Better service at McDonalds…read more We did receive an offer in five weeks, however agent stopped representing me upon receipt of offer. 16 moths after the sale I still have not received all of the monies due me from this sale. There have been multiple issues during the sale and now after the sale. Garrett Rothman ignored all of my questions, was unable to answer questions which I later found out the answers were standard language contained in the sales agreement, Garrett Rothman didn't know. He has sold a lot of properties, however as he said 'my wife would say I'm not very good with the details' that is not what you want from a realtor. 16 months later I now question the legality of this sale. With every problem post closing Garrett Rothman would deny any responsibility, and ultimately blamed me, he the 'professional realtor'? Garrett rothman refused to lower the price, Garrett Rothman NEVER answers any questions after receipt of a contract. Garrett Rothman isn't even aware of the standard language in a sales agreement. Garrett rothman is the agent on record for RSR Realtors, meaning he is responsible for his agents and agency, he is also in house council for RSR meaning he is an attorney. The buyers agent was also a RSR agent, and Garrett Rothman allowed the same staff member to contact both buyer and seller which is a clear conflict of interest, to allow one person to represent both the buyer and seller. Garrett Rothman gave away money I did not authorize, Garrett Rothman ignored my multiple requests to communicate to the buyer the need for the propane service to be transferred into their name, which he never did, costing me hundreds of dollars and half a day having the service disconnected. Garrett Rothman's agent arrived early for the walk through, while I still had the right to be home, during the walk through the buyers realized there was no propane service, and Garrett Rothman permitted them to have propane service installed without my knowledge or permission, this put the entire deal in jeapordy as it is unlawful for a realtor to take possession of a sellers property prior to closing. again Garrett Rothman denied responsibility, offered to pay me the fees associated with removal of a filled propane bottle, however he never compensated me. I have had better service at McDonalds, I paid Garrett Rothman more than I have ever paid anyone for a service and he failed on every front. He is great at gaining your trust but as his wife would say 'bad with the details' in a complex real estate deal the details matter, Garrett Rothman's inability to handle the details has created numerous problems all of which cost me thousands of dollars. This Is the worst experience of my life. Garrett Rothman's refusal to assist me with all the issues after the sale is diapicable. Always has excuses, he had no problem giving my money away during the process and had no problem costing me thousands in lost time from my business, and I'm still waiting for all the monies due me from the sale of this property. Just because he sells a lot of homes doesn't make him a great realtor, it means he ignores all his responsibilities to his client, in an effort to sell more. Slow down Garrett Rothman pay attention to the details, answer your clients questions, your fiduciary responsibility is to represent your clients, make sure we know what our responsibilities are, and please make sure the legal documents you have us sign are accurate and without error. Mind you this was a high end home, $350k. And I've been treated better buying a used car. Do not choose RSR Realtors or Garrett Rothman.

I have purchased 3 properties in the past 5 years and used Garrett/RSR for all 3. I send family and…read morefriends to Garett regularly because of how easy he makes the process. I have nothing but positive things to say about his approach, talent and work ethic. You should highly consider meeting Garrett if buying or selling real estate in the greater Central PA region. You won't be disappointed.

Aaron helped us relocate to the Cumberland County area. He was extremely knowledgeable of all the…read moreareas as well as good builders. He listened to what we wanted and answered our questions honestly. He help direct us to areas that matched our interests. He communicates very effectively and is easy to work with. I can recommend him without any reservations.

Aaron is very informative and answered our questions throughly. We spent many hours looking at…read morehouses and asking questions but he was always happy to help. He was quick to respond to an email, text or call. He provided us with great info and walked us through the entire home buying process. Overall he's an amazing realtor who exceeded our expectations!

Extremely Poor Communication and Ethical Concerns with Thomas Stewart of Cavalry Realty…read more I encountered significant challenges and frustrations during my attempt to purchase a property listed by Thomas Stewart of Cavalry Realty. The experience was marked by miscommunication, lack of transparency, and unfulfilled commitments, ultimately resulting in financial loss and wasted time. Below is a detailed account of the events: Nov 10, 2024: Viewed a property listed for $209,900. Nov 11, 2024: Submitted an offer $6,000 above asking price with contingencies (price escalation, inspection, and mortgage). Nov 12, 2024: The seller's agent, Thomas Stewart, informed my buyer's agent that the inspection contingency was an issue and insisted we complete the inspection that evening, citing urgency due to a "final offer" from the bank. I quickly arranged for an inspection and updated my offer accordingly. Nov 19, 2024: Received notice that the bank requested "final offers" by Thursday. Nov 20, 2024: After confirming with my agent that additional offers were allowed, I submitted a higher bid, making it the top offer. Nov 26, 2024: My agent communicated that I had the highest bid, and I was informed via text that I would soon receive paperwork confirming acceptance. This was corroborated by an email from Thomas Stewart indicating that my offer had been accepted. Nov 27, 2024: Upon request, I was granted permission to enter the property to take measurements for flooring and appliances in preparation for Black Friday purchases. Nov 28, 2024: Based on the understanding that my offer was accepted, I purchased flooring and appliances. Nov 26 - Dec 5, 2024: Followed up multiple times regarding the sales agreement, but Thomas Stewart consistently failed to respond via phone and only communicated sporadically via email. Dec 11, 2024: My agent informed me that the bank now preferred cash offers to close by year-end, despite previous indications that my offer was accepted. I attempted to accommodate by offering either a maximum mortgage-based bid or a competitive cash offer, but no negotiation occurred. Dec 12, 2024: Was informed that the bank chose another offer. My agent's requests for clarification from Thomas Stewart went unanswered. This experience has been deeply disappointing. While I understand the competitive nature of real estate transactions, the lack of clear communication and transparency throughout this process was unacceptable. Decisions were made based on representations that my offer was accepted, leading to unnecessary financial and emotional strain. I strongly urge potential clients to exercise caution when dealing with Cavalry Realty. Clearer communication, more ethical practices, and greater accountability are sorely needed to avoid situations like this in the future.

Thomas Stewart has been a stellar realestate agent that has represented me in the sale of two…read moreproperties. He is the kind of agent that makes selling a property a breeze. Professional thinks outside of the box gifted salesman. I highly recommend Calvary Realestate for all your realestate endeavors. I will continue to seek Tom out for any future realestate transactions. He is simply the BEST.

If you want someone who will get you into a new listing early, knows what's coming on the market,…read moreand will get you the property you want - go with Mick. He's part of the Berkshire Hathaway group I believe. We have bought and sold 3 houses now...and as a buyers agent, Mick is the best we've had. Here's why: - He is fast and good with communication. He was accessible, responsive, and able to answer questions quickly... - He knows the market amazingly well. When looking in Lancaster city itself, he was ON IT. He knew exactly what houses were worth, what was opening up (and why), and how quickly to move on a property if you're interested. - He only shows you things that you say you want. You know how some agents will send you listings that you'd never be interested in? Mick seemed to *get* our taste immediately, and everything he showed us was relevant. We found a house very quickly. - He can do everything electronically. For us as an "out of state" buyer, this was a LIFESAVER! We could sign documents easily, and get the deal done quickly. No faxing, no mailing or overnight stuff. - He was brilliant at negotiation, straight forward with advice, and goes to bat for you. We listened to him around what houses were worth, how fast they were going, and bid accordingly. He was also honest around what we could negotiate and what we couldn't. We listened to him, and everything went incredibly smooth. From what we've seen...the city of Lancaster is really on the brink of a boom. Tech companies are moving in, restaurants are coming in, and real estate is moving fast. If you want someone who can keep up with the pace and get a deal done quickly - Mick is the man. I really can't say enough good things about him. Really solid.

I bought my second manufactured home from Stoneybrook Homes last year. I can't say enough good…read morethings about them from the beginning to when I moved in. John McCall and his crew are top notch. Service was great anytime I needed it.

Worked with John and Dee to find options for disposition of my Mom's trailer. They came out and…read moreassessed the mobile home and gave our family great options to consider. Ultimately we sold the mobile home to them. The sale was completed without a hitch. Their experience in the industry and local area was vital to our decision. They answered all of our calls and questions along the way. John accommodated our timeline and special circumstances. These folks are professional, experienced, efficient, and caring.

Paula is a professional who knows the trade and makes a huge difference for the client. She not…read moreonly completed the sale but found us a new home as well. There is no one I would rather work with. Paula is everything you would want in an agent, and much more. I could go on and on... if you have a home to sell or need to buy one, this is the professional you want to work with!

My experience with Lyric Mateo as my Realtor was wonderful. She handled everything professionally,…read moreshe was prompt and very knowledgeable or the buying and selling process. She was in constant communication and it was clear and concise. I recommend her if your looking to sell your home or looking to buy one. Thank You Lyric for helping me and my husband with the sell of our homes. Enjoyed working with you. You made it quick and easy for us.

Ron and Mike make a great team!…read more We were in town just checking out the York/Hershey area since my husband got a job offer and we had literally just two half days to search for potential homes. We had originally been dealing with Ron but he brought Mike in too due to our time constraints. They worked around our schedule and strategically planned each showing so we weren't wasting time traveling back and forth. They also kept up to date on each listing so that we could cross a few off the list that suddenly went under contract. They listened to what we liked and didn't like at each showing so that we were able to further narrow down what we were really looking for and cross a few more off the list that didn't sound like they would work for us. I also appreciated their no-nonsense approach especially in dealing with a selling agent at a model home that was trying to put the hard sell on us and taking up a lot of time. Before our flight home even landed they located a house that met every single one of our parameters, and we had some tricky ones (At least 4 bedrooms, master on the main floor, no HOA, at least half an acre, in a town that is zoned for pet pigs!) We ultimately decided on relocating to a different state and decided not to buy in PA after all. However, should things change and we end up back in that area, we would immediately reach back out to Ron and Mike to help us find our dream home.