Fav pizza in Hamilton!! Service is great -- the folks are very nice! Pizza is consistently tasty. Love their red sauce & crust which are the foundations. I think their prices are great too! No tap to pay but credit cards are ok! read more

Great pizza made by great people. Always fast and consistent quality. There are a couple tables inside.

Casual environment and courteous customer service. They make delicious personalized calzones ! My family enjoys their pizza a lot! Great family run business! read more

Always 5 stars, ever since my first slice in 1986. Two huge slices and a coke for $2 back then. Not much has changed in nearly 40 years; still a great value in barebones surroundings. It's all about the pizza. read more

This rating is based on a regular cheese slice only. Stopped here right around lunch time for a slice. They had a few different types of pizza but I always get just cheese my first time. Very good crunch. It was overcooked but just the way I like it. The sauce was a bit on the sweet side but didn't ruin it. Cheese was ok. Inside the place was clean. The counter person was friendly. This place is acceptable. Yelp still doesn't do half stars but this is a 3.5 type of place. Worth a try for some pie. read more

New York Pizzeria - Plain Cheese Slice - Pizza Near Me - Hamilton, New York

They let the pizza speak for itself and my it is yummy. Gotta try it, cheese only for slices but worth it read more

New York Pizzeria - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hamilton, New York

Pizza & wings mmmmmmmm Sliced only come plain Love this place! Great owners, and amazing food! I used to love it as a kid, still do to this day (lost way too many quarters playing TMNT here as a kid) read more

They have a small menu but it fits the small town vibe with fast friendly service. Their pizza is delicious but single slices come in plain only so if you crave toppings it's best to order a whole pie. read more

Great theming, fantastic pizza. Literally the best pizza place in 20 miles! I would 100% eat here again! Love the Grateful Dead themed menu items! read more

If you're in Hamilton you absolutely must stop by and grab a slice. Super delicious and a Colgate tradition. The service is fast, the prices are good, and the pizza is great. The attitude could be much better - sorry there's a line, no need to be nasty to your customers. read more

Classic and simple local pizza place - unique and time-perfected slices of pizza. Their wings and wing sauce are also excellent.

I'm going back for more is all I'm saying. I bet Mom's in the kitchen fussing over a pot of pizza sauce

Pizza is pretty good! I'm from Buffalo, so I'm used to a thicker pizza, but for thin pizza I do find that my pizza crazing is still properly satisfied with this place. I really want to highlight the chicken fingers from here since I thought they were pretty amazing. Very crispy! The skin was just so goddamn good. Perfectly prepared chicken fingers for sure! Looking forward to more late night orders from here in the future. read more

Slices (The real name) is a decent pizza spot in Hamilton. The best thing is they stay open late, and if you really some entertainment, camp out around 12:30 on any thursday, friday or saturday night and watch as wild college students flood the premises. The slices are only $1.50 and pies are cheap as well. They deliver, also a nice convenience. In my opinion, it's the perfect college pizza spot. Their best topping is nothing, just order cheese. Ranch is good too for dipping if you really want to put the calorie meter off the charts. read more

New York Pizzeria - Plain Slices - Pizza Near Me - Hamilton, New York

Delicious pizza! This is our go to around here. It's definitely something I crave, and can't go to long without it!

Legitimately the hands down best pizza in the area! Every item on the menu is excellent and the family knows everyone by name! Every time I'm in town I stop for a slice and a quick hello! read more

Never had my pizza delivered. If a company says that my pizza is going to be delivered, and says that it will be about 30 minutes, then the pizza should be delivered! As someone who has worked in the restaurant industry, this is unacceptable. read more

I've been eating here since the '70s and the pizza has always been fantastic. Everett can't ever retire! Bring back the Annex!

A big shout out to Everett and LuAnn, who with no competition could offer terrible pizza to the town of Hamilton. They've ignored the temptation and deliver some serious pizza year in and year out-so good that a friend brought his cooler to Reunion so he could keep some in his freezer. The pizza is always hot. One night during finals, serving as pizza girl, I made $181 in tips within 4 hours delivering Slices on the hill. That's just sick. But also a solid commentary on how much appreciated a pizza delivery with a smile can be. read more

Honestly you can't go wrong with slices. In my opinion they're better than Oliveri's right across the street and have better prices. Love the staff in there as well, always kind and will make your pizza quickly (Oliver's will take over 45 mins for a pie...). Colgate students look no further. read more

I thought the pizza tasted better in person than when I had it delivered. For a while I attributed that to the following correlation: when I was out and eating at Slices, I was often....well...I'd had more than a few drinks. I figured that was why the pizza tasted SOOO much better. However, I soon learned that they make the delivery pizza's a little differently so you have to order your delivery-pizza "slices style" to get to taste every-bit as good as when you're having some late-night, post-bar pizza. There's a difference, but either way the place still gets 5 stars. read more

I have to confess that I haven't had it when I'm drunk, and I haven't had any other pizza in Hamilton, so maybe my review should be taken with a grain of salt. We walked in and ordered a medium pizza with a bunch of toppings, and got it remarkably quickly (just under the 15 min projected time) It wasn't terrible, but it did fail to live up to expectations in several key respects: - Sort of anemic/underdone in the middle (quite floppy and soft) - Possibly related to this, the sauce was watery, since it was more like chunks of tomato than a sauce. That could actually be a positive attribute (instead of that overly sweet sauce like tomato paste that so many places seem to use) But it made the pizza too watery, and thus harder to eat and blander - On the bright side, it wasn't overly oily or greasy, and they were generous with the anchovies. They also have RC cola. Overall, I'd probably rate it in that category of "pizza I'd reluctantly eat if it was at some function I'm attending, but wouldn't go out of the way for". It could be that we caught them on an off night, but I'm not rushing back to find out... read more

Hands down the best pizza in Hamilton. I eat this drunk, sober, anywhere in between. Whenever I've craving NY style pizza (which is quite often now since I've moved out of NY) - this is the epitome of what I'm wanting. Fast, cheap and so so yummy...! read more

Not only the best pizza in the area, but some of my favorite slices of all time. These slices have been the focus and goal of several road trips...including 5hour drives. Noteveryone's favorite style (wide thin soft pan pizza) but for the genre? Platonic ideal, baby! read more

Great example of doing something right and being consistent about it! Great job Everett! Love your "Slices"! Best Bets: Slices of cheese pizza, since they go back in the oven they get nice and crispy on the bottom. Top with garlic powder, red pepper, and parmesian cheese. Bonus: Reasons why THIS place works and so many other restraunts fail in Hamilton. 1. They owners are nice. Personality goes along way in the food business, and these people are honest and friendly. 2. The foods consistent. I've had alot of pizza from this place and it always meets the standards I expect from it. Why? Because the owner is the chef, he makes the pies, and he makes sure they are what they are. 3. It's not over priced. The owners AREN'T as greedy as other business people in town. Since the primary customers are A. College and High School kids, or B. Rural upstate New Yorkers, you can only rip people off so many times before they stop coming to your place. This place doesn't. It's REASONABLE and that's why they do so much business, and that's what keeps people coming back. 4. It's fast. You can get a slice in 3 minutes or a pie delivered in 30. 5. Ingredients are quality. I see the chef rip sausage straight outta casings and put it on a pie. Other places still use frozen toppings. read more

Great pizza, great prices, great people. Any time I'm in the area, I grab a few slices. I love to get slices at Slices...and remember, "slices come plain only"! Excellent. read more

Theres nothing better than a night out finished off with some slices. Loved this establishment as a college kid and still do as a visiting alum. No where else does a better pizza + ranch. read more

This place gets 5*s for being an institution for Colgate students. I am a 2014 graduate and when I returned for homecoming weekend, I was ecstatic to reunite with slices (in addition to my old friends too, obviously :p ). I personally think slices are just as good sober as they are while intoxicated, and have ordered them during late night study sessions, to provide lunch for my COVE club, and just because they are cheap and I didn't feel like cooking that night. When I came to Colgate, I discovered that pizza dipped in ranch is surprisingly delicious, thanks to slices. You will always have a special place in my heart :) read more

It's only *really* good when you're drunk, so 4 stars. But it's the best thing in the world when it's hot and fresh out the oven, you've finally convinced your friends to leave Nichol's or those sketchy other bars or.. worse.. the jug, and you're hiding away from a bajillion feet of snow. Yum! read more

My husband grew up in this part of the world and raves that this is the "best pizza EVER!". We have lived in several different states and when it comes to pizza, he is always truly disappointed. So when we moved back for a short period of time, I knew I had to try their "cheese only" slice and see what all the excitement was about. I have to say, the first time I took a bite, I wasn't impressed. I said, "THIS is your favorite pizza?" But the more I ate it, the more I fell in love with it. It is really one of my favorite pizzas of ALL time. The sauce is so simple yet complex and leaves you with a hint of sweetness at the very end of your tongue. And the cheese is great quality and an excellent pairing to the sauce. The crust is thin but substantial enough, without leaving you feeling overly loaded on carbs. MUST EAT HERE! read more

I graduated Colgate in 2002, and still make it back from time to time. "Slices" is my go to stop before heading back home. For a buck fifty a slice, you can't beat it. Quick, cheap and flavorful. A Hamilton mainstay. read more

Really good pizza for nice prices ($1.50/slice). It's a very popular place for drunken stops. Really friendly people.

The absolute best. You do not come to Hamilton without getting a late night slice at slices with ranch. Remember, slices come plain only!

Tasty pizza and best in town. Two slices and a soda for $3.50. Only one complaint, they skimp on the soda selection No Coke or Pepsi

Definitely the best pizza in town. And the people who work there are kind, patient, and helpful. A total staple of Hamilton.

We will go out of the way to pick up pizza from here when they are open. The best pepperoni pizza around. Make sure to order it slices style. read more

Best spot for good pizza at the Gate. Surprisingly authentic city style slices with quick service!

New York Pizzeria (aka Slices) is the best in Hamilton. Great pizza. Love how it's open late- nothing complements a night of partying quite like a slice. Or four. Try dipping them in ranch. Sounds weird but it's amazingly wonderful. The staff is friendly too. Great job guys. read more

Good pizza and great for late night after a beer or two. Unfortunately the late night is also their problem. Due to all of the rowdy drunken undergrads the inside of the place is pretty spartan and the men's restroom is unusable. It's good for delivery, carryout, catering or taking a slice around the corner, but frankly unless you're a drunken twenty year old, it's probably not the dine-in spot you're looking for. read more

Slices is a main stay of Hamilton food and probably the best pizza in town (though the argument falls on many sides). You can't beat the price, the NY style crust, or the fact they are open at 2am! read more