This was the first pizza place i visited when moving to the area . The pizza here is like eating…read morecardboard with ketchup on it . The shop was not that clean . The only reason im giving 2 stars instead of one is that the staff was friendly,li don't recommend this place and i wont eat here again

I'm sorry to say this was not as amazing as the reviews claim. I ordered a 12 piece and while it…read morewas a decent looking pizza it just tasted like bread, basic cheese and marinara sauce. The pepperonis tasted store bought as well. I placed my order and they said it would be 45 mins, so I set my timer and went to the store, after my timer went off and I got back it was still not done. Overall I'm just disappointed in the whole experience.

Definitely a new favorite. Some of the best pizza in the county. The stone baked pizza is…read moreamazing. The crust is light and fluffy, and their sauce is perfection. We ordered a Deluxe, a pepperoni, and tried their white. The Deluxe was absolutely covered with toppings. The only downside was attempting to keep the toppings on the pizza. The white pizza was, sadly, just average. It lacked the garlicky kick we are used to, but the fresh tomatoes and amazing crust made up for it. The bread sticks appear to be legendary, and our neighbors claimed that they were better than Pizza Hut's (!). The wedges also looked good, crispy and filled with sandwichey goodness. This is our new go-to pizza joint, and I can't wait to try the other specialties and subs.

For this area Mary Janes is above average, they use quality cheese…read more 'Grande ' and good tomato sauce. The pizza is a round thin crust . The staff is super friendly and every time i have ordered around 6 times the service and food have been great . The only negative thing about Mary Janes is the prices , they are high . I understand grande cheese is not cheap but $2.75 per toppings is a little steep especially for this area . I don't mind paying for quality but $2.75 for .20 cents of mushrooms is not reasonable. The hoagies are small and nothing special but overpriced also . My order of a large 16" 2 topping pizza & a 10" Italian hoagie plus two 1pint cartons of Turners iced tea was $48 no delivery i picked up . I hope people try this place the pizza is good but not worth the price in my opinion

My dad and I stopped in for a late lunch on a Friday afternoon. The small bar in the back was…read morepacked, but only about 2 other tables in the dining area were occupied. Our waitress was friendly and quick with the drinks and getting our order in. We noticed a sign on the wall that said the food might take a while and it wasn't a lie. We waited a good 20 mins for our pepperoni logs and then maybe 5 more for our sandwiches to come out. I had the cuban that comes with chips on the side. My dad ordered the crispy chicken deluxe and upgraded to fries for his side. We both loved all of the food. The pepperoni logs had a garlic parm butter on the outside and plenty of filling on the inside. The marinara served with them was warm. My cuban was delicious and stuffed with ham and pulled pork. My dad said his crispy chicken sandwich couldn't have been better. What surprised us both was the fact that they charged us $2.50 each for a cup of water. The prices otherwise seemed fair. I think it was around $3 to upgrade the side to french fries. The food was good quality, though!

I went to JP's for the first time, and it was everything I expected and more! I started off with…read morethe bruschetta and hot peppers and oil, and that's when I knew I was in for a great dinner. I also had the southwest burger, supreme pizza, and the barbecue sauce was the best I've ever had. The family and service there is so welcoming, and I can't wait to go back!

Awful wait time of 21/2 hrs! My sub was missing toppings and 2 inches of bread at the end! Called…read moremultiple times just to get it delivered and was lied to every time! So done! I usually support local businesses, but not this one!

4 stars for the food. 2 stars for the performance = 3 overall…read more Note they only take cash and check. Decent pizza. Had wings too. Wings delicious. Pizza had good toppings. Crust a bit soft. Could've been crispier. Not 5 star, but good. That being said, placed the order at 9:37. Not delivered till 11:10. Need to do better.

Glad I tried this place. Tired of the big name chain joints, and square pizzas. Ordered take out…read moreand picked it up hot and tasty pie. Delicious sauce and not under sauced like many places. Will be back.

Ordered 2 Calzones, large pizza, cheese sticks and a chicken salad with ranch. Order showed up,…read morepizza was burnt, cheese sticks were also burnt with marinara sauce spilled all over them, and salad did not get delivered. After a phone call, they said they would bring the salad and asked what dressing we wanted. A little later salad arrived without dressing. Will definitely not be eating here again.

I have bought Italo's chicken for years during different owners here always great until recently…read more This week the food was greasy and cold. Ordered breaded mushrooms and chicken dinner. Terrible all of it. This place needs a good cleaning. There also were children of one of the employees asleep in a booth and a very young one in the kitchen looking for his mom. Where are the owners do they know what is happening here? It's too bad, this used to be a great place. Won't be going back!

Great place to eat, best chicken in town. Meatball calzone is delicious and I think they've been…read moreserving pizza for at least 50 years.

Since I grew up around this area it was interesting to see the large photos they have displayed of…read morewhat East Liverpool years ago. Being able to go in the vault of the old bank was also interesting. The service was really good and our food was very good. I had the steak salad and it was superb.

The food was just okay, but the service was extremely poor. Our waitress seemed like she was…read morestationed on another planet--she had very little patience and made us feel as though she had better things to do. We were still eating our appetizer when she tried to take our plates away because our main course was almost ready. To top it off, she forgot our dessert. I would recommend staying away from this place.

Always disappointing, but if you're drunk at 2am and need a break from playing slot machines, even…read moreBig Al's will taste okay. The reason I'm giving them 2 stars is because the people that work there are really nice and it's kept clean. However, I don't recommend eating here, unless, like I said, your super drunk and need a break from playing the slot machines. I ordered cheese pizza and I thought it tasted weird, but the cheese itself was pretty good. So I deconstructed it (kinda like Chef Gordon Ramsay does on Kitchen Nightmares) and lo and behold, the crust was cooked on the bottom, but raw ("it's RAW!") under the cheese. Good thing I said the Hamotzi bracha before eating it because I'm feeling a little queasy. No, I didn't finish it, I just ate the cheese off of it. Definitely not worth the $5.00 per slice they charge. Too bad I wasn't drunk. But if you're stuck in the casino in this small West Virginia town, whatcha gonna do? I'd recommend getting the cheesecake or a cookie because I'm pretty sure they're not made in-house. Bottled water, that's always a safe bet. I'd like to end on a positive and reiterate that the staff are very friendly and personable, and the café itself is kept clean, so they get two stars for that!

Very poor customer service, extremely poor management. The place needs to be cleaned up all the way…read morearound!

I got a couple pieces to try Sauce not so great tasted more…read morelike spaghetti sauce 1* light on the toppings couldn't even taste the cheese 1* Crispie crustust the best part of the pizza excellent 5* Value pretty small for the price and amount of toppings 2* The crust is the only reason it gets a 3*overall doubt I will be going back with so many other choices