Great take out cuisine. Their pizza and panzerotti's are awesome! And all of there other food is…read morevery tasty too. Most of their food is homemade. The best pizza in town!! Excellent and friendly small town service as well.

From the owner: Stacey's Pizza, originally founded by Keith and Donna Stacey, has been serving customers since…read more1977. Now operated by Sabrina Rudy, Stacey's Pizza uses their own dough, fresh produce, and 100% real cheese to make their pizzas. There are also an assortment of other foods like panzerottis, burgers, chicken, subs, fries, garlic bread, and more.

Oh. My. God!!! My boyfriend and I visited Elora for a week long trip and decided to stop in and try…read moreNew Orleans Pizza as it was the only food spot open. We always get a ton of toppings on our pizza so when we were ordering, the lady who was working that night laughed and looked at us as if we were lunatics lol. After the pizza was cooked, the employee agreed it looked amazing :) By far the BEST pizza we have ever had! Crispy crust (even on the bottom), lots of good quality toppings and delicious sauce. This place makes us want to take the 3 hour trip back just for a pizza haha!

I like the pizza so much. Juice yet not with overwhelming source, with the appropriate cheese and…read morefresh toppings. This is a great place to try out on your adventure in Erola.

Changed their pizza dough. Ordered two mediums, dough was very flat and not very good at all…read more Disappointing!

I have driven by this pizza place so many times... Always said to myself that I need to go in and…read moretry the pizza,.... well, today was the day! I went in, I grabbed four slices which are quite large and I walked out of there for under $25 including three pops a garlic dipping sauce and tip... Great customer service and a delicious cracker crust with an abundance of toppings put this pizza place a step above the rest! Well done!! Thank you! Zeke

It's not bad there's not much selection in parked over and surrounding areas for pizza I do miss…read morepizza Nova I can't top that at all but it's okay for a part over it's standard I've been back for about six seven months..

From the owner: Pizza and Wingsread more

Wonderful deep dish pizza with garlic sauce. Tasty, juicy and lots of different flavors…read more Staff were wonderful on the phone and the delivery driver was very accommodating as we tried to sort out problems with online payment. A great experience and if I'm in the area again will definitely be ordering from them

First time ordering a pizza from here. We ordered the Deluxe XL and we thought it's the best take…read moreout pizza we have had in a long time. Next time we are heading back through Shakespeare we will definitely be ordering again. My husband said the staff were very friendly. I was next door picking up some delicious tarts, so I didn't go inside.

Very happy returning customer - Great pizza and great little pizza shop! Highly recommended -read more

This is a great local pizza place! Prices are affordable with great options on specialty classics,…read morelike deluxe and Canadian. Run by a family in town and great each customer very politely and ensure you're getting what you're looking for. Will definitely be stopping by in the future!

Pizza was decent. Better than the budget pizza restaurant chains. Although I found the crust to be…read moreslightly burnt and they charge 2.4% extra to cover the cost of accepting credit cards. It wasn't mentioned at the time of purchase, and I didn't realize it until I got home. We are the pizza about 30 minutes after pickup, and found the crust to be hard and chewy. For the reasons of the pizza being burnt, the surcharge, the tough crust, and that there are many pizzarias to consider in Toronto instead, so I will not be returning.

Not sure why listed as closed. Clearly open today 9 July 2024. Going to give it a try…read more Update. Ordered the square pizza, requested thin crust, well done. It was cooked perfectly. Found the sauce a bit sweet but otherwise a decent pizza. Maybe ownership has changed but place is definitely open and a good option for a non-chain pizza if you live nearby.

The new owners are idiots onion rings are rock hard and slopped together. Panzarottis come with…read morecheese and pepperoni usually but now there barely and cheese and 5 pepperonis. Pervious owners should slap you guys

Need to stay away from Pubs and Bars for lunch. Can't quite seem to lay off the brewZ…read more Didn't have a lot of time and wanted to do a quick take out. Subway...nah. Country something or another...no time. My kitchen...thingy place...not open. Small town...not a lot of choices. There was a Sobey's maybe they have a hot table like Longo's - doubtful! Out of know where, a red tomato on a white sign - and it say's Tito's. I always thought Tito was a Spanish name...Oh well...might was well try it. Went in, nice friendly people that was as surprised to see me as I was to see Asians. Turns out even in New Hamburg, an Asian Invasion has begun...Dum..Dum..DUUUUUMMM...{add dramatic music here}! Turns out that Tito's has several locations throughout South Western Ontario. No 11-11 or 0-0-0-0 Pizza places here + no FreeSex/FreeSex on a Rainy Day either! And I welcome that because the ZA at this place puts the other too shame. Grate (see what I did there! :) toppings on a nice tasty crust. Also, I got two slices + a pop for...Check This Out! $4.50. Nope...can only get a meager cheap cardboard slice at the other places back on the Hill for that much cabbage. The delightful gal that runs the place is Hong. If you somehow find yourself in this far out place, drop by and get some really great ZA! Cheers!