I cannot comment on the skill of this Doctor at all but I can say...I submitted a request for a virtual consultation as described on his website. I sent a request from said website. I never heard back from anyone. I called today and was told he does not do these consultations anymore now that the covid restrictions have been lifted. Someone needs to change the website and stop the false advertising. I live in NJ and can bearly walk so a in person visit is out of the question. I am a senior and all alone so.....Who do you believe or trust these days....not sure our medical system is in a sad state of affairs. read more

I was referred to a DO Dr. Varlotta from this office who put me through the most painful experience of my life, with absolutely no positive results. Furthermore, the procedure and practitioner overcharged and is not approved by medicare not insurance. I would find another office to trust you health and well being with. read more

Two years ago, Dr. Stieber performed an artificial disc replacement (ADR) in my C5-C6, and basically gave me my life back. I had been living with increasing pain from a herniated disc that at one point was so bad I thought I'd never work again, let alone watch a movie in a theatre or sit in a plane long enough to take a real vacation. I was on disability from work a couple of times, and had gotten to the point where I thought I was just one of those people destined to take opiates and watch daytime TV for the rest of my life with bad gray roots coming in. At the time, the ADR surgery was pretty new, so we considered a fusion briefly, but I was concerned about loss of mobility. I am so glad I selected this surgery and this surgeon! Dr. Stieber is exceedingly competent but he's also NICE and he cares about his patients as people. For my surgery (performed at NYU), he brought in a fabulous anesthesia specialist who seriously listened to me regarding my tendency to become quiet nauseous with general anesthesia and doubled up on the anti-emetic as a result. I was back at work in just 10 DAYS after the surgery, an amazing feat in my opinion, as I am part of a Facebook group of people who had the same or similar issues and surgeries. I had one of the absolute best experiences of anyone in that group. In fact, my mobility after the surgery is better than it had been in years. I am just so impressed and grateful, and every time i bang my head at karaoke, I think how lucky I am to have had Dr. Stieber as my surgeon. THANK YOU! Also, his office team is great too! read more

Well the Dr had my last review removed says it was not first hand well he still has not corrected MY paper work after I called and emailed them, He is still billing the wrong insurance company so how is this not first hand yelp. He still also recommended way to much surgery when all I really need is Strength building. read more

Was really impressed with my experience with Dr Stieber. Too often surgeons recommend surgery as an immediate fix to a problem, but he is the opposite. I became his patient due to chance when I ruptured a disk and was in extreme pain. He was the surgeon who conducted my surgery with barely any scar and immediate relief of the pain. Also, he has great bedside manner and actual personality so it's easy to speak with him openly. A few months after surgery I had another issue in my back which had me freaking out - I thought I needed surgery again and my wedding was only 5 weeks away. Dr Stieber saw me immediately, helped assess the issue, and assured me I wouldn't need surgery again. How often does a surgeon tell you that you don't need surgery? His office staff is very professional but friendly and on their A Game which I also appreciate. They reflect him as a physician. The only reason why I would consider knocking off a star is because appointments last about 2 minutes maximum, but unfortunately that seems to be the way of the world nowadays. read more

I recently (12 weeks ago) had Dr. Stieber perform a two level total disc replacement in my cervical spine (c5/6, c6/7) with mobi-c. I was experiencing significant pain and muscle weakness from left sided radiculopathy. I am an active weightlifter and was concerned about permanent nerve damage and strength loss. Going through with this surgery was one of the best decisions I have ever made. 12 weeks after surgery I'm near completely at full strength with no remaining symptoms. The entire process was smooth and all of the medical staff at NYU Langone were top notch and caring. I appreciate what you did for me Dr. Stieber and NYU Langone. I highly recommend Dr. Stieber to anyone who needs cervical spine/disc replacement surgery. One of the best in NYC. read more

Dr. Stieber is incredible! I was in an insane amount of pain in my leg due to the largest herniated disc Dr. Steiber had ever seen. He assured me that the surgery was minimally invasive and while there were risks--as there always are with surgery--that it was not a difficult procedure for him to perform. "I do about 80 of these every year," he said. That immediately put me at ease. I woke up from surgery pain-free and walked up the five flights of stairs to my apartment without any difficulty. People were amazed I returned to work so quickly and was walking as if I'd never had a back problem. His staff is also fabulous. They took care of all the icky insurance details before I even left the office and are both friendly and professional--answering all my questions and listening to my concerns. If you're having spine issues, go see Dr. Stieber. He's brilliant! read more

I'm actually pretty shocked to read so many positive results for Dr. Stieber. Not because I found him to be a terrible doctor--I'm sure he's a brilliant orthopedic surgeon--but because I feel that, after two visits to the office, I still can't make an accurate judgement call. Between the two visits, Dr. Stieber probably spent a maximum of 35 seconds diagnosing, explaining my condition, and recommending the appropriate course of action. After reading all of these reviews highlighting his clinical empathy and ability to make patients feel at ease, I am forced to think either that 1) this 'caring' kicks in once you become a surgical patient, 2) that he's done this so many times that he is simply on autopilot at this point, or that 3) some outward characteristic(s) of mine led him to believe that I was uninterested in or incapable of understanding an explanation of my injury. So ultimately, if you are searching for an accomplished orthopedic surgeon in NYC, I'm sure he's great. But if it is important to you that your doctor is also someone who manages to empower you about what is most likely a condition or injury that causes substantial stress and discomfort in your life, he is, in my opinion, not the one. read more

I recently underwent a C5-6 Total Disc Replacement Surgery with Dr. Stieber and his medical team at OrthoManhattan & NYU Langone, and I **highly** recommend entrusting this team with your care. From end-to-end, the experience has been the best it could have been. Everyone I've come into contact with in his office and during the surgery has been highly competent, caring, efficient, thorough, and professional. They've gone above and beyond to meet my needs, physical and paperwork wise. Dr. Stieber quickly won my trust and the trust of my family & friends, which is critical during these experiences. I had experienced a sudden onset of neck, shoulder and arm pain (an old yoga injury that crept up) that left me bedridden. My friend referred me to Dr.Stieber and his office was able to slot me quickly in for an appointment. From my friend's past experience and from my first interaction, I felt comfortable that Dr. Stieber has a conservative approach to treatment and does not like to rush into surgery. After receiving my MRI results, we confirmed it was a very severe disc rupture and there was high likelihood of surgery. I also had a doctor from HSS and medical friend review, and they supported Dr. Stieber's assessment. When the pain got suddenly even worse, I got a hold of Dr. Stieber directly who arranged my immediate admission into NYU Langone Orthopedic Hospital and booked the surgery the very next day while accommodating my mother being able to fly in. The NYU Langone care was beyond my expectations - nurses, anesthesiologists, nerve experts, transport services, food services, physicians, etc. The surgery went very well. I was again walking the day of the surgery, my scar is healing beautifully, and I am back to work after 2 weeks. I am so grateful for how well-taken care of and confident I've felt in what could have been a very scary experience. Thank you Dr. Stieber and to your entire medical team. read more

Dr. Stieber is absolutely incredible! I recently underwent a posterior and interior L5-S1 spinal fusion and today I am 100% pain-free. For years I experienced pain in my lower back, even when sitting. When I decided to go the surgical route, Dr. Stieber and his team made me feel comfortable every step of the way. He is a true professional and I wholeheartedly trust him - I am so glad I did the surgery. read more

Dr. Stieber saved my back and ended my leg pain. I have had an L5-S1 disk hernia for a couple of years and it was being treated by PT for that amount of time. A few weeks ago the PT started to become less effective. Then on Sunday night all hell broke in my back. I couldn't stand, I couldn't sit, I couldn't lie down. I could only lie down face forward. I was on all sorts of drugs for the pain. dilaudid was the only one that had any impact. I went to Dr. Stieber's office at St. Lukes Roosevelt and he had me admitted. I had an MRI within a couple of hours, and we scheduled the procedure for the next afternoon. Dr. Stieber performed the procedure flawlessly, painlessly, and with extreme precision. I was out of the OR and in recovery within two hours, by about 6:00pm that night. I was able to stand and walk that night. By 9:00pm I was back in my room, and I hadn't felt as good in two years. Dr. Stieber was amazing. Simply the best. He saved my back, and I'm well on my way to recovery. Thank you Dr. Stieber. read more

Over a month ago Dr. Stieber operated on my back. He is simply amazing. And the brilliant care is reflected in his entire office staff. They are professional and caring in ways I had not experienced before. From the way they handle patients in the office to their quick responses to phone calls, they made me feel that my recovery was truly important to them. I had been suffering from sciatica for 2 years when I went to see Dr. Stieber. Surgery was my last resort and I was very frightened about having any procedure on my back. Dr. Stieber's website with its simple instructional videos calmed my fears. But it was Dr. Stieber's clear and kind way of explaining what he would do that ultimately put me at ease. Five weeks ago one morning at 6am I walked into St. Luke's Roosevelt Hospital's ambulatory surgery center to have my procedure - a microdiscectomy at L4-L5 to remove the cyst that was pressing on my sciatic nerve. That afternoon at 2 pm I left the hospital after the surgery and walked seven blocks to my home pain free. I followed Dr. Stieber's aftercare procedure to the letter and today I am a new person, pain free and truly grateful to Dr. Stieber and his amazing team. Thank you so much. read more

Dr stieber corrected previous 2 surgeries that did not take. I had a L4-L5 fusion He is professional and listens to the patient feedback. I should have started with him from the get go - gold standard in todays medicine. read more

Dr Stieber fixed me from extreme pain and has such a great way about him. I've got nothing but the best to say about him and his team. I am a new person and my recovery was very quick due to his work. After 3 weeks, I was back in the gym doing light workouts. The man is great! read more

Dr.Steiber is an excellent surgeon! My husband happened to become his patent on the emergency basis. We simply lucked out! His skills, his bedside manners were extremely professional. The recovery time was minimum, the incision looked fantastic, and my husband did not even need physical therapy after all. His office staff was absolutely on par with the doctor: professional, courteous and friendly. It was a great fortune to have met you, Dr. Steiber. Best of luck!!! read more

Jonathan Stieber, spinal surgeon: at least 5 stars. My husand had a MIS laminectomy five days ago. So far we are very optimistic. The pre op pain miraculously is ALL GONE. He still has weakness in one leg but it's already improving. My husband had suffered for years, literally, pain, spasms, and major loss of mobility. He had been in accidents at different times in his life and he is big. Only his hip and foot were orig. affected but health insurance made us wait and wait, to try riduculous required nonsense until spinal areas became degenerative in places. Now I hope Dr. Stieber is going to get our insurance co to cover the services nec. to get the leg strength back to to normal.. Thank you Dr. Stieber read more

I have never felt the need to write a followup review but in Dr. Stiebers case, I have to. He is an amazing doctor, he gives as much time as you need during appts, gives you honest clear information and in general you makes you feel as though he really does care about your well being, which I honestly believe he really does care how his patients feel. I have also had the chance to speak to other doctors in NYC (I work around a lot of Doctors) and he is highly regarded among his peers, they all say they would go to him if they needed a spine guy, that tells you a lot. I can not say enough positive things about Dr. Stieber. In today's world were you are lucky to get 5 mins with a doctor, Dr. Stieber is a refreshing change. His office staff is also amazing, surprised to read a review saying otherwise. Both Jen and Nancy have been kind, helpful and have gone above what is required of them. If you are having issues with your back you are in very qualified and kind hands here. read more

Dr Stieber is very warm, caring, thorough, and conservative, and if he believes he can cure the problem without surgery, he will try to do so. I had fractured C2 and was taken by ambulance to the hospital. I was in a neck brace. One doctor said he would have to fuse C1 / C2 which would have resulted in loss of 60% of my head's left-right rotation. When Dr. Stieber reviewed the CT scan, he felt the fracture could heal well without surgery. Over the next 12 weeks he was very thorough in my followup visits, testing for neurological damage and taking additional films and carefully reviewing them to watch for potential problems. After 3 months he said the fracture had healed enough to remove the neck brace, and he seemed genuinely pleased to have been able to let me avoid surgery, even though that's his business. His entire office staff is fabulous and also very thorough. read more

Dr. Stieber is knowledgable, nice and careful; which are the characteristics I look for. He has consistently suggested alternate treatment before resorting to surgery and has been willing to go the extra mile to make referrals where needed. I would highly recommend him to my friends (and have). read more

Dr Stieber gave me my life back!!. After 6 months of agonizing pain, Dr Stieber performed a fusion surgery that enabled me to get back on my feet. I am eternally grateful for his fantastic work. His staff is second to none. The worked with me and answered all of my questions and dealt with a difficult insurance situation so i did not have to do anything. I cannot believe how good i feel now. I never thought it would be possible to be normal again but thanks to Dr Stieber , I DO. read more

I saw Dr. Stieber for a herniated L5-S1 disc and he is nothing but respectful, thorough, confident, and empathetic. I was desperate at the time when I started feeling symptoms in my leg but his caring office staff was able to accommodate me that day on short notice. He took the time to teach me in layman's terms what was going on, discussed my options including both conservative treatments and surgery, had enormous amount of patience to speak with my worried family, and continued to follow up with my progress and recovery after surgery. He looks beyond the disc herniation itself and considers the whole person- asking me how my symptoms affected my job, my active lifestyle, and daily activities. Though I was in pain and frustrated with my back, his warmth, support, and positive attitude helped me realize that everything would be OK- and he was right! I am so glad that I made an appt to see him, in particular, that day and I would recommend him without hesitation, in a heartbeat, to anyone with back problems. read more