This place is permanently closed. It was great but I've been by in the last couple of months and it is a new restaurant

Stopped here for lunch while passing through on business and was so glad I did! I walked in and instantly smelled the delicious food. My waitress was very friendly and even brought me a surprise garlic knot to try as that's their most popular item. The restaurant was clean and beautifully decorated... I felt like I was sitting in a little slice of Italy right in good ol WV. I'd definitely go back to this place again! read more

Mama Mia Pie & Pasta - Stromboli with sausage, pepperoni, and ham - Pizza Near Me - Elkins, West Virginia

If you're looking for home made style pizza and comfort Italian food, make this your next stop! It's great! Check out my video of the pizza we had...it was delicious. We tried it just once but we loved it and definitely plan to return next time we are visiting Elkins WV. It's a causal restaurant with a fairy big menu of pizzas and Italian favorites. Service was very good and attentive with answering menu questions, recommendations and refilling drinks and checking on us. read more

See all

Wouldn't say i had a great time, The service was t good, Recently it closed and im kinda glad. The family owned place wasn't good. The workers were rude and acted like they hated their job and took it out on customers read more

Adorable Italian place in Elkins with some awesome lunch specials! You get a salad and garlic bread with the pasta which is discounted at lunch. Egg on the salad was over cooked but everything else was wonderful. Menu isn't anything out of the ordinary but it is very good and well executed Americanized Italian food. Server was very attentive and I love that there is enough for leftovers! I'll have to check out their pizza! read more

See all

I was in town for a golf tournament and thought I'd give this place a try because it had good reviews. Parking was difficult to find for this restaurant is downtown Elkins. When I walked in there were about three tables of folks eating. I was welcomed and told to sit where I'd like. I chose a two seater in the front window. The waiter was pleasant and helped me right away. I ordered the veal cutlet parm with pasta on the side. Instead of salad I ordered minestrone soup. I wish I hadn't. The soup tasted watered down and was bland. I didn't finish it. I also ordered a small calzone to take home with me when I was finished. The veal parm came to the table after about 15 minutes but was sat down on the other side of the table from me. The menu said it was PRIME veal. Either it wasn't prime veal or it was previously frozen and overcooked. It was difficult to cut with a butter knife, which is all I was given. Because the spaghetti and sauce was soupy, I just pulled some of the pasta out of the bowl and put it on my plate. It wasn't fresh pasta and it was a bit overcooked. So when I checked out I was handed the small calzone I ordered in a paper bag, which by the time I drove to my hotel had torn through the bottom and grease was all over the seat. I had asked for a box at the restaurant, but the gentleman who handed it to me didn't acknowledge my request. There is certainly room for improvement in the food and service, for the place wasn't crowded. Just not sure I'll give them another try. The veal and calzone cost about $38 with tax. Tipped $10. read more

See all

Inviting from the outside and did not disappoint. Our waitress was very sweet and did a great job. They have a nice wine and beer selection available. The pizza was really good, as you can tell by the photo, we enjoyed and then remembered to grab a pic of the last piece. Highly recommend if you are in the area. read more

Mama Mia Pie & Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Elkins, West Virginia

We had pizza and a salad. They were so good! The presentation on the salad was such a great picture! Pizza was absolutely delicious! If your lucky enough to have Isabel wait on you you will have hit the jackpot! read more

I wish I could rate this place higher than 5 stars, because it deserves it. In case you're here for just the cliff notes: delicious pizza, amazing dough, clean, kitchy atmosphere that you'd expect, large pizza & huge calamari = $27. It's an entire experience... when you walk in, it looks, feels, smells, and sounds like an Italian American pizzeria. Spices and red sauce waft in the air, Italian music plays overhead, flowers and Godfather posters adorn the walls, a loud Italian guy is throwing dough and bossing people around. We ordered a large pizza - half with only cheese, half with cheese and meatballs. It was beyond delicious. The dough was perfect, the sauce amazing, and the meatballs were delightful. We also ordered calamari - the biggest serving I have ever seen for $10! It was perfect. Parking is free on the street (thank you, City if Elkins!) and locates right beside the new Tip Top. Definitely add this place to your itinerary! read more

Mama Mia Pie & Pasta - Outside - Pizza Near Me - Elkins, West Virginia

See all

Ribs were delicious, pizza was not. Server was friendly and quick despite being busy. Quaint and cozy, perfect for a date night

Waitstaff was so helpfull with our little ones. The food was great! Only had pasta dishes so we can't rate the pizza but they were awesome. Good view too! read more

We arrived at 5:30 and the restaurant was busy but many empty seats in all three areas. There were at least 4 waitresses plus a guy busing tables, two workers in the bar area and someone working with the to-go orders. You seat yourself so we sat in the back where all middle row tables were open and a few others. It took ten minutes to get served. We placed our orders then with me asking for the baked ziti and a cannoli (which was the main reason we stopped) and my husband getting a calzone and lemonade. I got my salad and rolls that came with my pasta pretty quickly but it took another twenty minutes to get our drinks which we had to flag another waitress down to get them and my husband asked her for just water since we figured our food would be coming and he wouldn't get more than one refill. At 6:30 we were still waiting and we were told it should be coming. At 6:45 we were told they only had one cook. At 7:00 we were told it was going in the oven. At this time the table beside us that came in half an hour later already had their calzone and pizza. At 7:10 my pasta came out on a cold plate and barely room temp pasta which was soaking in watery sauce on the bottom of the plate. The two pieces of pasta I did eat were very chewy and over cooked. At this point we decided we were done and my husband went to find a manager to ask about leaving. He never did find a manager and the other staff were not "out" so he finally got the attention of someone in the bar. His calzone ended up coming during this time after 1hr 50min. The waitress was nice enough to not make us pay for my salad that I did actually eat and we left everything else on the table when we left. We never did see a manager or even have an offer of anything else for our time, patience, or horrible experience. While my husband was trying to find someone to talk to he also saw several workers in the kitchen area in red shorts which means even if there were only one "cook", like we were told, there were many hands in the kitchen working. Would give zero stars if I could. It was the worst experience I have ever had at a restaurant. It looks like many have had similar experience based on reviews and sadly doesn't look like the owners respond to anything but 5 star reviews. What we experienced tonight should definitely be concerning to the owners and likely their making. read more

Mama Mia Pie & Pasta - Cold pasta with watery sauce that took almost 2 hours to get - Pizza Near Me - Elkins, West Virginia

We're on a road trip from SoCal and found this gem on the way to Virginia. My wife and all 3 daughters are gluten free due to allergies. Both of my son's and I are not GF, though. We had both types of pizza dough and they were great! We have pizza a lot and I would say that my wife and younger son are pizza snobs, and they thought it was very good. The service was awesome too, very friendly! Trinity and Belle were super sweet and helpful. The gentleman that was cooking (possibly owner or manager) was very friendly and super nice as well. The ambiance is old school Italiano, very nostalgic. We will definitely return if we ever find ourselves in Elkins again! read more

Love this neighborhood gem. We enjoy stopping by often for their the light, crispy crust pizza pie, garlic rolls, spinach and broccoli, bruschetta, and eggplant stack appetizers. I'm sure other dishes are equally well executed from the look of other happy dinners. read more

This place was one of my favorites but it's went downhill quick. When I arrived on a Friday night there were only 2 tables occupied but trash was scattered all over the floor and every empty table needed cleaned. Looked like younger people running the show seemed more interested in dancing in the back and talking than working. The pizza was not the same either unfortunately. First time writing a review on here but I'm that disappointed. read more

This Jersey girl has a rule: never eat pizza out of the tri state area. Pizza outside of NJ/NYC is always disappointing. Well, I am vacationing in WV and needed to eat dinner on a Sunday night. I did not want fast food so I looked up restaurants and found Mama Mia's. Since I was out of dinner options I broke my rule and ordered pizza. It is described on the menu as NYC style which it is not, but I was pleasantly surprised. The pizza was delicious. I'm guessing it was a WV take on NYC pizza. I recommend the mamas special pizza which is basically the works. The wait staff and atmosphere were friendly. So, if you are in need of a pizza fix, go here. read more

Quaint joint with yummy food - lots of choices including seafood. The garlic rolls are sinful. Very personable waitstaff. Booths and tables, but the table for two in the front makes for an intimate setting during date night. read more

Mama Mia Pie & Pasta - a plate of food - Pizza Near Me - Elkins, West Virginia

See all

A snap decision found us staying in Elkins, West by God, and looking for local places to try. Since this place was number 2 rated in the area and we love pizza, we decided to give them a go. The pizza is New York style (my fave), the crust was cooked absolutely perfecto and the service was great! We ordered, and a few moments later our waitress and another lady came over to confirm our order. I think they thought we didn't know how much pizza we just ordered! That was so cute! What little we didn't devour, we carried back to our hotel to eat for breakfast! Go here. You'll enjoy it! read more

Delicious! The Italian Feast is just that- yum. The salad was super fresh and the rolls mouth watering. The service was friendly and immediate. read more

Mama Mia Pie & Pasta - a close up of a piece of bread - Pizza Near Me - Elkins, West Virginia

This place has taken a downward spiral in the last 2 years. The food is horrible. I don't think I will be returning to this place again. It's a shame because it once was a good Italian restaurant with great food and service but now it's horrible. read more

I never ever had such awesome and mouthwatering Italian food in USA Just go for it ... I am vegetarian and the options I was offered were not only overwhelming but very very delicious Do try white Pizza and garlic rolls If you think Olive Garden n maggiano's are best you are about to change your opinion .... mind it the portions are too huge to finish by 3people.... their small pizza is 12inch read more

Mama Mia Pie & Pasta - Garlic roll - Pizza Near Me - Elkins, West Virginia

If you read no more of the the review than this sentence, know this: if you aren't happy with the order, I have every confidence the owner will make it right. I remember when he owned a small shop in Morgantown Mall, and he was always so focused on the customer then, so I'm sure that has been a constant of his career. I love a good thin crust pizza made with quality toppings, and boy did they provide just that. The carry out order was prepared quickly, and was delicious. It is worth every penny. Give them a try. You won't be sorry. read more

Mama Mia Pie & Pasta - Dining room - Pizza Near Me - Elkins, West Virginia

See all

We had high hopes based on past reviews but left disappointed. They seem to be struggling with staff and service as most establishments are. Our service was great but we noticed others weren't pleased. Our chicken parm and baked ziti looked amazing but tasted somewhat bland. Portions are large with a price tag to match. read more

Drove here during the power outage at Snowshoe. What a lucky find! Waitress was super nice and food fresh and yummy. Garlic rolls and pizza were great. I'm eating my leftovers for breakfast. read more

Mama Mia Pie & Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Elkins, West Virginia

Server seem completely shocked when I asked for a tea with no lemon and no straw. Actually had to explain it step by step. Cheese sticks were from a bag and cold on the inside. Pizza was only so so. I asked if they had any beer and the server just laughed. read more

Absolutely delicious and wonderful, friendly, attentive wait staff to our large family. Everything from the cook making the pizza in front of us to the taste, was superb. We even went the next day, and it continued to impress us. Definitely would recommend eating here! read more

Food was great, chef and server very welcoming! The complimentary bread was awesome and the pizza was even better. I recommend!

We went out this afternoon for the garlic chips at Siriana's in Davis. The town of Thomas was full with tourists, Davis was just as bad. Didn't want to wait in line. I had heard about a pizza place in Canaan Valley. Found Mama Mia's Pies and Pints in the small mall there. Bottom line is they have great food. I had a spicy seafood appetizer loaded with octopus, squid, shrimp, mussels, clams, hot italian sausage and of all things, meatballs, all in a spicy seafood broth. Oh, and they serve a garlic roll with it. It was great. Terri had a sweet italian sausage plate over linguini, also great. Good atmosphere, not crowded, will definitely good back. Only down thing I can say is it is very pricey, so expect that. Most entrees are $21+. I only got the appetizer, but am glad I did. Serving was huge and I had a hard time getting it all down. Give it a try. read more

My colleague and I had a fantastic Italian Sicilian pizza here last night. It was way too big, we couldn't finish half of it but it was delicious! The wait staff was great, love the ambience of the place and the owner personally thanked us on our way out. If you're in the area, you can't go wrong with this homemade pizza place! read more

Mama Mia Pie & Pasta - Italian pizza - Pizza Near Me - Elkins, West Virginia

Terrible! Total rip off! 2 extremely thin (can see through them) pieces of meat on an Italian sub, no mayo, hot peppers, oil or seasoning as requested. Barely any pepperoni on 2 pizzas. Several slices on both pies had NO PEPPERONI AT ALL on them! Our order was screwed up when we went to pick it up and had to wait for them to remake food. Italian sub was a joke, 2 pizzas were a joke. Very overpriced! Place is a joke and a total ripoff!!! There are MUCH better places in Elkins to get pizza and subs!!!!! read more

This is my favorite pizza place, but it also is great for salads and pasta and desert. The owners are really pleasant and happy. Best place in town. read more

See all

Our eggplant entrees were excellent. The waitress was friendly and provided us great service.

After a long weekend of backpacking 25 miles at Dolly Sods, the guys and I were looking for some good grub after surviving on dehydrated meals.. After pulling up Yelp we decided to give this place a look even though we were looking a little rough and may stick out.. GOOD THING WE DID! I may be wrong, but I thought I heard an Italian accent coming from the kitchen, so it may be ran by an Italian immigrant.. It sure tasted like it! We had 2 large pizzas that were extremely flavorful from the toppings to the crust and right down to the fresh and perfectly seasoned sauce. Oh, and what a lot of reviewers seem to not mention are their wings; they are honestly some of the best wings I've ever eaten! The only negative impression we got was from our server.. I'm not sure if we were just really stinky (which I don't think we were) or just we were a little too disheveled for her liking, but she wasn't very friendly.. Not rude, but just a little cold.. Maybe she was having a bad afternoon, but all in all we loved this place! read more

Great food served in huge portions. You'll be sure to have leftovers. I love everything I have tried at Mama Mia's, especially the pizza and the Stromboli. My husband will order wings and a salad when we eat there or for take out. I always recommend Mama Mia's to people who haven't experienced the food. T They give military discounts too. read more

We could only take the picture of the desert, because the food was so yummy it was gone before i could snap a picture! Eggplant ala mama with the garlic rolls was just so good! Love this place, made our visit to Elkins so perfect! read more

This place has lost its spot as my favorite. They switched owners and unfortunately it's just not the same. I would still rate it as some of my favorite. I would do a sausage / pep / xtra cheese. read more

We called And tried to place an order and the man who answered the phone was very very rude and unprofessional and told us to stop talking while we were trying to order. read more

This is the absolute worse experience I've ever had in a restaurant... We got there early, ordered waited 2 hours and nothing. We were then told that our order could be prepared but it would take a while because they were busy. Only offered 20% off our bill. We will never be back and will make it our personal mission to keep people from this trash place. read more

i have been here 2 or so times before today, and the food and service was good. However, when I went there today for dinner, the waiter took our drink orders, and I was sitting within view of the cook. i witnessed him wipe his nose about 5 or so times, (no mask) with his bare hands, and start handling the dough and etc. I got up and left. this Is not a covid issue, it's just not good practice. I'd also like to add that the last time I had the spaghetti, it wasn't worth the $18 they are charging now. Cmon guys. read more

This place is great! The pasta is delicious, and the garlic rolls are good too (nice chunks of garlic on top). Do yourself a favor and... Get. The. Gnocchi. With the vodka sauce. They bury it at the bottom of the pasta menu like it's a secret treasure buried in sea cave on the Oregon Coast and you gotta battle the Fratelli's with Sean Astin, Kerry Green, Corey Feldman and their crew to find it. Should be a feature item. Ask 'em to cook it a little longer than usual, so the gnocchis crisp up. Magnifique! read more