SO GOOD. Tried the pizza sandwich for the first time it's 10/10! Sauce, ratio, all of it is just so good. Couldn't recommend it enough!!

The atmosphere was wonderful, nicely decorated and very clean. Outdoor seating has nice sturdy umbrellas. The employees are very nice too and seemed like they wanted to be at work, very friendly. I would NOT recommend anything on the kids menu. The Mac and Cheese is obviously Kraft (which is fine because it's on the kids menu I suppose), however the chicken nuggets were frozen in the middle. Not fantastic. I got a personal pizza with krispy chicken, but the krispy chicken tasted like a cut up Dino chicken nugget. Not great quality. I think maybe I should've looked at past reviews or asked the employees what was good, because the French dip was absolutely wonderful! The bread was soft on the inside, crunchy on the outside, and the meat was pleasantly flavored. The dip was great too. So if you go, I would recommend the sandwiches because those seemed to be great. The pizzas are meh, and the kids menu is just store bought food prepared for you. The sandwiches are fully worth it! read more

See all

First time in was pretty good I do wish my cauliflower pizza was cooked a little longer but everything was delicious read more

See all

I have been eye balling this joint for the last year and today I finally got to try it out. It is conveniently next to Rocky Mountain High school so it was the perfect dinner after tonight's wrestling matches. I walked in around 7:30 tonight. The place was empty. Nobody was upfront so I just checked out the menu board. A worker did finally make it to the register. Being it was my first time there, I was really unfamiliar with their sandwiches. I asked a couple questions and dude wasn't a lot of help. His mono tone approach to helping me made me feel uncomfortable, like I was bothering him. I should have just left but I went a head and ordered anyways. I grabbed the whole Steak and Everything sandwich without the Everything for my husband. I got the half portion for myself. I added some chipotle ranch to mine. The whole sandwich is no joke! The size of the sandwich could feed 2 to 3 people. It was hot, the cheese was melty and the steak was tender. My sandwich was huge as well for a half size. There were bright pieces of green pepper, mushrooms and banana peppers. I really wanted to like my sandwich. It lacked flavor. Even though it had the chipotle ranch on it, it didn't do much for the sandwich. The peppers, mushrooms and onions needed some seasoning on it. It tasted like steamed veggies on cheese and steak. I did add some salt and pepper but it was still very one noted. The bread was nice and soft. The banana peppers did add some nice acidity to the sandwich and the steak was very tender on my sandwich. As much stuff there was on the sandwich, it just didn't hit for me. I'm not in this area a lot but I'm happy I got to try it out. It wasn't the best experience but maybe my next visit we will have a better experience. read more

See all

Great food. Had the hot Italian would recommend. Pizza was good as well. Great atmosphere. Employees were great. Must try

Date Night w/my man. Decided to checkout Papa Kelsey's in Meridian. Restaurant is spacious & clean. TVs available to watch sports. Staff super friendly and helpful. Sandwiches are baked, super big & comes with chips. Besides sandwiches they offer pizza & salads too. Definitely going back! read more

See all

HUGE whole sandwich. Very good bread is toasted perfectly and they don't skimp out on the meat. Great! read more

Papa Kelsey's - Southwest Chipotle Chicken - Sandwiches Near Me - Meridian, Idaho

Always great sandwiches!! No complaints!! Like the new mini size offer!! Nothing more to add.

Friendly fast service. One of the best toasted subs I've had. Bread is toasty and they don't skip on the meats. Pizza crust was also very good. Will definitely be coming back! read more

I've been to the location in Hagerman, but never this one. This five star review is for the employees working today (2/2/26, 2pm) great service. I ordered the all meat personal size, and my partner got a sub. The food was out quick which I appreciated, but the pepperonis were a bit burnt for my liking, (burnt bacon taste; some enjoy but not for me). I felt bad to even ask, but we asked if there was anything they could do and an explanation was given and they had no problem to make it right! Brought it back out and the pepperonis were hot but not burnt! I also enjoyed the soda and the music as well. Overall, quick service, very friendly, and good pizza. The ranch wasn't bad either (I'm a connoisseur) read more

What a great place to discover! This was the first restaurant to pop up when we were in meridian and looking for a lunch spot so we thought we'd check them out! Friendly greeting, FRESH FRESH food!!!! And yummy seasonings!! We are definitely going to come back next time we're in meridian! read more

See all

Great fresh bread Roast beef horrible Meatball sandwich good Sorry not open Sundays Good for a drop in sandwich read more

Wow is this place good!!! The bread for the sandwiches is insanely good as well as the quality of the sandwiches. We had the chance to meet the owner, him and his crew were so kind. You can tell they know how to run a business correctly. The inside is spacious with a garage door to the patio. Such a cool spot, wish we had one in Indiana!! read more

I really like this place. I have eaten here 3x in the past 8 days! First visit had the french dip, half sandwich, oh la la where have you been all my life; so good! I ate the whole 8" because i thought the bread, it's so light & delicious. Too much for me, I couldn't eat for the rest of the day. My second visit i split the half french dip sandwich with my friend, we each got our own portion of au jus dip. Perfect lunch size. Today my husband & I shared the Italian sandwich, it was unlike any other Italian sandwich I've ever had but very good. All their sandwiches are served hot. We also shared a small order of French fries. Air fried is a plus with yummy fry sauce too. Clean & comfortable place with good service. read more

Cool sandwich shop, love the warm atmosphere. My wife and I decided to try it out, we grabbed our sandwiches to go. The staff was really nice and very helpful and it's cool you can look right into the kitchen to see them making the sandwiches. I had and Italian sandwich, the bread was fresh and soft. The flavors were very good and balanced. Oh and did it mention the sandwiches are hot? Totally a plus when it's 30 degrees outside! Stop in and check it out, you won't be disappointed. read more

See all

Love their sandwiches and salads... the homemade bread is always fantastic! Service is always good and welcoming

Came here today for lunch with the family. The sandwiches are large, and the flavor was ok. The bread is so soft and good! My kids liked their pizzas. The sandwiches come with a small bag of plain lays potato chips. We ordered a side of fries, which I wouldn't do again. They were just ok, and there was no way any of us could eat them with how filling the rest of the food was! I did see they serve beers on tap! I was disappointed with the manager not taking a coupon which only expired a few days ago. read more

Food was Great and Service was even better!!! Amazing homemade bread and fresh ingredients definitely made it my new go to spot!!! Steak and Everything did not disappoint!!! Thanks Big Dan!!! read more

Just bland. Nothing to say! Bought a turkey supreme. Literally nothing was on the sandwich. Second visit, I would love to stop her because it's very convenient for me, but it's a hard no. Place was empty, now I know why. Very unfortunate read more

The bread is amazing. There's nothing else like it. The staff is very friendly. The restaurant is always very clean. The whole sandwich is 16", it's huge. read more

The food is great and the service is pleasant. We see the owner often, and he is kind and helpful. My husbands go-to is the meatball sub and I love the cauliflower pizza crust. But our littles LOVE the fries. It is an all-around family stop! read more

Papa Kelsey's - Crispy fries with fry sauce. - Sandwiches Near Me - Meridian, Idaho

Absolutely the best sandwich I've had in years!! The best bread out there!! Fresh, lite, crispy, but soft. Awesome overall!! Friendly staff!

I wanted to like this place since the staff is nice. However the sandwiches are subpar. I got the French Dip, and it's strange they used mozzarella as their cheese of choice for this. There was more mozzarella than meat, and it overpowered everything. And as much as I like buttered bread, I think the bread was too buttered so my sandwich tasted mostly like cheese and butter and ended up being too salty. I do like the bread they use but only by itself -- it wasn't the best bread for a French Dip because it disintegrated too quickly when dipped in the au jus. I don't even remember which sandwich my husband got, but he wasn't too happy with it either. That's saying something because he'll eat anything and generally loves all sandwiches. He's not a picky person and he doesn't have strong opinions about food, but he even voiced disappointment in his sandwich so that's saying something. The "spicy" fries were just seasoned fries, and while the flavor was good, the fries were so soggy. There wasn't a single fry that had crispiness on the outside at all, and I felt sad eating it. read more

Tried this establishment for the first time yesterday (Friday). Place was busy but order was taken quickly and food (Ham and Turkey Sub) was delivered quickly. Sandwich was hot and tasty; would have liked some Dijon on the sandwich but still good. Bread was great; not a huge hoagie or roll; they bake their own bread in-house. Did not eat the chips as sandwich was filling...8 inch almost too much (will modify order next time). Restaurant was clean; tables were cleaned in a timely manner as customers departed. Want to try their pizza in the future! read more

A great place to get a really good sandwich from Dan and the rest of the crew. Super nice place and I'm always telling people to go over there and get a great sandwich. read more

Papa Kelsey's - a roast beef sandwich with cheese and mustard - Sandwiches Near Me - Meridian, Idaho

Literally every sandwich is incredible. Best in-house made bread ever. Close your eyes and pick something, you can't go wrong! Big cinnamon rolls to boot. And the same dough is their pizza dough. Yum! Soft drinks are overpriced in my opinion. But the beer and wine just might be the cheapest in town! read more

Great food, quick service. Try this place in place of subway / JJ's / port of subs / etc. Prices are reasonable. Tucked off the Main Street read more

Stopped by for lunch based on our fellow Yelpers and the great reviews. Thank you. Upon entering the restaurant, I was greeted with a very friendly owner (I believe he was) which made my first time comfortable. I followed the reviews and looked at the sandwich section of the menu and ended up selecting the French Dip for lunch. The sandwich that I ordered was a half order with chips and let me inform you that the half order is a big sandwich and can not imagine eating a full order...giant I would guess!! As other reviews stated, the bread is super fresh and tasty...for those of us that love freshly baked bread...you will not go wrong. The sandwich had plenty of cheese to accompany the roast beef. Like other reviews, I would agree the amount of beer was a bit lite...but the flavors were great. The combo of bread, cheese, meat, and the au-jus worked really well...regardless of the lite beef in the sandwich. If you are looking for a local sandwich, I do not believe you will be disappointed with Papa Kelsey's. Cheers Always! read more

Papa Kelsey's - French Dip - Sandwiches Near Me - Meridian, Idaho

Pretty good sandwiches and pizzas here. Sandwiches are served hot and are on very good rolls. You can order half sandwiches and they are big enough to satisfy men. Order a whole and take home half for another meal. The pizzas are available with gluten free cauliflower crust. An individual pizza is about 9-10" diameter. Sort of thin crusts, but not cracker thin. Good crusts. Beer is available on draft, Payette brand which I like. Beer in bottles also available as well as soft drinks and wine. We will return and/or buy to take out. read more

This is NOT a franchise, at least not at this point. It is a family owned business with the original location being in Twin Falls. They make their own bread every morning using their own recipe. Sandwiches are amazing and larger than any competitor's. A half will be enough for most people. read more

Love Papa Kelsey's. Food is always a win, owner and staff are amazing and so kind. Bread is to die for. Good selection of sandwiches, salads and pizzas. Love that they now have soups. Sometimes you want something fresh and warm vs fried fast food. The restaurant is cute and they have nice patio for warm summer months. We love Papa K's! read more

Great new addition to the neighborhood. A solid four and-a-half stars. We had a couple of oven baked sandwiches and the bread sure stood out as fresh and tasty and the french fries were good as well. Nice clean spacious resataurant with a nice patio with a view of the mountains. it was very good and I can't wait to go back. read more

Neither good nor bad. Been here twice. It's just ok. Like sandwhich purgatory. Owner is super nice. Staff is young kids. Nothing against them. Just not experienced in customer service. The sandwich I had was ...again. Just ok. The pizza was also just sort of ...like play place pizza. I mean hate to blast them so I'm going easy. Just they brag about fresh bread and dough. But through the back door all you see is canned everything. Sadly won't be back myself. But wish them the best in whatever they do. Just not for me. read more

Ordered two salads which consisted of mostly iceberg lettuce. Generally pretty flavor less but very large. Dressings were also bland. Boneless buffalo wings were definitely microwaved and super soft, buffalo sauce came on the side. Ordered quickly at the counter. Inside was echoing and music was a bit loud. We ate on the patio which was nice. read more

I was a fan of Papa Kelsey's from a long time ago. I have been living on the East Coast for the past several years now and all but forgot about Papa Kelsey's. A quick search for a place to grab dinner on a work trip and Papa Kelsey's showed up. I knew I had to give it a go. I was not disappointed in the least. It lived up to every memory and expectation that I had. I even called my wife to let her know what a gem I had found in Boise. Their bread is simply the best, and the fry sauce is out of this world. read more

Papa Kelsey's - French Dip add Mushrooms and dip it in Fry Sauce. - Sandwiches Near Me - Meridian, Idaho

Never heard of this place and met some colleagues for a casual lunch. Kind of tucked away, but really a great find. First, an 8" sub is a serious 8". It is not some toothpick thin sub! I could not imagine trying to down a full 16" sub. Split that with someone for sure! Bonus, $7.99/$8.99 is a really good deal. The bread is really good. Taste great, but is kind of light. I did not feel like I ate a whole loaf of bread by myself. Bakes on site... It is really great. My only complaints that prevented 5-stars, the Italian sub came with sausage. Since this is a pizza place too, they just added pizza topping sausage to my sub. Didn't really love that. Would not hate if there were a lot more salami and pepporoni on my sub, but I feel like for a $7.99 sub I am really splitting hairs here! I will be back for sure. Probably would not do the Italian again. Maybe they have an option for me to pay a bit extra for double meat. Either way, I could see a 5-star review in my future! read more

Good hot sandwiches. I've driven past it a couple times and we finally tried it. Went with the French Dip. I really wish there had been some garlic butter on the bread to kick up the flavor a little bit but that's me nitpicking. Bread held up with the ju during the dip. Meatball sandwich was loaded with peppers. Didn't expect that. Needed a lil bit more sauce. Three Meat sandwich my husband loved. Roast beef, Turkey and ham. What's not to like about that combo?! read more

I had never heard of Papa Kelsey's before so thought to give it a try for dinner one night. I couldn't find anything super appealing so went with a grilled chicken sandwich and chicken noodle soup. My hubby got a steak and everything (whole sub.. that thing is the almost the size of a train) and should've got a half sub. So we both just felt like everything (meat wise) was pulled out of the fridge or freezer and warmed up and slapped on/into the food. The chicken just seemed weird to me in the salad and in the soup. The bread was good though. I may have to try this place again. read more

Papa Kelsey's - Grilled chicken sandwich - Sandwiches Near Me - Meridian, Idaho

See all

I had the chicken bacon ranch and my husband the steak everything, we were both pleasantly surprised by how tasty they were. Definitely recommend! And will be a place we go again! Fast and friendly service too read more

Friendly staff, new and clean, and food was good. My only issue was that waiting 15 min for a sub sandwich and chips is too long for me