We love Jersey Mikes ! Reminds us of our previous home in New Jersey because they make their subs with all the oil and vinegar, the Jersey way. I eat lunch there often as it's nearby. The chocolate chip cookies are the best ! read more

I had a little different experience at this store. The workers were fine. Not super friendly, but not rude or lazy. Although I will say there were like 3 people ahead of us and we were still there at least 20 minutes/half an hour. But the food was aweful. The meat was dry and tasteless. We each got a version of the chicken cheesesteak and neither sandwich was good at all. I ate at a different Jersey Mike's once and it wasn't good, but figured I'd give it another try because we were looking for something fast and decent for lunch. This wasn't fast, and it was really borderline inedible. Very dissapointing. Two stars for the pleasant woman taking the orders. read more

We love Jersey Mike's!!! We typically frequent the one closer to us in Hanover, PA; however, we were traveling and stopped by this location in Gettysburg. The subs are always so delicious and fresh! We love the fact that they freshly slice their deli meat and it's sliced thin. The employees are always so friendly and courteous. Jersey Mike's is typically a busy place, which is great for their business!!! So, it has a busy atmosphere, but it's always fun and organized!!!! read more

See all

I usually love Jersey Mike's, but not this one. I think they possibly need new management, because the young lady (Erin) making my sandwiches was rude to me and her coworker that was slicing the meat. I asked her for light oil and vinegar and she did the opposite. Then she smothered both sandwiches with mayo. I asked her nicely if she could take some off and I got an attitude from her. Obviously she was having a bad day, but don't take it out on the customers. Take a break if needed. Or find another job that you like. So if you want a sub go to Subway. read more

Food was good as usual, service was good also. Store was very busy, behind the line took a beating, however as soon as they got the customers taken care of EVERYONE , immediately started recovering, cleaning everything up behind the counter, no one was just standing around watching others clean, within 10 minutes they had it clean and ready for the next rush. Great team there Saturday afternoon!! read more

The only reason this is two stars is because the sandwiches were actually good with crispy bacon and decent bread. We ordered online as we were looking for a quick bite while shutting down the camper for the season. When we got there (at 3:50pm which was right on time) our food was ready but the receipt only showed one sandwich. We asked the guy behind the counter if this was our order because we ordered 2 sandwiches. He said "is there two in there?" We answered yes and he said "well I guess it's yours then". My wife reached in the bag and said "there is nothing hot in here and I ordered a chicken cheese steak". He looked at us again and said "is your name on it?" We answered yes he replied "then it's right". This is the first time we tried this place (we try to stay away from chains) but it was recommended by a neighbor at the campground. We just left with what we hoped was our sandwiches and couldn't believe how insanely small they are when we got back. Almost $20 for basically less than one regular sub if we went local. On a positive, they are tasty. On the negative, the customer service and price is absolutely absurd. Plus they pack the sandwiches with tons of lettuce so they can skip on the meats. We won't go back and we regret not using our local go to sun shop in town or even the other big chain sub place in town. read more

See all

Just what Gettysburg was missing! Can't say enough about Jersey Mikes. I know I'll be back. You can taste the quality, this is t subway. Was there on day one and then again a week later. Don't worry if they have a line it goes quick. I just hope we can get a White Castle next! read more

Very nice counter staff! Excellent service for us 7 customers. Subs tasted great, made to order. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Inside counter - Fast Food Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

I'll preface this by saying that I don't normally eat at chains as I find their quality below traditional mom and pop places. I also lived in north Jersey for 10 years and Jersey Mikes was not on the list of go to places because it was no where near the mom and pop quality of a real deli. Having said that, one thing I generally like about Jersey Mikes in the crusty bread, that set it apart from Subway, etc. in my mind, so I thought I would try this place when it opened. I had one of the Italian subs and was surprised to learn it didn't have crusty bread anymore, it was soft like at Subway and the rest of the sandwich was pretty much what I remembered. The meats were pretty meh although there was a good serving of them, the bread was definitely meh, so all in all the sandwich was meh. Was it bad, no... was it good, no... just meh. It is better than Subway so if that is your comparison you will probably like it. For me it was more of a "I don't see the hype" moment. I will say the staff was very friendly and this review is no reflection upon them. You have a given set of ingredients to work with. read more

One of the WORST jersey Mikes around. Go anywhere but here if you are in town or just passing through town. They are Lazy and ignorant children working here. They have zero leadership and no accountability. If they dont want to make your sandwich they will give you an excuse and try to make it appear as a company policy. Issue with this is i know their policies. sad because the old owner was an amazong owner that ran his company the way it is suppose to run, but no more. One of them apprently wants you to yell at him because all he says is "what did you say" over and over again. we went in there nobody there at all. Forgive me two people eating, nobody in line or waiting. they don't understand cross contamination at all. Which is one of the excuses they will give you for not doing their job. My son who went with me even made me tion of how badly the three boys, children were that were working. Bad Bad Bad, Do better! read more

I have zero issue with the food at this location. It's always good. The issue is with service. I was third person in line, but the line did not move for over 15 minutes. Employees were fulfilling a couple of very large orders, plus DoorDash. And ignoring the three of us in line. Even when four more people joined the line behind me, I didn't move even an inch. They kept filling orders for people not in the store. First, large orders should require advance notice and be fulfilled in between in-store orders. Second, DoorDash orders shouldn't take precedence over people in the store. When I finally got to place my order, the guy said, "Is it all right if I fill another order first?" Me: No! I wasn't rude, but assertive. There was no manager on duty to turn to. If this continues to be process, I will begrudgingly give up my Jersey Mike's addiction. PS: I don't order JM via DoorDash. Two bad experiences. One never delivered (not this location). Second, sandwich arrived soggy (this location). read more

I've stopped at this location half a dozen times. The service I received was bad when it first opened and I chalked it up to being a new location. I had a couple of reasonable experiences after that, but today was ridiculous. I walked in and was the only customer. There were 4 employees standing around chatting. An employee took my order. Another customer came in as the employee was pulling bread out. The new customer walked up beside me. Instead of continuing to make my sub, the employee ask the new customer what he wants. The new customer has a complicated order. The employee decides he needs to write it down. So he walks away from making my sub to get paper and pencil. Meanwhile, there are three other employees standing around doing nothing. I'm 62 years old and I can't recall having ever encountered such a dysfunctional shop. read more

Great food, efficient, friendly and outstanding selections! The employees seem genuinely happy to be there!

A turd on a roll would have been better than the sandwich I got. The roll was dried out and not good. It hurt my teeth to eat. The meat looked fatigued but I was so hungry I ate it. 6 hours later I'm sitting on the porcelain throne trying to expel it. Hard pass.... read more

We have 2 Jersey Mikes where we live in New Jersey . This Jersey Mikes in Gettysburg beats them in the quality of the sandwiches and the cleanliness of the store. The staff is so friendly and accommodating. I guarantee that we will be coming back to Jersey Mikes every time we come to Gettysburg . I give it 20 stars!!! read more

Prices are unusually high for a Jersey Mikes chain. A box of subs cost us $83 at this location compared to the $52.50 advertised online for all other locations. $83 for 4 subs is more than what it would have cost to purchase individually and cut ourselves, doesn't make much sense. We will not be purchasing catering from this location again, which is very disappointing. read more

These guys made one of the best NY style sandwiches I ever seen. Truly some great artisans crafting the stuff here. Made a rough night easy and a cold sandwich warm like the sun. Good meats good eats. read more