Fantastic! The wait was a little longer than expected, but it was well worth it. I ordered a…read morecalzone and it came stuffed with fillings, baked to a nice golden brown and pre-cut into nice sizes. On top of the great food, the business model is something special: profits are turned into scholarships for students, and much of the staff are students also (and they do a great job). In other words, you can enjoy awesome food while also making an impact on a small rural community. Definitely what I would consider a "hidden gem."

I'll give Elroy's 4.7 Stars. Only improvement that might ever be made is more seating room. But…read morerealistically, Stafford is a smaller town, so most days it's probably plenty. Great variety of pizzas on the menu. Superb quality too! Tonight we shared a medium AllMeat and a medium Chicken Fajita between four of us. I'm a big guy but by we had leftovers! These are not discount pizzas in cost nor in content, but they don't scrimp on ingredients either.

Excellent service and some of the best homemade restaurant pizza I've ever had. Fresh ingredients…read moreand perfectly crisp crust. Chicken salad was also very good. Portions are large, but leftovers were great! Update: Sadly heard they closed recently, otherwise definitely wanted to go back.

The ambience of this place is slightly nicer than a gas station. We were from out of town and the…read morereviews were good, and when we asked if we could sit and eat they said yes. But all the chairs were in stacks against the wall and we had to get our own chairs and put them next to the table. The specials list was old and torn. The server who helped us seemed shocked that we were there at all... Had almost no customer service skills. The pizza tasted like it came from an easy bake oven cooked by a lightbulb. Cracker-like crust that was not as good as something you'd get at a Casey's. Plastic plates and styrofoam cups for our drinks. Outdoor seating is a picnic table in the parking lot of a busy street. This is not a place to go if you want good ambience, good pizza, or good service.

I ordered my pizza before several other customers, yet somehow 40 minutes later I still had…read morenothing. I finally had to walk up to the counter myself to ask about it. I was told, "Oh, it should be out in just a few minutes." Another 10 minutes passed before my pizza finally came out. When it did, the quality was absolutely terrible. The pizza looked and tasted like something you'd expect from a concession stand, not a sit-down pizza place. Poor preparation, low quality, and clearly rushed despite the long wait. If you're going to make customers wait nearly an hour, the food should at least be worth it. Unfortunately, this experience was disappointing from start to finish, both in service and food quality.

Excellent work and great customer service. Breadsticks were great but could have used more garlic…read morebutter on crust. The overall cleanliness of the kitchen was great. Would recommend for any of your pizza needs. Will return for more later. Thanks. Travis

Always LOVE the pizza here. Dough is always fresh. Employees always friendly. And carryout time…read moredoesn't take forever. You'll NEVER catch me eating at Pizza Hut down the street. I used to work there, I know how they handle the food. But Casey's is the BEST PIZZA IN TOWN! And no there's no pic, by the time we remember we've eaten half the pizza. It's that good. We just dig in the minute we get it home LoL

This was a great stop. They have great pizza and great wings. The staff was very kind and friendly…read more ( chicken bacon ranch pizza and BBQ wings and plain wings). The restaurant was clean and the bathrooms were clean. I told the staff we were 30 min out and was in a truck. She said no problem it will be ready when you arrive. I give them 5 Starrs

One of the best buffalo chicken pizzas I have ever tasted. I will going back again soon!read more

Just passing through town, took a room and ordered pizza…read more Friendly people on phone and delivery. Pizza topping were top notch (Italian sausage, pepperoni and mushrooms)Sauced correctly, but only gave 4 stars due to underdone crust. Still if you are in town you'll find this pizza good.

Food is amazing and the staff are super nice and a great location to over all super amazing very…read morecool place

Taste is good. But i bet the topping guy was pretty over his day. Just tossed everything in the…read morecenter of the pizza.

We arrived here on our road trip from CA on the 4th of July. After we checked in to our hotel we…read morewalked to Pizza Hut because it was the only place open. We were greeted by. Cheyenne who happened to be very sweet and had great eye shadow for the 4th. She was the only one working the floor and the front and seriously busting her ass. There was only 1 other group when we got there and then the whole place filled up in addition to pick up orders. She was managing, serving, taking phone orders, filling orders, and even working the back! She was always very pleasant when we spoke to her and kept apologizing. I really wanted to help her but felt I would make things worse. I really want her to be acknowledged for how hard she was working. It's clear she cares about her job and her customers and should not have been the only one on the floor. Good job Cheyenne the food was great and I hope you got a lot of tips!!