pizzeria in Haddonfield, friendly, and courteous staff... five star service. I will go back three or four times and let you know about their pizza, Stromboli and sandwiches. read more

Horrible customer service. The girl took 3 times to take money in the phone. When I asked for a manager and spoke to Kim, she didn't seem to care and brushed it off. Absolutely HORRIBLE. Do not order from here. Always try to support small hometown business -- this one is HORRENDOUS. read more

One of the best pizzas I've had In new jersey amazing texture and flavors great seasoning

So psyched they're finally open again! They were closed for about six months doing renovations. The windows were covered for so long I started to wonder if they'd scrapped the pizza business altogether and opened a meth lab instead. The oldest pizza place in Haddonfield to my knowledge. They've been around for as long as I can remember, at least since I was in high school here in the 90's. This has been my go to Friday night pizza delivery place for years. There are tons of great pizza places around, but in my opinion this is the best one in Haddonfield. Finally got to order from them again last night for the first time in months, and the pizza was still as perfect as ever. Perfect crust and loaded with toppings. Love their website. So easy to order online for delivery and customize food exactly. Love this place and will continue to be a lifelong customer. read more

Nicky B's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Haddonfield, New Jersey

See all

Nicky B's is one of my go-to takeout spots in the area. The pizza is good, but there are better options in the area. Where Nicky B's stands out is their sandwiches. The cheesesteak is very good and the Parms are also very good. I especially enjoy the Soprano. Service is always friendly and delivery is pretty quick. read more

Tonight we ordered a pizza we never had before. Not only was our order delivered before the promised time. Extremely tasty. My new go to pizza is the "Soprano White". read more

Amazing pie so fresh the sauce was amazing. The dough was amazing. The cheese was amazing. can I say amazing overall 10 out of 10 if you like pizza even if you don't, please go eat here. Nicky b's will change your mind. I'm sure they have something you like because they have a lot that I liked. read more

Their grilled chicken caesar wrap is it , also love their grandma pie. But seriously, I order the wrap at least once a week for lunch and love it. Always friendly staff at the front desk. read more

I recently stopped at Nicky B's while in Haddonfield for work. Looked like a nice busy place so I figured why not. What a huge mistake it was. First off the place was pretty busy but not overwhelming. The pizza looked pretty good. I opted for the BLT wrap. Seriously, how do you mess up at BLT? Because, ya did. I'm having a few issues with this wrap in particular. First for the price it should come with fries, not a small bag of chips. Second, cook the bacon! This was without a doubt the worst bacon I've ever eaten. It was chewy, stringy and cold. Just because you put a "generous" amount on something, doesn't make it good. Do yourselves a favor and get better bacon. Considering it's a BLT you should do better. Lastly, diced tomatoes, really? It's not a salsa. Again, the pizza looked good and I would get a slice but stay away from the sandwiches. read more

Nicky B's Pizzeria - BLT wrap - Pizza Near Me - Haddonfield, New Jersey

I love ordering Nicky B's online. Every pizza night: Solid za, superb ingredients, with crispy crust that's perfectly cooked. Ordering pizza through their website is super easy and straight forward. Drivers are all local; all employed in house. I live relatively far from Haddonfield so I'm really happy they deliver to me. ::Pictures not included:: because pizza's always gone. 5/5 every time. read more

Fresh ingredients, a very friendly staff, and the food is always ready on time. Newly remodeled, and the interior is very bright and clean, with an expanded kitchen. I've been going there for years, and they've never given me any reason to be disappointed or think about going elsewhere. Nothing fancy, just hearty and well-executed pizzas, cheesesteaks, etc. read more

We'd been looking forward to a fresh hot pizza, so to save time, we ordered a large pizza, half mushrooms to pick up and eat at home. To be honest, they could've been a bit more generous with the mushrooms - LOL. It still was delicious. read more

Nicky B's Pizzeria - Paid extra for half mushroom pizza. I think they need to look up the definition of half. - Pizza Near Me - Haddonfield, New Jersey

I love this much spot and if I lived in Haddonfield It would be my no cooking tonight place. There caprese sandwich it to die for and there Italian sandwich is my go to. Wings are the best. And pizza !! Is the best around. And they love there clientele too and take care of us read more

Talk about "comfort Food"!!! We had never heard of "grandma pizza" before. A friend recommended it. It was more expensive than your standard pizza, but it was also much larger. We have been eating it for two days. I've eaten pizza all over the world and this is the best I have ever had. Truth! read more

Ordered a chicken steak tonight, it was so dry and overcooked it was like eating chicken flavored wood chips!

Nicky B's salads are awesome. I was shocked with how good they are - I feel like most pizza joints dont do salads well. I consistently order a Cobb and add Buffalo chicken - it's awesome! We've also tried the pepperoni Stromboli and it was great. Haven't tried the pizza yet. read more

Tried this place out a few times. LOVE the Italian hoagie. It definitely can be splits between 2 people or save the half for leftovers for tomorrow's lunch. Definitely recommend. The fries we ordered were just okay - nothing too special about them, but hits the craving if you're in the mood for something like that. read more

Nicky B's Pizzeria - Italian Hoagie - Pizza Near Me - Haddonfield, New Jersey

See all

we just moved here and someone told us to try their pizza i ordered a Sicilian pizza and breadsticks when we got the pizza we realized it was burnt and the breadstick was literally a peace of bread called the manger and he acted like we were bothering him and asked if we ordered their before i said no he said he would replace it gee thanks so much not a apology or anything they probably are going to spit in it never again read more

Nicky B's Pizzeria - our Sicilian pizza - Pizza Near Me - Haddonfield, New Jersey

Got wings on Friday night. They were very burnt, not edible. It was a Friday night ritual for wings from there but after that garbage we are done. read more

My office is around the corner from this place. So its a convenient place to grab lunch, I've ordered the hoagies and club sandwiches, which were perfect sized and flavorful. I can't really comment on the pizza, but I do know that my sammies were pretty good for a small place. The turkey club is pretty amazing for the price and all the hoagies are worth it, plus you can make two meals out of most of their sammies. I definitely will be trying more things on the item. But if you're in the area, stop by and give it a try. read more

Nicky B's Pizzeria - Turkey Club on wheat. Good sized portions. - Pizza Near Me - Haddonfield, New Jersey

Eh, after today's experience, I very unfortunately need to dock a star from my rating. Ordered Italian, expected Italian, the receipt said Italian, but my hoagie turned up American when I opened it back at my office. I certainly wasn't going to walk across town to bring it back since it was just a hoagie, but the experience *does* steer me away from future orders. read more

I went to Nicky B's today and was delighted when the old guy ahead of me, who was fiddling with his shirt to half cover his face, was given a mask. I thought, I'm going to write them an excellent review. Then I saw the guys making the food. One was wearing his mask as a chin strap, two others had them under their noses! Why make your customers wear masks if your employees don't? I get that the cooks are HOT. That's totally understandable. You made need to crank the AC a little higher to help the cooks out. But if you want your restaurant to have a mask policy you have to get everyone on board. read more

Sweet mother of god who does not exist, this pizza is foul. It is easily the worst pizza in the area - which has a papa John's nearby which is the usual epitome of crapitude. 3 bites was all I could take; the rest was thrown away. If you're a drunk frat boy , you might like it read more

Nicky B's was my favorite pizza place in Haddonfield before I moved to California and I can say I really miss their pizza! My favorite was the Mediterranean chicken pizza, but I never had a bad meal there. Delivery was fast, even to my apartment on the 4th floor. I can't wait to go back and have another slice! read more

Awful cheesesteaks! Stringy meat that is chewy and gets stuck in your teeth. So nauseating. They aren't cheap steaks and shouldn't be like that. Was very disappointed especially bc we bought 5 of them that night and no one liked it! read more

Just left there 5 minutes ago , they got 5 stars out of me becuase I know my cheesesteaks and they really hooked this one up everything about it is fresh and delicious ; got fries with it too and the fries are perfectly cooked and the cheese they use for the fries are amazing as well , just walk up their block you'll smell quality before you enter the place , staff was very nice too and that's very important as well , well done Nicky b well done , I'm from New York btw so this is big impressment for me read more

Nicky B's pizza is our go-to spot for delivery when we just don't have the energy or time to cook. They have very good burgers and wings. The pizza is a little bit thicker than most of the other spots in the area and cooked to the point where it is a little crisp as well. If you enjoy this in a pizza, which we do, you'll love Nicky B's. The only downside is that we have noticed some inconsistencies recently. For example, the hot wings used to be a little tangy but easily palatable by all. The last few times we ordered wings, the hotness has ranged from the convention we knew to fire-breathing hot. Unfortunately, the times it was too hot were points where we ordered wings for a very large group and hardly any were eaten. This is not enough of an inconvenience to prevent us from ordering there again in the future. However, in the future, we will likely need to ask how hot is hot. read more

Love this spot for lunch or even just days you feel like ordering out. Their cheese pizza is great, wraps, and their Italian hoagies. Even their wings with their hot and honey sauce is pretty delicious!! I signed up for their online account and it's great because I get the occasional coupon here and there, and birthday coupons. Definitely recommend ordering again. read more

I already love Nicky B's for their food. Try the Nicky Burger or Mediterranean Wrap...you won't be sorry! Brooke took my order tonight and it was like talking to a friend on the phone. She took my order and cc information quickly and accurately. She repeated the order (including a customized salad) and laughed at a joke I made about it! Awesome customer experience! Thanks Brooke read more

I have been ordering from here for sometime now. Every time I want pizza and sings. Honestly nothing I have ever gotten from here was bad. All good.I seem to always gravitate back here. Whether it's delivery or pick up it's always fresh fast hot and delicious. There was even one time that they went out of their way and delivered near to closing when some of the other shops would not. I highly recommend. read more

Stopped for a couple slices. Got a square slice and a plain slice. They had great flavor.

We get a lot of takeout from Nicki Bs and I thoroughly enjoyed the food. Portions are large, very filling, but the prices are a little high. For instance my favorite the western burger, which is large and in charge and comes with a ton of fries, is about $12 which is restaurant prices. This place has great sandwiches and calzones. Great delivery team! read more

Love this pizza! I've had it twice and was pleased. The square "grandmas" pizza with zesty sauce is on point!

Tried this place out and will definitely be making it our go-to pizza shop. Great food and location & all the employees were so friendly!

Placed a $45 order, they called back, said we are outside their area and cancelled oir order. We are THREE miles away from them. We are literally two turns away from their restaurant, I am surprised that they have such limited delivery area read more

We love Nicky B's quick delivery and friendly staff. The pizza always comes sooner than the estimated delivery time and super hot. Also, I have a food allergy and I love that it's noted in their system and they confirm it each time I call. I haven't had any other place do this so that's a bonus! read more

Awesome pizza great dough in Italian and impressed ! Really enjoyed the mozzarella sticks too ! Very fresh and clean too!

, I usually order the chicken cheesesteak hoagie lunch special and love it every time. The fries are always cooked perfectly and the chicken cheesesteak is always packed full on a fresh roll. The wings are great too! The staff even warned me that the meter maid was out writing tickets so I quick ran out and checked my meter. Friendly staff and great food. Can't beat this little lunch spot! read more

Omg the food here is so good. I've been filling in at the Haddonfield office and ordering lunch here. The first time I ordered I got a BLT panini with fries and it was absolutely delicious. Everything was fresh from top to bottom. It was a lunch special so it was fairly priced and it arrived very quickly. The second time I ordered I got the onion rings and cheese, mushroom and sauce turnover. The onion rings were extremely crispy and the turnover was HUGE. This past Friday I ordered the chicken caprese salad. This is my new favorite salad. I added an egg which made it that much better. Every ingredient down to the lettuce was fresh. Today I ordered the rodeo burger. It was cooked to perfection. If you are looking for a place to try I highly recommend this establishment. read more

Solid meh. Close to work. Food is bland and specials are too large for me to eat without regretting it later (although reasonably priced). The pizza is inevitably coming out my pores within an hour of eating it. read more