I typically get a plain or margarita pizza from here and will dine in with a beverage. The lemonade isn't sweet enough for me but may be just fine for someone else. The garlic knots and pizza are worth getting. I've also ordered their wings which I would describe as the same sort of wings you would get at any pizza shop. Staff is pleasant, very chill. I'll usually stop in for a pizza anytime I'm in the area. read more

PJ's Grill & Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Brunswick, New Jersey

See all

While showing my daughter around Rutgers, I came here to reminisce. I used to order from PJ's all the time when I was in school and wanted my daughter to have the experience. The grease trucks are gone (RIP), but had to get a Fat Sandwich like the old days. The young man at the corner was very welcoming. We ordered a Fat Daren and Fat Moon. Despite the goodness, I can only have once every couple of years. Thanks for the memories. read more

See all

PJ's has literally never stopped being the absolute best in covering all ranges of your food palate. The food simply is made with love and it shows. This salad was healthy and very delicious. It did not have one speck of iceberg lettuce, instead it was filled with robust greens. I truly enjoyed my dish and the place was clean and staff was great! It's a little tight in there but it's worth it! read more

PJ's Grill & Pizza - Healthy & Delicious Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad - Pizza Near Me - New Brunswick, New Jersey

My first time on DD ordering from them and it was amazing! Pasta dish in the late evening was fresh and they called to make sure I didn't want it left outside. I def ordering again! read more

My favorite pizza in New Brunswick! Always consistent and delicious. Quick service and quality food - highly recommend!

While this is close to college row, I question their food. Surrounded by other restaurants, I see some good reviews for PJs, so we went over. While every other spot was packed, no one was there. It was Labor Day at 7pm. As we entered there was a smell of non cleanliness. There were 3 people working the kitchen making stuff for takeout. And we may have stopped by on a bad day, but we turned around and left. As I'm sure many did. If a restaurant does not smell clean, I never recommending eating there. Sorry but kids from college come here for a quick bite. read more

Really like going here for the grilled chicken salad. This is a regular lunch spot now. I'll be venturing further into the menu and will be expecting good things! Worth a visit read more

PJ's Grill & Pizza - Grilled Chicken Salad with balsamic vinaigrette - Pizza Near Me - New Brunswick, New Jersey

PJs is a college staple for most RU alumni. I was excited to experience a moment is nostalgia and dig into a chicken bacon ranch slice but unfortunately it is not kept behind the glass anymore and must be ordered by the pie. I grabbed a penne vodka slice and it was just as I remembered. Not overly sauced, salty or soggy. Pizza had the perfect crunch and it was enough to satisfy my pizza craving. Note that they do not add and additional toppings to the pizza slices. Restaurant was clean, tables were cleaned off and they offered a pretty vast Snapple/drink selection. read more

PJ's Grill & Pizza - Penne vodka, cheese and pepperoni slice - Pizza Near Me - New Brunswick, New Jersey

I wanted to support a local business and feed my craving at the same time. Nothing says comfort food like pizza and PJ's has some of the best. Thick soft crust, perfect sauce, bread, cheese ratio. The system to order and get your food was simple. I went with pick up and added a tip... since the students are gone, I know revenue has gone down. Anywho, the pizza was delicious and did the trick. Another satisfied customer. read more

PJ's Grill & Pizza - Curbside pick up details - Pizza Near Me - New Brunswick, New Jersey

See all

Always delicious food, had an order delivered to work today and the driver was so nice and arrived in a timely manner. Definitely recommend!

4.5. Place is legit. Met my husband here for lunch not too long ago and ordered the Pork Schnitzel and Gyro sandwich. Both were bangin'. Full of flavor, not greasy, simple sandwiches. Definitely want to come back and try more from their menu. Guys working were really nice. Only PIA is parking but that's anywhere in NB. read more

PJ's Grill & Pizza - Beef gyro - Pizza Near Me - New Brunswick, New Jersey

Average pizza. Much better local pizza places close by. Figured I would try it based on reviews. Much over rated.

This used to be my favorite and go to pizza spot in New Brunswick, but over time the quality and staff has gone down hill unfortunately. The pizza was subpar - I've had better pizza at Domino's which is quite a let down, knowing I used to order pizza's from here every SuperBowl Sunday. Pizza recently has been dry, barely heated enough, and extra chewy. The staff has been extremely rude and they always seem to have an attitude. Maybe because they deal with college kids a lot but that shouldn't be an excuse for every interaction. read more

I had always thought their pizza was really good but I loved my 1st Caesar salad here. Chicken was grilled nicely and they give you plenty of fresh ensalada! read more

PJ's Grill & Pizza - Chicken Caesar Salad - Pizza Near Me - New Brunswick, New Jersey

Out of the hundreds of pizza places on Easton, PJ'S is my favorite. I love getting a slice of their buffalo chicken pizza with bleu cheese drizzle after a long night out. Though pricey (~$4 a slice), the heat from the buffalo chicken is perfectly balanced out by the warm bleu cheese. The staff is so nice, especially considering they deal with drunk college students all night long. PJ's tastes great whether you're drunk or sober! read more

PJ's Grill & Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Brunswick, New Jersey

Perfect place for pre or post Knight club fun! Had a pepperoni and penne vodka slice and they were REALLY good. It was very cheesy without skimming on the tomato sauce. I usually don't like penne vodka slices because they tend to be dry however this was one was loaded with sauce! Definitely worth a try. read more

PJ's Grill & Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Brunswick, New Jersey

Yummy pizza! Slices are pretty big. They are pretty pricey to be honest and the cheese doesn't stay on the pizza even after letting it cool off. I love ordering from here when I'm at my family house tho. read more

Quick, no frills pizza for drunk college kids. Except you won't regret it because it's actually pretty good. I ordered a buffalo chicken slice and it came out hot and crispy before I knew it. Not much else to say--it's a good standard pizza place for Rutgers. read more

PJ's Grill & Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Brunswick, New Jersey

I always come here for the White Pizza! It's so good. My boyfriend and I also enjoy their Penne Vodka. read more

Our favorite local spot for pizza. We tried a bunch of places in Edison and were not able to pin down something we liked -- all the crusts were too thin, the sauce too bland, etc. Plain pie -- crust was OK, slightly too thick and doughy. Margherita pie -- our favorite, light on sauce, mostly taste cheese. But when you hold up the square piece, it holds form and doesn't flop! Cheeseburger -- really good, but the bun is too large for the burger, and not sure if they layer it properly with the cheese/toppings, so whenever you take a bite, the burger kind of slides/falls apart. Maybe I need to take bigger bites! But enjoyable, and we will definitely order from here again. Penne vodka with grilled chicken -- bland sauce, can barely call it a vodka sauce at that point. And light on the sauce. Delivery is quick. read more

Second stop of my recent Easton Ave pizza crawl, 2 more slices under the belt in the form of a reheated Chicken Bacon Ranch, and a fresh out the oven Pepperoni, prices were high per-slice in typical Easton ave fashion, so was the up-charge for using credit / debit to pay to the tune of $.50, steep. Pepperoni slice was fresh out the oven and had a completely different texture and makeup than the reheated slice, cheese fell of pie while trying to eat, crust was also far less firm than their reheated slices less. Half the blame id id say lie in the pepperoni, it's one of the greasier ones and no doubt attributed to the lack of stiffness in the pie. While the pizza was falling apart, the flavor was still there, sauce had a little bit of punch to it, cheese was very decent albeit messy, a decent slice like i'd grab from some of the neighborhood shops in my own area Chicken bacon ranch on the other hand nailed texture. It held together very well and still had a decent amount of flavor. Could have been left in a little longer- but was still fantastic, nice flavor, nice toppings, bacon wasn't too crisp, chicken was tender, wasn't too smothered in ranch, very well put together. Pj's was good, but it suffers from the same price hike everything else in the area does, but, if i were walking the strip and needed pizza i wouldn't mind stopping in here. It's not my first pick, but it IS decent. Flavor & Presentation 3.5/5 | Speed & Service 3/5 | Pricing & Portions 2.66/5 Overall 3/5 read more

PJ's Grill & Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Brunswick, New Jersey

See all

I ordered their Margarita pizza, I loved it. I have a peanut allergy, and the head chef took the time to ensure that everything was safe for me to eat. He talked to me personally. They re-cleaned the prep area, re-washed their hands, etc. Amazing customer service and clean pizza place!!! I love it! read more

The food is always amazing and the delivery is always on time, hot and fresh. Definitely try the white pizza with garlic or the PJs sandwiches on focaccia bread. They make the focaccia fresh and it is phenomenal. Definitely a go-to place if you are looking for great food and great service. read more

This is hands down my favorite pizza establishment. There is no buffalo chicken pizza anywhere else like the one served at PJ's. I would order an entire buff chix pie maybe twice a week during my first senior year at FuddRutgers. Despite my old age (83), I maintain peak performance in both my gustatory and olfactory sensing devices. This is really the only reason I come back to New Brunswick. Pro Tip: If someone of the opposite sex, or any sex for that matter, flips their hair at you in an attempt to obtain free food. Look them in the eye as you finish the last slice read more

Delicious portobello panini! The seasoning in the bread add a great savory flavor. Nice outdoor seating- who does your planters? Friendly staff. Will return! read more

This has become my favorate place. Every since i relocated from they NYC area.. the slices give me the nyc feel. The dough is perfect for the pizza's, love the burgers, and gryo. If only they offer turkey pepperoni and beef sausage toppings, I would give it 5 stars. !!! read more

This is really a solid place! I've gotten takeout from here a few times over the past few months while on call and it's always been good. Their teriyaki chicken and paninis are very good and very filling. PJ's uses grubhub and that makes it super easy to order and pay online (especially if you don't usually carry cash). The prices are very affordable as well and you can easily have dinner for less than $10. Nice place overall! read more

PJ's Grill & Pizza - Chicken teriyaki - Pizza Near Me - New Brunswick, New Jersey

My favorite thing on there menu is the curly cheese fries and their pizza is also very good can't complain

This spot makes me continue believing that Jersey has better pizza than NYC! Highly recommend.

My favorite place in this neighborhood to go for pizza for over 11 years. They are open late and it's great for a 4th meal. read more

PJ's Grill & Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Brunswick, New Jersey

I came here 9/9/16 at 12am with my friends once we left Olive Branch in New Brunswick, NJ. We always seem to get a pizza craving after a night of going out so we decided to go to PJ's. My one friend got a fat Darren and my other friend got a plain slice of pizza. I ordered a mushroom slice. The fat Darren looked so good! I want to say there was chicken fingers, mozz sticks, french frieds, and marinara sauce on it. It looked to die for! My other friend's pizza was good too. My pizza I didn't quite care for because the mushrooms were already sautéed and put on the pizza where normally they just throw some cooked mushrooms on there and cook it with the pizza. I guess whatever they sautéed it with gave my pizza a funky taste. But I will return to try other things. So there is always room for improvement! The employees were very nice too. read more

PJ's Grill & Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Brunswick, New Jersey

I love this place for what it is. This is your go-to stop for late night (or anytime really) Pizza in New Brunswick. The busy storefront makes sure that there are always fresh slices available. The plain is amazing but the white pizza is incredible- with trying even if your not typically a fan of such. This is not one of those pizza places that you travel to go visit, but it is the spot you stumble into at 2am for the most mouth watering carb and cheese filled delights after a night of debauchery. read more

See all

The best pizza in New Brunswick, hands down. Great cheese, good sauce, and the crust is never too thick and isn't thin enough that it bends. Price is just right and always hits the spot after a night at Knight Club. read more

4 stars for their fat sandwiches. Their fat sandwiches are much better than the grease trucks'. I'm a Rutgers alumni so I can say this for sure. It's less greasy & much more flavorful, and dare I say, has more food in it? My favorite? Fat Flip w/ hot sauce. read more

I'm totally a crust gal. Pj's crust just can't be beat! And not only is there crust good, but their cheese, sauce, and toppings are all super good too. You could say Pj's is the most loved pizza place by the Rutgers students. You can always hear drunk students on Easton Ave talking about how they wanna go get a slice at Pj's. And without a doubt it's mobbed on weekend nights. But the line moves fast. My personal favorite is their Chicken Alfredo Slice. I do have to say that Pj's isn't a great choice for vegetarians. Their speciality slices always seem to be meaty. They only have plain cheese slices, and who wants that anyway?! My con of going to Pj's is that they charge an extra 50 cents if you pay with a card.I already find paying almost $4 for a slice of pizza crazy to begin with, but adding 50 more cents onto that... Ahhhh Overall, I could seriously eat Pj's crust all day long... So I'll DEFINITELY be back whenever I'm planning to get pizza. read more

The jalapeno poppers are cheddar and not served with marinara. Good fry, but obviously frozen. The wings were over breaded and disgusting. The hot sauce had a kick, but was also oddly sweet. Big pass on all of that. If anyone from PJs reads this, walk over to Hansel 'n Griddle and order their wings to see how it should be done. The cheese steak was good because of the bread. Not too thick, so you could actually taste the filling, and they were not stingy with the steak. I'd try some fat sandwiches from here in the future- really good. The PJ's pizza was also very good. Nice thick crust, able to hold the slice straight, and excellent cheese. Would 100% get another pizza from here. If it was just sandwiches and pizza, 5 stars. If it was wings and poppers, 1 star. Average is a 3, but they have some really good things going for them here. read more

Cant complain here. They are open late, food is cheap, and their pizzas are amazing. The cheese and sauce on the pizza are untouchable! Crust cant get anymore crispier than this place. The staff are quick and attentive too. During work hours I tried their cheesesteak here once just to go against the grain and try something different, and they didnt disappoint. Basically, if you happen to be around new brunswick and see PJs Grill & Pizza, do stop by. You wont regret it. read more

I had such fond memories of PJ's from college. Maybe I was frequently eating there after a night of drinking in college or maybe they changed ownership, because it just wasn't the same on my most recent trip. I was there on homecoming so maybe high volume in the afternoon had something to do with it. Instead of calling ahead, I just popped in while my husband waited in the car. I was quickly able to place an order for a large, plain pie. The pie cost $10 (I miss college prices!) and took about 15-20 minutes. Obviously, I got a piping hot fresh pie. It was just lacking the spices that I remember used to be cooked in. Also, the cheese just didn't want to stay on the pizza. It was hard to take a bite without ripping a big chunk of cheese off. The crust was perfect though as it was an excellent combo of crispy and doughy. It wasn't a bad pizza but it just wasn't the same (and I have a pretty good food memory). I refuse to let my good memories fade so I'll have to give PJ's another shot next time I'm back in New Brunswick. read more

PJ's fell off. This is supposed to be Ceasar salad. They made the grilled chicken and put it on the salad right off the grill so the greens are wilted and soggy. Plus a Ceasar salad should be romaine lettuce and not this. I spent over $20 on two salads...disappointed read more

PJ's Grill & Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Brunswick, New Jersey

BEST PIZZA IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD!!!! Their penne pizza is ridiculously good, oh my gosh! They load up on cheese and sauce, and woo it is amazing. I also really like their buffalo chicken pizza and even the plain ones. Definitely go here for your pizza, you won't regret it! read more

PJ's Grill & Pizza - Medium penne vodka pizza- delicious!!!! - Pizza Near Me - New Brunswick, New Jersey