I gave this long time local thrift shop 5 stars because I can rarely if ever go in here without finding items to buy. *Note that you park and enter in the rear of the building. This thrift shop used to be called Saint Kateri Thrift shop but ownership by the church was relinquished and the parishoners at St Kateri still volunteer to run this establishment. Many volunteers have been dedicated for decades. It was founded decades ago as a food pantry and thrift shop to directly benefit the local community, and it still does. Every penny goes to the community beyond the building expenses. The food pantry is located within but run separately. The prices can be varied from incredibly cheap to a bit higher, and I have purchased items in all price ranges. They have every thing here. Furniture, antiques, knicknacks, kitchen, jewelry, collectibles, books, electronics, frames and wall decor, art and craft supplies, luggage, purses, toys, housewares, baby equipment, shoes and boots, sports equipment, clothes from newborn to plus, men, women, children, new items and used. This is a favorite haunt of resellers. I had my eye on a little $5 child's toy and a regular reseller snatched that up and it is now $40 on FB Marketplace. Tuesday mornings when they open the line is around the corner. It is open an hour before Goodwill so resellers are in and out. I got there on a Wednesday at opening and about 15 people were in line. Today I purchased a large framed folk art print for $6, a pair of boots like new for $5, an American Girl knock off horse trailer for $15, a bath rug for $4 and a Glitter Girl doll for $3. I also got a nice wooden kitchen island chair for $8. There is some consistency in pricing but not always. They are open 3 days a week and will soon open 2 Saturdays a month. This is because they rely completely on volunteers. The ladies in there all have the patience of a saint and if you are a regular you will get to recognize them. I find the store pretty well organized. It is clean and for the most part there is adequate space in the aisles. A few can be a bit tight. Anyway, if you are a thrifter and looking for a place to be surprised with what you might find, you will want to check this out. But if you find something really really good, leave it for me! read more

See all

We have been regular here for just over 6 years, the last 3 with our VA prescribed service dog, Capt'n Jack. Today was an attack on us and the Captain. As soon as we walked in we were attacked, attacked, by a clerk and said if our service dog made a mess we must clean up after him. Well, that would be a huge infraction of a service dog and we showed her 2 different supplies to do clean up (meant for outside). After the assault ( if was pretty aggressive and demeaning). I asked to speak with someone who is in charge. She said she was. But then said later she would get her "boss". We were confronted with Elaine, it turns out she is the president of the 501 c 3 (and her husband is the secretary). President Elaine very much was the mid 50's heavy height, woman with a chip on her shoulder and demanded I change my attitude. "Loose the attitude." Seems to be her pet phrase. I'm an American Citizen and US Army Veteran. I have 1st amendment rights just as "Mrs. Loose the attitude Elaine" does.Elaine demanded we leave if we couldn't provide our service dog's "papers." There are none. That doesn't exist. Google it.Google it. And if she had done a quick google... I gave her my VA card which showed I'm service disabled. 93%. Meanwhile, my service dog did as my Dr's suggested trainer, TADSAW, trained him to do as I'm having a PTSD Panic attack, jump up in my arms and lick my face. Later he alerted me to take my medications for migraines. My partner agrees we need to take this to the federal government. Any quick google search will show what can and cannot be asked of a person with a service dog, let alone a US Army 93% veteran. The ADA fine is up to $75,000. Plus I've been advised to contact the DOJ and personal injury attorney. I served my country (4 yrs) and followed my VA medical directive and have a dog trained for 3 years. Capt'n Jack keeps me alive. Do a Google search. There are only two questions that can be legally asked of someone with a service dog. None of them are "papers." You can't ask for "papers" because there is no such thing. There are no national papers. You can't ask my disability. Which she did and I told her. She asked why I'm disabled! Korea in 1987/89. Rushed by North Koreans and in 2 anti-American riots in Seoul while protecting a field grade officer and having North Koreans march through Advance Warrior Base II during the Olympic games, 2 bus accidents while on duty to 2nd ID. We have benefitted from Parish in the past. Now, I don't want to leave my house. Period. Their board could contact a lawyer for advice. We are making a formal ADA complaint, $75000 fine and DOJ complaint and interviewing injury lawyers for no less than $1.5 million. Do a google search Mrs. President Eleane. A simple google search. What can a store ask for of a person with a service dog. But I think you will find out from the ADA and DOJ and the lawyer of my choice. read more

Visited the store on 5/2/26 . I believe the man ringing up sales is a crook and a bold face liar. We finished shopping and went to casher. The total was 51 dollars which seemed a bit high to both of us. There was a line behind us so we paid and returned to our car. We laid everything out and checked our receipt . There were three charges we didnt have mechandise for. Two three dollar charges and one five dollar charge. None of our purchases were 3 dollars or 5 dollars. We went back inside and questioned the male cashier and he claimed " things pile up and sometimes he rings them twice". How do you ring up something twice when it was never there in the first place. Upon hearing our complaint he was very eager to return our 11 dollars and have us leave. I wonder how many times this happens to other people. My advise to everyone shopping there is to check your receipt before you leave the store. read more

Nice selection of gently used items. You can try on clothes but will only have a curtain as a door to your dressing room. I wish it was more secure when dressing. read more

First things first, HARD WORKERS! Those volunteers who process all donations, my hats off to you! Thank you for sitting through bags and bags of stuff. The interior is large, a lot of items inside including furniture. Prices are not to bad either. It's a little dirty, but it's a thrift shop. There is also a small amount of clothing inside to sift through. You honestly never know what you will find as donations are put out of the floor. Going 1-2 times a week is a good recommendation. read more

Cute thrift store. Lots of interesting wall pictures and beautiful decorations for the house. Recommend checking it out!

I enjoy thrift shopping because I never know what I'll find. The volunteers are friendly and helpful. There is always a good selection of just about everything and anything you would want. I love going through this shop and always find something of interest. Prices are very reasonable. I no longer work in Poquoson and have moved to Richmond so I don't get to go as frequently as I did. This place is still my favorite thrift store and I sincerely miss going for my weekly shopping trip. read more