We had the carlina salad, house made focaccia, gnocchi, salmon and grilled artichokes. Everything was flavorful and fresh. Food came out quickly and the waiters were helpful and friendly. The restaurant is cozy and intimate. Would return. read more

The drinks were delicious although I wish they were a bit stronger! The food was also delicious and the pastas were cooked perfectly al dente. I would say the focaccia bread and pastas were slightly salty but still had great flavor and depth. The best thing about this restaurant is the service. The host and servers were attentive without rushing you and made great recommendations based on your preference. read more

Osteria Carlina - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Fantastic experience! For our appetizer, we had the beef tartare which was phenomenal and perfectly fresh. We each tried a different pasta, we had the squid ink with crab, lemon pappardelle , and mushroom pasta, and all were great. I will say the squid ink with crab could've used a little bit more flavor, but honestly, it was very light which I enjoyed and there was a copious amount of crab meat. An underrated addition to our meal was the focaccia which was genuinely some of the best bread I've had in a long time. I must say that the service is driving a large portion of my review. The host/manager could not have been more amazing and genuinely made our experience incredible. In conjunction with that all other staff was extremely kind and accommodating, and I simply have not a singular note on the service here. Ambience is lovely as well. It's intimate, cozy and casual. The perfect ambience for a relaxed dinner. Overall, I will 100% come back to Osteria Carlina and would recommend anyone stop by. Thank you for an incredible experience and making my mom's birthday one to remember. read more

Osteria Carlina - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Came here for their advertised happy hour - however, we were met by a very grouchy Bar guy who didn't even give us the happy hour menu until we asked him - which he was annoyed by doing so. We did not receive a menu just a verbal listing of what wine was on the happy hour... Which I had to ask twice when he was saying what was on it because the music was so loud. Which he was additionally annoyed by. i'm very sad by the whole experience because we live in the neighborhood and was very excited about trying out this place. Sadly, I will not be back. read more

Osteria Carlina - No menu when you go inside. Just a grumpy worker that you are even there. - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Really great no-frills Italian restaurant in West Village. Not loud, and easy to book a table with little notice. They definitely seem to take care in what they're providing, and the lighting is dim and intimate. The service was attentive. The pasta definitely tasted homemade and fresh, and the mushrooms that decorated it were deep and flavorful. The dish was well balanced and I would come back again, especially to catch up with someone. The ambiance is perfect for you to be able to have a conversation with someone. The tables are a bit tight together, so especially in the winter where everyone has bulky jackets, just be careful about bumping into other tables if you sit along the sofa area. However, they do have the option to check your coat in also. read more

Osteria Carlina - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

From the moment we arrived to the restaurant the GM was very attentive to our needs, and they were also able to accommodate to our late reservation and were patient with us. The GM helped with recommending dishes to try and every suggestion was delicious. The Beef tartar was a great appetizer and the salad they paired with it was a great choice. The lasagna sauce was amazing and I'm still thinking about it. The pot roast ravioli was good but not my fav. I would definitely come back to try other dishes on the menu. The Chardonnay that we ordered also paired with our dishes. Although the restaurant was tightly packed, we enjoyed our date night! read more

See all

More like 3.75 All the appetizers were had were very tasty. Pizzetta - chruncky texture fluffy bread, prosciutto with basil pesto sauce all together eas heavenly. Crab Tart - refreshing and delicious. Carlina Insalata - also very good if you like fennel. Refreshing. Veal - not my favorite but my friends enjoyed it. Pasta unfortunately not as wow-ed as the appetizers ... White Ragu Pasta - recommended by our server, feels lean, not complex, feel more like eating minced meat over noodle. Agnolotti - the filling was dense and dry. Mushroom Papadelle - very good. Probably the best among all. Dessert overall was fine. read more

See all

If you're looking for authentic Piedmontese cuisine, look no further than Osteria Carlina! We walked in without reservations, but Ramon made sure we were comfortable at the bar. The atmosphere is perfectly cozy and romantic, with soft jazz playing in the background. We ordered the vitello tonnato to start - pretty tasty, but could've used a thicker tuna sauce. The real stars of the show were the pastas. Having the Tajarin was like being transported right back to northern Italy. Every bite was heaven. The Agnolotti was also delicious - rich, savory, and luscious. We finished with an espresso and the tiramisu - a classic, you can't go wrong. Ramon was wonderful in making our night wonderful. Can't wait to come back soon! read more

See all

Fantastic Italian restaurant in west village! This was honestly one of the best pasta restaurants I've been to in Manhattan so far. I especially loved the mushroom pasta we ordered-- the texture of the pasta was fantastic and the sauce was creamy and scrumptious (but not too heavy)! Vibe was great-- definitely a good date night spot (especially in the outdoor patio). Service was fast and good. I'll definitely be back when I'm craving some pasta! read more

See all

Beautiful date night spot. First time having a lambchop milanese, it was very crispy and delicious. The lamb ragu tagliatelle was also very good. The asparagus was so well seasoned. There's an option to make your own espresso martini which I didn't do but I haven't seen this anywhere else and thought it was pretty unique. Don't skip the bread service! read more

See all

DO NOT GO HERE. Guy at front is rude. I showed up and realized the menu did not have liquor and told him that is my reason to leave and he charged me $120 for no show when I did show up. I told him online it's not clear that only one location has liquor. read more

Delicious food, great service, small and intimate and most wonderful of all QUIET! would definitely recommend. read more

This review is for dinner. I stumbled upon this place without looking it up prior and was VERY pleasantly surprised by the food and would come back! Walked up with no reservations during the weekday and was seated immediately. It's elevated and feels intimate (white linen tablecloths, waiters are dressed up), but doesn't feel stuffy at all. And doesn't necessarily feel like you need to dress up (lots of people stopped by in casual attire). Service was great. I ordered the below for two. We probably could've ordered one more pasta, but generally was enough food: -Pizzetta al Tegamino: great app. Comes cut into 4 slices. Bread is doughy. Favorite thing we ordered. -Capesante e Ciliegie (scallops): comes with 4. Scallops melt in your mouth. Sauce is fairly mild and light. -Tagliatelle D'Astice (lobster pasta): fresh and light. Sauce isn't creamy. Needed a little salt, but overall enjoyed. Great dish for summer. read more

See all

A middle school cafeteria with toursits vibe - $80 cover charge Saturday night, I made a reservation at Osteria Carlina West Village. We arrived 15 minutes early, took one look around, and decided it wasn't for us. Think tourist crowd with groups seated side-by-side on low chairs like a middle school cafeteria. We POLITELY told the host we'd like to cancel, he nodded, no problem. Yet we were still charged $80 for the privilege of not dining there. When I called to clarify, their solution was to offer us a discount if we came back. I said again politely, "Now I feel forced to dine, and I will not come under these circumstances." and the staff responded "Sure, bye". For anyone looking for an idyllic West Village night, this isn't it. I understand if you charge for no-shows and late cancellations. We arrived early and very very politely informed the host that we'd like to cancel. We've never been charged in NYC for canceling in person, so this charge is unwarranted. Sometimes being polite gets mistaken for being passive. So here you go -- may this image scream on my behalf. read more

Osteria Carlina - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Came back to this location as we wanted their Osso Bucco but it was off the new Spring menu (though still on the website menu). We had to settle for the rolled chicken and pasta bolognese. Very disappointed in both as they were tasteless. Chicken had the double whammy of a poorly executed wine sauce and dry chicken? Would a sous vide chicken worked better here? Just asking as I'm only a hobbyist cook and not a restaurant cook anymore. Salad was fresh, tasty and vibrant. That was the highlight of the meal and too bad it was the first course. Expanding any brand is tough. Did the cooks that were at the Hudson location change after opening the Varick Street location? I'm not brave enough to spend another $$ to find out. Sorry Carlina, you've lost my business... read more

A fantastic experience. We had the gnocchi with pesto and zucchini flowers and the pappardelle funghi. There's really not a lot of other veg on the menu that appealed to us. No matter. The pappardelle was excellent. (The gnocchi was ok.) also enjoyed my Barbera wine very much, a perfect pairing with the mushroom sauce. The unexpected piece de resistance was the hazelnut chocolate mascarpone cake. Wow. Go here. Eat that. Feel happy to be alive. read more

Osteria Carlina - From the outside looking in - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

The food at Carlina was outstanding; fresh and tasty, and well plated. I regret not knowing that they don't have a liquor license before coming - they have wine and Prosecco, and some wine-based mixed drinks, but no spirit cocktails. However, what made the experience a little less than ideal was the table layout - too tight/close to other diners - and the wait staff, who were not especially helpful or informative with menu questions. I'd visit again for the food, but would likely choose a quiet day or sit at the bar. read more

Came for dinner with two other friends and had a fantastic meal. Very cozy intimate spot, perfect for date night. We shared the crispy crab tarte, Cesare salad, short rib agnolotti, duck shredded pasta and potato side. The crab tarte was tasty but was probably not ideal to share. The short rib agnolotti and the potato side was our favorite, wished we skipped the duck pasta and just gotten two short rib agnolottis, it was a pack of flavor. For dessert, we got the lemon ricotta cake and the hazelnut mascarpone. The hazelnut was to dieee for and the lemon was a skip. Great spot overall, who doesn't love fresh pasta. Can't wait to be back for a date night. read more

Our meal was outstanding, from appetizers to dessert, and the wines that were recommended as pairings were spot on. The staff was very friendly and we enjoyed conversing with them about exploring Italian cuisine. Can't recommend the food, wine, staff, and romantic atmosphere enough! We'll be back! read more

Great Date spot. Beautiful on the inside. And the service was really good. They took care of us and checked on everything just the right amount without being too abrasive. The food was also really good. tartare was good, and the truffle butter pasta was fantastic we tore it up. lol. Star of the show though? AGNOLOTTI ALLA PIEMONTESE!!!! DO NOT MISS IT. Overall a great little spot for your back pocket. It was even better than Torrisi which I waited months to get into, the same northern italy style of cuisine, and quadruple the price for lesser or equal food. read more

Everything is amazing on the menu here; however, the desserts are especially amazing! Got takeout from here recently, and I just couldn't make up my mind. I got the bonet dessert again. My only suggestion for management and the chef, is to introduce a vegetarian section on their menu. Unfortunately, New York has a long way to go when it comes to being vegetarian-friendly, in comparison to California. read more

Osteria Carlina is a true neighborhood gem. The atmosphere is warm and elegant, the service is attentive without being intrusive, and the food beautifully showcases Northern Italian cuisine with thoughtful, seasonal flavors. From perfectly executed pastas to well-curated wines, everything feels intentional and refined. A wonderful spot for both special occasions and a memorable night out. read more

Very good tribeca spot, fine dining experience. Great date spot, not too much traffic and easy to park after 7pm. Italian dishes that had good presentation, taste, and service was very good. read more

Osteria Carlina is a nice addition to the West Village, with good Italian food in a cozy space that's not as loud as some of the restaurants on busier streets. Service was great, with friendly staff who were very attentive and had generous pours for wine by the glass. Appetizers were good -- the meatballs (polpettine) definitely stole the show! The beef tartare was just okay, it didn't jump out as particularly flavorful. And the tuna sauce it came with was a little weird, like eating a puréed can of tuna on top of the beef. I wouldn't go for that particular dish again. For entrees, the ravioli was delicious, with al dente texture and really nice filling. The tagliatelle left something to be desired, though. It was a tad overcooked, and the ragu didn't add much to the dish. Also a little more oily than I would have liked. Tiramisu dessert was well done, served in a glass cup with all the usual trimmings. I could taste the coffee-soaked biscuit and cocoa powder, very impressive. Overall the food was fine, service was great, and ambiance was nice. I think for the price, Osteria Carlina is a decent option if you're looking to venture off the beaten path. read more

See all

This is the type of place you pray does not get ruined by social media hype if the wrong person discovers the truffle menu. It's a perfect setting for a secluded, refined sampling of regional Italian excellence. For me, number one this month in the category of pleasant surprises--seems like a neighborhood spot from the outside but undoubtedly draws a discerning crowd of regulars from near and far. read more

Osteria Carlina - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

The slightly tacky decor (think "fancy" suburban restaurant) made our hearts sink a bit when we entered, but the welcome was warm, the wine advice good, and the carciofini fritti were excellent. The pastas, alas, were a mess. I ordered the maltagliati alle vongole and my wife the pappardelle nere, and in both cases the pasta was far too thick and leaden. Their pasta roller needs to be set for a much thinner dough. The result was that the pasta did not absorb either sauce but only sat swimming in it. (The truth is, for vongole you are much better off with dry, store--bought pasta that gets half-cooked in the sauce itself.) Also the pasta was under salted, adding to the leaden taste. We may go back some day just to try different pastas to see if they are better. But I urge the chef to rethink how the fresh pastas are made. read more

Sunday for brunch - It's my 3rd time coming here ( twice for dinner ) and this time for brunch. I was excited to come back because of my fond memories of the Prosecco and the dishes I previously had for dinner . Lunch vs dinner is different ( as all places ), my preference is always dinner but the lunch isn't too bad . We shared a salad to start , my friends had a burger and fries , risotto while I had the pasta with porcini mushroom and pasta. I decided to do half with a friend who ordered the burger as I'm a meat eater and love burgers . I wish I didn't as my pasta was the better dish ( pasta cooked al dente And the sauce was well seasoned , delicious ). The burger was medium rare as recommended by the server ( it was a bit rare for my taste). While all were tasty , the food was we're all different temperatures, the burger was cooked and was sitting there a while before served . I wasn't surprise as everything was slow ( from ordering to getting our dishes , check and paying ). I can't blame the server as he was one person with some help but for the amount of patrons , the restaurant needed more. It was disappointing but wouldn't deter me from coming back ( for dinner ) and hopefully my fond memories will remain positive z Great cute place perfect for a small group of friends , dates . read more

I came here after posting a rave review on Resy because our dining experience was THAT GOOD, we want to shout it from the rooftops and i am blown away by the reviewers who are like "meh, the place is small." Get a grip! This the west village, if you want something this restaurant cannot provide, go somewhere else. Elite Yelpers are the most annoying people on the planet. For Real, Back to this gem of a place... it was perfection. we ordered the pizza from the truffle menu and I felt like I'd died and gone to heaven! The pizza was perfection in execution and taste. We also shared the ceasar salad and it was by far the best take on a ceasar we had ever had. Finally, we shared two pastas, my favorite was the stuffed lobster. The flavors were other worldly and the pasta pillow melted in our mouths. The service was so lovely and attentive, 5-star all the way. This might be the best Italian food in all of NYC and we've been to a countless number. A perfect dining experience! read more

Osteria Carlina - A fresh take on a Ceasar salad. Delicious! I wish we took more photos but you'll have to take my word for it and try for yourself. - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

So glad we dined here because the food was amazing. From the breadsticks, to the scallops, ossobuco & aperol spritz. Delicious and incredibly fresh dishes. The drinks and entrees were some of the best I've had in a while. The food was perfectly seasoned and finely executed. The atmosphere of this cute little restaurant is warm and inviting + friendly service. Would definitely recommend this place to friends visiting the city who want a yummy authentic Italian meal. read more

See all

Looking for some European flair to your casual lunch? Look no further than Osteria Carlina! Came here on a Saturday noon, mainly because I wanted pasta. I was met by a wonderful waiter and decided to sit outdoors (because small tables with an umbrella on the sidewalk screams charming italian vibes to me). I ended up ordering a bellini with paccheri ai gamberi con ricotta e pesto and a side of peperoni alla Piemontese. The bellini was good, more alcohol than juice, which is always welcome. The paccheri curbed that pasta craving I had. The pesto was classic: nice basil flavor, not too overpowering on the garlic. The paccheri was tender with a nice bite, and there was enough shrimp added that you didn't feel cheated. The peperoni was a nice compliment, a bit of freshness and herbaceousness to the richness of the main dish. But honestly, you didn't need the peperoni to enjoy the pasta. In addition to the wonderful food, the service was so friendly! I was served by a waiter who enjoyed making small talk. And at a certain point the owner came around and asked us all how we were doing. Overall, if you're looking for affordable and classy Northern italian fare (unless you opt for the truffle menu, that's on you), I would highly recommend this place! read more

Osteria Carlina - Paccheri ai Gamberi con Ricotta e Pesto - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

first time here small place and packed. has outside seating. wine list is ridiculously expensive. Hopefully the food is ok. Not bad decent vibe. The food is average. The PAPPARDELLE CON FUNGHI SELVATICI was dry. The lasagna was good. Not bad wasn't disappointed not truly thrilled. Was ok but the wine list is grossly expensive read more

Such delicious truffle pasta!! I also recommend the scallops as an appetizer. They are small but marinated in the most delicious sauce. The truffle pasta is one of my favorites in the city. They give you a generous amount if you do the $90 one. I will definitely be back. Service was also incredible and so attentive. Truly a hidden gem in the village. read more

Osteria Carlina - Truffle pasta - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Good, but not great! I didn't agree with all of the choices made, although they seemed interesting on the menu: for example, the ensalata carlina was on a bed of sweet potatoes, but they were cold and the texture just wasn't inviting. I also didn't love the tagliatelle. I also thought the service was very slow, and my drink order came out wrong. I think there is potential but right now it's just not perfect. read more

Osteria Carlina - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Review was accurate .Nothing good about this place. Fake review ,my ass. Small portions of tasteless food. AVOID

We dipped in for a casual meal and fell in love instantly. Cozy, ambient lighting and a welcoming staff made us feel like regulars, although I had never been despite knowing the area. Ramon took care of us start to finish, with great recommendations, a stellar wine list and fresh selections. Food was everything and more--the cold veal, the fresh buratta, and a perfect shared potion of divine rabbit ragout pasta. A fantastic spot for any occasion. Highly Recommend!!! read more

We went to Carlina with friends during a week. The place has a beautiful interior and very thoughtful staff. Location is very central on a quiet West Village street. We shared charcuterie and pizza. The meat selection went well with the bread they brought for the table. Pizza was very thick like they do it in Chicago. It was fine. We ordered Paraprdelle with beef ragu, seafood linguine and Baby chicken with mash potatoes. While I enjoyed the parpardelle it felt over salted, the seafood pasta was nice but salty as well. The wine was great. We didn't have any desert. The place was so hot. Not sure if they can control the temperature but we were baked lol. read more

See all

Yummmmmmmmmm.... It was soooo delicious...Its a real Italian dish...The Italian host was very professional...Definitely, this is one of the best Italian restaurants in a town... Try it and you are not going to regret. Also, make sure double check with the host about today's lunch or dinner. We got a fresh and tasty ones...We loved the thank you sweet at the end... read more

See all

The good was the best Italian I've had for a long time! The service was excellent and the staff were very accommodating. The ambience is very cozy and inviting! Highly recommend, even though it's a bit pricey- it is well worth it! read more

This has become our " fancy night out" spot in NYC. The place is a real jewel box. Professional graceful service. Beautifully prepared food. Highly recommend !!!! ( that said... a few value options on the wine list would be nice) read more

Updated: I received a call from the GM and it's clear customer experience is important to this restaurant, and I appreciate that. My experience did not meet my expectation in one particular way: The menu boasts tajarin, a piemontese dish of finely hand cut fresh pasta. When this is handmade, the appearance and mouthfeel of the pasta is incredible. I think it's important to know that if you've dined at places that have hand cut tajarin, this is not that. Carlina advertised a tajarin but served a thicker noodle looking more like spaghetti/bucatini than angel hair. The GM did indicate that it's machine made and not hand cut, and they do not advertise hand cut pasta. In addition, they currently have a truffle menu in which prices are based on amount of truffle, 3g vs 6g. I was surprised that they advertised price per gram of truffle but then eyeballed the amount instead of weighing. I would recommend weighing for transparency sake. Finally, we sat outside which was fine. However our neighbor was loud and obnoxious at times. This is not the restaurant's fault, but took away from the overall ambience. Shout out to our waiter who was attentive and helpful. Again, if you are looking for the special experience of hand cut tajarin this place may leave you wanting. I appreciate that the GM and staff are attentive to customer experience, and called to discuss the review. read more