Only Pizza in Denver that I will ever eat is the best I've been eating there at 10 to 30 years I love it is the best in Denver fresh hot my family I love this place I go all the time I've taken all my family it's the best I love this place I love the people I love the service they're friendly I love that family they are my family I love them read more

1.the pizza was cold!! 2. the employees don't wash hands 3. i did not felt welcomed when i walked in i don't know what's going on, but they need to fix it. i will no longer bring my friends or family here ever again because i'm highly dissatisfied!!! read more

Love this place so much!! I live in San Francisco now and there hasn't been a place I love just as much! The employees have been wonderful!

I ordered a calzone for my 6 year old son, he took a bite and the dough was completely raw inside. At first I thought maybe it was the ricotta cheese, but no it was raw dough as there was no ricotta in it, only a small teaspoon in the middle!!! My son has issues with textures and it being raw inside made him throw up in the car! I turned around took it back, showed it to the 2 girls and they said that's the way calzones are and started arguing with me. I told them I'm Italian and no that is not how calzones are supposed to be! They also said there's no way my son would throw up from one bite. I asked to speak to the owner, she said she was the owner! (So very sad) Not only is this establishment filthy as the tables were horribly dirty, but the food was gross with theeeee worst customer service I've ever experienced in my life. Not only did they both yell at me, but they also gave me a hard time about giving me my money back. No wonder they didn't have any customers in the 20 minutes I was waiting for my food! Absolutely HORRIBLE, never again will I go there!! I suggest if you want good pizza, go upstairs to the food court to Sbarro's because this place was absolutely gross with the worst customer service in the world! I don't even want to give them a star, but have to in order to leave the review! read more

DO NOT GO!!! Especially if you have daughters!!! We've been customers of this place since my wife and I were in high school. Always regular visitors and must have spent over $5 grand total over all the years. Was there tonight and although the food was good as always, the service was offensive, threatening and ruined our family's night. "Pablo" is what he said his name was, an extremely rude pedophiliac who kept hitting on my 13 year old daughter. "Donovan" the other guy (who's family owns the place from what I understand) was laughing and joking at customers. A terrible way to thank our loyalty and behavior that completely RUINED the brand Peppino's for us. I think of them as Pediphilo's from this day forward. Never again. read more

Pizza's fine, but the part where the owner was verbally harassing an employee for not being Christian in front of me and other customers is completely unacceptable for a supposedly-professional-business. If you think such bigoted insults as "scientific retards" goes well with your pizza, go here read more

Great Pizza, horrible service. I had lunch here recently (as my sister suggested this place) and was totally caught off guard by how rude and unhappy the male cashier was. I tried to engage him a little but was totally shut- down and no, there wasn't a line as they had just opened. I told him my order was for there after he asked twice!! Not only did he put my food in a box, I had a hard time trying to get a refill on my drink!! I guess from now on, I will just get the pizza to go!! read more

I'm addicted to their pizza as well and I have to have a slice everytime I go to the mall. But their customer service is very stand-offish almost everytime I go in there, they seem to be bothered by the fact that they have customers. But if you can get past that i would recommend it! read more

When we are craving a pizza....this is where we go! We love Peppino's pizza and their calzones! You can get a slice (big slice!) and a soda and you're good to go! Nice, friendly staff and it always looks clean.But, we mostly love the pizza!!! I almost always get the pepperoni and mushroom and my hubby usually gets the sausage and mushroom. Sometimes we get a "special", has lots of good stuff on it. If there are only a few slices left in the display, we wait for a fresh pizza to come out...usually only takes about 10 mins or so and totally worth the wait! read more

This pizza is very good, always to peppinos when I'm at the mall. Its clean, the workers are nice, and the pizzas always fresh! Closest to ny pizza that I have found. The prices are good to read more

Felt very mislead by the yelp rating here. 4 stars is ridiculous. It's in a mall. This isn't a good thing. Maybe by the slice is better but the thick crust was barely average dough topped with bottom tier ingredients. I requested no black olives on a supreme. I got black olives. I ordered garlic knots. The kid pulled them from a hot lamp because they didn't make them fresh. This is a joke for the "top rated pizza in my area" read more

Great food & friendly service. Our pizza maker was uber excited about making our order. Great place for handmade pizza.

Very nice every time I have been in. Good food and yummy calzones. Pizza isn't as good as Anthony's -- but it is almost there.

I googled best Italian style pizza In Aurora, CO and this was 1st on the list. 6:00 on a Friday night. Mall was pretty busy but not this place. It's tucked back in a corner of the mall away from all the other restaurants. Yelp users gave it 4 and 1/2 stars...??? Pizza was hot but clearly had been sitting out for hours. Crust was hard as a rock and the sauce was really salty and I like salt. I've had better pizza at 4 am at 7-11. I see what everyone else talks about with regards to the staff. They look pissed and don't say anything to you but "here or go" and my total. Never again!! read more

Now you know when you get better NY pizza in Aurora than Manhattan they must be doing something right. Been going here since it was Scotto's Pizza (1977). Always fast, always good. Eat it while it's hot, and you will not be disappointed. Great toppings, great sauce, great service! read more

Excellent pizza. Very friendly crew and good prices. Had a pepperoni and cheese slice and they were both great.

Me and the family unit always order the extra large pie 1/2 Italian sausage and half cheese, a few orders of garlic knots and sauce, salad and a couple sodas. Never been disappointed - great taste, - abondanza !!! read more

Worst experience EVER ! I was waiting for my Mom to return to Peppinos from a store around the corner in the Aurora mall so we can order pizza ! I asked the lady at the register if I could use the restroom ? , and before she could answer some punk from behinf the registersaid "The restroom is for customers only!" and then the RUDE lady at the register said "Yea the restroom is for customers ONLY"! I began to walk away to AVOID any confrontation as I was not in the mood for HORRIBLE CUSTOMER SERVICE....the lady at the register then said "There's no need to be upset!" HELLO I WAS WALKING AWAY FOR A REASON ! ONLY IN AURORA...... ! WORST CUSTOMER SERVICE I HAVE EVER EXPERIENCED ! Oh and I've had their pizza before...it's 5.5 on a scale of 10 ! read more

Food: Awesome! Always tastes delicious; always hits the spot. We go here every week for our weekly Peppinos fix. Service: Most of the employees are great. There is one girl there that is so friendly and helpful. She always makes our canolis and is very accomodating. She recognizes us and makes us feel really welcome. Negative: There is a worker there (a previous reviewer mentioned him) that needs to get a new job. He never smiles, he is very rude and he looks completely miserable. Next time we're there (later today) if he is working I am getting his name and reporting him to the owner. There is no reason to be such a scrooge...especially when everyone else who works there is wonderful. But, regardless, we will keep going as long as the food remains yummy and the other employees are there. read more

Been my favorite slice in town for years. They do something different with their pizza. I don't know what it is, but I like it. The staff can have an edge to them. Like something bad happened there minutes before you got there, but you don't know what. But that's fine. Grab a slice and then cruise the mall! All the kicks, caps, and cell phones you could ever want under one roof. Plus, I saw what seemed to be a 10 year old boy driving the train through the mall for the other kids. It was awesome. read more

I have been taking my son to this place since he could barely walk (about to be 7 years old). Anyway, I now live in Centennial, but I will still go to Aurora Mall sometimes in middle of the day with him when not to busy (Park Meadows is always filled with housewives all times of day). Pizza is good and no issues with staff as I saw in other reviews. It is on of our tradition whenever we step in the Aurora Mall. read more

After spending $20 at this place and paid with a credit card, my friend who is a disabled adult wanted a cup of water. The owner wanted to charge 11 cents for cup of water. I told my friend to wait and we will get water later. The owner kept making remarks saying " you don't have 11 cents". I told her as you can see I paid with a credit card and there's no point to have a transaction for 11 cents and I informed her she was arguing with a disabled adult. But the owner continued to argue with the disabled adult and made it known that she was the owner. To top it off the pizza was cold and tasted like cardboard. read more

Wonderful as always never fails me. This place smells so awesome every time you go in by the door it's located at. This place has been here since I was little and I hope it will stay for many more years to come! read more