Best restaurant in all of Wisconsin!! I have NEVER experienced better customer service! Subs are top class and are priced well! Special shout out for Noah and Andrew Martin. Give them a raise immediately or I may have to talk to the higher-ups! This made track season super fun! Best restaurant ever! read more

I said it like 4 times and I'm gonna say it again. THIS IS THE BEST JERSEY MIKES EVER!!!! Andrew Martin and Noah are the best employees ever, need a raise, no glaze at all. AND, and, they got the most peak childhood memory inducing music, Life is a Highway! This is why Jersey Mikes is the best, truly, A Sub Above. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Sandwiches Near Me - Pewaukee, Wisconsin

See all

Stopped in on March 21 at 11:45 am. Was told they only accepting online orders. How stupid is that on a busy Saturday morning. Went next-door to chic fil a. read more

This location is the best. Becky, the GM, and her staff are always attentive, kind, and courteous. Very clean restaurant, and my order is always correct. The subs are always tasty, no matter my order. read more

What I don't like about the place is that not all of the workers wear hair covering so, once in while I get someone's hair in my food. It's a problem up and down Capitol, none of the "fast" food places completely enforce head covering, gloves, handwashing. This was an area where no one masked up during the Pandemic, less than ideal attitudes towards food service sanitation is part of the local subculture. I've eaten all over this suburban strip mall purgatory because of a part time job, and JM subs falls into the better than average around here category. read more

Service was rather slow for having 3 employees since they seemed more concerned about online ordering instead of walk in customers read more

See all

Finally had the chance to try Jersey Mikes and was very pleased. Had the signature Italian ordered Mikes way to see what it's all about. The oils and seasoning is great although it was somewhat bland, they offer peppers as an add on so next time I plan on stepping it up a notch. Overall great service and it's always nice to try something different. read more

Walked in at 6:30 and there was someone mopping the floor the entire floor was wet and was very hard to walk on not to mention getting around the girl mopping with the huge bucket then while ordering as this was my first time ever so I was not sure how it all worked the employee hit me in the head with her mop and no one said a word won't be back and I haven't even tasted the sub! read more

So I'm really happy they have gluten free bread. But the ambiance is TOXIC. There were 2 women and one man working today. Not speaking to each other, barely mumbling to customers. We almost left before ordering, these people obviously hate their jobs, or each other, or customers. Horrid place. read more

Was stopped on Capitol today as there was some road construction and witnessed the owner or an employee get out of his vehicle and exchange words with one of the workers. It looked as though he made a left turn when clearly there were signs that said no left turns and he may have almost hit the worker with his car as the man was doing his job. I will also add that all the turn arrows were red which clearly means no turns. He then proceeded to hold up traffic and curse at the young man.Very sad scene to say the least. Needless to say, I will not be spending money at this location If that is how the owner treats people that are trying to make our city nicer. read more

went at about 3, all workers were very rude. when i asked how big the bread was they pointed rudely and rolled her eyes. they were talking about us behind the counter and ignored us as we waited to order for a good 5 min, making online orders. immediately after handing us the order, everyone but the young boy working sat down and went on their phones in front of customers.my experience was terrible, i will never come back to this location, they were not wearing name tags either. i have a feeling they spat in my sandwich. they refused to get up off their phones for a customer trying to order. they did not greet us or talk while taking our orders. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Sandwiches Near Me - Pewaukee, Wisconsin

See all

I ordered two roast beef subs online. it said there would be a 45 minute wait. I walked in after 20 minutes and a young man was working on my order. I asked the manager and he asked him what he was making, and he confirmed it was mine. This made me sure that it wasn't a mistake or the manager didn't see it. She actually stood there and watched him. He proceeded to put two paper thin pieces of roast beef on each one. Then he picked up four onion "strands" about an 8th inch thick and three inches long. He placed two strands on each sub. He then grabbed a small handful of shredded lettuce and distributed it liberally on each sub. Finally, he put two paper thin pieces of tomato on each and squirted them with some juice (presumably italian dressing) He cut them in "half" and they packaged them like they were made of gold. Including a bag with a handle. I wish I had said something right then and there. When my wife saw them she laughed. What a joke. Bill was $22 already on my credit card. What an absolute rip off. I wish I had taken a picture when I got home. Go anywhere else. That place is a rip off! Ben Around read more

When my family and I walked in, new customers to Jersey Mike's, Dylan, and Greg hooked our family up! They had an extra sub laying around that wasn't going to get eaten. Dylan offered to add bacon to the sub and gave it to us for free! Overall, the 4 subs we got were amazing and we are definitely coming back! read more

i've never had a worse experience. don't get me wrong, the sandwich was fine, the staff however were so genuinely rude that i will not be coming back to this location ever again. walked in and immediately had all of them rolling their eyes at my two friends and i. we waited for about 5-10 minutes just standing there, no line, while they all sat on their phones and did not address us. they used as little words as possible during the entire experience while still managing to be rude as ever. at the end we talked to the manager and told him how it went and he was very sweet and made it a lot better. 2/10 overall, +1 for the sub and +1 for the managers efforts. read more

Out shopping and decided to stop by for lunch. Not a regular JM diner, so not familiar with the menu. Made my selection and the employee muttered something which I later discovered she was confirming my order by the number. Another woman appeared and prepared to slice the meat. Well, they made the wrong sandwich for which I apologized. Before I had a chance to reply, the slicer remarked that "they aren't going to want it anyway" and began prepping our next sandwich. When that sandwich was complete, she threw it on the counter so hard, the meat fell out onto the counter. Her attitude was unprofessional. A counter which clearly hadn't been cleaned after the last sandwich they made. I should have cancelled my order and walked out, clearly the staff here do not appear to care about quality service, and performing actual work is an inconvenience. I will never eat here again. read more

Walked in 20 minutes before they close and the staff told me they were already closed. Not sure if hours are wrong or if staff just didn't want to work. read more

Great sub, a bit overpriced. The customer service was excellent at the Peewaukee location.

My order wasn't ready at my specified pick up time, no big deal. I understand, wasn't the slightest mad or annoyed. Got home & noticed my sandwich was wrong. Called to tell them & was told "that's hard to believe, I made it myself" Does that sound like good customer service? Not at all!!!! Very disappointing. read more

Dine on 1-29-21 evening.....Excellent service and very deaf friendly!!! I'll definitely come back again!!! Clean and safety...

They have the best subs around by far. The staff is extremely friendly. I highly recommend this place. Many choices to pick from.

Placed an online order for subs at 10am to be picked up at 11:35 to get to my sons school picnic . arrived at 11:34 and subs were not ready until 11:48. I would have been better off ordering when I got there. Very disappointed how the service has been the last few months. read more

Jersey mike"s in Pewaukee on capitol is fortunate to have JORDAN ! Exceptional personality and expertise with his subcraft! JORDAN introduced me to his take on the original Italian on rosemary bread. What a wonderful suggestion,jalapeños, mayo. pickles, Assortment of italian meats and cheese s. what a treat. thanks JORDAN!!!. read more

What an amazing location. If they are busy they apologize when your in line and it's like a 3 minute wait they are apologizing. Have had many great experiences here but Jordan, what a Jem to have. He is so sweet and polite. Delish sandwiches but awesome workers especially Jordan! Hope you get the pleasure of having him serve you. read more

I went here and the employee wasn't paying attention to my sub she was making and poured plenty of oil n vinegar onto it!!!! I told the girl that I didn't want it and to remake it. Then she rolls her eyes and starts a new sub, the other employee, a man , comes and butts in n states WE ARE NOT MAKING NO MORE SUBS FOR YOU, You take what we make or GET OUT OF MY STORE!!! I was appalled at his customer service because I wasn't upset about the sub that was made wrong at all since she was remaking it! Then he tried to overcharge me by almost ten dollars! And kept saying he was right, etc so he then says you don't like the price go somewhere else! How rude! I was buying 4 giant subs! Never again at this location! I emailed the jersey mikes corporate and I'm guessing they just sent the email to that owner and I never got a call nor a email back from ANYONE!!!! Never go here they suck at customer service!!!! read more