Great pizza, pretty cheap, they make it insanely quick every time I've ordered even on weekends and…read morestaff is always very nice

Staff is on the ball and get it right every time. Price and quality are good. This is our only go…read moreto pizza place in town.

Finding myself in Port Hope a little later on a Monday evening and having not eaten all day I…read moreneeded to find something, and certainly didn't want drive through. Well, at 9:30 there wasn't a lot of choice so I took a look at Yelp. And Jim's had a pretty good rating. I ordered and then received my pizza very quickly. Man, this is good pizza. Loaded with toppings! So much cheese! My wife would love this. The cheese has more flavour than you will usually find and Jim's sauce stands out through the toppings. It tastes like real tomatoes not spaghetti sauce. And has texture. Seems they are using real food ingredients rather than super processed alternatives that may be cheaper. The funny thing is, this pizza is very inexpensive. I would definitely return to Jim's next time I'm in Port Hope. I look forward to trying more of the items on their menu. And if it's during the day, I may sit on their sidewalk patio and just enjoy this charming town!

We came by there around 7PM on Sunday, and we ordered for take out. We originally wanted to dine…read morein, but it doesn't look like they are offering dine in at the moment. The pizza was decent, lots of toppings, but it was missing the mushrooms we asked for. They also offer a few complimentary toppings like granulated garlic and chilies flakes. The spaghetti was average, it came out of the oven so it was hot and steamy. It came to around $35 for our medium pizza and spaghetti. We had a few slices leftover for two people, and we were both pretty satisfied.

Ordered online the small lasagna. Was ready within minutes of ordering. When I picked up my order I…read morecould not believe it was a small. The lasagna took up an entire pan tray. Very affordable. As far as the taste, I would say average but very friendly staff, fast, affordable.

on Christmas Eve I ordered on line for two pizzas to be picked up at 5:00 pm. I got my…read moreconfirmation and got on with a busy day ahead. I arrived a little before 5:00 to pick up and found out that the internet was down all day at the restaurant, they hadn't got my order. however without even looking at my online receipt, I was believed and offered an apology and they said they would make my pizzas then and there, and by way of further apology they offered a choice of salad to add to the order free of charge. I might add it was pretty busy at the time. there were plenty of deliveries being picked up by delivery guys as well. I waited the 20 min and noted that the staff were very friendly to the patrons, some of whom seemed to be regulars too. I got the pizzas which were great and enjoyed by all. so thanks to the original spaghetti house , we will be back.

$$ Not quite an Italian Pizzeria; highway robbery $$ Good…read morebut not great; no fresh arugula, and a $5 upcharge to have very small cheese and pepper condiments on the table. Our brief discussion with owner was also very disappointing. I'm not going back and I wouldn't recommend you do so either... Perhaps the condiment upcharge can go towards acoustic tile to improve ambiance...

I would contemplate coming to Peterborough just to eat a delicious slice of this thin-crust heaven…read more This place is nestled in between cafes in downtown Peterborough, with a swinging screen door, and a great group of patio tables. Beware - you're not going to get super-friendly service here, or be able to come with a group. It's take out only and things move fast. But don't let that get you down! With delicious options like barbecue chicken, goat cheese with swiss chard, and plain old pepperoni, it kills me that this place is over 3 hours away. I devoured some delicious goat cheese and veggies with an amazing dill and lemon dipping sauce. We sat outside on the patio, which was good because it was super hot inside and there wasn't a lot of space. What space there is is chock full of live-music posters, colourful paint and bar stools. If you're in in, or nearby Peterborough you need to come here.

Good pizza with interesting topping choices. Conveniently location downtown to just have a slice or…read morepickup. Friendly staff.

I always make sure to stop in to Stefano's when I'm driving through the area. They have affordable…read morepizza and so many options! The staff is always super friendly and it's easy to order over the phone. It's about a standard 15-20 minute wait time.

As far as Pizza on a rural roadside on the way up to cottage country goes, Stefano's Pizzeria hits…read morethe mark. It's not fancy, and not pretty but the price is right and at the end of the day it was dough, sauce, cheese and toppings cut in a triangular shape, so it was A-OK in my books. Stefano's always has slices ready to go but with some advance planning you can order a fresh pie or any number of Italian staples (pasta, sandwiches, etc). Would I? Probably not, it's just not my personal taste and realistically stopping for a full Italian dinner on route to the cottage in the midst of traffic doesn't make sense. So pizza it was and pizza I ate. Slices were pretty big, I thought I was hungrier than I was and ordered 3 slices, big mistake. I was pressing full by the middle of the second. So either their dough is heavier than others or I was just stuffed. Compared to the chip truck, Subway and Mexican joint in this plaza, Stefano's offered the quickest option for getting back on the road again, and I would stop in again in driving through again. Eatcrest Out

I like their pizza a lot but not my wife. Service is good…read more My friends love the food here.

Great pizza great people! Family owned. Been getting pizza from there for many years. Try the…read moredeluxe!

Greeter's and servers are all so friendly and helpful. Comfortable seating and spacious…read more Atmosphere and decor is family oriented, bright and airy. Love their tomato based soup, the warm bread and butter and haven't found anyone else in Town that makes a Chicken Parm dinner as generous or tender and East Side Mario's. My wife love's their Italian wedding soup and salads and agree's with my comment regarding their Chicken Parm.

My kids and I love love love this location and the food. Always a pleasure never a disappointment…read more Staff are friendly and prompt. We always return. The pasta is to die for.