Such a cute little place! I went for lunch on a Sunday and sat on their front patio, it was gorgeous sitting outside. They were understaffed and busy so it took quite a while for my food to get to me, but when it did it was piping hot. I got an omelet with peppers, mushrooms and feta with a side of home fries and sourdough toast. The omelet was perfectly done, the home fries I could eat a whole plate of, and the toast was great! Definitely recommend this place. read more

Old Saratoga Eatery - Omelet Home Fries Sourdough Toast - Pizza Near Me - Schuylerville, New York

My husband and I tried somewhere new! The old Saratoga eatery. At first impression, there were only two guests in the joint and it was quiet. The waitstaff were super friendly and we were promptly greeted. We put in our order for wings, sweet potato fries and two sandwiches. So glad we were somewhat fast, because the place was hopping within 5 minutes of sitting down! Their sweet potato fries are freshly cut there and they make their own sauces (you can tell from how fresh the pesto is). We will definitely be back. The menu is really big so everyone will have something to choose. We had a blast. Came in as strangers and left as regulars read more

See all

The owner did call me to let me know they had some new employees. And he did offer to replace the wings. I haven't taken them up on his offer because I just haven't been out that way. I did appreciate his kindness and I do understand sometimes things happen. I would go back and try it again when I'm in the area. read more

See all

Great Breakfast Spot in Schuylerville......My wife had the best sandwich there for dinner...Friendly staff

Sigh. I debated updating my previous review because I know how hard it is to keep a business afloat these days...especially food/restaurants. I stopped in recently on Monday with a colleague, since we were between meetings and had a little bit of time to grab a bite. Old Saratoga eatery was the only restaurant open in the entire town besides subway. All of the tables were occupied with one exception, and I probably should have read the room ...nobody had food in front of them. Long story short...the food took so long that we actually didn't have time to eat and took everything to go. It was probably an hour and 15 minutes that we waited for a salad, garlic, knots, French fries and chicken strips. Right before I was getting ready to leave, I was offered my money back, which was a very nice gesture, but I did not accept it. So, one star is for the truly lovely staff there and the second is for my decent salad. Unfortunately, my colleague did not have great things to say about his food. I probably should have asked how long the wait was going to be, but it would definitely be helpful if they let people know that they are very behind when they are initially seated. read more

We were a party of 6. Arrived at 6:00 and left at 7:30. We were the ONLY people there. It took an hour and 10 minutes to get our food. It was not worth the wait. Tasting notes from our group: The Philly cheese steak was dry. The zucchini hummus wrap was pretty much void of zucchini and spinach, and seemed to only have red onion and hummus. The pizza was not great. The breakfast sausage tasted "strange." Our server was nice, but couldn't make up for the sub-par food quality and long wait. read more

Stopped here out of convenience, best choice ever. Small place, service was excellent, they went above and beyond. I'm from Philadelphia, so for me to say their cheesesteak was excellent is a big deal. read more

We ordered two separate order of 10 wings... my math says we should have gotten 20 wings... but we only got 15. When the waitress brought them out and said I think you got some of his wings.... I figured she could count and knew we got shorted. read more

There is outside eating area for our dog.nicest wait staff and cook. The food was great. I can't say enough about the hospitality. GREAT PLACE!!!!!!!! read more

Very good and pleasant staff. I personally love the Senator breakfast sandwich. Eggs-cell-ent. I go as often as possible

Owned by local women, providing standard diner food for the right price. If you expect more than the above you will be disappointed. Support your local businesses! read more

Old Saratoga Eatery - Pizza Near Me - Schuylerville, New York

I like to support local, small businesses when I can. Olde Saratoga Eatery has always had very pleasant, competent and friendly staff. Tonight, I called in a take out order and was told it would be ready in 45 min. I arrived there just at 45 min mark, but waited an extra 15 min. That was ok, but the server asked me a minimum of 3 times who I was and what my order was, may have been 5 times. A bit annoying, since the restaurant was not full, so I could not attribute it to that. I had ordered a pizza and crispy oriental chicken salad. Pizza was good as usual, but salad was lacking ingredients. There was supposed to be tomatoes, almonds and carrots that were missing. There was lettuce, red onion and cheese ( both not listed as ingredients ), crispy chicken, and very light sprinkling of chinese noodles. Most oriental salads include a nice oriental salad dressing, but not in this case. That is not offered, but should be. So, I was very disappointed in this salad choice. It was just a very strange and out of character experience tonight at the restaurant. I am giving 5 stars, b/c I don't want this review to discourage other potential customers from trying other tasty menu items. read more

Decent food and price. They have lots of options to choose from too. We had a group of 9 and they quickly accommodated us. Most of us had burgers and were all happy with what we got read more

We had a bad experience last year when ordering a delivered meal, over an hour, cold and poorly prepared. We only live about a mile from the establishment. We didn't complain, stuff happens. We tried again this evening and our pizza took 1 hour and 17 minutes to be delivered and yes only about a mile away. I handed the cold pizza back to the driver. I do feel bad for not tipping the driver, it's not her fault. I was angry and feel bad for the driver. However when the owner called me as if the cold pizza was my fault, I decided to warn everyone about the bad experience. I won't make the same mistake again. read more

Stopped in for lunch during a COVID era drive to some area parks. Glad to find that they were open and serving with all proper COVID precautions in place. They had 3 tables outside well spaced, all workers wearing masks. Time to give these small businesses some love and the nice weather makes it easier. Food was good - the SO enjoyed the Zucchini Hummus wrap but felt there could have been more hummus. The $5 2-slice and soda special was OK but my slices lost most of their heat before they got to me. Staff was friendly and efficient which makes up for the minor shortcomings in the food. read more

Supposed to head to Sweet Lou's for lunch but they were closed so stumbled upon this place for lunch Pros: - Zucchini hummus sandwich was delicious. Wrap was packed to the brim with veggies. Forgot to ask without onions, other than that the wrap was great. - Service was quick (less than 10 minutes) - Street parking Cons: - None! read more

We have really enjoyed our meals at Old Saratoga Eatery while in Schuylerville! The menu had a lot of variety from nostalgic diner food (like the open face turkey sandwich with mashed potatoes I had the first night) to pizza, salads, sandwiches, and a great breakfast menu. The portions are very generous and the staff are really friendly. The first night we were here we sat outside and they kept coming out to check on us because it looked like it might start to rain. This morning we had breakfast there before leaving. I enjoyed the omelette and home fries, and my wife ordered the fried dough (which was huge!) and said it was like a big donut with powdered sugar! We will definitely go back next time we are in the area! read more

Old Saratoga Eatery - Omelette with spinach and mushroom, home fries, wheat toast - Pizza Near Me - Schuylerville, New York

Excellent food every time. Service is a bit slow so wait for the food is long BUT it's absolutely worth the wait!! The menu selection is huge and prices are great. They offer breakfast, lunch and dinner. I enjoy dine-in as a nice way to spend time with family but also LOVE getting a pizza to go as well. read more

Stopped here late on a Sunday afternoon. Not much else was open and we took a chance. That was a really, really good idea! Great food. Great prices. Friendly staff and the place is clean. Don't let it's size and location fool you, it is definitely worth the trip. We'll be back! read more

Good ole breakfast, great service and atmosphere. Prices are reasonable. Owner is approachable and very friendly

Our lunch at Eatery was an absolute treat! The staff was incredibly attentive, and so accommodating when we asked to sit outside even though we were clearly the first group to do so today. Service was quick, and all 5 meals warm and delicious. We were particularly impressed with the freshness of ingredients and obvious attention to detail! Thank you for a great lunch, hidden away from the bustle of Saratoga! read more

Today was our first visit to Old Saratoga Eatery and it was well worth the drive from Ballston Spa. This simple no-frills eatery has a retro vibe and super friendly staff. The breakfast menu included breakfast staples as well as specialty items that you would only expect in an upscale restaurant. My tea was served complete with a teapot and a choice of tea. I definitely recommend the stuffed French toast and the sausage patties, which were slightly spicy and cooked just right. My Husband went for bacon and eggs, with bacon nice and crispy. The full menu offers lots of reasonably priced choices for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. It will be worth your while to give them a try. read more

My son and I eat here and try something different every time. The pizza is really good - thin crust, creamy cheese, and just the right tang in the sauce. Burgers, breakfast, and in between, everything is good and freshly made. read more

Sat outside on a sunny day. Delicious food, love eating breakfast anytime. Service was friendly and prompt. Specials!! Desserts!!

We happened on this place mostly because not much else was open in the afternoon on a Monday. But I'm glad we did because we had amazing service and the chicken pesto sandwich was amazing. Good prices, quick turnaround to get our food and nice people working there. We highly recommend. read more

We were there on a hazy lazy Monday afternoon 1pm. It was a hot day but the A/C was keeping it cool. I had the truffle grilled cheese and it was amazing!! My husband had the cheeseburger burrito! It was a chance stop on our way to get strawberries in the parking lot in Greenwich from the Amish folks!! Great choice. We will be back one day! read more

Shut up and take my money! This place is amazing! I'm only here visiting family a few weeks but I'll be ordering a lot more before I head out! I definitely recommend this place! read more

Old Saratoga Eatery - The size of this calzone! - Pizza Near Me - Schuylerville, New York

Ordered take-out for the first time from Old Saratoga Eatery tonight. It was possibly the best take-out food we've ever had. We had the cheese ravioli, garlic knots, wings & house salad. The portions were huge. The food was delicious. Real tomato sauce (with chunks of tomato), Buffalo wings that impressed my wing-connoisseur boyfriend, and a salad full of fresh ingredients. We are so happy we decided to try something different than our usual take-out place tonight! The delivery took a long time (little over an hour), but when I called the owner explained that they were unexpectedly short staffed (understandable during this Covid situation) and her husband drove our order out himself! Will definitely return. read more

Went for a drive and stumbled upon this wonderful little eatery by chance. I had the Old Saratoga salad and ice tea. They have great food, old town environment and excellent service. We are looking forward to returning soon! read more

See all

By far the best pizza in Schuylerville. The owners here managed to get it right and filled one of the things that has been missing. Old Saratoga Eatery is a newer business in the area and has definitely made their mark on the growing restaurant industry in the village of Schuylerville. All of their food is great and the owners are a pleasure to sit and chat with while you wait on your meal. Thank you for bringing back the taste of great pizza in Schuylerville! read more

Such a cozy and friendly environment, hands down the best garlic Knots I have ever eatenThe staff here was all wearing masks and very kind. They have a large selection of food beyond just pizza. Will definitely be visiting again soon! read more

We came here for lunch after seeing their menu online. We are docked down at the Schuylerville Yacht Basin and this restaurant was only a short walk away. My husband and son settled on white pizza. And I went with Cobb salad with grilled chicken. Coming from the NYC area, it's hard to find good pizza elsewhere but this thin crust white pie was delicious. The crust was the best part too. And the salad was large and very fresh. Warm grilled chicken on top made it perfect. Excellent service. Place to sit outside and properly social distance. And from the looks of their menu, there is definitely something for everyone. read more

This place is a gem! The food is soooo good. Pizza is the best I've had outside of NYC. Thin, crispy crust, fresh sauce, and the most delicious caramelized cheese. Also had the stuffed shrimp, and they were amazing. Kids had grilled cheese, and it was perfect. Loved the fries too. Definitely try the pizza though. Friendly and quick service to top it all off. Go here if you can. I would go all the time if I lived locally. read more

Stopped by on the way back from the Saratoga National battlefield site. Huge menu sometimes indicates they don't know what to do well. Not the case here. Three of us ordered very different meals...but each was fantastic. Mine was the Truffle Grilled Cheese. Amazing! A ricotta stuffed calzone and beef barley soup were also ordered. Sampled both. Both amazing. Oh and we stared with an order of onion rings. Perfectly battered. Service was very fast and polite. Jayme - the proprietor - was fantastic!! We'll be back for years to come. read more

I hope this place gets better...I think it would have potential. I know that N.Y. pizza is thin, but please make the slices big if the pizza is thin. It was $3 a slice. I was still hungry after 2 slices. There should be a lunch special: - 3 slices of pizza and 1 drink for $7 I kind of gave up after my knife fell apart when I was slicing my pizza. I cut up my pizza so it cools down faster. Would I go back: I'm honestly not sure read more

Once again my order is delayed. Almost 15mins past whatever they say every time. Kitchen is yelling at each other and some even heckling me. Damn, just get your shit together. This money is keeping you alive. read more

This was a great place. Family run. They take pride in their business. Food was delicious. Service excellent .

Little local family owned gem! Amazing service and equally amazing food every time we come! Good prices and huge portions! Highly recommend! read more

Old Saratoga Eatery - Pesto chicken - Pizza Near Me - Schuylerville, New York

See all

Awesome food served with warmth and personality! So nice to see smiles greeting you when you walk through the door. Large servings of stick-to-your gut comfort food. Just visiting this weekend but would love to come again on my next drive through town. read more

Really good pizza and fabulous service. The waitress brought out toys for my kids and a pickle for the baby and even helped wipe the spaghetti sauce off of the five year olds face! read more