Interesting tale. People like to say that places have gone downhill over the years. Well, what's the opposite? I won't say they've gone "uphill", but back when I lived in Livingston, we tried Enoteca and all agreed we didn't like it, off our list of pizza places. Since then, a number of the old places are gone, or (I won't name Calabria) have indeed gone downhill, and some new places have entered the equation. I bring this up because my parents mentioned, "You know what? We haven't been to Enoteca in ages. Let's try it sometime." So I surprised them with a pie. Now this is no ordinary surprise - my power went out Saturday night, I went to my parents to recharge my phone and sanity and to get fed, and something reminded me of Enoteca. I checked - the clock said 9:25, Enoteca closed at 9:30, but... they stay open for pickup? So I called, and sure enough they do! So I placed an order that totally went in the oven after their closing time, and showed up shortly after to wait. They were apologetic about the wait, but I felt apologetic about the call in the first place. So I sat, waited, chatted with the staff and the one gentleman sitting at the bar. Lovely people here, nice atmosphere - more expansive than a pizza place, with only the second legit bar I know of in L-Town besides Landmark just a bit farther uphill/downhill on Route 10. (See what I did there?) Pizza box came out piping hot, straight to my hands, straight home, for us all to evaluate. The food verdict you've all been waiting for: Hands down the best place in Livingston as of 2026. Is it better than Calabria's was 30 years ago? I can't compare. But I can tell you my father loved the sauce, my mother loved the cheese, and we all appreciated the balance of ingredients in our toppings (this year's special of anchovies, garlic, onions, mushrooms - don't ask). When they visit me, I've got my pizza here. When I visit them, we now have established their pizza there. Enoteca all the way. read more

A few weeks ago, my husband and I had a Friday night dinner at Pizzeta Enoteca for the first time together. When I suggested it, he had no clue about where I was talking about. Both having grown up in the area, I figured that he had passed it numerous times but never went in - like I had - but I had to give directions when we drove there. We had a great time and a wonderful meal there. We were seated at one of the booths by the bar. He ordered Eggplant Parmesan. I ordered one of the entree specials that night - Roasted Porkchop with sweet sausage, potatoes, onions, vinegar peppers in a white wine reduction sauce. We both ordered the salad special of the day. The food was so good! We plan to come again for date nights and with friends. Loved this place! In addition to the delicious food and charming dining atmosphere, that night they played good music. I remember being really into the playlist that night - Cake's "Going the Distance", Sonic Youth's "Bull in the Heather", the Cranberries' "Dreams", the Cure's "Friday I'm in Love", Smashing Pumpkins' "Tonight, Tonight", Radiohead's "Lucky", Mazzy Star's "Fade into You"... It was 90s/00s nostalgia and I was all about it :) read more

See all

Interesting spot in Livingston another place for alcohol in town and their food is good but the spot is a little shaky I don't know what's going on there... read more

Pizzeta Enoteca - Italian Near Me - Livingston, New Jersey

Ok. 4th time getting pizza to-go and every time it's different. Very inconsistent. Every time it gets worse . Tonight it was not good. Flat & dry. I'll go some where else next time. read more

Good pizza. Good sauce. Not too crowded. Outdoor seating. $3.50 for a slice, which is 1/4 of a small pie. read more

Pizzeta Enoteca - They give you 1/4 of a small pie as a slice. - Italian Near Me - Livingston, New Jersey

Only 1 of 2 happy hour in dry boring Livingston , been here for decades. Come to see Chris iconic chatty bar- therapist, attentive savvy staff as Lori , also regular menu unusually homemade with mussels, good Italian huge salads. Parties, bat mitzvah and other events show its local place of honor read more

Restaurant choices in Livingston can be spotty. Evidence of this is the longevity or lack thereof of many local eateries. Places that I thought were pretty damn good have gone out, replaced by places that may or may not be their equal. In this myriad of confusion is Pizzeta. The food and service are consistently good, even when there is a wait it moves quickly and they have a fireplace. Is Pizzeta, outstanding? No or I would have awarded them the coveted 5th Star. Would I travel a long distance to eat there? The answer again is no. But if you are looking to enjoy a nice meal in a nice restaurant, it may just be for you. Worth mentioning is their mozzarella selection. It's varied and outstanding. You can choose one of several varieties or order a mixed platter of them all. I eat at Pizzeta several times per month and truly enjoy it. A solid local favorite in a town that is missing a lot of solid local favorites. read more

For a relatively small place in Livingston they have surprising fair prices. We checked out Pizzeta for happy hour and tried some of the $5 small plates and beer specials. The pizza was the same as you find in an elementary school cafeteria but the meatballs were a good size and good quality. Overall I would recommend checking it out. Update: We gave it a try for late night drinks and were not impressed. The beers were fine but we had to send the margarita back, it was all lime juice. When the bartender brought a new one it was the same except more tequila. I think maybe the staff were young. read more

Pizzeta Enoteca - Meatballs and pizza (Happy hour specials) - Italian Near Me - Livingston, New Jersey

See all

Excellent food here at Pizzeta and great staff. Restaurant is very clean. I met the manager ("Neftaly"?) who was very professional and helpful about items on the menu. Very nice & classy atmosphere as well. read more

See all

Did not give me a drink when I ask for one. Mike should be fired for ever. Do not give a job to mike. And gave one to Jake instead. Still no drink. 5 min later and still nothing. read more

Pizzeta Enoteca - No drink here - Italian Near Me - Livingston, New Jersey

Surprisingly good food!!! Went for a last minute birthday dinner and was superb. Great wings, great white pizza, and paninis. All were very satisfied with their meals. Def a return visit for me. read more

I would give 5 stars for food and ambiance alone. There portions are massive and the panini and pasta salad were to my liking. The service, on the other hand, was extremely slow and sporadic as it took forever to the waitress to refill water, and bring drinks. This place is great for camping out when on a weekend, but if you have any commitments afterwards. Avoid during rush. read more

We have been eating here for years since moving to the area. There is such inconsistency in both the food and service so it makes reviewing the restaurant a bit tough. For a great take-out option, the large pizzas and salads made to order are great. They have a whole wheat crust option, lots of choice toppings, real mushrooms (a must if it a pizza place is worth any muster), and fast preparation from ordering to pick-up! Every now and then, the crust isn't quite as crispy but overall, a nice option for thin crust in the area. The chicken paillard and salmon with white beans and escarole are solid entree options. The dining in experience though really leaves you wondering. The pizza crust triangles in the bread basket are habitually cold and doughy. Service is spotty. Food is hit or miss and pizzas can only be ordered in personal pizzeta size at the table. The liquor license/full bar is a nice feature of this kid-friendly place so it caters to a wide variety of diners. Given the tabs for the food, though, we just prefer to take ours to go since there are other places around to dine out for better food and service. PS the whole wheat 1/2 melanzane 1/2 poggio ( grilled eggplant and mushroom) is by far our favorite pizza! read more

Our family had a Celebration of Life luncheon last weekend. It was excellent. They were very accommodating for the party size, dietary restrictions and young children. The food, customer service and venue was excellent! Be sure to order the vegetable lasagna! You will love it!!! Thank you Tony for making it a wonderful experience in an otherwise stressful day. read more

We usually come here at least every 4-5 weeks. This was one of the worst visits. Service was inexistent. Restaurant was almost empty as it was early (around 4:30pm). It took them more than 25 mins to come and take our order, after asking for it twice. Water came only 10mins later. Bread took another 10 and again, only after asking for it. They never came back with more water. We could see all waiters chatting around the bar altogether for the entire 1h15min we were there. We used to like this place, we will try to not come back read more

My brother has several friends in the Livingston area and has visited Pizzeta many times. He had been raving to me about the delicious food for months, and since I trust his food opinions (I trained him well, after all!), I was psyched to finally sample it for myself. I accompanied his group of buds to the relaxed restaurant one evening and was a bit surprised by the decor. The building resembled a standard, suburban diner, but the interior had been completely renovated to resemble a fashionable, yet cozy space. They even had an upscale bar section that served fruit-filled sangria and martinis. The clientele appeared rather wealthy and upper-class, despite the reasonable prices. Though the pastas and pizzas sounded fabulous, I wanted to order something on the lighter side. I contemplated one of their interesting salads, but felt it would be a waste of a visit to such a great restaurant. Instead, one of my brother's friends suggested that we all share the enticing Chop Chop Salad. I ecstatically jumped at the opportunity, since this was the blend I was most leaning towards anyway. The massive bowl was lined with romaine lettuce and mixed greens, but full of Mediterranean toppings like garbanzo beans, kalamata olives, tomatoes, red onions, and carrots. Its light red wine vinaigrette added the perfect amount of seasoning to an already flavorful mixture. Since I was able to satisfy my salad craving, I decided to get a full-size entree for my main course. I guess I still somewhat copped out by ordering the Chicken Paillard, since the grilled meat was also served over arugula, plum tomatoes, and shaved pecorino romano, all drizzled with a balsamic vinaigrette. The chicken had been pounded thin and was well-marinated, leaving it tender and moist. I sampled my brother's Whole Wheat Pasta Primavera, which was full of soft chicken and crisp garden vegetables. Its creamy vodka sauce was decadent and bold. I will admit that it was pretty difficult to steer my fork away from his plate. Pizzeta's food surpassed my expectations. The fact that its pleasurable environment was casual, yet stylish made it that much better. I look forward to a return visit. read more

We have been going here for years. We have always enjoyed the food and the quiet atmosphere when we have dined in. The staff has always provided kind and courteous service. The other night there was a mix-up with our order. Why the 5 star rating if there was a mixup? They acknowledged the error and bent over backwards to ensure the error was corrected and we were satisfied, offering multiple options in the process. Errors happen, but acknowledgement and a positive response can help retain customers for life. read more

family member ate at restaurant. After their meal, money was missing from her purse. After looking for money and stating to friends,her money was missing, she noticed restaurant employee dropping money from a napkin and kicking money under a table next to hers .Employee then stated," oh is this your money?". the amount was exact dollar amount missing called manager and never got back . don't trust this staff .Not even proper courtesy to reply back . Don't recommend this place read more

Amazing service- Mariam is a great waitress and deserves a raise!!

My wife ordered the blackened chicken ceaser salad last week and asked me to pick it up on my way home from work. I was beyond disgusted to see what was going on in the kitchen - One of the cooks was preparing food for customers was eating a salad WITH HIS HANDS at the same time. Unfortunately for me, i didn't notice this until after I had paid. At that point I knew the food was going in the garbage and was so disgusted I just needed to get out of there. I would advise caution before visiting this place. read more

Overall a 1 due to the awful service we had with the manager on duty, but food only I'll give it a 3.5. I've been to Pizzetta 3 times, but the third was the last. The manager on duty during our last visit could not have been any more obnoxious and rude. There was a price mis-print on one of the menus and he more or less mocked us for assuming the price was correct when we received our check. He unwillingly honored the mis-printed price and then docked pay from the poor server (we saw him walk over to her and say it loud enough for half the restaurant to hear). We gave her a very large tip to make up for it and then some. Suffice it to say I have never experienced such unprofessional behavior by a restaurant manager. Simply mind boggling. If I was the owner and knew my management was acting this way I would be fuming. No rhyme or reason here and I hope the owner reads this. The way you treat your customers has a ripple effect larger than you can imagine. If it weren't for that one incident, we would be regulars, but oh well. Needless to say we have already passed this message on to all of our friends in the area. read more

Used to come here all the time when I worked in the area. Food was always good and the service is decent. I was in Livingston for an errand last night and decided to stop in for dinner since I was with a friend who is gluten free and I recalled Pizzeta having a generous GF menu. I used to always order the vegetariana panini because it's made with their basil mayo which is AMAZING. I'd literally dip anything into that stuff, it's so good. However, I was also craving pizza so I did what any logical food lover would do: I ordered the melanzane pizza for dinner and a vegetariana panini to go so I could eat it for lunch the following day (of course, I asked for an extra side of basil mayo for French fry dipping). The pizza was delicious. Probably could've been slightly crispier in the crust but the toppings and flavors were on point. My friend ordered the ziti pizza which they made with gluten free penne and crust. She was also very happy with her pizza, but agreed the crust could've been crispier. I ate my panini at work today and I'm happy to report, it's just as good as it was a few years ago. If only they would bottle and sell that basil mayo! A girl can dream.. read more

Pizzeta Enoteca - Melanzane pizza - Italian Near Me - Livingston, New Jersey

See all

This is our go to pizza place for Friday night. They make a great classic pie and great margherita pies. Always friendly and delivers fast. Definitely recommend. read more

Wow, this place has really declined since I was last there a couple of years ago. The room needs a refresh. It is looking quite tired. The service was rather uninterested in your dining experience. The food was entirely uninspired. We shared the rice ball (arancini) and the Caesar salad to start. The rice ball here used to be fluffy and wonderful, in a beautifully vibrant marinara sauce. This latest visit had us share a leaden, gigantic and rather mediocre tasting version in a sauce that I did not want more of. The Caesar salad had no life to it. It was almost like eating romaine lettuce with no dressing. Yuck. One of us had the buffalo chicken pizza, which used to be far better. I had a special of farfalle with shrimp, chicken sausage, asparagus and peas in a garlic and oil sauce. It should have been far tastier than it actually was, and the shrimp were overlooked. Our server also took his sweet old time processing my credit card payment. We will not return any time soon. Sad that places go downhill like this. read more

This place is terrible! I've been there 4 or 5 times. The wait staff couldn't care less about your dining experience. Also Is this dump a singles bar or a restaurant? they play this horrible loud music all the time. When I asked the waiter if we could move to get away from the music, he said, no, it's the same volume in the entire restaurant. Will never go there again. read more

Ordered catering last night and the food was delicious! My son who is rather critical raved about it as did many of our guests. The delivery was on time and the person even brought the trays in. I loved when it was still nice and hot. Thank you!! read more

I like this place. It has great mini (big enough for two!) pizzas, a full bar, and a variety of entrees and salads. They offer a lot of variations of pizza, like cheese steak or shrimp and they offer wheat varieties. They're salads are some of the tastiest I've had and the portions are huge. Their menu has a lot to offer. The atmosphere is nice - a mix of a casual and classy in the dining room and bar and the prices are pretty cheap. Definitely a good spot for a nice lunch or dinner without the hassle. read more

If someone tells you the salads are good, listen and order one. HUGE fresh and delicious. Also tried the chicken parm panini... I give it and the fries a 3 out of 5. Plain cheese pizza was very good... very cheesy with a thin crust. We went around 1pm on a Saturday and it was empty. We had a nice comfortable table for 5.. they filled our water right away, however they were not attentive when it came to refilling. We had to ask when our meals came, and I could have used another refill but he never came back to ask. It was a little warm when we walked in, but then I could tell they kicked the a/c on because it got cooler. Overall a nice place that I would check out again. read more

Detoured in Livingston. Some crazy accident on the I-280 East and the Trooper told me 3-4 hours to clear ... so much traffic! Trying to find an alternate route and discovered Pizzeta! Enjoyed the Di Casa insalata and my special request for Linguini pasta with a spicy red sauce and steamed vegetables! Added a tad more crushed red pepper ... delicious! Finishing now with an espresso and then back on the road. Cheers! read more

See all

buffalo chicken pizzeta is AMAZINGGG! We always get this. Also good are their paninis/sandwiches ! tiramisu served in a martini glass is nice and light...YUM! I really like the ambience- nice and modern but still cozy and casual. Can get packed on weekends. One of our favorite places in LIvingston area for any occasion. read more

Pizzeta is a neighborhood watering hole that happens to be an italian inspired eatery. Menu is varied enough for everyone to find something enjoyable. Specials expand the many options already noted. Positives: Excellent salad dressings, generous portions, great eggplant appetizer, tasty grilled salmon, sandwiches easily convert to panini style. Restaurant is casual and menu extends itself easily for either lunch or dinner. Busboys are attentive with refilling water. Wait staff is usually attentive. Good drinks. Delivery and pick up available. Negatives: The restaurant is a little too air-conditioned (bring a sweater), On some rare occasions, wait staff has been understaffed. read more

Amazing food! We order takeout from here every week. The pizza is delicious and the crust is perfectly cooked. The staff at Pizzeta are awesome. We highly recommend takeout and dine in! read more

So amazing, we sat at a socially distanced table, food is on point, staff is friendly and happy- really enjoyable night!

Try the Italian hot dog mini's that they serve as an appetizer. They are really good. Nice thin crust pizza's read more

I ordered the Brussels sprouts, Greek salad, and margarita pizza and all of it was delicious. Well prepared and fresh...it sure hit the spot!! read more

Yummy grilled sandwiches served with fries that arrive to the table well presented. The portions are not too big...I hate when. Restaurant gives enough food for 3people. So I think their niche is salads, panini, and fries. O&Pizza read more

I've been here a few times, and I'm suprisingly impressed with every visit! The bar is really nice for starters - and very reasonably priced. I don't drink much, so I can't speak for the quality of the beverages, but I did have a nice sangria, and my husband's microbrew beer was only $4. As far as food, it's always good and always hot. Portions are big...and yet, I usually finish my dinner! My favorite entree so far has been the Cavatelli and Broccoli, which I've gotten with whole wheat pasta. The texture is excellent, and the fresh cherry tomatoes are a nice touch. The salads are also fantastic. The service is probably the only thing I'm not totally impressed with. The wait staff is friendly and makes every effort to be attentive, but they're not the experienced pros a busy place like this should be hiring. Case in point: our waiter last night brought the parmesan and pepper for my pasta five minutes after it had been served. He was super-nice about it, but it was half-gone by then! Also be aware that this place gets loud, it gets crowded, and people bring their kids. So...not great for an intimate dinner for two. But perfect for a girls' night or (in our case) a brief escape from the kids! A final, helpful tip: Pizzeta is on Restaurant.com, so you can get great discounts. read more

Place was great, service was quick and kind. Food was stunning and came out fairly quickly. Had the bacon egg and cheese panini with steamed veggies. Definitely must come back soon. read more

Pizzeta Enoteca - Italian Near Me - Livingston, New Jersey

Been here a ton of times. Have always had a good experience. Good fish, good lasagna, good pasta, good sangria, good service, get the point. Price point is good. read more

I have only had the buffalo chicken pizza but oh my the beautiful thing that man can create. Whoever makes this pizza doesn't just throw toppings around but places it accordingly. Presentation was great but this pizza has never let me down. No artificial buffalo taste. Anytime I get it, I love it! read more