Maybe my husband and I went here on a bad night, but I thought La Tolteca was rough. My husband had a burrito and he said it was okay. I had a chicken taco with beans and rice. The taco shell was stale. The refried beans looked like doody on my plate. I couldn't even look at them because it was a mountain of cold, brown beans. I guess it's Plaza or nothing in Williamsburg. read more

Delicious spot, great service, carne asada tacos were great! Save room for Churros! read more

We absolutely love La Tolteca! Jose Ayala and his family never disappoint. Great food, great environment and great service. Pro tip...try the street tacos!!!! read more

La Tolteca has been our family's "go-to" Mexican restaurant for the past 15 years. Our kids, who are now in their 20s, still get excited about going there. Everything we've tried, from burritos to fajitas to their salads, has been great. Best of all, the service is always fast and friendly. read more

We have been going to los toltecas for several years and love it. We always look forward to eating there and the food authentic. This time we met Janet our waitress and she made our experience great. Can't wait to go back. Hi Janet! read more

This place is our favorite for a reason - they are consistently excellent. Great food with fast friendly service. No one can best that. We both eat in and get take out regularly. They have a wonderful variety with large portions. La Tolteca is the best! read more

Worse service ever. 1.5 hours and 2 of our party of 8 have no food! Food delivered that wasn't ours We cannot get a manager Absolute disaster!! read more

We are here last night after reading the good reviews and left with mixed feelings. I had a #102 and my wife had grilled steak, shrimp, and chicken with tortillas. Mine was just a bunch of burrito like items wrapped in beef and red sauce while her steak was a fatty cut of meat she said it was good. Mine was fine just not great or special. read more

La Tolteca - Mexican Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

Very nice and friendly staff! And even though the restaurant wasn't very busy now in winter time and we hesitated if to go or not, we do not regret! Their street tacos was one of the best I've had so far! read more

La Tolteca - Street tacos and tamale - Mexican Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

Good service! My parents loved their burrito. I got the spinach and bean quesadilla from the lovely (and lengthy) vegetarian menu. It was pretty good but not very big--about the size of a taco. Would have liked a little bit more since the salad and rice weren't much. read more

Chips and salsa were great. Beans and rice were also very good. We had the chimichangas with beef tips and white queso on top and they were fantastic. Also the food was so fast it was like magic. (9:30pm service!) read more

We came here with 3 children and 3 adults. The service was horrible. We got served 3 meals. Then another came. We waited for the other 2 meals of which one was a macaroni and cheese. It was another 10 minutes for the one meal and the child's meal did not come. I had to ask for that meal. When the meal was over I talked to the manager, who made excuses. Did not do anything for us for not being able to eat together. I would never recommend this if you have children. Maybe adult service is better. Will not ever return again. read more

Another fine lunch. The entrees always full of flavor and the server was on point making sure we had every thing we needed. Truly the best Mexican restaurant on williamsburg. You must check them out!!!!! read more

La Tolteca - the burrito was awsome another fine meal . grate job La Tolteca. - Mexican Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

Best Mexi around! Salsa was just ok but the food and friendly staff made it a wonderful experience I just wish I lived closer to make this a regular stop. My girlfriend had the California wrap and I had the choi pollo both were the best we've had in a long time. read more

Happened upon this place as we "touristas" were out and about. Food was excellent (I had the tacos supremos, with carne asada, and was impressed!). Washed it down with a 23-ounce Negra Modelo draft. Our server was Angel, and he was great. Extensive menu that we wish we could sample further, but alas, we are headed back to Ohio. read more

Fabulous authentic Mexican food. Packed parking lot, parked in pancake restaurant and walked over. Owner on site. Will be back.

We always get a great meal with friendly service from them! Any dish you order is great, the fajitas for 2 are a great takeout order and their cheese sauce is delicious. read more

This is by far the best Mexican food in Williamsburg and maybe on peninsula. I am a local and it is my go-to and it's not close. Do yourself a favor and go here if you want some delicious, authentic Mexican cuisine. read more

Gross. Mole wasn't even mole and chicken was tough. No flavor idk why its so highly rated

Great food, fast service, reasonably priced. What more could you ask for? It is easy to miss though, as it is a smaller restraunt and set back in the trees a bit. The place serves authentic style Mexican food, though most of the dishes aren't as spicy as I would have expected. This is one of the few restraunts on the east coast that serves mole poblano dishes. Try it if you haven't. Unless of course chicken with chocolate chili sauce isn't your thing. read more

We were traveling from Iowa and spent a week in Williamsburg. Naturally we ate seafood being on the East Coast. That being said we wanted to take a break from that and stumbled upon this and we were all very glad we did. Admittedly it was 3pm so we were the only people in the restaurant, so we were not surprised that the service was excellent and the food was brought quickly. What did blow us away was the food itself. It was very good. It was flavorful and made with fresh ingredients. As a warning the large margaritas are large (this is not a complaint, it's nice to not get skimped). We would highly recommend taking a page out of our book and take a break from seafood to go south of the border. read more

Good Mexican food east of the Mississippi? You're joking, right? Here's a quick test: If you recognize (and will eat and/or drink as appropriate) horchatta, carnitas, al pastor, and pico de gallo, you'll probably like this place. In fact, the worst thing we had was their salsa, which was fairly standard. But at least two of their food items were "just like home" (okay, maybe that's not saying much...but the pico de gallo and Mexican guacamole were made the pretty much as I make them, which is to say they were fresh and very tasty). read more

This is one of the best Mexican restaurants in Williamsburg. Food is great, service is excellent. Our waiter Alex was on point. I would have given 5 stars, but the parking is terrible. The Burrito San Jose is excellent.... the chorizo was fabulous and not dry or overcooked and the chicken was really tender. A must try if you are in the Williamsburg area! read more

Do get the guacamole! Everything was good except the guac! Sad that one thing can ruin the experience, but really?? I've had better guac that was rotten and gave me the squirts. This stuff was horrible. read more

The atmosphere is nice and quiet, the service is friendly and fast, and the food is pretty damn good. I would highly recommend it!

It met my expectation for a Mexican joint in W'burg, but overall my food was bland (asked for it to be extra spicey) and nothing special. Price was decent, but not any better value than most Mexican restaurants. They did serve me more food than I could eat with my entree order, and I did enjoy the meal overall. If you liked this restaurant, try Plaza Azteca a few miles down the road. Be warned, it is much busier than La Tolteca but I thought the food was better (better taste and freshness) for the same price. read more

I can't believe all the good reviews. The food was awful, my steak was 90% fat and 10% gristle. There was a group of ten with me and not one person enjoyed their meal. I rarely leave reviews but want to save someone from eating here. Sorry read more

By far the best Mexican food this southern California born boy has had on the East Coast. There raspberry margarita with actual raspberry liquor instead of flavoring was amazing, I heartily recommend it. We visited at seven on a Saturday night and it was full but didn't have any problem getting a table read more

This is one of the best Mexican restaurants I have been to. The staff is friendly and the food is great!

Tasty, fast, and cheap! We wandered over here during a lunch break while at a conference and made it back with plenty of time. They also did not have any problem with us paying separately at the register. They do accept credit cards. read more

Pretty good food, and much better than I expected for the area! We both got good meals at a good price, and were very pleased with how flavorful everything was. Plus, they had a hot sauce on the table that I discovered when I was in Mexico. Mariachi music, great wall paintings and soccer (/football for the rest of the world) made for a great atmosphere. read more

OutSTANDING!!! Generous portions, excellent service and the food was amazing. Only one problem: it's 600 miles from my house (my wife and I are visiting). read more

The service is always fast and friendly and the food's cheap. And last time I went I got my Dos Equis in a cool frosty mug! I don't know much about authentic Mexican but my friend from Austin, TX seemed to like it OK. read more

This restaurant saved our vacation! Good food, great service.

This is the only Mexican restaurant in town that we go to on a regular basis. The food is excellent, the prices are comparable, and they have the best Pico de gallo. Also the family that owns and operates the business are very friendly. read more

Well our server was nice but that's about all I can say about this place, food was bland, and you have to pay 2 dollars extra for more chips and salsa!! Never had to pay extra for that before, but again I was raised in a Hispanic household and I would much rather just eat at home than here. Prices were cheap so I guess you get what you pay for but seriously with all the amazing restaurants in Williamsburg like the second street bistro across the street no need to come to this place read more

We decided to try this Mexican restaurant as per the positive reviews on yelp. The menu was extensive with many Mexican favorites. The dish prices were average in my opinion. The service was very good. Our waitress was warm and friendly. The wait time for our food was really quick. Unfortunately one of the dishes at my table was under seasoned. However my steak,chicken and steak fajitas were fantastic. My 5 year old daughter had the kids meal which was a taco and burrito. She ate 3/4 of the dish with no issues. I highly recommend for dessert the burrito mazzana. It was really a treat to end our experience there.I would without a doubt come back and try some of their many other Mexican dishes. I do recommend this place regardless of the one dish that was under seasoned. read more

Loved it! Went here after a day of fishing in Williamsburg. Great food, drinks and service. Ordered the burritos carnitas with a dos Equis ambar the xangos for dessert! Amazing meat. Will return as a regular. read more

Overall, a good experience. The restaurant is clean, cozy and friendly. Service was outstanding and the food was served very quickly. We had the Tex-Fajitas and it was delicious. The fajitas could have been served up a little more sizzling, as it was barely making a sound on the plate and the beef was quite tough. I also found the margarita somewhat tasteless. Chips and Salsa were fresh and delicious. read more

We spent the weekend in Williamsburg staying at the Quality Inn next door. I pulled up this restaurant on Yelp and after reading the reviews decided to give it a try. I'm so glad we did! We're fans of Tex Mex and this place was perfect. All of our food was fresh, hot and served quickly. Our waitress was delightful and the prices can't be beat! read more