Lunch with family.. no complaints about service, orders taken, drinks refilled promptly.. food served on time and no issues.. (they had a buffet, but we passed.. nothing special for $14.) The pizza was good just not outstanding.. the kids had tenderloins and they cleaned their plates. Mama had chicken wings and picked the bones clean. Again, the service was good.. pizza was hi hum. read more

Mollys Pizzeria - Inside of Molly's Pizza... - Pizza Near Me - Chillicothe, Illinois

Went with a friend who had heard good things about this place. Dingy and dirty looking when you first walk in . There was a long table with seating for 10 that had not been cleaned off yet. 2 employees were sitting at the bar watching tv and doing something on a computer. We were there almost an hour and a half and when we left, the table was still filled with dirty dishes and food. Gross. I had a salad with chicken which was okay. My friend had a basic pizza with sausage. She said it was just ok. Neither of us has plans to go back. read more

We stopped in for dinner and we sat at our table for 10 minutes without anyone acknowledging that we were there. Someone gave a customer a beer in a red solo cup - I can only assume no glasses were clean by the massive pile up of dirty glasses on the bar. Several people went up to the bar to get drink refills or to try to pay but had to wait because it seemed like the only person actually doing any work was the one server. We also saw one of the kitchen staff take a huge hit off of their vape and leave a cloud in their wake and then handle food without washing her hands. After observing all of this we left. Very disappointing. read more

Pizza at Molly's is great! They have the thin crust and hand tossed as well. Service was alright, the waitress never came back to refill our drinks. read more

Mollys Pizzeria - Cheese Pizza & Garbage Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chillicothe, Illinois

See all

The pizza was dried out overpriced. We've eaten here before. That's why we returned, but this visit was a ripoff.I guess is the bottom line. Typically, a place will offer 2 make you a new pizza here. There was no offer of making another pizza. It was so dried out that the the crust was crinkled. Very poor food read more

sat there for 25 minutes and was not even aknowledged..waitress walked by us a dozen times and didnt even take a drink order.

Awesome. Friendly service. Amazing thin crust with a wide list of ingredients. All the usual plus avocado oil, vegan sausage, vegan cheese, anchovies, garlic, chicken sausage and others. Hand tossed crust too. Beer on tap, sandwiches, appetizers. Perfect if one of your party is vegan, or not. Great ambience including screened three season room. I split a vegan cheese thin crust veggie pizza plus garlic that was delicious. I generally prefer the taste of a real cheese pizza, and this was as good any thin crust pizza I ever had. Crisp, great toppings. read more

We have ordered several different items from the menu over the last several months. Everything has been great. We especially like the calzones. The crust is crispy and the i nside is great because they don't add sauce. Instead they serve Marinara on the side. So good food, friendly staff and a nice atmosphere. read more

Great pizza and wonderful staff. I am happy there is a decent pizza place in Chillicothe.

Slow service The food wasn't really good and the drinks were flat Overall just a bad place too at eat at. Would never recommend. read more

Food and service is excellent. Servers are very good at their job. Great variety of food on the menu. Meat galore pizzza very good

Just not crazy about their pizza, some other items are fine. The service is very good but the ambiance leaves a lot to be desired.

Excellent food. Great value. Friendly service. Have tried various pizza, wings, sandwiches & salad bar. Our favorites are the Garlic Parmesan wings & the Hot Luau pizza. It has become a weekly trip from Peoria for us. Love the open air side in nice weather & to watch the games. We sit on the cozier side where the salad bar is when it's cold outside. read more

Great thin crust pizza, way better than the chains. Nice addition to town and would recommend giving it a try.

Molly's Pizza is very good! The beer is cold, people are friendly and the atmosphere is fantastic!

Such a great pizza place! So glad Chillicothe got a superb pizza spot! The sandwhiches and appetizers are yummy too!

After being upset about a past problem, Mollys addressed and accommodated my concern and made up for it with a free order! I really appreciated their openness to help! I really love their pizza its my top third favorite! Better than monicals!! read more

This is talking forever and there's not even that many people here. And she haven't even asked for refill.

Loved the pizza at Molly's! Nice crisp crust, fresh toppings and so cheesy. The pickle sticks are sooo good. Pretzel bites and wings were delicious too. read more

Mollys Pizzeria - Veggie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chillicothe, Illinois

My wife and I decided to try Mollys for lunch today. We ordered a large classic hand tossed pizza. We both thought the pizza was fantastic. The sandwiches that that kept passing our table looked really good and can't wait to give those a try next we visit mollys. Service was friendly and excellent. read more

We had a break during a soccer tournament nearby and stopped in on a rainy Saturday for some pizza. The pretzel bites with cheese were delicious, the hand tossed pizza was great, and we loved the atmosphere. Would definitely go again! read more

Over an hour of sitting for a few pizzas. Our group sat with empty drinks for for at least 45 min. Pizzas came out wrong. Our checks were all mixed together including items that no one ordered. Worst dining experience I have ever had. Will not return. read more

Stopped in for a pizza tonight! 11-8-21 ! Tonight we order 3 8" pizzas and a order of kids chicken strips and fries. First took forever to get waited on. When a waitress finally arrived we order our drinks and meal at that time! Took well over and hour before we found out that a pizza in our order was made wrong ! And would be 10 minutes longer then expected. Again slow service in between all of this. When pizzas finally arrived they were all cold doughy and down right disgusting. We didn't complain bc we were already late to the Mossville Chillicothe game at IVC we paid or tab and that'll be last time we go back. Castaways is still best restaurant in town and owner is from Chillicothe and a IVC alum. That's where we will be! Zero 0 outta 5 ! read more

Food was great they were super busy with only two people working so service wasn't great. If you or someone you know has Celiac disease please use caution. We ordered a gluten free pizza and it tasted fine but she got very sick immediately after. The restaurant claimed they took all these precautions but obviously they didn't. read more