desert choices...so impressed! I would definitely recommend! read more

The food was amazing and the atmosphere perfect for our party of four. I ordered the spring pasta it was so fresh and filling. For the appetizer we had the muscles which were the best I have had. Big thumbs up to the chef. We had a wonderful time and highly recommend this restaurant! read more

Hotel Sutter Restaurant - Spring pasta - New American Near Me - Sutter Creek, California

Great spot! Good service good food good ambiance! Cute hotel either nice outside seating.

Went for a birthday dinner a week or so ago. We had a reservation for the deck on the second floor overlooking the street and shopping area. They had misters going and that really cooled things down. Started off with the almond crusted prawns and they were delicious! For my entree I got the tri-tip and I'd give it a 8/10. My girlfriend got the fish n chips and she said she loved them. My mother got the Salmon burger and she liked it as well. Lots of options for food and drinks ranging from medium to high price. If you find yourself in this area I suggest stopping by or making a reservation to check it out. It's a super old building with a lot of history. Thanks for the good food and service ! read more

Hotel Sutter Restaurant - Almond crusted prawns and a refreshing beer. - New American Near Me - Sutter Creek, California

Day trip to Sutter Creek and we decided to bring our pup. It was a Saturday so everything was up and running in town. Mid afternoon we were hungry and noted two restaurants on the main drag that had outdoor seating - necessary as we had our dog with us. Hotel Sutter had some empty two tops so we sat down to eat. We discovered that if you eat inside, it's a full service restaurant. Outside, you pick up a menu at the front desk and then order at the bar. Both lunch menu or new brunch menu - We chose brunch which is available 10 am to 2. We split the Brisket Hash with potatoes and two eggs. Delicious and filling for two. No dessert this time as I had also recently finished a hot chocolate from the coffee shop next door. But they had some tempting items including lava cake. A favorite on a nice fall day. Great place to eat and people watch when you have a dog. read more

Hotel Sutter Restaurant - Brunch outside with your pup! - New American Near Me - Sutter Creek, California

I started with cocktails at the Hotel Sutter bar (be sure to order in the bar and then seat yourself outside to get a nice view of the street and on goings or live music). I had the French pear martini. It is always a delightful treat and such a delicious way to end the work day. The French pear is my favorite Hotel Sutter cocktail; perfectly curated and a beautiful presentation. Yum! I then moved into the dining room for a pleasant dining experience. Danielle was a delightful server. I usually get the Brussel sprouts, they are delicious! They are crispy and flavorful with a bit of bacon and parm and a creamy aioli. For my main, I ordered the chicken saltimbocca. It was wonderful. The presentation on a cobalt blue ceramic plate was very pleasing. The chicken was cooked perfectly and the sauce was divine. I highly recommend this dish! Overall, another very nice experience at Hotel Sutter. read more

I loved this place! The ambiance was great! Service was slow to get our food out but it was worth it! I had the Whiskey Burger replaced with the non meat Impossible Burger and fries. The fries were the best I've ever had and so was the burger. I wasn't sure what it would be like because you never know in small towns. It was outstanding! I'm not going to complain about price. If you go out to eat this is what it is so. I thought the portions matched up with price! read more

Tiffany was a great server. Very friendly and helpful. The Brussel sprouts were amazing.

We keep coming back! The food is delicious and the service from Tiffany is second to none! You won't be disappointed!