Best beverage store on South Shore, bar none! The two gentlemen running this establishment are well…read moreinformed, helpful and run a clean and well stocked store. Just ask one of the owners when you enter the store what you need and they will grab it for you. Truly a well run business.

I'm looking for Heineken Dark beer........very hard to find. So I walk into All Island and look…read morearound by the german beer, they got Heineken and Heineken light......no dark. So I go to the counter and asked if they carried. Wow, both the guys at the counter were, polite, informative, told me they would get it and would call me when it came in. Simple customer service the old fashioned way, won them a customer for life................ I would go 5 stars but parking sucks.................worth the suckiness

Wonderful shop. The owner is extremely knowledgeable and helpful with any questions about wines or…read morespirits. The shop is immaculate and is incredibly well stocked. Years back I asked if he could try getting a specific vodka and not only did he stock it but has kept ordering it since. Just an absolutely lovely local business. Recommendations: Lagavulin 16, VDKA 6100, Maker's Mark.

Owner is very knowledgeable and makes amazing suggestions on wine. Entire staff is friendly. My…read morego to liquor store!!

The owner is so pleasant and helpful- they also have a great selection and always know the answers…read moreto my strange questions.

I came here a couple minutes after 6 on a Sunday and they were closed. However the owner was in his…read morecar in front and called me as I was walking away. He opened back up for me even though I said no it's ok, he insisted. He was also super nice to me and kind. Great service! Great selection as well.

Frank and Alan are no longer the owners and I noticed the customer service isn't quite as good as…read moreit once was. The store seems messier and the new owner isn't as personable. I wouldn't recommend this place like I would in the past.

Frank does not own the store anymore and every positive review below is from a much different time…read more It is currently being run by a man who does not drink and lies to customers in order to sell the product. If you have a more in depth question he will just google it, he doesn't know what he's talking about. The store is disgusting and hasn't been mopped or cleaned since being taken over which is evident by all of the dust and dirt on the bottles (don't ask about the bathrooms). If you order delivery from the store directly or on the app, any tip you leave for the driver that isn't cash goes straight to the owners pocket. Prices have gone up steadily and will continue to rise conveniently in time for the summer. The "company car" that the tip-less drivers are provided with has the ABS lights on (and yes the breaks are awful) and a slew of other safety issues that would fail a real inspection in 3 minutes. The alternative is to put miles on your own car for minimal compensation. These past reviews are out of date and do a VERY poor job of representing the current state of this store. Everything that made Seaside worth going to is gone. Prices are higher, anyone with any real knowledge of the product is gone, and delivery times will be higher as there is only one POS car to go from Massapequa to Freeport. Unless you're coming in specifically for tequila, (the tequila section is still good) just shop at Total Wine.

I come here on a regular basis because it's very convenient…read more It's the start of the summer & I've googled different summertime drinks. I want to try out a few different cocktails & buy a few different Liquors & stock the summertime liquor cabinet. Vodka, Rum, Sangria etc. I ask the woman at the front desk ( that's obviously an owner) why does everyone rave about "Tito's " vodka. Her answer which was barely audible was "because it's good ". Well that was helpful. Whenever I come here the service is less than nil. It's easy to stop in & buy whatever liquor you know & serve on a regular basis. Prices are competitive. Don't come here if you are looking for service.... Not happening.

Under new ownership and recently remodeled this is a much nicer liquor store then it's former self…read more On the smaller side when it comes to liquor stores but the staff is friendly and they have most things you'd need.

Good selection and open late. I work night shift so I appreciate that. Also the individuals working…read morethere seem helpful.

Worst delivery service. Told you they were on their way. Took almost 2 hours and forgot part of the…read moreorder.

Closest bevy to where I live, but will happily go elsewhere. Seems that since they bought the other…read moreside of the building they're trying to turn it into a hang out spot instead of a business. They have a large selection of beers, and a large walk in fridge. Stopped in before our annual block party, and was told my the organizer of the BP that they extended a 10% discount on all beer, water, soda and ice and when I asked for the discount, was told it was only 5% (my neighbor was told it was only on beer when he went to buy multiple bags of ice) so needless to say, I'll be bringing my business elsewhere.

Classic always has a huge choice of beer. They bring in a massive gluten free selection, which is…read moreamazing, specifically my favorite brand, Ghostfish. The cigar prices are good and they have a wide variety there as well. I don't go anywhere else for beer, cigars, or ice

My favorite local liquor store. The owner is always in a good mood and super friendly, and there's…read morea decent selection of wines. He also carries pretty much every major liquor (aka the big brands) at a reasonable price. Compared to a "larger" liquor store, you'll either pay a couple of bucks more here or the same price. If you're in the area, it's a great place.

Wouldn't sell my boyfriend and I liquor AFTER showing him our Id's. Then proceeded to ask my…read moreboyfriend his old PA address. When that wasn't good enough for him we showed him my ID and he wanted me to use my card to pay when my boyfriend wanted to. Then told us to find another store. Don't waste your time or money here.

Amazing spot to get your liquor needs! Their prices are even comparable (and sometimes cheaper…read morethan) Total Wine & More. Great selection of all things wine, liquor, mixer and even accessories (gift bags, cork screws, shot glasses, etc).

They have a very good selection of alcohol at a great price. They usually have good deals too. The…read morestaff is friendly and helpful! I was able to stop by and grab what I needed with no problems. The business is kind of small, located in a strip mall, but all the essentials are there. This is my go to place for alcohol when I am in the area.