We absolutely loved Mario's while staying in Niagara Falls. We dined here twice while on our trip (usually against our rules unless it leaves a lasting impression on us!) Mario's is a cute little spot you may dine in or carry out, located on one of the main drags in Niagara. The delicious slices were served up quickly with a smile, both times. ;) I love the cheese, but the authentic pepperoni had me wanting that meat! You must try Mario's, it's amazing! read more

See all

I've never been to place that didn't have sausage pizza??? It's a first but my wife went with the pepperoni pizza slice. It's not New York style like big apple by along way. Not a Military friendly pizza place. read more

Mario's Pizza - Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

Just an ordinary Pizzeria in the tourist spot. Nothing really special about the place, but they use such good sauce on pie and my pepperoni pizza was really good! Friendly young girls assisted us with nice smile which made our days! Good stop by for quick lunch or snack pizza! read more

Mario's Pizza - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

My boys and I were just looking for someplace to eat down here in Niagara Falls before my son went back to Canada. We decided on pizza. My son Jeremy went in and got what was already made and just sitting there waiting and said it was OK but nothing great. I went in and asked if they had any pepperoni pizza and there was one in the oven so I had to wait for that one to get out. It was nice, hot and fresh. It was a huge slice of pizza for about $4.30 maybe ? I didn't check the price I didn't really care I just was starving. Lol. So I got two slices of pizza and I really enjoyed it. I like the sauce, the cheese, and the pepperoni was a little spicy pepperonis, which was yummy. We had a whole bunch of pizza pies already done all different ones inside the cabinet. The employee had a bit of an attitude, but it was hot, and the place was busy, and it was hard for them to keep up with their pizza. They were tables and chairs inside, and then a bunch of tables and chairs outside. It was so beautiful outside that we just sat out and ate. I really liked it and I would definitely go back. Their menus upon the walls were clear and easy to read. The cabinet where the pizza was, was all lit up and easy to see what was inside and what was on each of the pizzas. It's a decent little place, and, like I said, I would definitely go back there. read more

See all

It's tough living in NYC and having to review pizza outside of the area... Marios has an efficient staff, indoor seating, outdoor seating, but...not the best pizza. Sauce and crust weren't the best. Pizza itself may be 4-5/10 but the prices were also higher than expected. I understand this is a tourst area, so the prices will be higher...but $12 for two slices and a 20oz. soda....definitely not worth it in my opinion. I know buying by the slice may not be the best...maybe others may have better luck with buying a fresh pie. read more

See all

Affordable pizza near Niagara Falls. It wasn't amazing but it was also not bad. The price was reasonable, but no wow factor. I really did like that the slices were big. The serving staff was nice and they welcomed us as soon as we came in. Service was great. The ambiance was more pizza parlor. Indoor and outdoor seating. read more

Mario's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

Got a couple slices of pepperoni. Not great but not horrible either. Good amount of pepperoni and cooked nicely. Sauce was bland with not much flavor. read more

I really like the cheese pizza here - can't figure out why Yelp and google say it's closed - just dined there 2 days ago. I didn't order a full pizza since I was traveling and no place to store the rest but I liked it. read more

It was fine, not great. We tried cheese, veggie, and pepperoni. Cheese was the best, I thought. Sauce could be more flavorful, and a little light on cheese on all of it read more

The New York style pizza was super flavorful! There are some types of slices, but the more interesting pizza toppings are only available on their larger pies (meant for 2-3 people). I enjoyed Buffalo chicken, white sauce pizza. There are a number of tables with umbrellas in their outdoor seating area. read more

Well, it's not that we didn't recognize we were in a tourist trap block right by the entrance to the state park: the street's something of a pedestrian mall. And I won't deny that the slices we got were good pizza. But two slices of pepperoni and a single bottle of Diet Coke cost us $13, which is a ripoff by any stretch. (Could be worse. The cheapest they charged for a whole pizza was $26. Seriously? That size pizza is EIGHT DOLLARS CHEAPER in the college town in which I live, and they do soak the students around here..) Yelp billing this as a single '$' establishment is false. read more

This place is awesome. My pie was perfect. The ingredients is the key for delicious pizza. My favorite ingredient was the ham and pepperoni. If you are in Niagara Falls, Check out this place. read more

Just wanted a quick bite so a slice is what i was cravin. Went here and was not disappointed. Ingredients were fresh and flavorful. The slices were huge as I could barely finish mine and at the same time so good I wanted more. If I had more time in Niagara Falls I definitely would have had another meal there! This is a great little local joint to support if you're into supporting the locals. read more

Mario's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

We were expecting typical tourist-trap food (overpriced and tasteless) but were absolutely delighted in our experience. We ordered a basil pesto and sun dried tomato pizza which arrived piping hot and delicious. We dined outside and the waitress even brought a bowl of water for our dogs. I highly recommend this restaurant if you're looking for a really good example of a New York pizza. read more

Off the chain or out the trailer?!?!? Nice place pizza was well done. Nice portion and price per slice in a tourist trap town. Small sit down area and wide variety of pizza. Well cooked about all you can ask for when you just need something quick to power through more working read more

Seriously one of the top pizza places I've ever eaten at! Mario is a super great guy got a chance to meet him when I was there. He takes his business serious and it shows. The ingredients and the love he puts into each pie. This is a tourist trap area restaurant but it is so much more than the BS that is near by. This is a block from the US side of the falls. This is the first time my wife ever had a New York style pizza and she loved it. My wife is from California I am from New Jersey believe me I know what I'm talking about. She may not, but she did after this trip. We ended up getting a couple cheese slices and a couple of pepperoni slices. This is a fantastic stop if you're going to the Niagara Falls on the US side. This does for the belly, what the water falls did for my eyes. Mario, please keep the quality high as good food like this only comes from love of your craft. I ate at the Keg for $200 and I wish I had come to your place instead for dinner too. Great job read more

So so good! NY style at its finest. Various topping options. Friendly staff. $20 for a whole pie. They also sell by the slice. Convenient location near the visitor center. Indoor space is small but they have outside seating as well. They do tend to sell out by the time dinner hits so my advice is get there for lunch. read more

Mario's Pizza - Cheese - Pizza Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

See all

Great pizza! Nice thin crust! A+ They have a small seating section indoors and a nice outdoor area as well. read more

See all

The pizza was actually pretty tasty...or maybe I was just really hungry. My family and I came here after a day of walking around Niagara Falls. Since we ordered a whole pizza, we had to wait about 30 minutes before we actually got it. The pizza was great, but I do wish that the crust was a little harder. When pulling a slice of the pizza out, since it was still hot, a lot of the toppings slid right off. lol The sauce, toppings and of course the cheese were all great. I would go back if I was in the area, but I would probably let the pizza cool down a bit before grabbing a slice and hope that the toppings stay in place. Wow, just writing this review kind of makes me want more. Mmm. Not quite the Lombardi's pizza in NYC, but good enough. Review 59/100 for 2016 read more

See all

Pizza slices were pretty good. I had vegetable and a pepperoni. My daughter went with the vegan. They don't have vegan slices, you have to order a whole pie. So if you want a smaller portion you have to get vegan on gluten free crust. It was so so. I'm giving them 3 stars because I really wanted buffalo wings with my pizza. They don't sell them here. I drove all the way from southern Indiana and really wanted wings the entire way and all I got was NY style pizza. I'm going to NY in 2 days. I can get better pizza there. I can't get authentic buffalo wings. read more

The last time I was in New York, I didn't get a chance to get a slice. I knew I had to this time and Mario's was located close to Niagara Falls State Park. There were three options for individual slices: cheese, pepperoni, and vegetarian. I went with vegetarian ($4). It was a filling slice. I heard several other customers comment how it's the best pizza they've had, I don't know about that but I did enjoy it. read more

Mario's Pizza - Vegetable - Pizza Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

While visiting Niagara Falls in New York my family decided to give the New York style pizza a try. We needed to lay down the facts of who has better pizza, NY vs Chicago pizza. Hands down NY takes the gold medal!!!! Mario's pizza is located in the heart of Niagara Falls, USA. The service was outstanding! Our cashier was very friendly and energized! We ordered the cheese & pepperoni and pepperoni, mushroom, and jalapeño pizza. The pie was not greasy at all. The pizza sauce tasted fresh! The crust was perfectly cooked and not doughy at all. It was perfect all around! They sell them by the slice as well. I would order the entire pie because it's well worth it! We went back twice while we were vacationing. How I wish I can have the same back at home! read more

Mario's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

Always has great pizza, and right next to the state park and waterfalls. Usually only open in the summer. Worth getting a slice.

I ate here for the first time today. Wow! So simple yet the flavor is so robust and complex! I went with a couple pepperoni slices, & this sauce is mind boggling! Sooooooo good! I'll definitely be back! I would say this is a must stop when in the area! read more

Mario's Pizza - So simple yet the flavor is so robust and complex! I went with a couple pepperoni slices, & this sauce is mind boggling! Sooooooo good! - Pizza Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

One of the best pizza places I have ever eaten anywhere in the US, Canada or Mexico!!!

Mario's pizza was a last minute decision as others were closed at the time we wanted food. I'm so glad! It was delicious. Mario offered to accommodate our request for a half and half pizza which was so kind. We thoroughly enjoyed it and if they were open early we would have tried to grab one for the road!! read more

Mario's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

This is some solid, quality, New York pizza. Just a 3 minute walk from the hotel I am staying at (as well as a lot of the city) Mario's was the perfect dinner for our stop in Niagara Falls. I was looking for some vegan food, and I was able to get a delicious Primavera pizza (peppers, onion, black olives, mushrooms, Daiya cheese) and I am so glad that I did! I walked down after calling in a take out order and it was ready in about 18 minutes. This pizza is huge! Definitely enough to feed 3 people, possibly even 4. I was just surprised that there was only one size that you could order... I HAD to order the 18 inch pizza, costing me 27 dollars (sigh). But now I have enough pizza for the next two days! They did have single slices of some of the pizzas if you weren't starving. read more

Mario's Pizza - Best New York style pizza I've ever had! The Primavera, vegan style. - Pizza Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

Best pizza ive had on my vacation in niagara falls! Ive only had it twice but both times its been amazing! Definitely recommend if you're near it. read more

Well got to Niagara wanted a good pizza so went to Mario's ...took a hour to make us a pepperoni pizza and we didn't care for it I think the crust was a little burnt had that burnt taste but the cheese and pepperoni was ok ? read more

Pizza was OK, NOT a family establishment! music blaring was vulgar and profane and sexually explicit. Totally inappropriate unless it was a strip club. we will never go there again. Disgusting! read more

New York style pizza!! I'm usually not a big pizza fan but this place so good! I got supreme pizza slice and thought it was amazing. That means a lot coming from someone who doesn't really care for pizza. The slices were huge and thin crust. The place was pretty busy which must mean they have a good reputation. Def recommend this place! read more

Mario's Pizza - Supreme - Pizza Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

See all

First time in New York and I love the pizza slice special they had! They were fast and quick with hot delicious pizza!

I'm a transplanted New Yorker, so last weekend when my born-and-raised Hoosier fiancé and I were visiting Niagara Falls, I jumped at the chance for him to experience the NY pizza he's listened to me rave about and lament missing for years. Mario's did not disappoint, and my fiancé is already plotting our next trip back for his next fix. At $8 and change for two slices, it was also the cheapest meal we had our entire visit. read more

Mario's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

We stopped in today for lunch because we saw their signs around town advertising vegan pizza. We purchased a whole pie with cheese for our family and asked about purchasing a slice or smaller pie for our son who is vegan. We were told we'd have to purchase a full 18 inch pie. My son had a couple of slices and asked us to leave the rest on the table because it wasn't good. He is an adventurous eater and not picky at all so it must have been pretty bad. Extremely disappointing considering the $21 price tag. read more

Great pizza at an affordable price right next to the Visitors center. Appreciate the cleanliness and quality

Pretty good pizza here. Although, I didn't see any vegan options, I still thought the veggie pizza was really good. Edit... just found the vegan options lol read more

The pizza is good but the place is small. People just seat out side to eat. We just ordered for togo. read more

Mario's Pizza - It's good - Pizza Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

Why is the pizza crunchy? Sure that may be style but you should also work on the dining area. It isn't fun being swarmed by a swarm of wasps- The store was also too cramped and it was hard to sit inside of the store or atleast wait for your food. So my rating is a 3/5 do better, Mario. read more

Grabbed slices and pop from here while doing tourist things in Niagara Falls NY without falling into the tourist trap eateries. We were able to grab two huuuuuge slices from here and pop for pretty cheap. Enough to tide us over until dinner. Big, cheesy, and quick. Pepperoni filled with oil. Chewy, soft, good crust. Yum. and a spot to sit outside and people watch. I wish we had been able to try another variety, but this place will be in the back of my mind to visit next time we go up. read more

The pizza was one of the best pizzas I've had lately! My family came at a time when it was extremely busy, and yet our food still came 10 mins earlier than they said and cooked perfectly. We devoured a whole pizza AND went back for an extra few slices. The individual slices are big (almost two regular slices put together) and everything was a very reasonable price! Their vegetable pie was delicious and not layered with too much vegetables like many pizza places I've been to. Plus, the plain pie has the perfect crust. It's an awesome place to eat right there. You can eat either outside or inside in the AC. It's a great place for lunch when visiting Niagara Falls amongst all of the food trucks on the street. I definitely recommend! read more