Wow! This place REALLY surprised us. We were looking for something different from the usual burgers, pizza, and tacos routine after my girlfriend mentioned she'd been craving gyros. Naturally, I started searching for places nearby, and while there was no shortage of options, Nicky's immediately stood out. Their photos looked incredibly well presented, with gyro meat piled high and genuinely generous portions. When we arrived just before 7 PM, the parking lot was nearly full, and after our experience, I can absolutely see why. The staff were incredibly friendly and welcoming. They could tell it was our first visit and happily walked us through the menu, answering every question with genuine warmth and patience. The food itself was excellent. Everything came out piping hot, fresh, and full of flavor. The gyro meat was tender without being overly fatty or dry. The hand-cut fries were especially impressive, perfectly crispy on the outside, fluffy on the inside, and seasoned just right. The onion rings and mozzarella sticks were equally well executed. The real showstopper, though, was the imported Greek baklava. I've had baklava from many different regions and styles over the years, and this was easily some of the best I've ever had. Rich, syrupy, incredibly flavorful, with a heavier note of cinnamon layered throughout that made it truly stand out. The menu is expansive, covering all the classic greasy spoon favorites you'd hope for, and the restaurant itself was clean, bright, and bustling with people clearly enjoying themselves. Near the end of our meal, the same staff member who helped us at the counter came by to check on us and ask if we needed anything else, which was a really nice touch. She also mentioned this is the original family-owned location, and honestly, that care and pride really shows. Overall, a fantastic first experience, and we're very glad we decided to stop in. We'll definitely be back soon to try more of the menu. read more

Nicky's Red Hots - The bill - Greek Near Me - Naperville, Illinois

See all

Popped in as a first timer for lunch. Had a cheese burger and fries. And my buddy had a gyros. Both meals were very tasty. We Both had the meal that included the main dish , fries and a beverage Very good. Service was good and the dining area was clean and comfy Definitely a stop in the Future read more

See all

The best gyro I've ever had! This family owned business has been around since 1994. There's a reason it's been open for so long and I highly recommend you go in and find out why. My husband and I stopped in for a late lunch, 230pm, and it was consistently full of customers dining in and carrying out. This casual spot is kept clean and can seat maybe 40-50 people. They also have an outdoor area for when the weather permits. Staff members were friendly and our food took about 5-10 minutes. We were in and out within an hour. Back to the gyro.. OH MAH GOODNESS! The meat is seasoned and cooked to perfection. It's tender and full of flavor. The tzatziki sauce they use is also very delicious. The pita brings it all together. All the components of this sandwich is of high quality and HEAVENLY. The portion is generous with very fair pricing. I tried the mozzarella sticks which were better than your standard moz sticks. Seriously... check this place out! read more

See all

Service: fast Food: Friend zucchini: 3/5 this was very flavorful Cajun chicken sandwich: 2/5 I would want to try to get something else again next time I'm here Gyro platter: 4.5/5 this was good and very large Oreo shake: very thick and good amount of sweetness read more

Nicky's Red Hots - Greek Near Me - Naperville, Illinois

Fast service and fast food with my favorite food stand ambience. Nicky's has been a staple for anyone who wants a great gyro and fries. I crave their gyro with extra tzatziki and lots of onion and tomatoes. Patty Melts are oniony cheesy goodness. Great Chicago style Polish sausage sandwich. Greek potatoes are a hidden gem! I recommend for on the go meal. sure to please! read more

Nicky's Red Hots - Gyro sandwich with fries. - Greek Near Me - Naperville, Illinois

I read a lot of reviews about generous proportions, so I ordered a gyro and fries 15 bucks. Gyro was small. I've had bigger from many other places.. very small. Fries were crispy and delicious. I asked for ketchup. She gave me 3 packets for a large fry , 3 strikes . Over prices 3 packets of ketchup for a large fry Very cheap on the gyro meat. Over hyped. Padded reviews by workers and fanboys. Never will eat here again. read more

We just moved here from the East Coast and have been looking for Philly cheese steaks. No luck until we found Nicky's! Delicious sandwiches and quick service. Mt chicken gyro was incredible, too. read more

Fantastic little place! We were visiting the area and looking for something to eat, so after quickly reading some reviews we decided to drop in here. So glad we did! It was busy but things moved quickly. Our counter attendant was patient, friendly, and helpful as it was our first time. DH ordered the beef sandwich combo, I opted for the pork souvlaki combo since none of the Greek joints where we live serve souvlaki, which is a favorite of mine. I overheard several people placing orders for a wild rice soup. We didn't order one but it seemed popular! Our order was called pretty quickly. Everything was hot, fresh, and delicious. We even took a chicken souvlaki to-go for a family member. The dining area was clean and comfortable. We people watched while waiting for our order, and everyone seemed to be enjoying their meals. Someone was digging into a whole roasted chicken with great enthusiasm. That looked really good! A lot of people were eating soup- not sure if they have more than one kind or if it was the wild rice we overheard, but a lot of people were enjoying it on that chilly and damp day. Prices were very reasonable, too. I could have happily eaten here every day during our visit, and it's definitely on our list for next time! read more

Nicky's Red Hots - Pork Souvlaki Sandwich was hot, seasoned perfectly, and delicious! - Greek Near Me - Naperville, Illinois

Amazing food and service. Have ate here many times and the inside is great. Started using them to cater meals for a team I coach and they over delivered on my expectations. Will be using them again. read more

Stopped in tonight for a quick bite. As always, the food was great and the service is top notch. I usually only order carry-out but decided to dine in tonight. Clean and comfortable setting to enjoy whatever you order from their extensive menu!! Been coming here for awhile and will continue to do so. Great food, excellent service all in a comfortable and clean environment. Keep up the great work!!!! read more

The food was fast, good and hot! I would definitely try this place again. If you are ever in the area, eat here.

Clean, fast, and friendly. Nicky's is always consistently good every time. Great place for a quick dinner that won't break the bank.

Pepper n egg dipped with hot giardiniera. Fries well done. Good, not great. Would expect a bigger sandwich at that price, but eggs are pricey at the moment. read more

Nicky's Red Hots - Pepper and egg sandwich with French fries - Greek Near Me - Naperville, Illinois

Have gone to Nicky's for years. Still the best fries in Naperville. However, since around December of 2025, the gyro meat seems to have changed. It is a different consistency, dry and almost no spice... it's just not as good. Not sure if they changed suppliers or brand of meat, but unless they fix this we'll be going to Gemato's for gyros. read more

Food is delicious and service is great! The food is fresh and authentic. Definitely one of our favorite spots!

Absolutely delicious. This was our first time eating here & for a fast food place, it was very satisfying. The young lady at the register was super patient, kind & helpful. She helped my husband and I with both of our orders bc we came in super indecisive. Our plates didn't take long to be made, everything was fresh & hot when it got to our table. This first impression was everything, i very rarely put 5 stars for a fast food place but I can't wait to go back. read more

Nicky's Red Hots - Mediterranean Bowl & Italian Sausage Sandwich with mozzarella & marinara sauce - Greek Near Me - Naperville, Illinois

Nicky's has consistently great food and service. I usually order out but they also have a seating area. You can order online and pay when you get there. Last night I got a gyro, my favorite, and fried zucchini. Yum!! The gyro came jam-packed with meat. Enough for leftovers. The fried zucchini was a first for me and it was so good. The garlic dipping sauce is amazing. read more

I come here a least once a week and the food is always good.From the gyros to the ribs, everything is delicious! I will always patronize this place. read more

Always love going to Nicky's Red Hots! I drive across town past other Greek food because nothing compares to Nicky's! Staff is always professional and I have never had a problem. I love everything on the menu but my favorite is the gyro, still having long strips of meat and not shaved like other places do! I highly recommend!! Restaurant is alway clean and has a great atmosphere! I'll always be a customer! read more

I've been coming to Nicky's for years and have always enjoyed their food. However, they committed the unforgivable act of charging a hidden10% surcharge. This is deceptive, and there is no sign stating that they charge a surcharge. This might even be illegal. Just raise the menu prices! Everyone understands that labor and food costs have gone up. read more

Nicky's Red Hots - Receipt - Greek Near Me - Naperville, Illinois

Amazing place, huge options from menu. Gyros was great and onion rings were not greasy but crispy. Portion was good for the price point. Very comfortable and clean dine in. read more

Nicky's Red Hots - Gyros Sandwich - Greek Near Me - Naperville, Illinois

I'm always hearing everybody rave about this place so I happened to be in the area today and I figured let's stop there. Of course I've never been there and they have a pretty expensive menu. I felt extremely rushed. No one seemed interested and really customer service at all. The guy working behind the counter is a big grouch and I'll get to that later. How bad can a hotdog joint be? so we got a bowl of soup with bread (which was almost 6 dollars?!) and a grilled cheese with fries and coleslaw the fries were pretty disgusting, pretty clearly they were frozen types of fries. The grilled cheese and coleslaw were actually good. I got a drink (which I normally don't get a drink when I'm out because you can never get a refill or they give you crap about it.) So I did finish the first drink and when I bought the drink, I asked if there were refills they said yes I went up for a refill and I always ask for extra ice so there's hardly any drink in there on the way out. I wanted to top my drink off, so it was like maybe an eighth of the glass Because I had to go back to work and I wanted something to drink The cranky guy behind the counter said "you have one more refill coming, OK" and I said that's OK. I'm leaving anyway and this is just a top off. It's not even a full refill. Three dollars. And honestly, I did not drink anywhere near three dollars worth of tea not to mention they're $.85 surcharge sign so I paid cash which that was all the cash I had on me because I never carry cash. Back to the gentleman at the counter, This is the same gentleman that when I walked in the minute I stepped in the door said can I help you and I said I've never been here. Can I look at the menu and he just walked away And knowing that I'm a first-time customer way to impress somebody with the nasty drink comment. I'm sure that that three cents of iced tea that I got was worth you never having a customer come back again. The food was severely overrated, and the prices are very much on the higher end of a hotdog joint Won't return The employees act like you're bothering them the cashiers is sitting on her phone. I can go elsewhere and get better service and better food and I intend to. read more

Decent prices on food for the area. Good burgers and the ribs fall off the bone. I don't order much takeout, but they are always on point.

Our family LOVES Nicky's because there is something for everyone and the food is always outstanding. It's served hot (even for pick up) and is always fresh. Family favs: Ribs (me), absolutely outstanding & includes baked potato & their delicious soup of the day - along w garlic bread! Kids love the chicken fingers, burgers & dogs. Wife loves salads & all the Greek food. You will come back a second, third & fourth time after your first visit! read more

Nicky's Red Hots, How I enjoy a good Chicago style hot dog and French fries that are not over or under fried. The two hot dog special with a soft drink fits the bill. Before COVID we enjoyed dining inside and viewing one of their many TVs. Ordering is easy, grab a seat and wait for your number to be called. When your done, like mom said, clean up after yourself and don't put the tray in the garage. One of my favorite spots in the area for a good hot dog. read more

Nicky's Red Hots - Greek Near Me - Naperville, Illinois

I've ordered from here and never been disappointed. Tonight i chose to order and pick up to take home. It's 5 minutes from my house so it's still hot when i get home. The ribs are melt in your mouth and falls off the bones. So mouth watering and strongly suggest you order them. I spilt the slab with my wife along with my two sides. Tonight I chose the baked potato that was made to perfection. They sent butter and sour cream and that's all I needed. I also got the Cole slaw which was creamy and very tasty. I think they could have been more refrigerated but was still extremely good. The bread was your basic toasted bread so didn't eat much of that with the delicious tasty dinner. I strongly suggest you order the rib dinner. The best around. read more

Nicky's Red Hots - Greek Near Me - Naperville, Illinois

See all

Delicious hot dogs and salads. I'm sure the rest of their menu is solid as well. They seem to focus on food quality.

I grew up in Chicago in the '60s and don't get back all that often. When I do, I always stop someplace for a hotdog and an Italian beef in an attempt to recapture my youth. My wife was with me on this visit and is allergic to gluten. I picked this place because they advertise gluten-free buns. Sadly, when we got there, they told us that it was only their hamburger buns. Anyway, I'll leave it for her to review her meal. For my part, it was a mixed bag. The hotdog was OK. Not the worst Chicago dog I've had and far from the best. The Italian beef was disgusting. It had a chemical taste and was weirdly too hot, like it had been put in a microwave for too long rather than allowed to simmer in "juice." This is the first time I've had to stop eating one of these things after only a few bites. read more

Nicky's Red Hots - Greek Near Me - Naperville, Illinois

I thought the food was excellent! The service was friendly! The indoor seating is comfortable and it's in a good location!

Nicky's, where have I been? Here, there, and back again. You've come a ways since I last visited, and for the better too! I had the Mediterranean bowl with chicken over rice and tzatziki. What a combo! Plentiful, tasty, and a good value. If you're looking for an alternative to the other fast food places, Nicky's should be at the top of your list. Gyros, ribs, bowls, shakes, and more. I can't wait to try the souvlaki! Dine in or take out, your stomach and your wallet should be happy either way. read more

Nicky's is a great place with a diverse menu and high quality food and service. I have been going here for years with my family and have never been disappointed!! read more

Came here for gyros and this place did not disappoint. As we spent several minutes deliberating what we wanted the cashier had our order in before we even asked and it came out super quick. Gyros - not too lamby. Tons of flavor and pita was fluffy Greek salad - one of the best Greek salads we have had. Plenty of tasty feta and kalamata olives read more

I went to dinner with a friend, walked in at 7:45. Got our food at about a little before 8:00. They close at 8:30. Ordered a gyro plate and salad. Nothing major. As I'm eating in there the bus boy starts loudly flipping chairs, making us feel uncomfortable with loud chairs banging, as if we aren't welcome to be eating there by that point. Then this jag bag manager apparently named Jimmy tells the same bus boy to come over to our table and ask to take the ketchup bottle. As we are STILL USING it for our french fries, way to make us feel even more uncomfortable? And while I am dining there as if I can't use the ketchup because you're in a rush to literally close and lock the doors even before your scheduled closing time? It's insanely rude. So I tell the busboy to tell the rude, not hospitable manager to come over and ask for it himself. All while we audibly hear the loud obnoxious manager complaining by proxy about customers being there late eating a meal. My friend proceeds to order a Greek burger to go, the same jerk gives her attitude while she's ordering and doesn't even say thank you or have a nice night as we're leaving. Absolutely rude establishment. Next time I'll just go to Gematos down the street next time where food is just as good, if not better, and owner / staff is way friendlier and gracious. And I've dined there many times before and usually it's really nice employees working at the front. A younger gentleman and lady and a nicer younger kid working the register. But this guy this evening was totally rude. Update: same owner creepily tracked me down and stalked me on Facebook as opposed to responding on proper channels here on Yelp and harassed me in a personal message telling me he wasn't rude. Basically validating my stance to begin with of being rude. What happened to customer is always right? I basically said my experience was supper uncomfortable and rude and you want to track me down on a personal app and harass me? read more

Great food, prepared quickly. We have enjoyed dine in and take out from this business for quite a few years. The food is consistently well made. I recently had the quarter Grecian Chicken Oreganato, with Greek potatoes and Greek salad. It was all absolutely delicious! They have a good selection of menu items. The restaurant is always clean when I've been there. read more

My work always get catering from Nicky's for events and it always goes well with our staffs and visitors. Nicky's have a lot of options from gyros and Italian beef which is definitely a recommendation for entrees. The Greek salad is good and a great addition to any meal. They have rice and potatoes for sides and they always give us a lot of additional sauces and dressing. read more

This Nicky's location is a Naperville staple! Variety of Chicago classics (hot dogs, Italian beef, etc.) plus Greek classics (gyros, spanakopita, etc). Food served quick & hot upon ordering at counter. Generally a busy spot, which I take a positive sign of many repeat customers young & old. Staff are consistent, familiar faces! My family always enjoy our meals here! read more

Love love the gyro! This satisfies my craving a gyro sandwich! The fries are yum the sauce is perfect! Juicy and delish. The service is fast and friendly! read more

Clean. Fast. Food is okay. Not bad. Not great. Stop if you're hungry but probably won't be back. read more

Nicky's Red Hots - Menu - Greek Near Me - Naperville, Illinois

See all

The food is good, you get your order fast, and those that work there are always professional.

Incredible food. Great service. Best ribs in Naperville! Haven't had anything on the menu I didn't love. Always high quality food and service. read more